First time Mod
-
So many questions! What's the tool life like - how many parts could you get out of it? How accurate and stable is the finished part, and what are the mechanical properties? Did you do the machining (CNC I assume) yourself?
-
Wow that is very good looking! Excellent work!
-
Hmmm...maybe your company might want to expand into the SAK mod market.

-
Wow, first welcome aboard, and second I must say that is a great design, love it! JR
-
That's an excellent intro post and very impressive first mod.

Welcome to the forum.

-
Wow, nice.
You should change the design however and use button head screws for the 84mm range (thus use almost no countersinking). The reason behind this (as already stated) is to allow the pivots to extend into the scales as much as possible. The holes in the scales define the position and correct alignment of the pivots/pins which directly affects the tension of the springs and thus the snap of the tools.
The tension between the scales is by far the hardest thing to get right. I even think it's easier to get the correct amount when peening instead of using threaded pivots with screws.
-
Beautiful mod, although I would problably have gone for the second-last sketch instead, but that's just me. Nice pictures and walkthrough and nice result. I hope you get the last small parts figured out, so you'll truly be happy with your SAK. :D
-
How did I miss this so far? :D Neat idea! Someday I want to make skeletonized Ti scales as I think that would be a sweet look.
Thats an interesting factory defect, looks like the washer meant to sit with the blade, ended up on the wrong rivet. I assume you used a washer with the blade though as that will be a problem if you didnt as the blade is thinner than the backspring.
Generally though it sounds like your issue is frame rigidity, and most of that is going to be reduced by how far the pivots extend into the scales. For good rigidity you need the pivots to go in about the whole thickness of standard cadet scales. This is why countersinking them just doesn't really work on thin scales. And its why I stopped working on that size of SAK.
The pioneer thicker alox scales I work with, the pivots extend about 1.5mm into the scale and provides a nice rigid snap.
As others have mentioned if your material flexes that will be an issue too.
To test my theory of the pivot in the scale distance issue, here is what I would do. Rebuild the SAK with long rods instead of pivots as a temporary test. If all the tools work great with rods right through the scales then that is your problem.

-
Wow that looks fantastic! I can't help you with your modding questions but I think you did an exellent job

Welcome to MTo!
-
Really nice scales and concept. Perhaps you could increase the rigidity of your CF scales adding thin metal liners (like brass, for color contrast) behind them. I believe than an additional benefit is that the cutout will stand out a lot more (sort of like a filigree design).

-
Holy smurf! that's some very impressive work :ahhh
-
Excellent work.
I personally don't like skeletonized scales as they present many problems but they do look cool.
-
-
@hiraethus said:
So many questions! What's the tool life like - how many parts could you get out of it? How accurate and stable is the finished part, and what are the mechanical properties? Did you do the machining (CNC I assume) yourself?This is quite a basic tool, so I would think I could get 100 shots out of it easily.
The finished part is VERY accurate, I did not in this case but you can take material shrinkage into account by altering the mold, the amount of shrinkage is dependant on the material being molded.
Yep, I did the CAD, CAM and CNC Machining myself. I am not a fitter and turner or dedicated machinist, I have a degree in Mechanical Engineering and work as a "Product Development Engineer" but luckily my employer trains and encourages us to do the practical work as well as design.
When bent by themselves, the scales do flex a bit more than the standard alox scales. The material itself is very stiff, the stiffest I have seen for a polymer/plastic. As an example, the Spru you can see in the last photo I posted (propping up the pair of scales) is un-breakable by hand.
-
You should change the design however and use button head screws for the 84mm range (thus use almost no countersinking). The reason behind this (as already stated) is to allow the pivots to extend into the scales as much as possible. The holes in the scales define the position and correct alignment of the pivots/pins which directly affects the tension of the springs and thus the snap of the tools.
The tension between the scales is by far the hardest thing to get right. I even think it's easier to get the correct amount when peening instead of using threaded pivots with screws.
Yeah I'm thinking this is my main issue. I like the countersunk screw heads, the head is slightly larger than the the pivots so I could easily drill out the scales to allow the pivot to extend further into them, and I think there would still be enough contact with the head to hold it all together.
Current hole geometry.

I just need to figure out a clean and accurate method to cut the pivots down. Any suggestions?! The lathes we have are all too large, and the jaws will not grip such a small object. I may try and make a jig to clamp them in the manual mill.
-
@toolguy said:
Excellent work.I personally don't like skeletonized scales as they present many problems but they do look cool.
Thanks.
Problems due to stiffness? In their current state I'm not convinced that this is the issue in my case. Also, if I make these scales slightly thicker, they will be just as stiff as the standard Alox scales. That may be something I look into down the track!
-
Thanks jerm. Loving your work.

@Jerm said:
I just need to figure out a clean and accurate method to cut the pivots down. Any suggestions?! The lathes we have are all too large, and the jaws will not grip such a small object. I may try and make a jig to clamp them in the manual mill.I use a collet chuck on the lathe we have here to hole the bar stock when making the pins - do you have one for any of your tools? Other option would be to hold the pin in the jaws of a drill press or mill and bring it down onto a file to remove the end.
-
Welcome to MTO and envious

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
