Why no Yeoman?
-
Well see that's the thing. On paper the combo tools is great, in pratice I personally dont like it. The combo tool does not replace a dedicated opener layer. The versatility of the bottle opener / can opener are part of what makes a SAK a SAK to me. The combo tool is much thinner and much more flimsy. Its ok as a can opener, but aweful as a pry tool, bottle opener, screwdriver.
Now that being said, I would still prefer an explorer without the mag glass. If I could do the phillips across from both openers trick on a 91mm SAK that is a big winner to me.
- small blade / main blade
- scissors
- phillips / can opener / bottle opener
The closest stock model to ideal to me is a super tinker. That is 3 layers of awesome tool right there. Or deluxe tinker if you are ok with 4 layers.
I started to write a response, then Syph said everything I was about to, even mentioning his Alox mod of the phillips across from the openers (which I need to get one of these days :) ) My usual carry is a Super Tinker, occasionally an Explorer if I can deal with carrying an extra layer.
I do still miss the Yeoman though (traded it away), even if only for light duty use. Might have to make up another one someday.
what kind of bottles are you guys trying to open with the combo tool??
I agree that it doesn't stand up to prybar-like use. I haven't tried opening a can with it, but I'm guessing it won't do too well. But I've been carrying a Yeoman around the house lately (thanks eddie!), and the combo tool opens my evening beverages without any problems at all... -

Love my yeoman.
Prettiest sak I've ever seen...

Thank you. Probably my most expensive build to date.
Combo tool as can opener works very well. I use one almost 3 times a week for canned tuna and it works exactly as it should. The yeoman is without a doubt the best tool layout for urban environment.
-
Gotta have Alox. Gotta have a symmetric 3 layers so I can have a pocket clip. Gotta have pliers! 3 layers and pliers means I can't have both openers. I have a Stanley pocket screwdriver at home, in my car, at work, and in my bag to cover extra Phillips and flathead needs.
A custom Alox SAK would be my pocket knife + extra. Not my entire toolbox. I love the small Vic pliers. They're like a small pair of metal fingers in my pocket. I think people over look the pliers because they have to in order to get the other tools on their SAK and still have it be comfortable in the pocket. I have to have the slimness of Alox and screwed on pocket clip. The plastic scales + suspension clip is too long and thick.
Combo tool does a little bit of scraping/poking/awl-ing, a little bit of Phillips, a little bit of flat heads, a little bit of prying, and bottles & cans. For me, it's not combo vs seperate openers, it's combo vs awl. I still choose combo though.
Clip >
Scissors >
Combo tool > < Blade
Pliers >So my point is I like Pliers over 3D Philips & mag glass.
Or you can just SAK up and carry a Spirit X :P -
Well see that's the thing. On paper the combo tools is great, in pratice I personally dont like it. The combo tool does not replace a dedicated opener layer. The versatility of the bottle opener / can opener are part of what makes a SAK a SAK to me. The combo tool is much thinner and much more flimsy. Its ok as a can opener, but aweful as a pry tool, bottle opener, screwdriver.
Now that being said, I would still prefer an explorer without the mag glass. If I could do the phillips across from both openers trick on a 91mm SAK that is a big winner to me.
- small blade / main blade
- scissors
- phillips / can opener / bottle opener
The closest stock model to ideal to me is a super tinker. That is 3 layers of awesome tool right there. Or deluxe tinker if you are ok with 4 layers.
I started to write a response, then Syph said everything I was about to, even mentioning his Alox mod of the phillips across from the openers (which I need to get one of these days :) ) My usual carry is a Super Tinker, occasionally an Explorer if I can deal with carrying an extra layer.
I do still miss the Yeoman though (traded it away), even if only for light duty use. Might have to make up another one someday.
what kind of bottles are you guys trying to open with the combo tool??
I agree that it doesn't stand up to prybar-like use. I haven't tried opening a can with it, but I'm guessing it won't do too well. But I've been carrying a Yeoman around the house lately (thanks eddie!), and the combo tool opens my evening beverages without any problems at all...Glad it's getting put to work :D As a cap lifter, the combo tool is fine. As a screwdriver, I had some concern about using too much torque (especially at the 90-degree position). As a prying tool, that's where it bent. I realize it's not sold as a pry tool or anything, but I've often used the standard cap lifter as a pry tool and it does fine. So that's my internal debate, give up a little sturdiness or give up the slim 3 layers...
-
@mrog said:
Gotta have Alox. Gotta have a symmetric 3 layers so I can have a pocket clip. Gotta have pliers! 3 layers and pliers means I can't have both openers. I have a Stanley pocket screwdriver at home, in my car, at work, and in my bag to cover extra Phillips and flathead needs.A custom Alox SAK would be my pocket knife + extra. Not my entire toolbox. I love the small Vic pliers. They're like a small pair of metal fingers in my pocket. I think people over look the pliers because they have to in order to get the other tools on their SAK and still have it be comfortable in the pocket. I have to have the slimness of Alox and screwed on pocket clip. The plastic scales + suspension clip is too long and thick.
Combo tool does a little bit of scraping/poking/awl-ing, a little bit of Phillips, a little bit of flat heads, a little bit of prying, and bottles & cans. For me, it's not combo vs seperate openers, it's combo vs awl. I still choose combo though.
Clip >
Scissors >
Combo tool > < Blade
Pliers >So my point is I like Pliers over 3D Philips & mag glass.
Or you can just SAK up and carry a Spirit X :PI've done combo/blade/pliers/scissors a couple times on alox. It is a nice slim package if you need pliers.



