Considering a motorcycle
-
For MTO members who are also motorcyclists, I need some advice.
I've decided I am not going to buy a car, and for those occasions when I need one, I'm going to get a Zip Car membership. I can't see myself needing a car more than once or twice a month, so I have no desire to tie up $400-$600 a month in payments and insurance for a vehicle that will see less than 100 mi. a month in use. As such, for personal transportation needs where a motor is required, I'm strongly thinking about a motorcycle. I will still be using my bicycle for my primary transportation; commuting to work, grocery shopping, recreation and exercise etc. But, I also recognize that having a motorized form of transportation can be highly useful, even desirable.
That said, my history is that when I was a young punk (18-21) I had a couple of motorcycles, and so I do have some experience with motorcycling, so don't feel I need a itty-bitty bike to start with. At the same time, I'm not interested in a huge bike either, I've ruled out anything over 1,000cc. I've been reading a lot the last several days, and have a few ideas that I'd like some feedback on, and any suggestions you all may have would be welcome as well.
First, just because I love the look and the mystique, a BMW F800GT has been hovering at the top of my list, although from what I've been reading, Beemers aren't the kings of the road they used to be. I like the fact this one has a belt drive and a mid size engine, but I've also read it's a bit buzzy at speed and the engine is on the anemic side for its displacement. It's also damn pricey for an 800cc bike.
I was also considering something like a Yamaha FZ-09 which is a great value. But after reading that it's very wheelie prone, that it gets lousy mileage, has some handling issues, and has a small gas tank, I don't think it's the bike for me. That said, other similar bikes I'm not going to be interested in either.
The Honda NC700X is a bike I find both attractive and repulsive... the price, the mileage, and the utility of it are all fantastic from what I've read. The low rev limit on it though really drops the appeal for me. I thought maybe it would be a good starter bike to get back into motorcycling after a long hiatus, but I'm not convinced it's a bike I'm not going to want to trade in in less than a year...
The two bikes that keep coming back up for me, when I consider my needs and my WANTS, are the Suzuki V-stroms... the 650 and the 1000. The bare 1000 is a reasonable price, gets good mileage, and I've yet to read so much as a bad thing about it. Because of price concerns, I was thinking about a Wee (the 650), but I live in a place where I'd be doing most of my riding on the highway, so the 1000 is more attractive to me.
Anyway, any input on any of these bikes would be appreciated. And, if there are suggestions any of you have, please let me know. I would prefer to keep my budget at or under $10K, and want something in the 'sport-touring' or 'adventure' categories.
Thanks!

-
How about a CB500X? Very comfie and frugal at 70+mpg there's quite a few aftermarket adventure parts like racks, screens ect...
Plus there just over 5k over here so should be within you budget :)
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
-
I know it is out of your style, but have you taken a look at the V-Star Bolt?
I can't comment on the adventure/sport touring class. I agree with you, the Vstrom is a great motorcycle. I haven't heard anything bad about it either.
Just a few things to keep in mind, and I know you already know this.
- Heavier motorcycles do not get tossed around as much in winds, or drafts from passing 18 wheelers.
- Sooner or later, you will want a windshield
- Sooner or later, you will want saddlebags, or something to store stuff in
The nice and hard thing, there are so many excellent models to select from. I would go to a magazine store and buy a motorcycle buyers guide which list all of the different models with a few specs, and ballpark prices. That is a great jump off tool.
-
I have a few questions:
What would you view its use as? Shopping trips? Freeway travel?
Firstly, I would stay away from BMW's I've owned several. Parts are expensive. Buy in is expensive. My F650 was a great bike but I had to do several common repairs (water pump, voltage rectifier, cooling fan) and parts were a killer. Same was true with my R1100S.
Of the bikes listed, that V Strom 650 is is extremely well liked and can be had for a very good price. Lots of luggage options, almost as fast as the 1000 version and much lighter (ie easier to throw through the twisties).
If you're looking for a shopping sled, take a look at Burgman 650. I owned one. Quick, good mpg's, tons of storage, really a 650 motorcycle in the shape of a scooter. I embarassed a lot of sport bike riders on it because the center of gravity is so low, it rails through the corners like nobody's business.
-
My neighbor just sokd his Boulevard in favor of a Burgman. It might not look as cool but it seems like a much nicer ride.
Def
Sent from a digital multitool
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
My neighbor just sokd his Boulevard in favor of a Burgman. It might not look as cool but it seems like a much nicer ride.Def
Sent from a digital multitool
I was stupid. I traded it for a Ducati 996. It was beautiful and massively fragile. I sold it to the scapper for $750. :(
That Burgman was indestructible.
-
Life is short, live it. Ducati Multistrada.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I just want to remind you that with a bike, dozens of accessories are needed you don't need for a car. Helmet, boots, gloves, jackets, pants, bags etc. Rain gear? Summer gear? Your partner likes to ride with you? She needs gear to. All that adds a considerable amount the the price of riding.
