How long could you survive?
-
I like the topic a lot but am suprised by the answers you guy are giving.
People survive with out ANY food for over a month. It is pretty low on your survival radar, water is the issue.
There is water in your toilet and water heater that needs to be saved for drinking not for umm well toilet use. Pick a room or basement corner and that becomes your new toilet, Better yet cut a hole in the floor for said activities.
I love animals. Dogs, cats. birds they all taste great. Survival situation, instead of wondering how I will keep them fed I wonder what they will taste like with some farva beans and a nice chianti.
Don't get me wrong I have lots of bottled water and MRE's in my house along with a rotating supply of the things my young daughter likes to eat. She is picky and in a short term situation would like to see her have the stuff she normally likes.
I am just saying don't underestimate how long you could last and the things you need to do in order to make that happen.
Now I am hungry all of a sudden, strange.
-
I forgot something.
If you are prepared with enough blankets and cold weather clothing electricity while nice is not needed at all.
Does not matter how cold it gets if you have a house for shelter and a piles of blankets you will be fine. Very unhappy but alive.
Now I would like to add maybe where Joel lives (Artic circle?) some way to start a fire would make things more comfortable but still is not mandatory.
-
@HarleyXJGuy said:
I like the topic a lot but am suprised by the answers you guy are giving.People survive with out ANY food for over a month. It is pretty low on your survival radar,** water is the issue.**
There is water in your toilet and water heater that needs to be saved for drinking not for umm well toilet use. Pick a room or basement corner and that becomes your new toilet, Better yet cut a hole in the floor for said activities.I love animals. Dogs, cats. birds they all taste great. Survival situation, instead of wondering how I will keep them fed I wonder what they will taste like with some farva beans and a nice chianti.
Don't get me wrong I have lots of bottled water and MRE's in my house along with a rotating supply of the things my young daughter likes to eat. She is picky and in a short term situation would like to see her have the stuff she normally likes.
I am just saying don't underestimate how long you could last and the things you need to do in order to make that happen.
Now I am hungry all of a sudden, strange.
Agreed. We have our own water well, pond water and a river not to far away. I have Lifesraw, Sawyer, Katadyn and Pur water filters. Cholor-Floc, Potable Aqua, Aeroobic Stabilized Oxygen besides boiling for purification.
@HarleyXJGuy said:
I forgot something.If you are prepared with enough blankets and cold weather clothing electricity while nice is not needed at all.
Does not matter how cold it gets if you have a house for shelter and a piles of blankets you will be fine. Very unhappy but alive.
Now I would like to add maybe where Joel lives (Artic circle?) some way to start a fire would make things more comfortable but still is not mandatory.Good point!
Remember the rule of 3's. You can survive for:
3 minutes without air
3 hours without shelter
3 days without water
3 weeks without food -
We have gravity fed water here, and a river about 1km away, but if I had to stay on my property, and water cut off...
Water would be an issue. I guess i could collect water from the drainage manhole (dont know the english word, a concrete drainage cistern) in my driveway, it would need filtering and boiling, but would work. I can connect my canoe and kayak to the drains on the roof and collect rain water in them.
I would close of all rooms but the livingroom and kitchen and use the wood stove to cook and keep us warm. We have plenty of clothes and blankets.
We have some canned and dried foods that would last a couple of weeks of normal eating, that could be stretched quite a bit. Deer regularly pass over my garden, and so do birds. If I could get a deer and a bird now and then, ( i need to stack up on ammo) we would have food longer.
Id say 2months, probably longer as long as we dont get sick.
If we could leave the property, then we could make it a lot longer. The neighbour property is a farm with a large grain storage.Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
-
Deer and other wild animals are excellent to supplement your diet in a situation like this.
Do not count on them though. If everything goes to smurf everyone and there aunt will be killing and eating anything with four legs.
Forgot to post the 3's rule. Guess I am getting old.
