The truth about butane lighters and why you should never get a refillable one
-
Lol, that title sounds sure sounds like a conspiracy theory eh?
But really, I bought a zippo butane lighter at yard sale over the weekend, and in the (failed) repair process I now know how they work and they are designed to fail.
It all comes down to the metering mechanism in the release valve. Instead of a needle valve (like on your propane torch, camping stove etc.) that can be adjusted via the dial on the other end of fuel reservoir, they use a piece of sponge. Yes you read that right, a piece of sponge.
Here's a crude graph of the mechanism.

In the valve body, a lever pull up the release tube to open the valve and butane comes out, but to control how much butane comes out, a piece of sponge (pointed by red arrow) is squeezed by the threaded rod and the more it's squeezed less butane seeps through.
The problem is this piece of sponge gets clogged very very easy. You must've heard how you should use triple filtered butane and all that crap, but the truth is other than this sponge, other passages are like train tunnels as far as butane is concerned, they aren't going to clog unless you started dropping sand in there.
If you have a butane lighter that stops working, it's this sponge that's clogged, everything else works fine but the lighter is dead anyway.
So yeah, don't spend more than a dollar on these things, they'll clog soon or later.
-
I wonder if thats how the Victorinox butane lighters work too? They are pretty famous for not working. All the butane lighters I ever bought stopped working in short order too, so I just buy disposable Bics that work.
-
I didn't know that mate
I'm not a big lighter user as I prefer ferro rods in the woods, but that is appalling that they are designed with such an inherent weakness like that :(Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
-
Yeah, on the zippo I opened the sponge color changed from all the contaminants. I cut a blob from weatherstripping and got it to work for a while, but it wasn't dense enough to work long term.
-
I am a regular user of refillable butane lighters and don't have much issue with them not working. I mainly use Xikar products that have an excellent lifetime warranty. If it does break, which I've had a couple, I send it back for a new one or take it to a Xikar dealer for exchange (if one similar is available).
-
That is fascinating Jie! I have had a lot of problems with butane lighters. They seem to work better if used regularly. I wonder if the sponge gets brittle and degenerates if there isn't a regular flow of butane, leading to too much flow to light or clogging of the needle with degenerated sponge.
Makes one wonder...

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