-
@rickinFL said:
Love my yeoman. Combo tool as can opener works very well.
As mrog already said:
@mrog said:
Combo tool does a little bit of scraping/poking/awl-ing, a little bit of Phillips, a little bit of flat heads, a little bit of prying, and bottles ...but indeed is a great can opener

So, of course, as a screwdriver/prybar the combo tool can't compete with "openers" (in prying, scraping, orange peeling >:D, large SD, small SD ...), but that is the "no-openers tax" one have to deal with :D
-
I definitely prefer the Explorer to the Yeoman. The separate openers/drivers are much more useful and effective than the combo tool (and you get the awl), and the small blade on a SAK is my most used tool. I've built two Yeomen (sold one, the other's in the toy box) but keep breaking Explorers for the phillips driver for other knives. Traded the last one for a Cybertool. :) I really ought to get another for keeps. If I had to go for three layers instead of four, I'd go for the Super Tinker instead.
-
@jerseydevil said:
Honestly I prefer the Explorer. Why? One of the most important uses my SAKs have is light prying and opening paint cans using the flat driver/bottle opener. The combo tool isn't thick enough for this. I've tried it several times with different knives including a Yeoman, and I've stopped because each time I was afraid I was going to break the Combo tool! :ahhh I have no problem pocket carrying a larger SAK, my Swisschamp sees plenty of pocket time, attached to a belt hanger to keep it vertical. Never had an issue.I'd for the explorer too!
-
The Rand edition Yeomen is my fav......

That aside, I was always a fan of the Explorer! It seemed to have everything that was needed in a compact pkg!

-
You guys make good points about the benefits of the Explorer (I prefer Plus whenever possible). It has always been my favorite of the production models.

