Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Saw test

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved General Tool Discussion
64 Posts 1 Posters 13.4k Views
  1. Home
  2. Tool Talk
  3. General Tool Discussion
  4. Saw test
Saw test
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • Lynn LeFey Offline
    Lynn LeFey
    Posts: 7,918
    Lynn LeFey Offline
    Lynn LeFey
    wrote on last edited by
    #36 Quote Reply

      My next round of saw tests.

      I set these tools in order of their saw length (as measured from first saw tooth to last saw tooth, not overall tool length).

      What we have here:
      Berkley Mini Fishing Tool, Husky 14-in-1 Multi-tool, the 'Bear Grylls Strata' from the Ultimate Survival Pack, Leatherman Juice CS4, Wenger EVO S17, Victorinox Farmer, and returning as the benchmark the OHO Trekker.

      The first surprise I had was with the Berkley Mini Fishing Tool. See that dinky saw? Guess what? It works. It doesn't work GREAT, and I swear I could have gnawed through the branch faster, but it DID cut, and didn't go dull, unlike the saw on the SAK-Alike knives. Shocking.

      The Husky seemed like a dream come true to cut with after that Berkley, but it was still slow and terrible. There was a slight improvement when i moved up to the 'BG Strata'. It was an obvious jump in quality going from the Strata to the Juice CS4. That saw cut like a frickin' lightsaber compared to all before it.

      And from that point on, all of the saws cut extremely well. The Juice was a bit better than the Wenger EVO S17, I think, but not by lots. Among Leatherman and SAKs, it mostly just seems that the longer the saw, the faster the cut. One doesn't cut better than another, only faster due to longer stroke length.

      As far as ergonomics, the Berkley was terrible, the Husky was profoundly uncomfortable, being a huge chunk of metal. The Strata was okay. The Juice was incredibly comfortable. The screwdriver on the EVO was somewhat annoying. The farmer was probably the best of them all, and minus the OHO protrusion on the Trekker, it would be perfect. As it is, it's about on par with the EVO.

      Like my original test, this was done on an oak deadfall branch.

      The Oak branch

      After Testing

      1 Reply Last reply
      • Nhoj Offline
        Nhoj
        Posts: 2,791
        Nhoj Offline
        Nhoj
        wrote on last edited by
        #37 Quote Reply

          I can't believe I've never found this thread before. I really like the saw on my wave but I am still a little surprised a 91mm vic saw is longer than it.

          1 Reply Last reply
          • enki_ck Offline
            enki_ck
            Global Moderators
            Posts: 20,936
            enki_ck Offline
            enki_ck
            Global Moderators
            wrote on last edited by
            #38 Quote Reply

              Lynn, we have to get you a 108mm SAK (GAK) to test and compare. :D

              1 Reply Last reply
              • Gareth Offline
                Gareth
                Admin Team
                Posts: 37,725
                Gareth Offline
                Gareth
                Admin Team
                wrote on last edited by
                #39 Quote Reply

                  Good stuff Lynn. :salute:

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • nuphoria Offline
                    nuphoria
                    Admin Team
                    Posts: 15,038
                    nuphoria Offline
                    nuphoria
                    Admin Team
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #40 Quote Reply

                      Thank you for that :cheers:

                      I have some of the the same tools myself (or similar) and my OHT would definitely be 1st choice for it's saw :tu:

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • Cupboard Offline
                        Cupboard
                        Posts: 2,018
                        Cupboard Offline
                        Cupboard
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #41 Quote Reply

                          I think the Leatherman OHT's saw would be a bit of a joke in comparison to the Vic OHT :tool:

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • SwissArmy Zippo Offline
                            SwissArmy Zippo
                            Posts: 152
                            SwissArmy Zippo Offline
                            SwissArmy Zippo
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #42 Quote Reply

                              [quote author=Lynn LeFey link=topic=37422.msg601471#msg601471 date=1336593001]
                              A brief saw test.

                              Do u have this test on video? I'd like to see it if u do. Thnx 4 sharing

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • SwissArmy Zippo Offline
                                SwissArmy Zippo
                                Posts: 152
                                SwissArmy Zippo Offline
                                SwissArmy Zippo
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #43 Quote Reply

                                  Using the LM Wave Saw. Worked fantastic on a 3/4 hardwood (poplar) dowell.

                                  image.jpg

                                  image.jpg

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • Lynn LeFey Offline
                                    Lynn LeFey
                                    Posts: 7,918
                                    Lynn LeFey Offline
                                    Lynn LeFey
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #44 Quote Reply

                                      No, no video version, sorry. Watching me sawing an old branch sounds pretty horrifying to me as a video.