-
@Aloha007 said:
So I have been giving this a lot of thought lately. I live in California and many of you know this an earthquake prone area of the country. There are also wild fires and mud slide in some areas.With all the potential natural and un natural occurrences that can happen in your city, town how long could you survive starting NOW.
All the services are no long working from electricity, gas, water, or what ever runs your home. You only have what's in your pantry and fridge and whatever means to cook it besides those listed.
If you have a generator then fine. Solar system with battery stored power great. You have a propane tank, charcoal briquets, wood, coleman stove, fine.
You wont have the ability to leave your property under any circumstances. You property is not damaged so you have shelter but only the provisions you currently have on hand RIGHT NOW.
you cannot leave, you have what you have.
I could last about 2 weeks and possibly 4 by rationing out what I do have. Flushing toilets would prove most difficult so the restroom visits would be very interesting to say the least.
Listen MTo I was trying to make anyone who was interested look more closely at their current situation. I was trying to stir some ideas or jump start the ones you already have about what you want to do or have planned on doing.
I thought it was interesting that Lynn made a thread about prepping and insanity and I believe there is a line, grey but there one. I dont feel I'll plan for every scenario but I am better off than some.
I have water as my main "concern" as Harley is right. Access to water is going to be vital. I plan to have a 55 gal drum ( or 2 ) soon so I'll have water that I can hand pump in addition to the cases I have.
Now keep in mind the water needed to cook with and also clean with ( body ).
The key word I chose was SURVIVE not make it or last. I know most want to be comfortable but it might come down to a lot of discomfort. I was wanting to have you look at your situation and evaluate where you were NOW, not next week or month.
-
So I have been giving this a lot of thought lately. I live in California and many of you know this an earthquake prone area of the country. There are also wild fires and mud slide in some areas.
With all the potential natural and un natural occurrences that can happen in your city, town how long could you survive starting NOW.
All the services are no long working from electricity, gas, water, or what ever runs your home. You only have what's in your pantry and fridge and whatever means to cook it besides those listed.
If you have a generator then fine. Solar system with battery stored power great. You have a propane tank, charcoal briquets, wood, coleman stove, fine.
You wont have the ability to leave your property under any circumstances. You property is not damaged so you have shelter but only the provisions you currently have on hand RIGHT NOW.
you cannot leave, you have what you have.
I could last about 2 weeks and possibly 4 by rationing out what I do have. Flushing toilets would prove most difficult so the restroom visits would be very interesting to say the least.
Listen MTo I was trying to make anyone who was interested look more closely at their current situation. I was trying to stir some ideas or jump start the ones you already have about what you want to do or have planned on doing.
I thought it was interesting that Lynn made a thread about prepping and insanity and I believe there is a line, grey but there one. I dont feel I'll plan for every scenario but I am better off than some.
I have water as my main "concern" as Harley is right. Access to water is going to be vital. I plan to have a 55 gal drum ( or 2 ) soon so I'll have water that I can hand pump in addition to the cases I have.
Now keep in mind the water needed to cook with and also clean with ( body ).
The key word I chose was SURVIVE not make it or last. I know most want to be comfortable but it might come down to a lot of discomfort. I was wanting to have you look at your situation and evaluate where you were NOW, not next week or month.
Water to wash myself with is water I am not drinking. I will pass.
-
When a disaster goes into the 3rd week or 6th week how are we all fairing? Medications, addictions, tempers, monotony, and so on. If we are able to leave our homes then like in my city and I'm sure most the supplies are so limited if there are any.
I remember Y2K
, people in costco buying so much stuff. Heck when the wild fires hit the water at the local markets was nearly all gone. Face masks were all gone from every store. When Northridge Earthquake hit people got worried about after shocks and started to buy out stores of their supplies. I mention not leaving your property because there may not be any thing on shelves anyway.Even if you could leave your property then what? For those who live in areas where there are farms, lakes, hunting grounds, then what? It cannot be that easy to procure a meal that easily IMO. I dont hunt so I dont know.
My goal is 90 days of self reliance.
