New Sarcasm Smiley
-
It has been mentioned that we need a sarcasm smiley, and so here we have a bunch that I have found that we could use. Please pick your favorite, and at the end we'll add it to the forum smiley set. I imagine it'll be the most used smiley around here! :D
Sarcasm Warning:

Sarcasm Big Sign:

Sarcasm01:

Sarcasm 02:

Sarcasm 03:

Sarcastic:

Sarcasm Alert:

Sarcasm On:

Ohhh the sarcasm:

So that's it- you can select up to three of your favorites and the winner will be our new smiley. :D
Oh, and if you type out "sarcasm" too many times or say it in your head it really starts to sound like a very stupid word... :P
Def
-
This might be a very English thing to say, but doesn't "flagging" the fact that you are being sarcastic kind of defeat the object of being sarcastic in the first place?

-
::)
Oh wait, I meant
:P
Def
-
Point taken.
But: On the innertubes, sarcasm can be hard to project, especially given the wide cultural differences here.
I don't think it always needs to be added, especially when responding to another member you know well, but in potentially inflammatory settings, I think it may help.

I know, I know...

-
Now, an emoticon for irony could be useful :P
-
Were you thinking of a little Alanis Morrissette image, or did you want real irony?

Def
-
:D
-
Personally I feel the :P and the ;) and the ::) and the
and the :D not to mention the >:D and the
serve the purpose of replacing shortfalls in the written form just fine 
... either that or learn to communicate better >:(
... either that or learn to communicate better ::)
... either that or learn to communicate better :P
... either that or learn to communicate better
>:DJust testing
Yup, they work fine :D :D :D -
@50ft-trad said:
Personally I feel the :P and the ;) and the ::) and the
and the :D not to mention the >:D and the
serve the purpose of replacing shortfalls in the written form just fine 
... either that or learn to communicate better >:(
... either that or learn to communicate better ::)
... either that or learn to communicate better :P
... either that or learn to communicate better
>:DJust testing
Yup, they work fine :D :D :DAgreed. Some may underutilize the emoticons, I think.
-
Just for clarity I vote none of the above - not needed

-
Maybe it is needed..
I have posted some comments that were obviously sarcastic/humorous and had people thnk they were serious and proceeded to correct what I was saying..
Only today I sort of claimed that Rupert Murdoch runs the BBC and someone pointed out that the BBC is not actually run by him

-
@dks said:
Maybe it is needed..I have posted some comments that were obviously sarcastic/humorous and had people thnk they were serious and proceeded to correct what I was saying..
Only today I sort of claimed that Rupert Murdoch runs the BBC and someone pointed out that the BBC is not actually run by him

i've seen a few cases like this !
-
i like all the smileys ! can't have too many of them in my book.
although i doubt I'd use a sarcasm one
-
Given the limitations of this medium I'd say more emoticons are better. It saves having to explain the meta-message involved in what you're saying; information that is conveyed in body language and tone of voice that can't be accounted for in a print medium. In fact, I'd say more than one would be nice to have, so that we can indicate sarcasm in our own statements, as well as to indicate when we think we see it in others' posts.
A lot of misunderstandings between people happen because even in face to face conversation, the meta-message is misinterpreted. A good book on this aspect of verbal communication is You Just Don't Understand, by Deborah Tannen.
-
@dks said:
Maybe it is needed..I have posted some comments that were obviously sarcastic/humorous and had people thnk they were serious and proceeded to correct what I was saying..
Only today I sort of claimed that Rupert Murdoch runs the BBC and someone pointed out that the BBC is not actually run by him

Actually, as you are obviously aiming that comment at me I will clarify that I mostly pull you up for being sexist. It's not funny, it's not sarcastic, and it's not welcome here. It's akin to any other other kind of offensive bigotry which is something I think you fail to see.
Unfortunately your frequent links to the UK gutter press often lend themselves to the same, as they tend to required naked woman to sell their rather tenuous "news". So over all it doesn't really come across well, and I had a sense of humour failure about it... try and remember this is not a men only forum ;)
-
@50ft-trad said:
Personally I feel the :P and the ;) and the ::) and the
and the :D not to mention the >:D and the
serve the purpose of replacing shortfalls in the written form just fine 
... either that or learn to communicate better >:(
... either that or learn to communicate better ::)
... either that or learn to communicate better :P
... either that or learn to communicate better
>:DJust testing
Yup, they work fine :D :D :DOnce again I've got to agree with Al. All of the above can be used to convey humorous sarcasm.
I will also add that sarcasm is not necessarily funny, even if you make it obvious you are being sarcastic it doesn't mean you've not going to cause offence. In other words; know your audience well.
Definition:
the use of remarks which clearly mean the opposite of what they say, and which are made in order to hurt someone's feelings or to criticize something in a humorous way -
Quite right Gareth, and I also agree with Al that we don't really need more smilies.
If folks can't be civil and respectful of others without realising they are being interpreted as offensive, we're here to enlighten them. How they handle that info is up to them. It's the collective atmosphere that makes a forum; the sum of all it's parts.
-

I thought this was the sarcasm smiley?

I really did..... now I'm confused :-[
-
@Heinz Doofenshmirtz said:
Given the limitations of this medium I'd say more emoticons are better. It saves having to explain the meta-message involved in what you're saying; information that is conveyed in body language and tone of voice that can't be accounted for in a print medium. In fact, I'd say more than one would be nice to have, so that we can indicate sarcasm in our own statements, as well as to indicate when we think we see it in others' posts.A lot of misunderstandings between people happen because even in face to face conversation, the meta-message is misinterpreted. A good book on this aspect of verbal communication is You Just Don't Understand, by Deborah Tannen.
I'm going to go out on a limb here and say too many emoticons can be a bad thing. Words can (if used effectively) convey more than any one of the emoticons shown. Most people here will use our common emoticons in the same manner, but if you start introducing more and more emoticons you run the risk of miscomunication through the graphics, whereby someone would ordinarily NOT have misinterpretted what you put UNTIL you used an emoticon which that other person uses for other tonalities.
There's an example above where ::) is used as a
or a :P Personally I'm in the
crowd, and wouldn't interpret it as a :P ... and at times I've had to think "did they really mean ... that"There's a few fun ones that people use such as the hiding behind the sofa, or the baying mob, or running dog, or whacking hammer. They're great and can add to the fun of the post, but start chucking in loads of extra actual "emotion" ones and it'll get confusing ... and lets face it, people can get very confused with body language, tonality and facial expression too. It's not just words we misinterpret.
With respect to all, if we want extra graphics - fine
However, let's not think ... how shall I say this ... let's not think that recent events have highlighted any failings in our emoticon quota ;) the emoticons were NEVER the issue ... and I shall cunningly withdraw from that topic now :D -
@50ft-trad said:
With respect to all, if we want extra graphics - fine
However, let's not think ... how shall I say this ... let's not think that recent events have highlighted any failings in our emoticon quota ;) the emoticons were NEVER the issue ... and I shall cunningly withdraw from that topic now :Dding
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login






