Keychain Leathermans
-
What's the general opinion of pliers-based keychain sized Leathermans? Squirt PS4, Style PS, etc. They look like they might be a good fit for me, but I've heard mixed things over the years about quality (specifically that the jaws tend to snap under medium pressure and the fold out scissors are junk).
Thoughts?
-
Leatherman's strength for me, generally lies in their larger framed tools, and I'm not a big fan of their smaller offerings. The Squirt P4 was a near hit, though let down by quality issues, and the PS4 would have been a real winner had they replaced the file with the scissors instead of the mini driver and awl. I currently have a P4, S4 and Micra (I don't consider the Mini to be a Keychain tool) which get very occasional carry to complement a SAK on light carry days. The Style PS is better in my opinion, and I have one in my pocket right now. It still however suffers a weak scissor design and mine had to be returned for warranty after the scissor spring broke after a rather short space of time.
For keychain pliers, I generally prefer the Gerber Dime and the IDL T7. The Dime offers what to me is a slightly improved package over the P4/PS4. The pliers are similar, though the backsprings are not as robust due to the location of the "saddle" pupport piece. The knife blade is ground properly (both sides) and is a very nice shape. The scissors are actually the same weak design as the Squirts and Styles, so there is the same potential for spring failure from both manufacturers. The screwdrivers are as modest on the Dime, if not slightly more so, and the "file" is a complete waste of space. The bottle opener on the Dime is WAY superior to the Squirt's, plus the Dime also offers a very nice package opener and a pair of tweezers, and overall the package of tools on the Dime beats anything offered by LM in my book. Others will disagree. I did a straight swap with Cupboard at the last UK meet. He got what I considered to be a defective P4, and I got what he considered to be a bloody awful Dime. We were both very happy to have gottent rid of a tool we despised and have it replaced with a tool which was at least twice as good. Trades don't get much better :D
The T7 has rather substantial little pliers, with 4 rather decent drivers. You'll struggle to find a Keychain sized Phillips driver as good on any other tool as the T5/T7. The only ones that spring to mind are the Swisstech pliers, which don't really have a very good plier head, and the insanely dangerous "Dead Fly" or Solstice to use it's correct title. This is scissors based and is particualrly vicious and psychotic - and is to be avoided by anyone who likes to keep their blood on the inside of their skin
However, my mainstay keyring companion is a Vic Manager. No pliers, but the lightweight package of tools has proved excellent for me, and will remain on my keys for the foreseeable future. I Usually have some other form of pliers on me anyway, even if it's a keychain sized set clipped on the lanyard attachment of a SAK
-
I love the IDL T10, a real homerun for those don't need scissors.
-
Kampfer, the T10 appears to be discoed, so you might want to keep your eyes open for nabbing a couple of spares

-
Thanks..

Now you got me wanting a T10

-
@50ft-trad said:
Kampfer, the T10 appears to be discoed, so you might want to keep your eyes open for nabbing a couple of spares

Yes sir. I tried to order some from IDL but they dont make them no more, I got lucky to obtain one from Rex
Weren't they made under a different name again? I seem to remember reading something like that a while ago.