-
Harley, short term I agree. Realistically I'm not talking about gallons of water. 16oz would suffice.
-
3 minutes without air
3 hours without shelter
3 days without water
3 weeks without foodThat's a generalization of course. Some people can live for 5 minutes without air and 6 or more days without water.
Our fridge is usually full but we are fast eaters, so we should rationize what we have and it would give us about a month. If it is allowed to eat the neighbors, then we could do it ad infinitum. Water is a problem here, we don't get much rainfall. Shelter is not a problem for 9 months out of 12, the weather is great. People survive outside in the winter, except the worse ones we get every now and then, but the last three winters are mellow, many people don't even use heating and that's good because the financial crisis and the rise in petroleum price was a deadly combination (somebody still loves that small country that refuses to die for 4 millenia).
What about sex? I get pretty nervous after 3 days without it and don't confront me after 7 days. I guess that we'll have that because my wife will be in the house, so I won't care about much else and we always wanted to die together because leaving the other behind would be like hell. Then we'll go as long as possible and die happy. -
@HarleyXJGuy said:
People survive with out ANY food for over a month. It is pretty low on your survival radar, water is the issue.You can SURVIVE. You can't get much DONE. I assume if I'm trapped on my property, there's something i need to be doing to remedy this, and manual labor is calorie intensive. I'm always shocked when i hear people doing prep supplies and not planning for food, even for a 72-hour bag. Have they never tried hiking? You 'hit the wall' prety qucik with no calorie intake.
@HarleyXJGuy said:
There is water in your toilet and water heater that needs to be saved for drinking not for umm well toilet use.All those sources are taken into consideration for my numbers.
@HarleyXJGuy said:
I love animals. Dogs, cats. birds they all taste great. Survival situation, instead of wondering how I will keep them fed I wonder what they will taste like with some farva beans and a nice chianti.We keep a stockpile of food for our cat, and she consumes minimal water. I'm not eating my cat. Ever. I'd rather turn her loose and hope for the best, slim as the odds might be.
Now, eating someone else's dog... sorry... if it comes to it...

EDIT: oh, one last thing, if you have water available, but just need to make it potable, don't forget plain chlorine bleech. Most folks have it around for laundry anyway. I also have other methods of water purification, but this is maybe one of the easiest. Sure it doesn't deal with heavy metals, and some chemical issues, but it'll kill bacteria, which is the big short-term health concern.
-
I also would not be eating my dog either in reality. Great point Lynn about having food for the pets. I also factor in my little guy ( 3lb dog ) for food and water. I wonder about the fish people? Those aquariums needs constant pumps right?
-
@Aloha007 said:
When a disaster goes into the 3rd week or 6th week how are we all fairing? Medications, addictions, tempers, monotony, and so on. If we are able to leave our homes then like in my city and I'm sure most the supplies are so limited if there are any.I remember Y2K
, people in costco buying so much stuff. Heck when the wild fires hit the water at the local markets was nearly all gone. Face masks were all gone from every store. When Northridge Earthquake hit people got worried about after shocks and started to buy out stores of their supplies. I mention not leaving your property because there may not be any thing on shelves anyway.Even if you could leave your property then what? For those who live in areas where there are farms, lakes, hunting grounds, then what? It cannot be that easy to procure a meal that easily IMO. I dont hunt so I dont know.
My goal is 90 days of self reliance.
With a goal of 90 days things begin to get interesting. While the same basics apply some things may be more of a priority at times such as security, medical conditions, personal hygene, sanitation, proper waste disposale. If you dont have access to a doctor or dentist during that time what will you do if you brake a bone, get a bad infection from a cut, abscessed tooth. filling falls out, etc.. :)
-
When a disaster goes into the 3rd week or 6th week how are we all fairing? Medications, addictions, tempers, monotony, and so on. If we are able to leave our homes then like in my city and I'm sure most the supplies are so limited if there are any.