                                      "And here I am..."
                                      Vfff, vfff, vfff, vfff..... vfff, vfff, vfff, vfff..
                                      (Fast forward 4 minutes)
                                      "And that was the Berkley. Pretty slow. Let's try the next."
                                      Vfff... Vfff... Vfff...
                                      (Fast forward ten minutes)
                                      Vfff... Vfff.... Vffff...
                                      (Pause video, go get beer... drink beer, read a few e-mails, surf I-Am-Bored... come back to video)
                                      Vfff.... Vfff... Vfff...

                                      :D

                                      EDIT: yep, I liked the Wave saw too.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • J Mackrel Jones Offline
                                        J Mackrel Jones
                                        Posts: 731
                                        J Mackrel Jones Offline
                                        J Mackrel Jones
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #45 Quote Reply

                                          Thanks for the testing Lynn. Sensible and realistic as always.
                                          Here is a saw test from The Swiss Army Knife Owner's Manual (with Mr. Young's permission):

                                          "In a test of 30 seconds cutting with sharp wood saws on 1 ½ inch square redwood the new-design Wenger was the winner, barely ahead of Victorinox; then the Chinese and the Spanish Aitor about tied, just ahead of the old-design Wenger; the German Korium proved to be rather ineffective. On 3-inch plastic pipe the Victorinox saw was the winner. The only saw to cut worse than the old Wenger design was the Spanish Aitor. The German Korium placed in the middle of the group. The modern-design Wenger was almost as good as the Victorinox, just beating out the Chinese."

                                          saw test.jpg

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • bleedingthumb Offline
                                            bleedingthumb
                                            Posts: 19
                                            bleedingthumb Offline
                                            bleedingthumb
                                            wrote on last edited by
                                            #46 Quote Reply

                                              @Lynn LeFey said:
                                              No, no video version, sorry. Watching me sawing an old branch sounds pretty horrifying to me as a video.

                                              "And here I am..."
                                              Vfff, vfff, vfff, vfff..... vfff, vfff, vfff, vfff..
                                              (Fast forward 4 minutes)
                                              "And that was the Berkley. Pretty slow. Let's try the next."
                                              Vfff... Vfff... Vfff...
                                              (Fast forward ten minutes)
                                              Vfff... Vfff.... Vffff...
                                              (Pause video, go get beer... drink beer, read a few e-mails, surf I-Am-Bored... come back to video)
                                              Vfff.... Vfff... Vfff...

                                              :D

                                              EDIT: yep, I liked the Wave saw too.

                                              Um, I'm pretty sure I would watch the whole thing. :whistle:

                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                              • SwissArmy Zippo Offline
                                                SwissArmy Zippo
                                                Posts: 152
                                                SwissArmy Zippo Offline
                                                SwissArmy Zippo
                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                #47 Quote Reply

                                                  @Lynn LeFey said:
                                                  No, no video version, sorry. Watching me sawing an old branch sounds pretty horrifying to me as a video.

                                                  "And here I am..."
                                                  Vfff, vfff, vfff, vfff..... vfff, vfff, vfff, vfff..
                                                  (Fast forward 4 minutes)
                                                  "And that was the Berkley. Pretty slow. Let's try the next."
                                                  Vfff... Vfff... Vfff...
                                                  (Fast forward ten minutes)
                                                  Vfff... Vfff.... Vffff...
                                                  (Pause video, go get beer... drink beer, read a few e-mails, surf I-Am-Bored... come back to video)
                                                  Vfff.... Vfff... Vfff...

                                                  :D

                                                  EDIT: yep, I liked the Wave saw too.

                                                  Ummmm yes I'd watch it!

                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                  • Lynn LeFey Offline
                                                    Lynn LeFey
                                                    Posts: 7,918
                                                    Lynn LeFey Offline
                                                    Lynn LeFey
                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                    #48 Quote Reply

                                                      Another round of tests.

                                                      Same test 'subject' as all the previous. I found a deadfall branch off of our oak tree, about 1/2" (13mm) to 3/4" (19mm) through the solid wood section, not including the bark.

                                                      The contestants today were the Leatherman Sidekick, Wenger Handyman, Victorinox Spirit X, Victorinox Farmer (coming back as a standard for comparison), and the Wenger Ranger 58. In the first pic, I arranged them by saw length, shortest on the left. If I recall correctly, the Wenger Handyman and Vic Spirit's saw are so close to the same length that I can't tell the difference.

                                                      Sadly, I don't currently have a Vic 111mm to compare against the Wenger Ranger, but I have a Rucksack on the way, and hope to do a head-to-head when it arrives.

