"System is imploding"
-
Let's not forget that since the US has so many more people, the actual system will have to be much bigger. And since it's a gov't run operation there will be inefficiencies and gobs and gobs of red tape.
Like I said before, comparing these countries that have 30-60 million with the US is apples and oranges. If you really want to see how gov't run health care will work in a large, populous and economically and racially diverse country look at the former Soviet Union and/or China.
-
You can debate as much as you want about what system is best, but one thing is for sure. When you have a system that will not treat the weakest people in society because they can’t afford health insurance and they have to rely on charity and good will to be treated for the simplest things then something is just plain wrong.
I am happy with the Norwegian government run system, it has it’s flaws but in my opinion it is better than the US run system, but we are only 5 million people that live in Norway.
-
@Greatest Moderator Ever! said:
What does that have to do with anything?
Larger population base means more funding, means the system should work better then ours in Canada, which has very few people, less of a taxable population, and is stretched thin far and wide.
It doesn't necessarily mean more funding... don't forget the US also has approx 20 million "illegal" aliens that would be able to access the health care system, and who won't be paying taxes to help fund it. More people using it than funding it.
What I see is a system that will start out stretched to the limit with regards to the number of people it can service. Then, when the number of Doctors start to decline (like what happened to Canada), the Doctor to Patient ratio will skyrocket.
Why does a barter system scare you?
At least with the barter system you know the prostitutes will be well cared for... :D
Def
-
When you have a system that will not treat the weakest people in society because they can’t afford health insurance
I don't have a problem helping the "weak" people in society. Most Americans don't. Hell, we are some of the most charitable people on Earth.
However, WAY too often it isn't the weak but merely the lazy who have problems. I'm sorry but I've met a lot of people in my life and 95% of the "poor" people I've met are poor because of stupid decisions they've made. Not because of the "evils of capitalism". From getting in trouble with the law to getting pregnant in high school to having too many credit card and etc etc.
So, why should us people who were smart enough to not screw up our future be stuck with their medical bills?
Like I said, I have no problem helping those who NEED help. Bad things happen, we all get unlucky streaks now and then, but I think it's wrong for for hardworking people in society to have to pay for lazy parasites.
Edited to add:After reading this I sounded heartless. I want to clarify something. I am against gov't run health care but I am also smart enough to realize that the current system is broke. I am a hard core capitalist and I think that competition is the key to good health care.
The problems right now are plenty 1) HMO's (which was another wonderful gov't idea), too much gov't involvement and rules. Liability concerns, a LOT of medical bills are the result of stupidly high lawsuits for malpractice suits. Insurance is killing the private doctors.
Now, I propose that the gov't NOT supply the insurance but basically set up some guidelines about how it wants most people covered and then let competition work out the details. Due to competition, we have personal computers that are more powerful than the ones that sent man to the moon, I truly believe that if we let businesses actually compete against each other they can drive the cost of health care back down.
-
finally....... a post from another nationality.... now.... could you let us know what your tax rate is medic88?
the way i see it:
if we have 47 million uninsured that # is comprised of 20 million illegal. now we are down to 27 million... but waite... there' more....
of that 27 million i'll wager that 15 million or more are already on gov't assistance i.e housing, food stamps, SSI, medicade/ medicare .... now we're down to 17 million. of the 17 million i think there are at least 8 million that would'nt participate in any program whatever and are hard core umeployable.... now we are down to 9 million. but waite... there's more....
of those 9 million clearly 7 million (or more), would work and likely have insurance if they could find or had not lost their job. i don't have a problem giving the assistance these people desearve and i think we can do that w/o raising taxes or creating yet another gov't agency. 7 to 9 million people has a lot of clout. they should not have to go broke from a short term delima.
frankly, no one is refused care in the US.... the rest of us pay for it through our insurance premiums anyway. this issue does seem to be manufactured for a desired result. -
@ducktapehero said:
...
Like I said before, comparing these countries that have 30-60 million with the US is apples and oranges.
...You do have a point, but you may not realize that it has already been considered and dealt with. Even with 33 million people, Canada chooses not to have Federal government running healthcare. The health care is provincially administered, and the role of the Federal government is managing "equalized" transfer payments to the provinces, as well ad acting a a sort of a watchdog on the quality of care. Also, even running health programs within a province like Ontario (13 or so million people, and ) requires more granular management. Currenlty there are 14 LHINs ("local health integration networks") set to manage integrated care. This may sound like more "administrative waste", but again, healthcare spending in Canada is 10% of GDP vs. 16% in the US.
On the subject of illegal immigrants. Canada has around 100,000 of those, which indeeed is nothing compared to the US. However, for years we have been getting approximately 300,000 (or 1% of population) of legal immigrants, who are immediately entitled to health care. This includes many elderly people thorugh family re-unification, who put additional strain on the system. This is how Canada chose to structure our immigration system, and I disagree with a number of policies that are totally messed up, but as far as health care is concerned, the system somehow survives.
