Phillips Photo Spread
-
I hardly ever encounter regular flathead screws anymore. Seems like most things these days use phillips screws. Some factory automation guys I know say that this is because phillips screws (and torx and hex for that matter) are suitable for rapid assembly line techniques, whereas flatheads definitely are not. Whatever the reason, the phillips screwdriver on my multitools sees a lot more use than many of the other implements. Here's a few pictures and thoughts on various multitool phillips screwdrivers.
25 years ago the first Leatherman PST's had a pretty decent phillips on them. The body and shank were polished, so it would fold out smoothly, but the head was left rough, allowing it to "grip" a stubborn screw better:

The only flaw in the design of those first phillips was their tendency to fold up under pressure. Ouch! In response, Leatherman started equipping their tools with a "bent" or offset phillips. Under pressure, the forces work to hold the phillips open, rather than allow it to fold up.

Later, when the Original Wave came out, it used the same principle:

Meanwhile, across the state line at SOG headquarters, they were using a phillips screwdriver very similar in design to the original PST. SOG drivers have a reputation for toughness, but on the old non-locking PowerPlier and Pocket PowerPlier you can see how this design is susceptable to folding under pressure:

And it looks like SOG continues to use that same investment casting for their phillips to this day. The fold up concern is no longer an issue however on locking blade models like the SwitchPlier or PowerLock (pictured below).
I would like to see SOG include a #2 phillips instead of the little #1. SOG tools themselves are large, intended for large jobs, and it doesn't make sense for them to be equipped with such a small driver. (IMO)
Original Gerber Multi-Pliers came with a full square phillips. The head size was a #2, and the solid shank meant they were stronger than their competitors. Offset heads meant they didn't fold up. The downside?
- Short length
- Full width shank took up space that could have been used for other blades.
- Reports of stripped heads call into question how well the heat treat was on some tools.

The next generation of Gerber Multi-Pliers (600 series and 400 series) addressed these concerns somewhat, giving the phillips a slightly longer reach.

But then on the Diesel they went with a flat phillips blade, which did allow more blades to fit in that handle, but does not seem to grip screws very well. (pictured below)
In my opinion, the best compromise to this engineering challenge is to give the phillips a full size head, but then reduce the shank size to allow more blades. We see this arrangement on the Leatherman and SOG tools pictured earlier, as well as Victorinox and others to follow.
Most recently, it seems as if Gerber engineers have taken a giant step backward. The new Flik has a flat phillips like the Diesel, and the length has been reduced to an almost ridiculous stubbiness:

At Victorinox they had been making screwdrivers for a long time prior to the SwissTool and knew how to do it right. The phillips has plenty of reach, a full head, and a reduced shank. How they actually make it I do not know. It appears as if the head area has been "squashed", with the metal from the grooves being displaced out into the teeth, flaring the end somewhat:

Later on when the Spirit arrived they used the same proven manufacturing technique.
Some folks complain that the high polish on Victorinox screwdrivers causes them to slip easier on tight screws. My own observation is that for some reason the Vic phillips doesn't fit snugly in many of the screws I try it on. There seems to be a bit of wiggle and rock, which no doubt contributes to the slippage factor. Perhaps some difference between European and American phillips standards?
Not one to rest on their laurels, the folks at Leatherman continued to innovate. When the 2004 Wave and Charges came out, they were sporting an interchangable bit driver along with proprietary flattened hex bits. Some people like the versatility this provides. Some people hate the limited reach it restricts them to:

Personally, I prefer the current generation of Leatherman dedicated phillips drivers, like this one on the Kick. (below) It has a good reach, a #2 head that fits into screws like a dream, a textured finish, and is properly offset:

Even better is the one on the Core, which is longer still:

Length comparison shot, with Kick on the left, Core on the right:

How about the other guys? The old original 360 BuckTool had this really short, goofy 3-toothed phillips that was flat on the back side:

Backside of an early BuckTool phillips below. Apparently this design allowed them to squeeze more blades in.

Later on the Buck engineers came to their senses and switched to a full 4-toothed phillips. They also put some little gripping ridges on the teeth, which were intended to grab the screw better. It was still pretty short in length though.