                                                      So, I think this is the first time I've done this kind of test, and not had a junky saw in the bunch.

                                                      The second pic is approximately in order of how they performed. No different from the initial organization. I think this leads me more strongly to believe that among good saws, length is the real determining factor. With a couple caveats.

                                                      The Sidekick has a pretty good saw, and the tool was comfortable in-hand, with a nice large handle to grip on. I wasn't super thrilled with the pull-only cut of the blade, though.

                                                      The Handyman cut the same as the previously tested Eco S17, except it has an annoying chain flopping around, and really enraging me. Also, I didn't remember it from the previous test, but the handle seemed REALLY hard to hang onto. The grip and chain are the only two things that set it below the performance of the Spirit's saw, IMO.

                                                      The Spirit X's saw, despite being a good deal wider than the Wenger 85mm saw, cut just as well. With more tool to grip onto, and maybe I was just less afraid of using it aggressively, particularly on the push stroke. I wasn't afraid of busting up plastic scales.

                                                      Farmer. Wow. Great grip, solid. No fear of banging it up, I just let 'er rip, and it cuts so amazingly well.

                                                      The Ranger was a beast. It cut SO fast. I am rather excited to give it a run against a 111mm Vic. I suspect the Ranger will clearly take the match. As I recall, the Trekker was a tad better than the Farmer. The Ranger was clearly better. I had some concerns about the OHO 'loop' on the Ranger's blade possibly getting in the way, but it didn't seem to cause a problem. The grip on the tool while cutting was so solid.

                                                      The only issue here is... how much weight do you want to cart around for a good saw. I think for the weight, maybe the Farmer is winning? Sure, the Ranger is better, but it's a LOT heavier, and more bulky, where the farmer slips right in a pocket. So... Hmmm... Still testing.

                                                      I also noticed today that the test, on a stick, pinned to my railing with one hand, and cutting with the other, might not be the best test for the bigger saws, where it might be possible to get a lot more force applied. I might see if I can find a little tree around to cut on to really push them.

                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                      • Huntsman Offline
                                                        Huntsman
                                                        Global Moderators
                                                        Posts: 5,781
                                                        Huntsman Offline
                                                        Huntsman
                                                        Global Moderators
                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                        #49 Quote Reply

                                                          Hi Lynn
                                                          Glad to see the Wenger Ranger finally made it into the test :)
                                                          I think the combination of the longer blade with the very comfortable handle makes it a clear winner for sawing.
                                                          Although I take your point about the size weight etc

                                                          If you know you have some serious cutting to do (eg backpacking trip when you will cut lots of wood for a fire) then the Ranger is what you should have in your pack/on the belt.

                                                          When I got my first Ranger I thought the handles were too big and a bit ridiculous.
                                                          Now I have had it a while, and used it for jobs like this I can see why they designed the handles the way they did.
                                                          As you say - it fits so comfortably in the hand.
                                                          It will beat all the others on this criteria...
                                                          Then add in the longer length = quicker cutting time = Winner

                                                          Thanks for taking the time to do the test and making the post.

                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                          • Lynn LeFey Offline
                                                            Lynn LeFey
                                                            Posts: 7,918
                                                            Lynn LeFey Offline
                                                            Lynn LeFey
                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                            #50 Quote Reply

                                                              Thanks. It's been a long time coming to get to the Ranger. This thread is almost 3 years old.
                                                              :facepalm:

                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                              • neillcurrie Offline
                                                                neillcurrie
                                                                Posts: 860
                                                                neillcurrie Offline
                                                                neillcurrie
                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                #51 Quote Reply

                                                                  A few years ago I modded a saw blade to fit in the jaws of my Crunch securely: the Dremelled slot in the end of the blade is ground till the wire cutters close perfectly into it, preventing rotation of the blade.
                                                                  I also made a sheath for the blade, even chose the blade length to fit the Crunch's sheath perfectly, if you have it with you when you need it it might be useful...........though a longer blade would probably be better at cutting.
                                                                  Obviously there's quite a variety of blades out there. I chose one called "Remgrit" which is supposed to be able to cut through pretty much anything.
                                                                  The negative factor with using a saw blade in the Crunch's plier head is that the "handle" part of the saw(the Crunch, opened), isn't very ergonomic. Either wear work gloves, or restrict sawing to short bursts.
                                                                  http://blogericious.blogspot.com/2013/06/leatherman-crunch-saw-mod.html

                                                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                                                  • Spatha Offline
                                                                    Spatha
                                                                    Posts: 355
                                                                    Spatha Offline
                                                                    Spatha
                                                                    wrote on last edited by
                                                                    #52 Quote Reply

                                                                      Excellent test, Lynn! :salute: I'm interested to see how the Ranger does head to head against the 111mm Vic.