The only real "drawback" of the public health care is that the government, on behalf of the taxpayers, aggressively goes after the "freedoms" of smokers and tobacco companies through heavy taxation, anti-smoking advertizing, etc. Having accepted the link between tobacco smoking and health issues as a medically proven fact, I do not have an issue with this. Smoking a different plant is a whole different story though :D
-
@sappyg said:
...
frankly, no one is refused care in the US.... the rest of us pay for it through our insurance premiums anyway. this issue does seem to be manufactured for a desired result.
...Now we only need to find out whether it is manufactured by the islamic terrorists who control Obama administration, or those pesky Canadians who want US to suffer the same misery as they do in their igloos.
Seriously though, "no one is refused care in the US"? Surely, you did not mean that. My co-worker spent a number of years as a hospital administrator in Jamaica Queens hospital in NY. I had to politely ask him to stop telling me all the stories, I just could not handle them...
-
The only real "drawback" of the public health care is that the government, on behalf of the taxpayers, aggressively goes after the "freedoms" of smokers and tobacco companies through heavy taxation, anti-smoking advertizing, etc. Having accepted the link between tobacco smoking and health issues as a medically proven fact,
Fact? Maybe not so much if you actually dig a little.
http://www.lcolby.com/index.html
Now I'm not sating that smoking is good for you, however, I do think it has been greatly exaggerated about how "bad" it is for you.
-
The only real "drawback" of the public health care is that the government, on behalf of the taxpayers, aggressively goes after the "freedoms" of smokers and tobacco companies through heavy taxation, anti-smoking advertizing, etc. Having accepted the link between tobacco smoking and health issues as a medically proven fact,
Fact? Maybe not so much if you actually dig a little.
http://www.lcolby.com/index.html
Now I'm not sating that smoking is good for you, however, I do think it has been greatly exaggerated about how "bad" it is for you.
All I can answer to this link is:
http://www.elvis-is-alive.com/
:D -
Just to go back to the illegal immigrant thing... the Canadian system is actually set up to deal with that. Each province issues a health card to citizens who are entitled to medical coverage. People without a health card are treated and billed personally, or to their insurance if they have it. Whoey, who was a legitimate citizen of Canada but whose ID wasn't up to date (things got confusing when he got out of school, but that's another ball of wax!) was charged for stitches he got in his hand after a slight accident at home.
So, basically illegal immigrants will get treated, but will also be charged for the privilege.
Def
-
...
frankly, no one is refused care in the US.... the rest of us pay for it through our insurance premiums anyway. this issue does seem to be manufactured for a desired result.
...Now we only need to find out whether it is manufactured by the islamic terrorists who control Obama administration, or those pesky Canadians who want US to suffer the same misery as they do in their igloos.
yes i did mean that. do you think that my premiums are based on me and my needs alone or do you think that they are based on the insures overall cost and spread among policy holder? here comes that nasty word again.... proffit.... there i said it... insurance companies are not in the charity business and niether am i. hard as it is to believe i work for proffit.... even gain and to increase my wealth.
if you want to live in an ingloo that is your business. i do not subscribe to a conspiracy theory. i do think that there are limits to the provisions rendered in the US constitution that limit our gov't's actions in this specific regard.
no one wants to see people suffer. i think most of us really want individual freedom and responsibilty. and brother... that takes hard work and sacrifice. -
@ducktapehero said:
Now, I propose that the gov't NOT supply the insurance but basically set up some guidelines about how it wants most people covered and then let competition work out the details. Due to competition, we have personal computers that are more powerful than the ones that sent man to the moon, I truly believe that if we let businesses actually compete against each other they can drive the cost of health care back down.Devil is in the details. By making a reference to the computers you are missing a crucial point, which is that there is simply no positive "innovation" that is possible in insurance, banking, and, to a large extent, primary health care business. We have seen the fruits of competition and innovation in Wall Street "innovation" in the form of credit default swaps. This is capitalism in its pure form, and I doubt that many people would like to see more of it.
-
Now, I propose that the gov't NOT supply the insurance but basically set up some guidelines about how it wants most people covered and then let competition work out the details. Due to competition, we have personal computers that are more powerful than the ones that sent man to the moon, I truly believe that if we let businesses actually compete against each other they can drive the cost of health care back down.
Devil is in the details. By making a reference to the computers you are missing a crucial point, which is that there is simply no positive "innovation" that is possible in insurance, banking, and, to a large extent, primary health care business.
i respectfully dissagree and i openly admit to taking your statement out of context. :ahhh...
like all business we are involved in competition. i win... you loose.... you win i loose.... it is not for practice. it is for keeps. i don't need any practice at doing what i do and i dought any of us do. i admit that sometimes when i get up and go to work i am going through the motions... that is from practice. when i gotta make a difference in what i do.... that is from competition and i hate loosing. -
@sappyg said:
finally....... a post from another nationality.... now.... could you let us know what your tax rate is medic88?Sure. The tax rate on our income is not fixed, I have no debts what so ever so I pay around 36% income tax while a person that has a bank loan so he could buy a house will have to pay around 10% income tax.
Everything that you can buy in this country has a 25% sales tax, but on alcohol and tobacco the sales tax is around 80%.
-
We have seen the fruits of competition and innovation in Wall Street "innovation" in the form of credit default swaps.