Never a company known for finesse, the crew at Bear MGC included this massive, solid cast beast of a phillips on their tools. I swear the thing takes up the space of three blades. (sorry, picture doesn't show the width properly) It does fit screws rather well though.

Schrade Cutlery's ST1 phillips screwdriver is somewhat flattened, with two full teeth and two shallow teeth. It has decent length to it, and gripping ridges like we saw on the BuckTool.

The Kershaw driver reminds me of the early Leatherman or current SOG style, with its full #1 head and reduced width shank. They did get the offset right though, which is important in a non-locking multitool.

~Bob :)
-
Nice comparison

I personally like the Core Phillips driver best, and the Vic one's least. I also find the Wave/Charge bit exchanger work very good and the bits are tough.
-
Awesome writeup

The actual head on the Swisstool doesn't bother me much, but the odd shaped shank does; sure it's long, but it can't fit into recessed areas...so that kind of negates it's length :P
Those Gerbers though...shiver :-X
-
Simply Awesome Bob. Can someone say sticky!

-
Nice comparison. Never handled a Bucktool and was surprised at the photos.
-
This is simply an amazing post. Definitely should be stickied.

-
great post.personally,I hate limited reach Phillips .a long,thin one is my favourite.


-
Damn fine article Bob, really enjoyed it

You could well be right about there being some differences bettween standard European and US made Phillips screws
, as I've never had many problems with Swisstool's (or Sak for that matter) slipping :). I also thought most people were all for the new LM bit exchanger style, (I'm not) so it's good to know there not univesally thought of as a good idea :) -
As someone who frequently uses a phillips, this was particularly interesting, thanks. :)
I have had slippage with my Vics.
-
Excellent review Bob! I hope this info will find it's way into the Multitool Encyclopedia....

Perhaps another photo, showing each of the screwdrivers from shortest to longest would be a nice addition to it!
Def
-
Great comparison that Bob 8) It's great to see how so many companies had roughly the same idea with just minor (and in some cases major) difference in application of that idea :)
-
Awesome work Bob!
Any speculation on why, if you look at the face of the driver when the tool is flat, the head of the driver makes an X if it's Swiss (and the early Gerbers) or a + if it's American?
-
@Spoonrobot said:
Awesome work Bob!Any speculation on why, if you look at the face of the driver when the tool is flat, the head of the driver makes an X if it's Swiss (and the early Gerbers) or a + if it's American?
That's a very interesting point that

-
@Spoonrobot said:
Awesome work Bob!Any speculation on why, if you look at the face of the driver when the tool is flat, the head of the driver makes an X if it's Swiss (and the early Gerbers) or a + if it's American?
I believe what you're seeing is an optical illusion. If you look at the very tip of the Swisstool's driver, the flat cut on the tip is a +, not an x. The driver appears as an X because of how the outer corners of the tool are "slanted" due to the tool being created from a shaft with a rectangular cross section.
I hope that makes sense...

-
Oh, I didn't explain myself very well.
If you place the tool flat on the table with the phillips drivers out the SwissTool/Old Gerber phillips head is rotated 45 degrees from than the other tools.
That is, when flat the SwissTool/Old Gerber has the cut facing upwards and the other tools have one of the tines facing upward. Here's an illustrative picture with a Paratool and a Spirit.

I'm curious if the rotation is just a product of production methods or if it has any meaningful purpose. I haven't noted any functional difference.
-
It does give you more material to play with and bigger tines as the diagonal distance is greater than the horizontal (or vertical) distance assuming the same basic starting block.

-
Trust Victorinox to come up with such a brilliant idea :)
-
Oh, so ideally you could have a smaller overall implement but have the same size tines due to the diagonal cross-section. Interesting!
-
@micky d said:
Trust Victorinox to come up with such a brilliant idea :)
Ahh but did Vic do it before Gerber? Aren't all SAK philips formed from round bar? (I don't have a SAK with a proper philips :( ) And Gerber had it on their old Multipliers

And yep thats right Spoon!
The phillips on the champ is the same style as the swisstool's :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