Explorer Plus. I probably own 6 of them. -
I'd also probably pick the Explorer over the Yeoman. But the Yeoman-Mechanic is a handy bit of gear. I built one and it's been along for the ride a few times.
But it's not so great that it's on the "Never pull apart" list. -
@jazzbass said:
So you end up with great knives like the Scientist and Yeoman sitting on shelves, unsold. Sad really. But if there was a big market for these knives, they'd make them. You don't stay in business for 125+ years by not knowing your market.Would be GOLDEN to find those old stores with unsold Scientists and Yeomans brand new in box on their shelves. I'll buy them all. hahaha

-
If I could do the phillips across from both openers trick on a 91mm SAK that is a big winner to me.
- small blade / main blade
- scissors
- phillips / can opener / bottle opener
I was just looking at pics of your alox one.
How much of a mission is it to do on a 91mm?
I'm thinking of...- awl / electricians blade
- scissors
- phillips / bottle opener / can opener
Thoughts?
I tried to do it o a 91 and its really not possible. 91s are not symmetrical so the springs cant be flipped around. Symmetry is part of what makes the 93 a perfect platform.
Thanks. I wish we could hang out together. I have so many questions.
-
I love the combo tool and the phillips, wish I could have that combo on my Farmer. The can opener works pretty well, but I would love to have a dedicated phillips driver. I can do without scissors.
-
After reading how a lot of you would go with the Explorer I would like to explain my thinking.
Like the Explorer. What I am going for with this build is more of a minimal situation. No back tools will be the big difference.
Combo opener, Blade, Inline Phillips, Mag Glass and Scissors.

The thing I am undecided on is Cellidor or Alox. Would love the T&T but also love the whole Alox situation.
-
-

This guy. Tells me hit him up AFTER the holidays and I will make you a sweet Alox. Then he posts up a picture of one of my grails.

-
Despite actually quite liking the combo tool, I never did quite get along with the Yeoman I made for myself. Couldn't say why either, as it really appealed to my on paper.

On the other hand I really do like my Explorer. Nothing rational about this I suspect.

-
@Gareth said:
Despite actually quite liking the combo tool, I never did quite get along with the Yeoman I made for myself. Couldn't say why either, as it really appealed to my on paper.
On the other hand I really do like my Explorer. Nothing rational about this I suspect.

So you say you made yourself a Yeoman that you don't like?
Seems like maybe the thing to do is sell it cheap to some deserving person. Just saying.

-
This guy. Tells me hit me up AFTER the holidays and I will make you a sweet Alox. Then he posts up a picture of one of my grails.

Those customs are very tempting aren't they? >:D They're addicting too, but your wallet will hate you for that ;)
As for this whole combo tool vs opener layer debate
I've gone back and forth on it multiple times. My first cellidor custom (Yeochamp) was based off of the Yeoman, which at the time, was my most desired SAK. I hadn't considered the potential versatility of the dedicated opener layer much. Over time, I came to think I'd rather have the opener layer, and when I had the chance, had my Rogueneer made up. I also really wanted a small secondary blade (electrician's blade) since I use that one more, so that was part of it too.However, while carrying only the Compact during the Minimalist challenge last month, I found that the combo tool was sufficient, and that I rarely use the opener layer for anything other than the occasional bottle opener or scraping with the can opener edge. I also should mention that the combo tool was one of the best bottle openers I've used on a SAK or MT. I only tried it as a can opener once a long while back, and it did work, but not quite as efficiently as a dedicated opener. I don't have to open a lot of cans though normally, and even if I did, it's likely to be in the kitchen where I have an actual can opener.
With the whole driver issue, the opener layer obviously has the edge. This depends on how often you need to use your SAK for drivers though, which in my case isn't often. If you have an MT you're also carrying, then that would likely cover most driver needs anyway. Since both the Yeoman and Explorer have the inline phillips, that removes one of the uses for the can opener tip, so if you have little use for the can opener at all other than as a phillips driver, it may seem redundant to have that layer.
This also goes with the prying issue. The combo tool is fine for light prying in my experience, but the bottle opener is better if you would be using it for this purpose regularly.
Overall, the combo tool does a fair amount and can be somewhat versatile itself, as long as you use it within its design limitations. I've found it's mostly sufficient for my typical needs, but that's me. Still, the potential uses and versatility of the opener layer wins out just a bit over the combo tool for me.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