We must not also forget that the latest recession is also the result of massive gov't "handling" of the economy. One of the biggest reasons of our "recent troubles" is that the Clinton and Bush administrations forced banks to make high risk loans to unqualified applicants. Also Americans were also so deep in credit card debt that they couldn't see straight. Those 2 things right there are probably the 2 biggest mistakes we've made.
However, this recession shows the value of capitalism. Even in this lousy economy I don't see people starving in mass numbers. I don't see thousands of homeless in my immediate neighborhood. Sure, some people lost a lot of money and that's terrible but we've still got plenty in this country. We've hit a speed bump, rattled a lot loose but we'll come back in a couple years stronger. In a few ways this recession was good for us.
The economy has been, more or less, flying high since the 80's. And a lot of that was because of easy credit. Maybe this bubble popping will show people(and companies) that maybe instead of getting credit for the things you want that instead it's better to save just a little.
All I can answer to this link is:
http://www.elvis-is-alive.com/ufox9al, did you even read my link? Obviously not because there's some glaring inconsistencies in the whole "cigarettes are bad for you" debate. Like I said, I am not going to argue that they're good for you but if you're going to debate then one should do so with an open mind. That's how you learn.
Like one, the Japanese are smoking fools. 60% of their population smokes yet they have some of the the highest
life expectancy in the world. You'd think that with that many people smoking they'd be dying in their 50's.Another from the article
there were guidelines issued by the American Cancer Society, and that when a person dies of certain conditions and has smoked, the doctor is instructed to list the "due to" as "smoking"
Does this seem fair? If this is true then a huge number of the people that die "from smoking" probably shouldn't be considered on the list.
But it's up to you if you want to read it. IF you'd rather just simply accept what popular culture and the gov't has spoonfed you I don't blame you. It's easier than thinking for yourself.
Edited to add: I had an Elvis sighting once. I was living with my uncle down in Clarksville TN and decided to go to Kansas City. Being afraid of flying I took a Greyhound bus. I was sitting toward the front. While I was sitting there I looked in the big mirror by the driver and who did I see? Yep, ELVIS. This was 1994. Of course at first I thought "I've officially lost it" but I watched him and listened. Well, it wasn't Elvis, he talked with a Northern accent of some sort. Boston maybe, definitely somewhere way up North.
So I guess I didn't really see Elvis but I DID see an Elvis impersonator. He looked just like him but his Yankee accent blew the cover.
-
Yet again, propaganda and conspiracy theories seem to prevail.
...Clinton and Bush administrations forced banks to make high risk loans to unqualified applicants...
What forced the banks to give out high-risk loans is the free-market competition. Banks needed higher returns and were giving out high-risk mortgages. Government's setting up Freddy and Fannie as mortgage insurers in itself did not cause the fall of Wall Street investment banks, not the AIG. What caused the collapse is the invention of "mortgage-backed securities" and CDRs by the ivestment bankers chasing commissions and profit. You may want to read up research literature on the subject, or popular literature, like "Origins of Financial Crises" by John Cooper. Then you will have sufficient ammunition to blame the US Central Bank... but for a completely different thing :D
Regardless, you did not seem to dispute my statement about the total absence of [positive] innovation in insurance business in the last 200 years or so, which was the original point I was making.
ufox9al, did you even read my link? Obviously not because there's some glaring inconsistencies in the whole "cigarettes are bad for you" debate.
I clicked on about 1/2 the links, looking for references to the peer-reviewed publications, but found only ranting editorials...
Let me make this debate very simple. In all the lawsuits filed (and won) by the US goverment, the tobacco companies did not even attempt to argue the harm, caused by tobacco smoking, but rather attempted to prove that the harm was "not intentional", or, at best, that they were not aware about the harm, and when they were made aware about it, there were no FDA guidelines, etc. You should definitely feel free to promote your opinion (or exposing "incosistencies"), but I will choose accept that tobacco smoking costs billions in healthcare cost as an undisputed (at least, by the very rich tobacco companies...) fact.It's funny that the debate focus shifted to tobacco, as both US and Canadian systems "punish" smokers, albeit through through different means.
US insurers use higher insurance premiums (same thing in Canada for life insurance), while Canadian government uses tobacco taxes.The core point, again, is that in case of health insurance "competition leads to innovation and lower costs" does not apply.
With that removed from the equation, there is not much left to object to the government-controlled health insurance system. -
finally....... a post from another nationality.... now.... could you let us know what your tax rate is medic88?
Sure. The tax rate on our income is not fixed, I have no debts what so ever so I pay around 36% income tax while a person that has a bank loan so he could buy a house will have to pay around 10% income tax.
Everything that you can buy in this country has a 25% sales tax, but on alcohol and tobacco the sales tax is around 80%.WOW.... thanks for the insight medic88. it seems strange that if you have debt you pay less in taxes but if it works for you then great. the kicker is that sales tax though. i think the avarage American pays 17-25% in taxes. in the state i live in i pay 6% in sales tax. today i think i paid $2.32 per gallon of gas. of that i think $0.22 per gallon is tax.
if you don't mind could you tell us what a gallon or litre of gas costs and how much of that is tax?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login