Why no Yeoman?
-
I love the combo tool and the phillips, wish I could have that combo on my Farmer. The can opener works pretty well, but I would love to have a dedicated phillips driver. I can do without scissors.
-
After reading how a lot of you would go with the Explorer I would like to explain my thinking.
Like the Explorer. What I am going for with this build is more of a minimal situation. No back tools will be the big difference.
Combo opener, Blade, Inline Phillips, Mag Glass and Scissors.

The thing I am undecided on is Cellidor or Alox. Would love the T&T but also love the whole Alox situation.
-
-

This guy. Tells me hit him up AFTER the holidays and I will make you a sweet Alox. Then he posts up a picture of one of my grails.

-
Despite actually quite liking the combo tool, I never did quite get along with the Yeoman I made for myself. Couldn't say why either, as it really appealed to my on paper.

On the other hand I really do like my Explorer. Nothing rational about this I suspect.

-
@Gareth said:
Despite actually quite liking the combo tool, I never did quite get along with the Yeoman I made for myself. Couldn't say why either, as it really appealed to my on paper.
On the other hand I really do like my Explorer. Nothing rational about this I suspect.

So you say you made yourself a Yeoman that you don't like?
Seems like maybe the thing to do is sell it cheap to some deserving person. Just saying.

-
This guy. Tells me hit me up AFTER the holidays and I will make you a sweet Alox. Then he posts up a picture of one of my grails.

Those customs are very tempting aren't they? >:D They're addicting too, but your wallet will hate you for that ;)
As for this whole combo tool vs opener layer debate
I've gone back and forth on it multiple times. My first cellidor custom (Yeochamp) was based off of the Yeoman, which at the time, was my most desired SAK. I hadn't considered the potential versatility of the dedicated opener layer much. Over time, I came to think I'd rather have the opener layer, and when I had the chance, had my Rogueneer made up. I also really wanted a small secondary blade (electrician's blade) since I use that one more, so that was part of it too.However, while carrying only the Compact during the Minimalist challenge last month, I found that the combo tool was sufficient, and that I rarely use the opener layer for anything other than the occasional bottle opener or scraping with the can opener edge. I also should mention that the combo tool was one of the best bottle openers I've used on a SAK or MT. I only tried it as a can opener once a long while back, and it did work, but not quite as efficiently as a dedicated opener. I don't have to open a lot of cans though normally, and even if I did, it's likely to be in the kitchen where I have an actual can opener.
With the whole driver issue, the opener layer obviously has the edge. This depends on how often you need to use your SAK for drivers though, which in my case isn't often. If you have an MT you're also carrying, then that would likely cover most driver needs anyway. Since both the Yeoman and Explorer have the inline phillips, that removes one of the uses for the can opener tip, so if you have little use for the can opener at all other than as a phillips driver, it may seem redundant to have that layer.
This also goes with the prying issue. The combo tool is fine for light prying in my experience, but the bottle opener is better if you would be using it for this purpose regularly.
Overall, the combo tool does a fair amount and can be somewhat versatile itself, as long as you use it within its design limitations. I've found it's mostly sufficient for my typical needs, but that's me. Still, the potential uses and versatility of the opener layer wins out just a bit over the combo tool for me.
-
Despite actually quite liking the combo tool, I never did quite get along with the Yeoman I made for myself. Couldn't say why either, as it really appealed to my on paper.

On the other hand I really do like my Explorer. Nothing rational about this I suspect.

So you say you made yourself a Yeoman that you don't like?
Seems like maybe the thing to do is sell it cheap to some deserving person. Just saying.

Sorry buddy, IIRC it got re-made as a Scientist or something.

-
I like the idea of a second or for me backup blade. I have one on my GEC #78 but find that other then using it just cause I can there is not much need for it.
Monrogue what do you use the small secondary blade for so much? Opposed to just using your main blade for whatever task it is?
Despite actually quite liking the combo tool, I never did quite get along with the Yeoman I made for myself. Couldn't say why either, as it really appealed to my on paper.

On the other hand I really do like my Explorer. Nothing rational about this I suspect.