I remember Y2K
, people in costco buying so much stuff. Heck when the wild fires hit the water at the local markets was nearly all gone. Face masks were all gone from every store. When Northridge Earthquake hit people got worried about after shocks and started to buy out stores of their supplies. I mention not leaving your property because there may not be any thing on shelves anyway.Even if you could leave your property then what? For those who live in areas where there are farms, lakes, hunting grounds, then what? It cannot be that easy to procure a meal that easily IMO. I dont hunt so I dont know.
My goal is 90 days of self reliance.
With a goal of 90 days things begin to get interesting. While the same basics apply some things may be more of a priority at times such as security, medical conditions, personal hygene, sanitation, proper waste disposale. If you dont have access to a doctor or dentist during that time what will you do if you brake a bone, get a bad infection from a cut, abscessed tooth. filling falls out, etc.. :)
Ding Ding Ding, you Sir are absolutely correct which is part of why I posted this thread. Thinking about how far out you'd like to go and are comfortable with planning for. Realistically services should be up and running in a large city like mine and all things "back to normal" pretty quick.
While hygiene in the short term is not important 14 days out it become a concern IMO.
This is why I also keep asking about addictions and fitness ( mental and physical ) and health issues. Diabetics, mental health, dialysis, etc will be very challenging for some families. Evacuation for many will be very difficult for some not possible.I am thinking thru my worst case scenario and then having a plan vs panic and fear. I know I cannot Survive indefinitely and I have a cut off to which I'll plan for ( 90 days ). Again to Lynns thread preparedness vs insanity, there is a line IMO and I'm personally very clear of this.
90 days is my goal and beyond that well................. eat the neighbors >:D
Security will be an issue when panic spreads and looter began to seek "targets" if a scenario goes past a "certain" point. That too is planned for at my home yet again not at some military lever as some. It'll be hard to breach my property for lightly motivated people but holding off a crowd of highly motivated well.......
-
@Aloha007 said:
90 days is my goal and beyond that well................. eat the neighbors >:DThis is why I did not want to live on the Army base. Most of the people there are not very good subjects for eating.
My wife did not understand this so we ended up live on post. I hope to change her mind at some point though.
-
On the subject of addiction and medical condition.
Addiction: The only addiction I'm aware of that I actually HAVE is to caffeine. It's not a joke, but it's also not a huge thing. 3 days of lethargy and headaches, and the worst is over. Plus, I have tea bags, which last roughly forever, and usually have the better part of a big can of coffee.
As far as medical conditions, my hubby has a very special medication he's on, called Kuvan. It's to help control phenylalanine levels caused by his PKU. Without this medication, he has a slow build-up of phe, which leads to headaches, irritability, and eventually to mental retardation and death. But that'd be over the course of years. It's actually possible at this point (our mid 40s) that we'd die of some other cause before his pku killed him.
Luckily, neither of us smoke or have alcohol issues. A number of prepper types talk about storing tobacco or booze for barter, and I have to be honest and say... maybe not the absolute worst idea. I have my doubts about being able to find people willing to trade silver or gold. I have NO doubt about being able to trade a bottle of whiskey or rum for something. My mom rolled her own cigarettes, and got cans of tobacco. I think those might store for a while. Personally, I wouldn't bother with storing tobacco, though.
As for medical prepping, for broken bones, sutures, tooth problems... well, you could have that happen on a 5 day hike, and i never packed for those. Yes, they can happen, but you can't really plan for everything, and you have to cut it off somewhere. I consider broken bones and abscess and such beyond reasonably likely. YMMV. I guess I'm thinking more of portable stuff, though. It might not be as unrealistic in a stationary home kit.
On my day to day EDC, I am strongly considering beefing up my first aid to include treating a gunshot wound, particularly if I decide to start concealed carry. If I'm willing to put a hole in someone, I think I ought to be ready to TREAT that wound. Accidents happen. Also, self DEFENSE is just that. It's not 'smurf you, you deserve to die.' Again, YMMV.