-
@microbe said:
I just want to remind you that with a bike, dozens of accessories are needed you don't need for a car. Helmet, boots, gloves, jackets, pants, bags etc. Rain gear? Summer gear? Your partner likes to ride with you? She needs gear to. All that adds a considerable amount the the price of riding.And let me further add: Tires last at best 10K miles. Motorcycle tires are as expensive as car tires, such that, at 20K miles or so, you will have purchased 4 tires. Who buys tires that frequently for their car? Chain maintenance, valve checks...
When all is said and done, bikes are minimally less expensive than cars, mostly due to initial purchase price.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
I just want to remind you that with a bike, dozens of accessories are needed you don't need for a car. Helmet, boots, gloves, jackets, pants, bags etc. Rain gear? Summer gear? Your partner likes to ride with you? She needs gear to. All that adds a considerable amount the the price of riding.
And let me further add: Tires last at best 10K miles. Motorcycle tires are as expensive as car tires, such that, at 20K miles or so, you will have purchased 4 tires. Who buys tires that frequently for their car? Chain maintenance, valve checks...
When all is said and done, bikes are minimally less expensive than cars, mostly due to initial purchase price.
Live to ride, ride to live!
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
I just want to remind you that with a bike, dozens of accessories are needed you don't need for a car. Helmet, boots, gloves, jackets, pants, bags etc. Rain gear? Summer gear? Your partner likes to ride with you? She needs gear to. All that adds a considerable amount the the price of riding.
And let me further add: Tires last at best 10K miles. Motorcycle tires are as expensive as car tires, such that, at 20K miles or so, you will have purchased 4 tires. Who buys tires that frequently for their car? Chain maintenance, valve checks...
When all is said and done, bikes are minimally less expensive than cars, mostly due to initial purchase price.
Live to ride, ride to live!
Love to ride, ride to work!
-
I love my bike. I would like to ride it more often. But can not find time for it. Usually weather here sucks big time.
Choose bike that has good powerful engine. Good driving position, and it is big enough for two persons to travel comfortably.
-
Limiting to the options you mentioned, if you want something reliable, low maintenance and that can handle almost anything you would want and be able to do buy the v strom without a doubt. The choice between the 650 and the 1000 is up to you. Remember that the 1000 has a bigger engine but its also heavier and less agile.
As a personal suggestion i would strongly suggest you to consider the kawasaky versys. More agile than the strom, same option of engines between a 650 and a 1000 and its been around and tested long enough.
Remember that looks are important but when you are riding you want your motorcycle to be good for what you are going to use it first.
Cars are for being practical and comfortable, motorcycles are for being happy

-
Hey guys, thanks for the responses... definitely some good info!
I've been doing more reading, and the V-strom is definitely the front runner for me. Admittedly, I'm not completely committed but it would be nice to have. As I mention above, I'm not sure I want to tie up a lot of money in a car that I'm not going to use all that often. That said, I've also been looking at the Triumph Tiger 800. It's got great reviews, and seems very versatile. I've also read a lot of good things about the Honda NC700X... though the low RPM limit on it gives me pause. Not like I'm going to be racing though, and the high MPG is attractive too.
Nate, good questions; I'd be using it primarily for highway riding, such as some occasional commuting and a trip here and there. I'll still be sticking with my hybrid bike for that... believe it or not, I can carry almost an entire cart full of groceries on it with panniers and my cargo trailer... I doubt I'd be able to carry that much stuff on any motorcycle other than a full bore touring machine. Your comments about BMW's are pretty much what I've been thinking... awfully expensive for what they are.
That brings me to my usage considerations; I can't honestly say I'd be using it for much more than what I state above... which gives me second thoughts about the usefulness of having a motorcycle. As I mention, most of the riding I'd be doing on it would be highway riding, which is why I'm considering something in the 800 - 1000 CC range. I'd also potentially be using it to go camping as well, but not really off-roading with it.
Anyway, thanks again for all your input everyone... it's helpful. Any other info, please just chime in! More info is always better.
-
Only chiming in quickly (as I need to get soem work done...):
Have you thought about the Kawasaki Versys 650?
It´s got the suspension travel of a dual purpose bike, but road tires, wind protection as teh V-strom and in my opinion 72 hp are more than enough for highway ridin gas long as you are no left-lane junkie.
The Honda Deauville (NTV 650) is another contender - bulletproof engine, integrated storage, fair wind protection. OK, it´s ugly as hell, but it will work reliable.In general, I think for a commuter and travelling bike, 50 hp are ok, anything above is icing on the cake.
I would go for a naked biek, personally, but that is me.Another point:
Have you thought about buying used? With a given budget, this will broaden your choice, and a first-hand used bike with low mileage is totally fine in my book (Well, this advice comes from someone whose most modern bike was a Kawasaki EX500 from `94, bought as a non runner for 400,-€...)
I think maybe FJR 1300, Honda ST 1100 are good candidates to substitute a car.I have heard good things about both teh tiger 800 and f series BMWs, although none of those strike my fancy.
-
Have you considered a Honda 500x? I seem to gather nothing but really good reviews about those. Seem to be a do it all type of bike.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login