Rivited multitools
-
What's your opinion as to why some multitools are rivited while others are screwed or bolted? What are the advantages and disadvantages?
Leatherman use torx screw on most models except the Squirt and Juice. Most if not all Gerber and Sog multitools are bolted. Victorinox, Buck, Schrade, Kershaw are all riveted. Am I right?
Edap
-
EDAP:
I had nearly this same post a while back. I was looking at a new job and wondered whether my Victorinox, with its rivets, would be as strong as my Bear Jaws, SOG Powerlock or my Supertool- all of which are bolted together. The general consensus of the posters was that the Victorinox rivets are very strong and that the tool would tear up or break before the rivets would. My Swisstool had a couple of tools that were just right for the job and I do love my Swisstool. Having said that, I have to be truthful when I say that I trust the bolted tools more, though there is no rational evidence to support that trust. I guess the small diameter bolt which threads into the pivot of the bolted tools could strip or break just as the rivet could. I didn't really answer, but these are just my opinions. Regards, Bill.
-
I don't think that either is stronger, but that the bolted ones are far more convenient to dismantle and clean, and for the repair staff to fix.
-
Why do different manufacturers use different assembly methods? Must be each one uses the technique that they are most familiar with. Victorinox for instance makes millions of riveted Swiss Army Knives, so they no doubt have the equipment and expertise to use rivets on their multitools.
-
Rivets prevent Joe-jackhole from dismantling his tool and sending it back to Vic with a big cry about not being able to fix it again - Rivets can also be ground down flush and polished, which some may find appealing. Rivets also don't run the risk of loosening during general use. Rivets won't shear or gore as threaded fastenings can.
When it comes to building steel bridges and tankers, Rivets are the chosen fastening, whether this is because they are cheaper or faster is not known to me, but they're obviously up to the task of load bearing, even if they don't take advantage of fabulous inclined plane technology.
-
I agree with what Bob said. I think it's just what the tool makers are used to and have the equipment to do. Having said that I can't imagine what the Vic Spirit would look like with it's sleek lines taken away with either the LM curled screws or the SOG bolts. I like the rivets on it.
-
I dislike rivets, or really any thing that keeps me from dismantling my tools, knives or flashlights.
Example, today I found an odd duck Buck 360 that has a broken lock spring so the tools on one side of the handle flop around loosely. If this tool were screwed construction I could merely tighten the fasteners as a stopgap measure and then eventually disassemble the tool and repair.
-
Rivets I'd imagine are chosen because they are faster. You simply put the insert into the socket, press and you're done. I'd guess you could do three rivets in the time it takes to thread and torque a bolt. I'm not really dissing the rivets. As I previously said, I haven't had a rivet come apart during use. It just seems the press fit of the rivet would be a bit more suspect that the thread attachment of the bolt.
-
I suspect the rivets can be more precisely controlled for tolerance in the shop - especially if they're using CNC machines. It seems to work very well for Vic. Their consistency of manufacture is excellent!
Tom
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login