-
I think the 90 day goal is a good realistic goal. 6 months to a year planning is not a bad idea for certain type disasters but you run into storage and security issues. In a longer term situation unless you are very wealthy and can hire your own private army your going to be killed and all your stuff will be taken. A person cant prepare for every thing as Lynn noted so if you have friends you trust and can network with this can help cover some bases you might not be able to do your self. :)
-
@David said:
In a longer term situation unless you are very wealthy and can hire your own private army your going to be killed and all your stuff will be taken.I've heard this a LOT and don't agree with it. Wolves don't go pick a fight that gets half their pack killed. They go for easy targets.
Any serious resistance is going to drive away all but the most desperate/crazy folks. Put yourself in the shoes of the forces trying to take out an entrenched defender. Do YOU want to be the nameless thug that is first through the door to catch that 12-gauge blast in the gut?
Better just to find an easier target.
If you disagree, feel free to set this up on a paintball course. 2 or three people defending a 'house' that they get to set up beforehand. See if you can get a team in there without a lot of guys 'dying', then ask yourself if that was reality, who would be stupid enough to try it, especially for a completely unknown reward.
Again, my opinion, but I think a LOT of people don't think through the whole 'I could die doing this' reality. Pistols aren't that lethal right now LARGELY because there is good medical service. In a SHTF scenario, you might even survive an initial encounter, only to die a week later from sepsis. From a .22. To the little toe.
And... I'm sorry, I really can't imagine big gangs of folks willing to do this. And even if such a gang formed, they'd get taken out (or rapidly reduced) pretty quickly.
Again, my opinion. And again, I'm thinking of where I live. Various locations might have different parameters. I live in a 'Castle Doctrine' state. It's legal for me, at this very moment, to use lethal force on a home invader.
This is another of the areas where I think preppers SUPER over-prepare, in firepower. I see guys talking about carrying seven 30-round magazines for an AR-15 ON THEIR PERSON. I somehow don't think any realistic scenario would ever use that much ammo. Like, over the course of a months-long problem, let alone for a few days. People talk about having 1000 rounds for their primary firearm. Okay... I guess they assume this is 'Red Dawn', and they're 'Wolverines'. How about maybe a pellet rifle for small game instead? 1000 rounds for that? Sure. 1000 rounds of 22lr? Sure, why not. 1000 rounds for a rifle? Uhhh...
I personally think most actual hostile engagements would require somewhere in the 2 +/- 1 shot range. And those would be very few and very far between at most. Statistics I can find seem to support this.
Not that I have an opinion on this or anything...

But plan according to your own perceived situations.
-
Hmm, interesting subject.. Well in some ways were set, but in others kinda screwed,
water wise, hmm, I'd say screwed although there is a fire hydrant like right outside and well I have pipe wrenches?
Electric, err, screwed again, both the fridge, second freezer and stove wouldn't work so I loose everything,
gas, well then I loose heat, now I do have a small propane heater, and also grill, so it depends on if I could get any propane?
As for food well, I guess I loose all in the fridge and freezers, but I got an entire closet full..Now, back a few years we lost everything except water, for a entire week, we pretty much pitched tent in our bedroom and living room, closed off the rest of the place in order to keep where we were sleeping and living warm off of the propane heater, had a small camp propane stove to cook everything off of and also just went outside on the big grill, since it was in the middle of winter, we took plastic tubs (shoebox size)and packed them with snow and stuck them in the fridge and freezer to keep them cool, the other freezer was outside so that staid cold, besides that froze our butts of in order to go to the can! But other then that we were ok, unless we would have ran out of propane, now if our water heater and stove/oven was propane, well that would have made it really nice! JR
-
I think its good for everyone in your family to have they're own 72hr bag, and know what to do, like the red cross even recommends., It doesn't have to be some dramatic era we have to prepare for. House fire, mandatory evacuations for natural disasters, etc... any amount of preparedness is better than depending on someone else. And I'm pretty sure the majority here would agree in being prepared, or you all wouldn't be carrying your favorite MT. :D its awesome to see the thoughts and plans from others around the world.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login