-
The T7 and other tools like it unfortunately won't work for me as scissors are a requirement (bad wording on my part). I've heard about the Dime, but thought it was supposed to have a worse reputation than any of Leatherman's offerings. I'm heavily considering a Vic Midnite Manager because I like the tool layout and trust Vic. I really want pliers though, I'm just not sure how much I'm willing to sacrifice overall quality to get them.
-
You talk as if the Leathermans have a bad rep?
The dime is fine (though not built to the same quality as Leatherman). The Leatherman PS4 is excellent.
I've deliberately tried to abuse mine. I damaged the screwdrivers by trying to screw wood screws into a hunk of pine without any pilot holes (to see what it could do) and I've undone bolts and pulled/twisted projectiles out of some large caliber rifle rounds which took a lot of squeezing... far more than I'd expect the little tools to stand up to.
I'd recommend the PS4 to anyone.
Don't forget, the Gerber has a lifetime warranty and the Leatherman has Leatherman's 25 year no questions asked guarantee. You break it, send it in and they send you another one.
-
@RimfireNZ said:
Don't forget, the Gerber has a lifetime warranty and the Leatherman has Leatherman's 25 year no questions asked guarantee. You break it, send it in and they send you another one.Yeah, being able to replace something half a dozen times for free is nice and all, but I'd rather a tool that doesn't break in the first place. Time is money.
-
@RimfireNZ said:
Don't forget, the Gerber has a lifetime warranty and the Leatherman has Leatherman's 25 year no questions asked guarantee. You break it, send it in and they send you another one.Yeah, being able to replace something half a dozen times for free is nice and all, but I'd rather a tool that doesn't break in the first place. Time is money.
Agree, like insurance, i hope that is something I will never need to use.
-
Well I have two approaches to this question, the first is to forget the "keyring" requirement and just to pocket a Juice S2. While I do have S2 backspring concerns it is IMHO vastly more useful than a Dime (on a keyring). No experience of a PS4.
My other approach is to pair a Style PS (on a keyring) with a plierless, sometimes also scissorless, SAK in the pocket. A really flexible combination.
-
Neither of those are going to work for my use case, though. I'm specifically looking for something small that can fit in a coin pocket/purse for when I can't carry my normal full size EDC.
-
What capabilities must the tool have as an absolute minimum?
-
I'm not 100% sure yet. What I'd LIKE to have are:
- pliers capable of handling small stuff, bending paperclips, small electronics nuts, etc.
- scissors
- #2 size phillips
- #1 size phillips
- some kind of medium sized flathead screwdriver similar to the bottle opener / combo tool on a 91mm SAK, that can also function as a very light duty prybar
... but I've never seen anything in this "weight class" that has all of these in one package. I haven't fully decided yet which of these I'm willing to give up and which are hard requirements (besides scissors). I'm fine with doing some basic grinding and polishing to convert a tool I don't need into a screwdriver tip. I don't really need a blade of any form (scissors are good enough at this size), nor do I give a crap about the ubiquitous can/bottle openers (although I doubt I could find a multi that doesn't have one in some form).
The PS4 looks like I could grind down the bottle opener into a #2 phillips and sand the end of the file into the flat. Dime maybe I could do something with that bottle opener hanging off the end of the handle. Style PS loses two drivers, but maybe the lighter weight makes up for it? Midnite Manager loses the pliers and flat, but the pen/light is handy so maybe it evens out, and I know Vic's quality.
-
I'm a big fan of combos rather than relying 100% one one tool. If you are prepared to consider that, an IDL T5 or T7 combined with a Vic Classic or Vic Rambler/Manager would have you covered.
The reason I've said this is the PH2 driver. You can get flat Phillips drivers, but they are limited, wheras the T5/T7 offers a full 3D form, plus the flat driver would be better for light prying than a weedy flat driver as found on most keychain tools. The T& has additional smaller flat and Phillips drivers which pop out to the side. If they work, you'll be fine with a Vic Classic, but if you think that might restrict access being effectively Tee handled, you could stick with a T5 and upgrade to a Rambler/Manager for the smaller drivers (combo tool and driver tip on the end of the file)
-
Oh yeah, size:
The absolute extreme max size would be like a 2 layer 84mm SAK, (8.5cm long, 2cm wide, 1.5cm thick), but that's bursting-at-the-seams big for the pockets and pouches where I'm trying to cram this. Ideally I'd like something a lot smaller. I'm currently using a modified Squirt S4.I kinda don't want to deal with multiple tools if I can avoid it. I guess I don't really have a good reason for this, I just find it really inconvenient. The situations where I most need this is like where I'm wearing formal clothing or little clothing (beach) and either don't have the pockets to carry a bunch of stuff or I don't want to have to keep track of it all. (I don't keep any tools on my actual keychain, too much hassle).
And the 'flat phillips' drivers don't bother me that much. Vic's SD tip works fine as does most of the ones I've used on other keychain tools. I know at this size I'm not going to be doing any high torque stuff like wood screws in furniture. I just want something that can get the side panel off a computer or the batter door off a toy.
[edit: making three separate posts of one paragraph each is dumb]
-
.
-
.
-
I like all the little leatherman's
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login