Need some experienced advice
-
Hello to all, I am a newbiew to this site, but I am sure glad I stumbled across it on Goolgle!! I have just spent the last 2.5 hours searching the tools sites and this one looking for a replacement for my Craftsman 21 or Schrade ST5 as I have found out who made it for Craftsman! Anyway I STUPIDLY left it on the trailer after repairing the tail lights and I can NOT live with out it any longer!! I am by "profession" an all around maintenance guy and used that thing EVERY DAY!! Can anyone recommend a replacement, seeing that it is no longer available?? I loved and used the interchangable screwdrivers, 5/16" , 1/4" nut driver, and pliers the most. The reviewes for the LM did not seem all that great, any info would be Greatly appreciated!! Thanks!!
-
Hmm..interchangeable drivers really narrows down the choices to the Leatherman Wave/Charge/Surge. There are add ons for some of the older LM tools that allow for various bits, but they look bulky and must take a while to unsheath, attach to the tool, select the bit, then undo the whole thing to sheath it again.
Victorinox has a small stand alone bit driver that fits in some of their sheaths along with the main tool...The SOG Powerlock has an attachment to allow for 1/4" bits..
There are literally dozens upon dozens of great quality tools out there to choose from, and you'll probably end up getting a few over time and seeing what you like. And if you're thinking of replacing the Schrade PLEASE make sure it's an older model made in the USA, NOT the Chinese made copy. The crappy foregin ones are labeled Schrade also (the name was sold), but they are bogus.
-
SOG powerlock would be a good option as well, because it has the 1/4" drive which you can use for nut driver attachments or bit driving. Great tool as well.
-Dough
-
Welcome to MTO.
-
DO NOT BUY ANOTHER SCHRADE!!!!
Schrade went out of business a few years ago, and the name was purchased by a company that makes terribly cheap copies of the old tools/knives in the worst parts of China. I'd hate for you to fall into the trap that many do, where you liked the tool you had and figure you'll just replace it with the same tool.....
Might I also recommend the Crunch?

It's an often overlooked, tough as nails tool that I think would serve you quite well in building maintenance.
Def
-
The Crunch is my next must have Multitool
Dunc
-
Welcome!
Agree that the Leathermans with bit drivers would work well (Wave, Charge, Surge--Skeletool, maybe not as tough), but they do require special bits.
Vic tools are fine too, but the bit drivers/ratchet is a separate part to keep track of.
SOG's bit driver works well, but the spring that hold things in can pop out pretty easily.
Crunch is good. No standard pliers, just locking pliers (vise grip style). A bit awkward to use the bit driver, cuz you have to unscrew the adjustment knob completely...
Like you, I really like the tube arrangement on the Scrade bit driver, but sadly that is NLA new except as a collector piece on eBay and EDCsource.com
Good luck in the hunt! (Personally, I prefer the LM Charge, btw).
-
Two possabilities spring to mind , a Leatherman Crunch , and a Victorinox Swisstool or Spirit ( preferably a plus package ) combined with a Leatherman Universal Tool Adapter . An Old Skool Wave with a Universal Tool Adapter is also a great candidate . I have used all of the above lots and can vouch for them .
Pics of my bit set up !
Chris
-
@Styerman said:
Two possabilities spring to mind , a Leatherman Crunch , and a Victorinox Swisstool or Spirit ( preferably a plus package ) combined with a Leatherman Universal Tool Adapter . An Old Skool Wave with a Universal Tool Adapter is also a great candidate . I have used all of the above lots and can vouch for them .Pics of my bit set up !
A Leatherman Supertool 300 might serve you well . Lots of great choices , not an easy descision !
Chris
-
@maintmanmike said:
The reviewes for the LM did not seem all that great, any info would be Greatly appreciated!! Thanks!!Have a second look at LM tools,bro. The Surge, ST 300 or Core might be the right tool for you!
Welcome to the forum Maintmamike!
-
Thanks for all the replies, seems like I have a decision to make! I do have another question, of the LM are they all pretty much created equal, durabiltiy wise? I have looked at the LM Charge and Wave at Tyler Tool. The Charege claims to have stronger pliers and made of a better grade of stainless. Any truth to this or is it pretty much a choice of accessories. Once again THANKS, I was NOT EXPECTING such great advice on short notice!! If I would have known I would of gotten back to this sooner!!!
-
The new Wave and the Charge series all have the same plier heads I belive, although some Charges have a cap crinper in the head also.
The differences in steel are probably references to the main knife blade...the Wave is a basic steel, but some of the Charges have S30V or 154CM. There's nothing wrong with the plain old stainless steel of the Wave IMO..
BTW when you read "new Wave" it refers to the Wave model that came out in 2004 that has locking impliments. The "old Wave" was slightly smaller and thinner and none of the inner tools locked.
Check and see if there are pocket clips available at that store also, both the Charges and the new Wave can be fitted with one and lots of people like carrying it that way.
-
@maintmanmike said:
Thanks for all the replies, seems like I have a decision to make! I do have another question, of the LM are they all pretty much created equal, durabiltiy wise? I have looked at the LM Charge and Wave at Tyler Tool. The Charege claims to have stronger pliers and made of a better grade of stainless. Any truth to this or is it pretty much a choice of accessories. Once again THANKS, I was NOT EXPECTING such great advice on short notice!! If I would have known I would of gotten back to this sooner!!!That claim I believe dates back to when the first Charges were released, and at the time it was true. Since then, LM have pretty much fitted their new range out with the stronger pliers design, so that shouldn't be a deciding factor for you amongst the 4" tools.
However, if strength is what you want, LM do make bigger, stronger tools like the Core and the Supertool 300, but if you want the interchangeable bits, then maybe the Surge is where you should be looking. The Surge is basically a big Wave (clever naming huh?) with a T-Shank adapter which could be useful in your line of work.
Here's some pics:


-
Oh - I should have added that I carry a Charge every day, and it has never failed me in any way!
-
If you can stand the weight I would recommend the Surge. The Wave is good the Charge is good however I would go by way of the Surge. You could look at a few of the sponsor sites here or jump to EDCsource.com or lastly Ebay for one at fairly good price.
-
OK, again I guess I can NOT say how MUCH I appreciate all the input and response I have recieved!! You guys really do know your stuff, you have also made me realize just what subdtle differences there are in these tools, that I have not noticed before!! Anyhow, I believe I have come to a conclusion!!! After looking at the recommended Surge and Charge, I am going to give the Charge ALX a try. The 1 thing that I finnaly noticed was that the Charge was the only Pliers that where not just Needle nose. They have the indent as "pliers" which will be needed in grabing that bolt or nut when that second set of channel locks is 3 floors down and out in the truck!! Also I liked the "gut" hook feature, might come in handy tring to grab that erant wire from the back of the box (power better be off, using an ALL METAL tool!!!) Again THANKS to ALL!!! I WILL CONTINUE to visit this site, and I have already let a few of the guys know about it. I will post some updates after I get this Charge and the bit set from LM to let ALL know how its going to stand up in this new job.
-
Just remember the gut hood is sharpened inside so don't pull to hard on any wires that you are trying to snag!
Good luck with the Charge! It's a great tol and I doubt you will be disappointed! :D
Def
-
Welcome to the forums Maintmanmike,it sounds like you make a good choice on the ALX,I was in Aircraft maint. for over 30yrs.
& 
-
Welcome mike, hope the Charge works out well for you - I love mine :D
Come back and see us soon and bring
beerfriends
-
Welcome dude. Personally... I would have said Surge... but we all know I would say Surge. Big tool

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




