Natural ability over technology?
-
Not a proud moment in Canadian military history...what happened to those snipers.
-
@Chako said:
Not a proud moment in Canadian military history...what happened to those snipers.I remember reading that at the time and hearing the rumors. disgusting
-
Believe the Germans rated the heavy-barreled Norwegian Krag with metallic sights effective to 600 meters. All other metallic sighted rifles were considered effective to 400 meters.
The US military did some sniper work in WWII, but was more likely to throw a couple of 105mm rounds at a distant target on the grounds that if you saw one enemy soldier, there was probably a group of them.
The Springfields weren't really intended for that sort of use anyway, were they?
The '03A4 was the dedicated sniper version of the Springfield. It was a version of the M1903A3, which itself was a cheapened for mass production version of the '03, and produced by Remington and Smith-Corona. The '03 was a very accurate rifle in its own right. The Marines who landed on Guadalcanal carried '03's, not Garands BTW. There were sniper variants of the M1 as well, and they saw service right into Vietnam. Not as accurate as a bolt action weapon perhaps, but they did the job.
@Lynn -
on mentioning Billy Dixon. He's best known for that shot, but he's also one of only eight civilians to be awarded the Medal of Honor.According to Roy Dunlop (Ordnance Went Up Front) the Springfield was fitted with a Weaver scope that did not hold up in the tropics. The sniper version of the Garand used a Lyman Alaskan scope which did much better. Dunlop was a civilian gunsmith turned Ordnance tech sergeant, who worked on both Allied and foreign small arms in WWII.
-
An interesting book is McBride's "A Rifleman Went to War". He was a Canadian sniper in WWI; for him it was basically big game hunting of the highest order.
-
@ColoSwiss said:
An interesting book is McBride's "A Rifleman Went to War". He was a Canadian sniper in WWI; for him it was basically big game hunting of the highest order.I've read that, very interesting book. The Commonwealth nations did treat sniping much more seriously than the US did, especially in World War I. Another famous Commonwealth sniper is the Australian Billy Sing, known for his performance at Gallipoli.
In terms of natural ability as a soldier, there are plenty of times where initial appearances are very deceiving.
<a href="http://s1102.photobucket.com/user/Jerseydevil379/media/Audie_Murphy_zpsb872505d.jpg.html" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://i1102.photobucket.com/albums/g448/Jerseydevil379/Audie_Murphy_zpsb872505d.jpg" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
-
Heskith-Pritchards book is a must read where WW1 sniping is concerned. It gives a really great overview of sniping from the person most responsible for its development by the British and allied forces :)
Sent from the astropathic choir.
-
My last training/assignment was being that what we called a "group sniper". Each company has 3 platoons and each platoon has 3 groups. Each group has (additional to the regular riflemens) a 2 man MG team, a anti tank guy (with one of the riflemans helping him carrying additional ammo), and the sniper.
I believe group snipers were called "dedicated marksmen" in the US. We didn´t had those fancy big guns and the additional spotter, our guns were modified G3s (higher selected, and exchanged the practical airborne collapsible to a regular fixed shoulderstock, and a small Hensoldt-scope), that way we kept the ammo and the rifle-parts interchangeable with our comrades when the shtf. So my base of knowledge is not the same as the cool snipers seen in so many movies.

Long speech, short meaning - Lynn was right. Same as with a hunter - the higher the amount of huntable ducks within your target range, the higher your count.
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
Heskith-Pritchards book is a must read where WW1 sniping is concerned. It gives a really great overview of sniping from the person most responsible for its development by the British and allied forces :)Sent from the astropathic choir.
Do you have a title? The author's name is not showing up on Amazon.
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
Heskith-Pritchards book is a must read where WW1 sniping is concerned. It gives a really great overview of sniping from the person most responsible for its development by the British and allied forces :)
Sent from the astropathic choir.
Do you have a title? The author's name is not showing up on Amazon.
-
Yep, Sniping in France :)
Sent from the astropathic choir.
-
Just got that and A Rifleman went to War on Kindle for less that £4!!!
Sent from the astropathic choir.
-
@Mike, Lord of the Spammers! said:
Heskith-Pritchards book is a must read where WW1 sniping is concerned. It gives a really great overview of sniping from the person most responsible for its development by the British and allied forces :)
Sent from the astropathic choir.
Do you have a title? The author's name is not showing up on Amazon.
Thanks. :salute:
-
@Lichtbote said:
I believe group snipers were called "dedicated marksmen" in the US.I qualified Marksman in Basic Training in the Air Force... And that was the last time I touched a weapon in my job in the military. My score was actually good enough that I would have qualified Sharpshooter, but the Air Force doesn't recognize that level, and you can't qualify Expert without additional training beyond Basic Training. At least, that was my understanding.
I tell this joke that weapon training in the Air Force is like this: An instructor holds up an M-16 and says 'See this? It's an M-16. If you find one, pick it up... and give it to a Marine. They'll know what to do with it."

