Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Ultrasonic Cleaners

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Reviews
3 Posts 1 Posters 3.3k Views
  1. Home
  2. Reviews
  3. Ultrasonic Cleaners
Ultrasonic Cleaners
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • eodtech Offline
    eodtech
    Posts: 2,423
    eodtech Offline
    eodtech
    wrote on last edited by eodtech
    Quote Reply

      Ultrasonic Cleaners

      When I was in the market for a UC a number of years ago I put out a
      post looking for info and received a number of replies. Alan
      Tischler has had extensive experience in using these critters and
      the majority of the information comes from him. At the end of PART
      II of the message I will discuss what I purchased as well as SOS for
      the different models. SOS = source of supply.

      (Not for use with volatile solvents.)

      There are 2 completely different tools that are often referred to
      as "ultrasonic cleaners" (UC's). The best way to differentiate
      between the is to look at the price tag. If the list price is around
      $50 or below, this is NOT in the category that most actually would
      call a true UC. These are most often sold in places like jewelry
      stores and can get away with calling them UC's because they vibrate
      water, but the ultrasonic waves they produce have very little power
      to them. Yes, the will make the water dirty if you stick in a metal
      watch band that hasn't been cleaned in a few years in with the
      detergent. But you could get the same cleaning effect with a hand
      held vibrator (The shape is the user's choice) and holding it
      against any container with a detergent solution in it. A Real UC is
      very powerful unit. It sends very high-pitched and very powerful
      waves through the container, which is usually stainless steel. These
      high powered and high pitched (i.e. ultrasonic) actually cause
      microscopic bubbles to be formed in the solution and it's these high
      energy microscopic bubbles are what causes the desired cleaning
      effect. When a detergent is added it will be transferred with the
      high energy microscopic bubbles to hasten the cleaning process.
      There are several ways to separate the real and the impostors. First
      is price. For fountain pen / multitools / etc work we really only need
      the smallest units made and these will list from about $100 to $150.
      These will generally pull 40 to 50 watts of power and will produce ultrasound waves in
      the vicinity of 60,000 cycles per second. While you may not be able
      to hear 60 KHz itself, you will certainly be able to hear the effect
      of the microscopic bubbles in the tank. Much of the energy that the
      waves give off, like almost any source of energy will be lost in the
      form of heat. In a 40 watt unit that has a one cup capacity,
      starting around room temperature, the water or detergent solution in
      the unit will increase roughly 1 degree F per minute. THIS IS VERY
      IMPORTANT TO CONSTANTLY AWARE OF! The unit I got 7 years ago
      is made by Koh-I-Noor. This is an excellent unit for small items and
      if you know of another source for it, I can highly recommend it. Another unit they
      have made by Alvin, is one that I've seen in action at the now
      replaced Michael's in San Francisco. The employees there held it in
      high praise. According to the Reprint catalog, it lists for $148 and
      sells in the catalog for $99. It comes with a thermostat, a lid and
      an insert made for cleaning the nibs and feeds of almost any
      fountain pen, by holding them vertically. This is the perfect way
      every week or so to remove inks that are starting to concentrate in
      the feed and nib. A UC is certainly not a mandatory piece of
      equipment. Although for my money, it would rank very near the top.
      If money is very tight, you might not want to spend your money on
      one, even on an excellent unit costing only $99. I would, however,
      put it's usefulness way ahead of a lathe as was seriously suggested
      as a more useful tool in a discussion on the pen-pencils newsgroup
      long ago. This is a tool that I would not only recommend for anyone
      interested in pen work, but for virtually every repair person, or a
      just a very useful household tool. Like any tool must be used
      correctly. I has incredible usefulness in our hobby, but used
      incorrectly can do significant harm. The most important source of
      harm has to do with the heat buildup mentioned above. A timer,
      either one that cuts the power, or one that is on your person is
      very important. If starting with tap water, the time that it takes
      the bath temperature above about 125 degrees F should always be the
      absolute maximum. For most jobs, the limit should be under 100
      degrees F. For Pyroxylin plastics this is about the hottest that the
      plastic will be safe. Much hotter than this, the plastic can undergo
      totally unexpected changes, the most damaging is plastic shrinking.
      Also, hot temperatures can cause the plastic to melt and disfigure.
      This can all be prevented by length of time exposed or tossing some
      ice chips as suggested by Fultz. There are a few false claims that
      have given a bad name to UC's by some (who don't use them). Some
      have claimed that it can lift-off inlaid pen nibs as in many Sheaffer
      pens. After this was suggested as a problem in the heated discussion
      of the past on the pen-pencils newsgroup, one repair person,
      described putting a section of a PFM section in a powerful cleaner
      for a full 18 hours (I take it that this was one that have full heat
      control.) His comment that the only change was that it came out
      immaculate. I personally called Sheaffer and spoke with one of the
      staff in technical service as to how old PFMs, Imperials, Targas and
      now Lagacys are treated to get out dried ink, as this is one problem
      that all these inlaid nibs have in common-it's hard to get the last
      traces of ink out of them. I was told quite simply they use UC's. To
      date I know of only one general case that is likely to be harmed by
      an UC. On the other hand, the things that can be accomplished with a
      UC are nothing short of amazing. When restoring any sac-filled pen,
      removing the section from the pen and cleaning in a 1:1 solution of
      Formula 409 to water for 5-10 minutes will render the whole
      section/feed/nib as clean as knocking the parts out and cleaning
      each by hand separately. The majority of the time even a totally
      clogged section will be completely cleaned in 15 to 20 minutes. One
      of the things that I've found that only a UC can do is remove
      staining in a plastic pen due to dried ink. At other times it may be useful
      to use a milder solution or one that will leave no trace after evaporation,
      like ammonia. While I wouldn't recommend filling the whole bath with
      clear household ammonia--this is fine if your work area is outside.
      On can very easily treat a piece in ammonia by placing the parts in
      a vial of ammonia/water solution and placing the vial directly in
      the bath. The uses are really only limited to your imagination.