So you say you made yourself a Yeoman that you don't like?
Seems like maybe the thing to do is sell it cheap to some deserving person. Just saying.

Sorry buddy, IIRC it got re-made as a Scientist or something.

No worries mate. Just have to put Syph to work.
-
They were probably getting too many lawsuits from chaps who had busted their knuckles when the terrible nasty combo tool closed up when they were trying to actuate a screw.
-
You give it much thought. I know, it's the MTO, that's what we do here. But a Swisschamp is still 91 and just a little fatter and still lightweight and it fits a fist perfectly. It isn't much expensive either.
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
Monrogue what do you use the small secondary blade for so much? Opposed to just using your main blade for whatever task it is?I use it for pretty much everything I need a knife for normally. That is usually cutting open packages, the tape sealing boxes closed, cutting the plastic sleeve type thing that houses packing slips on boxes...stuff like that. There's not much else I use a knife for really
The occasional food prep use, or anything larger that would require the main blade doesn't come up often, but I like having a nice, clean main blade for potential food needs, etc. This was one of my only gripes with the Compact last month-having to cut a bunch of tape to open boxes and getting the blade covered with adhesive gunk.If you had the awl that comes on the Pioneer (or Farmer) on your alox custom, that handles all of those above needs I mentioned just fine. It makes a great utility blade on its own really. However, to have that, you'd have to ditch the combo opener tool I believe, and have the dedicated opener layer. This only applies to the alox though. If you're still debating cellidor vs. alox, then that's another whole issue in itself ;) I believe that came up in another thread recently, where I and several others discussed this, yourself included I think

-
@kkokkolis said:
You give it much thought. I know, it's the MTO, that's what we do here. But a Swisschamp is still 91 and just a little fatter and still lightweight and it fits a fist perfectly. It isn't much expensive either.Dang enablers. Found a SC for just over $50 today and I am not doing well resisting it.
Monrogue what do you use the small secondary blade for so much? Opposed to just using your main blade for whatever task it is?
I use it for pretty much everything I need a knife for normally. That is usually cutting open packages, the tape sealing boxes closed, cutting the plastic sleeve type thing that houses packing slips on boxes...stuff like that. There's not much else I use a knife for really
The occasional food prep use, or anything larger that would require the main blade doesn't come up often, but I like having a nice, clean main blade for potential food needs, etc. This was one of my only gripes with the Compact last month-having to cut a bunch of tape to open boxes and getting the blade covered with adhesive gunk.If you had the awl that comes on the Pioneer (or Farmer) on your alox custom, that handles all of those above needs I mentioned just fine. It makes a great utility blade on its own really. However, to have that, you'd have to ditch the combo opener tool I believe, and have the dedicated opener layer. This only applies to the alox though. If you're still debating cellidor vs. alox, then that's another whole issue in itself ;) I believe that came up in another thread recently, where I and several others discussed this, yourself included I think

Didn't think about using the #2 blade for dirty jobs. Which is strange since I carry two Spydercos and one of them is pretty much dedicated to that while my Millie is the one I eat with.
-
I was once told that everyone should have a SC
i cant live without mine now 

-
Yeah, I should get one, one of these days.
-
One of these days he says.
I been doing some looking at can not seem to find a CT Lite for less then $100 but can't swing a dead cat without hitting a sub $60 SC.
Seems strange to me.
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
One of these days he says.I been doing some looking at can not seem to find a CT Lite for less then $100 but can't swing a dead cat without hitting a sub $60 SC.
Seems strange to me.
CT Lite being sold right here on the forums for $60. Better be quick though ;)
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
One of these days he says.I been doing some looking at can not seem to find a CT Lite for less then $100 but can't swing a dead cat without hitting a sub $60 SC.
Seems strange to me.
I really like my CT41. I did kinda owned a SC. It was a Super Timer. Which is a SC but has a watch in the scale.
-
One of these days he says.
I been doing some looking at can not seem to find a CT Lite for less then $100 but can't swing a dead cat without hitting a sub $60 SC.
Seems strange to me.
CT Lite being sold right here on the forums for $60. Better be quick though ;)
Thanks for finding this for me.
no funds atm though so will have to pass on it.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