My best 'real world' shot was a groundhog (about 35lbs, very low to the ground, and facing directly toward me) at 200 yards with an AR-15 using iron sights, from prone. I took the shot, didn't see the thing move, and didn't see a 'splash' of dirt. We walked across this unused corn field, to get to it, and it didn't move as we approached. When we got there, it turned out I'd hit it in the mouth, straight through the whole body. I lived in an area where farmers had considerable crop damage from groundhog, and they were often more than happy to let us shoot on their land, as long as we helped with the groundhogs. That was before I joined the military. Shooting was a pass-time in my home area (rural Ohio), and it's why I scored so well in Basic. I had a lot of practice.
I guess maybe my second best shot was shooting a .22 casing at 20 yards with a Ruger 10/22, iron sights, prone, on my second shot.
So, I consider myself a good shot with rifle. NOT a mile-and-a-half good. LOL I figure, with a scope, I could probably start getting out to 800 yards. With a Spotter, MAYBE a little more, but I don't think I'd be able to do it consistently. Now I wanna go try some extreme range shooting.
-
There was also sniping in the US Civil War. Sedgewick was killed by a Confederate sniper at the Battle of Spotsylvania Court House.


-
Nice joke about the Air Force training on the M-16, Lynn!

-
This "Group sniper = dedicated Marksman" is nothing i know for sure, i just found it on the net somewhere when searching for differencies between what i´ve learned and what we see in todays movies. So i can´t really compare what´s needed to qualify, and if there any differencies in training/work between a GS and an DM.
Qualifying in shooting was needed first, but we also had to get the required skills in finding the best place for securing our group and the free fireline to the enemy, without being to obvisiously. Building a shooters nest (camouflaged position with free firing range and still hiding the muzzle flash). And (something i never understood) additional training in orientation and marching with hand drawn maps and compass - when starting the sniper education we all already were trained paratroopers, so we all were able to do that. But you don´t argue with the training sarge, that gives no good.
-
@ColoSwiss said:
There was also sniping in the US Civil War. Sedgewick was killed by a Confederate sniper at the Battle of Spotsylvania Court House.I was going to mention John Sedgwick. On May 9, 1864, at the Battle of Spotsylvania Court House, Major General Sedgwick commanded the Union VI Corps, on the right flank. His units were probing Confederate skirmish lines to their front, and Sedgwick was directing the positioning of his Corps artillery, right on his front line. The rebel lines were about a thousand yards from his position, and there was some sniper fire from enemy soldiers armed with the .45 caliber Whitworth rifle. Seeing members of his staff flinching under the long-range fire, "Uncle John" laughed and said, "What! Men dodging this way from single bullets? What will you do when they open fire along the line? I am ashamed of you. They couldn't hit an elephant at this distance!" He had barely finished the sentence when a Whitworth bullet hit him under the left eye. John Sedgwick was the highest-ranking Union officer to be killed in action during the Civil War.
-
I thought the reason he didn't use optics was because they weren't reliable enough and fogs up all the time.
I'm a crappy marksman but scopes made me a little less crappy. Maybe it doesn't matter if you are top of the top, but technology will make 95% of the people better.
-
I had wondered that as I know it was a big problem in the first world war, and maybe they still hasn't figured out a way of sealing them in such horrendous conditions yet?
Sent from the astropathic choir.
-
Not sure if it's the same guy, but I remember reading about one of the Scandinavian sniper saying he prefer iron sight over scope because it's more reliable in the field.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login