      ultrasonic cleaner - PART II

      I learned a valuable lesson today as I went to read the post I wrote
      on which types of stains and discolorations can be removed with an
      ultrasonic cleaner versus types that can't. I found the post to be
      essentially unintelligible! It could easily be the worst written
      post I have posted yet. At least I hope so. For this I feel
      embarrassed and I apologize to many of you who have appreciated most
      of my efforts in the past and tried to follow this particular piece.
      I assure you that this does not represent that I have lost it
      altogether. I made the horrible error of trying to write something
      while I was in fact falling asleep at the keyboard. It was a
      question that I was eager to address, but I now realize that there
      is no question that is so important to address that it can't wait
      until morning. In a much more concise way, I think I can condense
      what I was trying to say into a single lucid paragraph. Vintage
      plastic pens, almost all of which are made from Pyroxylin, are
      relatively porous materials. In these plastics, discoloration falls
      into 2 categories. One type is when the stain or discoloration IS
      NOT chemically bound to the plastic. These, which are most commonly
      due to inks, can be removed in principle with the aid of an
      ultrasonic cleaner. The other type of discoloration is when stain IS
      chemically bound to the plastic. This can occur under a number of
      conditions including heat, light, and exposure to reactive agents
      such as fumes from rubber sacs and some types of inks. This type of
      stain or discoloration cannot be removed from the plastic
      essentially because the discoloration has become an integral part of
      the plastic itself. Unfortunately, this type of discoloration occurs
      frequently in many colors and patterns that are highly desirable,
      such as jade, pearl, onyx and lapis among others. Even pure
      colorless Pyroxylin becomes ambered, an irreversible reaction that
      is induced by exposure to light, heat and chemical reactants. ALAN


      There is at least one factor alone that could explain the
      difference. That would be the efficiency of the wave generator. As
      even 40 watts for an appliance that is only used minutes at a time
      is almost negligible, there isn't much incentive to design and
      produce an efficient unit. For a company like Bronson, who
      essentially makes nothing but UC's up to tanks that hold many tens
      of gallons, there is an incentive for more efficient design. In
      short they may just have the engineering in place to make an
      efficient unit without having to invest much effort in it. Another
      factor would be in the difference in the frequency of the waves
      generated. In principle, 60 KHz would be preferable than 40 KHz and
      this would take more power to generate. But once again, efficiency
      is a big question mark. A good analogy is to compare a 60 watt light
      bulb to a 40 watt bulb. If we define that the watts pertain only to
      incandescent bulbs than the 60 watt bulb produces more light at the
      filament. But this begs two questions. One is how far away from the
      incandescent bulb you are. If you are 10 feet from the 40 watt bulb
      and 50 feet from the 60 watt bulb, which is going to look brighter?
      This speaks to how efficiently the energy generated is directed into
      the system. The other question is what happens when the bulbs are
      not constrained to be incandescent? This is what I was primarily
      referring to above. Obviously a 40 watt fluorescent bulb will
      generate far more light at the source than a 60 watt incandescent
      bulb. This is the kind of thing I was referring to when speaking of
      the efficiency of the generator used. I can't say for certain that
      your small Bronson unit will be better or worse than the units I
      found. All I can say is that I know from experience that Bronson
      makes quality UC's in general. It would be good to come up with some
      standard by which we could compare the units directly. Perhaps the
      time needed to remove the stain made by a particular ink on a given
      surface. I suspect you will be happy with the Bronson UC, unless
      there has been some big changes in the company since I bought my
      last unit from them 10 years ago. This was their smallest
      thermostated unit at the time. I believe it had a half-gallon tank
      and sold for over $500. ALAN


      Before I had a Bronson ( Branson is the correct
      name of the UC (note ALAN refers to it as a BRONSON) )UC in every
      lab I worked in. They are indeed the largest manufacturers of UC's
      that I am aware of. In fact, when I first decided to by one for my
      pen work, I contacted the regional Bronson dealer. At the time, at
      least according to him, they didn't have one in the $100 to $200
      price range as the smallest model was significantly larger. I would
      think that if they now have one in this size and price range it
      would be an excellent alternative to the ones I mentioned. I would
      also recommend posting this information on the Zoss list, if you
      haven't already, and you may certainly cite my recommendation of
      Bronson.