                                                                      :popcorn:

                                                                      Last week I was tidying the front garden a little and I was sawing up some branches, so I took the opportunity to compare the saws on the several different tools that I seem to have amassed. I too found that the Farmer seems handle really nicely, in particular I found it was binding up very little compared to the others. The wood I was cutting was pretty green, for what it's worth.

                                                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                                                      • Steinar Offline
                                                                        Steinar
                                                                        Posts: 3,435
                                                                        Steinar Offline
                                                                        Steinar
                                                                        wrote on last edited by
                                                                        #53 Quote Reply

                                                                          Just a :tu: for actually doing the experiment and sharing the result with us. Thanks!

                                                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                                                          • SolomonKane79 Offline
                                                                            SolomonKane79
                                                                            Posts: 614
                                                                            SolomonKane79 Offline
                                                                            SolomonKane79
                                                                            wrote on last edited by
                                                                            #54 Quote Reply

                                                                              Like for the scissors tests, i can only say: thank you! :tu:

                                                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                                                              • Lynn LeFey Offline
                                                                                Lynn LeFey
                                                                                Posts: 7,918
                                                                                Lynn LeFey Offline
                                                                                Lynn LeFey
                                                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                                                #55 Quote Reply

                                                                                  So, I got a 111mm Victorinox with saw (Rucksack) the other day, and decided to go out in the back yard to do a final head to head against the Wenger Ranger 58.

                                                                                  I'd also gotten a Rebar in, and decided to give it a go against the (virtually identical in size) Sidekick.

                                                                                  So, here are today's participants...

                                                                                  I was using a thicker branch than I'd used before. I wanted one to give a better test to the longer saw blades. Unlike previous posts, I was wearing gloves during the test, because it was frickin' cold. This may have some effect on my perception of the ergonomics of each tool, but I can't say how much. I was also being more aggressive with my cuts. It was cold, and I was 'highly motivated' to get back inside, so I was bearing down much harder than previously, and the gloves allowed it with a lot less wear on my hands.

                                                                                  And the findings:

                                                                                  The Rebar and Sidekick were identical in cutting ability. And I was shocked how well both of them cut. I ripped through the oak branch pretty easily with each. The difference in blade position (one being inside open, one outside open) didn't make a difference. The handle on each tool also gave a good grip. the pull-cut teeth appear to like the more aggressive cutting technique.

                                                                                  Next up was the Rucksack. It was even MORE comfortable in-hand, with longer saw blade, but the lighter weight made it easier to handle. It was awesome.

                                                                                  And finally, the Ranger 58. It... uh... Hmmm. I really expected it to do better than the Rucksack. I'm not sure if the saw blade cut noticeably better. What I AM certain of is that it was a much heavier, more cumbersome tool, and for some reason, the size of the grip made my hand cramp.

                                                                                  Okay, maybe I'd just done all that OTHER cutting, and it was messing with me. So, back to the Rucksack, and... no. No problem with the Rucksack. Huh.

                                                                                  I think the extra width of the Ranger was causing me problems. The much higher weight of the tool was certainly an issue. In any case, if the blade was cutting better, the benefit was offset by the worse ergo.

                                                                                  I have to give this round to the Rucksack.

                                                                                  It might be different for people with larger hands, that find the size of the Ranger a more perfect fit. It might also be that a vic 111mm with a lot more layers would be less comfortable in-hand, or that a Ranger without the safety blade layer would have been more comfortable. In any case, for me, the added length of the Ranger blade didn't make up for the discomfort of the tool in hand compared to the Vic.

                                                                                  And, finally, here's a look at the 'test subject', the branch that was used. It's oak with a solid center about 1 1/4" (32mm) thick, and a total thickness, including bark of about 1 3/4" (44mm)

                                                                                  1 Reply Last reply

                                                                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                                                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                                                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                                                                  Register Login

                                                                                  1. Home
                                                                                  2. Tool Talk
                                                                                  3. General Tool Discussion
                                                                                  4. Saw test
                                                                                  Reply
                                                                                  • Reply as topic
                                                                                  Log in to reply
                                                                                  COMMUNITY LINKS
                                                                                  EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                                                                  Operational Funds

                                                                                  Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                                                                  Make A Donation
                                                                                  November Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  Due Date: Nov 30
                                                                                  Total Receipts: $0.00
                                                                                  Below Goal: $300.00
                                                                                  0% funded
                                                                                  • Login

                                                                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                                                                  • Login or register to search.
                                                                                  • First post
                                                                                    Last post
                                                                                  0