      Several years ago I posted a question on the net asking for sources for a
      good, powerful and reasonably-priced Ultrasonic Cleaner (UC). I
      received a few suggestions that were worth following up. The
      suggestion that I got from Marc Brown I believe was THE answer. He
      told me about a small, powerful unit made by Koh-I-Noor,
      specifically for cleaning Rapidograph technical pens that use
      pigmented ink. I ended up buying the unit from the source he
      suggested, the Re-Print Corp. for $112 (list is $135). This unit has
      a round stainless steel tank that measures approx. 3 5/8" in
      diameter and 2" high - very small size. I am used to laboratory
      units 5 - 10 times more costly. This unit, for it's size is every bit as powerful.
      My first test was a Parker fountain pen that seemed to be clogged
      with India ink. Placed in the unit, the crud started shooting out
      both ends immediately. The section was completely clear in minutes.
      A good way to check the power of a UC is to put in cold tap water.
      The power of the Ultrasonic waves should heat the water to warm in
      about 10 minutes. This unit passed this test with flying colors.
      Even though the unit is shallow, It is possible to clean long
      objects by placing them in a along with the cleaning solution in a
      plastic container and placing this container in the tank, which
      would then contain tap water only. This is actually a very efficient
      way to use any UC as only as much cleaning solution as needed is
      used. For cleaning purposes 409 to water, about one to one is about
      right for very stubborn jobs, while much more dilute detergent, or
      even no detergent at all will suffice for easier jobs. Dilute
      ammonia can also be used but it is ill-advised in a room that is not
      adequately ventilated. ALAN


      Rather than posting info on solutions used to clean pen, nibs,
      parts, etc. the winner for cleaning solution to use in your UC tank
      is a 50/50 mix of water and 409 cleaner. It should be noted that
      certain items should not be cleaned in a UC. I am sure there will be
      posts covering the specifics as the tread develops.


      Based on all the info presented and reading the tech specs as well
      as ALAN's love for Bronson's that is what I purchased off the
      Internet. I later sold it and acquired a Koh-I-Nor which has a
      smaller capacity but is a far superior machine when it comes to
      cleaning small parts. Recently I sold the Koh-I-Nor and purchase a
      UC from Harbor Freight for $50 which is a good size for MTs.
      Listed below are the sources for UC's .

      http://www.micromark.com/ULTRASONIC-CLEANER,8024.html

      http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/ctaf/Category.taf?CategoryID=774

      http://www.bransonic.com/

      http://www.cleanosonic.com/

      http://www.sonicsonline.com/gemoro-ultrasonic-jewelry-cleaner.html

      Use "ultrasonic" in the search engine in each of the above sites to
      locate the cleaners. I hope this helps all that are looking for a
      ultrasonic cleaner

      UC FAQ - http://www.coleparmer.com/techinfo/techinfo.asp?htmlfile=ultrasoniccleaner_faq.htm&ID=792

      EODtech
      12/24/2002 - original review
      9/29/2009 - updated

      Why do I carry a 45 ?
      Because they don't make a 46 !

      1 Reply Last reply
      • Chako Offline
        Chako
        Posts: 22,725
        Chako Offline
        Chako
        wrote on last edited by
        #1 Quote Reply

          I have a cheaper machine with stainless bowl bought at one of the local stores, and I love it. It does everything I need it to. It does wonders cleaning MTs. I for one do not need a higher powered unit. With that said, that was a cracking good read. I learned quite a bit about them. Excellent. :salute:

          A little Leatherman information.

          <a href="http://forum.multitool.org/index.php/topic,52305.0.html">[b]Leatherman series articles[b]</a>

          Merit Badges
          One Piece Collector MTO Tool MP600 Collector Juice Collector Level 3 Japanese PST Charge Collector Sporkman OCD Squad Flashlight Fire Making Scale Changer Photographer Gun User BO Tools Level 3 Time Lord Level 3 Airgun User ALOX Colors Level 3
          1 Reply Last reply
          • stressmaster5000 Offline
            stressmaster5000
            Posts: 3,414
            stressmaster5000 Offline
            stressmaster5000
            wrote on last edited by
            #2 Quote Reply

              Thanks for this review about UC's. I found it informative. Could you or anyone else that has had luck using these with SAK's or MT's please tell us of your cleaning success or failures?

              1 Reply Last reply

              Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

              Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

              With your input, this post could be even better 💗

              Register Login

              1. Home
              2. Reviews
              3. Ultrasonic Cleaners
              Reply
              • Reply as topic
              Log in to reply
              COMMUNITY LINKS
              EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
              Operational Funds

              Help us keep the Unworkable working!

              Make A Donation
              November Goal: $300.00
              Due Date: Nov 30
              Total Receipts: $0.00
              Below Goal: $300.00
              0% funded
              • Login

              • Don't have an account? Register

              • Login or register to search.
              • First post
                Last post
              0