firearms
-
@Gareth said:
Interesting that they've gone back to/stuck with a relatively low capacity pistol. The Walther PPQ 45 in the above video holds 12 (if my ears counted right). I understand that there are, of course, other factors that come into play, but you'd have thought one or two more rounds might have been nice.Besides it being a traditional design, it's role as a secondary weapon might explain it's 8 round capacity, Marines are rifleman first. If a sidearm has a primary weapon role, in law enforcement for an example, one can see the desire for larger capacity pistols. I used to have a buddy in the DEA and for his 92 Beretta, he carried 2 extra 15 rd mags and an extra 20 rounder for when things really got hairy. That's 66 rounds. :o
Additionally, a single stack design helps keep an already heavy pistol's weight to a minimum. Something to consider if you carry one every day, all day long.Another thing about it being single stack is the the grip remains relatively thin and oddly, the USMC was supplied with 2- extra 7rd mags.....nearly everyone uses 8 rounders. 1911 designs are easy to shoot well, they point naturally and are heavy enough to tame the sharp recoil but maybe I'm biased by my 41 year history with them. ::)
-
Discovered that in a pinch, the big Vic 130mm Yachtsman sheath also make great 1911 double mag pouch.

And reaffirming my curmudgeon status....notice that those 8 rounders are only loaded with 7 rds.

-
@SAK Guy said:
Discovered that in a pinch, the big Vic 130mm Yachtsman sheath also make great 1911 double mag pouch.
And reaffirming my curmudgeon status....notice that those 8 rounders are only loaded with 7 rds.

Traditionally the 7-round mags are actually eight round ones. The pistol is loaded with an eight-round clip, and the pistol charged. That makes it 7+1. The 1911 wasn't traditionally carried by troops with one in the chamber......
-
Interesting that they've gone back to/stuck with a relatively low capacity pistol. The Walther PPQ 45 in the above video holds 12 (if my ears counted right). I understand that there are, of course, other factors that come into play, but you'd have thought one or two more rounds might have been nice.
Besides it being a traditional design, it's role as a secondary weapon might explain it's 8 round capacity, Marines are rifleman first. If a sidearm has a primary weapon role, in law enforcement for an example, one can see the desire for larger capacity pistols. I used to have a buddy in the DEA and for his 92 Beretta, he carried 2 extra 15 rd mags and an extra 20 rounder for when things really got hairy. That's 66 rounds. :o
Additionally, a single stack design helps keep an already heavy pistol's weight to a minimum. Something to consider if you carry one every day, all day long.Another thing about it being single stack is the the grip remains relatively thin and oddly, the USMC was supplied with 2- extra 7rd mags.....nearly everyone uses 8 rounders. 1911 designs are easy to shoot well, they point naturally and are heavy enough to tame the sharp recoil but maybe I'm biased by my 41 year history with them. ::)
+1
I think you are right on with all of your observations, but I bet this is probably the main one. Going with more rounds would suggest a double stack magazine design which moves a good bit away from the classic 1911 feel, IMO. Look at the 1911 market, and it's obvious that there are all kinds of popular upgrades (sights, grips, triggers, different slide serrations, etc.) over the original govt 1911 design that sell, but double stack higher capacity doesn't seem to be a popular one given how few models are out there.
-
Discovered that in a pinch, the big Vic 130mm Yachtsman sheath also make great 1911 double mag pouch.

And reaffirming my curmudgeon status....notice that those 8 rounders are only loaded with 7 rds.

Traditionally the 7-round mags are actually eight round ones. The pistol is loaded with an eight-round clip, and the pistol charged. That makes it 7+1. The 1911 wasn't traditionally carried by troops with one in the chamber......
All the orig Colt mags are 7 rounders, the 8 rounder is something from the last 15-20 years.
See the difference from an orig 80's Colt and a post 2000 Kimber?
One less hole in the Colt and It only holds 7 rds.
edit: Double checked the 8 rounder date, 1986 (30 years ago). Chip McCormick Shooting Stars which is my mag of choice these days. That Kimber in the pic is made by Chip McCormick as well.
-
Huh, my bad. I thought the Colt was always issued with an 8-round clip. Thanks for the correction!
-
@jerseydevil said:
Huh, my bad. I thought the Colt was always issued with an 8-round clip. Thanks for the correction!Its a magazine not a clip.

Never thought I would see the day I had to
you for this. :'( -
@captain spaulding said:
Huh, my bad. I thought the Colt was always issued with an 8-round clip. Thanks for the correction!
Its a magazine not a clip.

Never thought I would see the day I had to
you for this. :'(Me either. It is a sad day.
-
I can't believe I did that! I'm usually the first one to point that out! Sorry boys. :( -
@jerseydevil said:
I can't believe I did that! I'm usually the first one to point that out! Sorry boys. :(JD the MTO Firearms thread police. Has a certain ring to it.
-
@jerseydevil said:
I can't believe I did that! I'm usually the first one to point that out! Sorry boys. :(Its alright. You get one pass, but if there is a next time you have no excuse. ;)
-
I can't believe I did that! I'm usually the first one to point that out! Sorry boys. :(JD the MTO Firearms thread police. Has a certain ring to it.
Actually, I think the Captain has taken over that position here...

-
I can't believe I did that! I'm usually the first one to point that out! Sorry boys. :(JD the MTO Firearms thread police. Has a certain ring to it.
Actually, I think the Captain has taken over that position here...

Lol, good point.
-
On another note...

https://youtu.be/ttF08RIhlYM... aliens wear sneakers?
-
@Xelkos said:
On another note...
https://youtu.be/ttF08RIhlYM... aliens wear sneakers?
Of course they do.

-
I can't believe I did that! I'm usually the first one to point that out! Sorry boys. :(JD the MTO Firearms thread police. Has a certain ring to it.
Actually, I think the Captain has taken over that position here...

Maybe, but let's face it, JD has forgotten more about weapon history and firearms than most of will ever know, put together.
Nate
-
I can't believe I did that! I'm usually the first one to point that out! Sorry boys. :(JD the MTO Firearms thread police. Has a certain ring to it.
Actually, I think the Captain has taken over that position here...

Maybe, but let's face it, JD has forgotten more about weapon history and firearms than most of will ever know, put together.
Nate
:D Thanks Nate. I've been studying them since I was a little kid, learning how Dad's Mausers were different by helping him strip them down.....
-
[quote author=jerseydevil link=topic=53984.msg1293308#msg1293308 date=1467223405]
I can't believe I did that! I'm usually the first one to point that out! Sorry boys. :(JD the MTO Firearms thread police. Has a certain ring to it.
Actually, I think the Captain has taken over that position here...

Maybe, but let's face it, JD has forgotten more about weapon history and firearms than most of will ever know, put together.
Nate
:D Thanks Nate. I've been studying them since I was a little kid, learning how Dad's Mausers were different by helping him strip them down.....
[/quote]Maybe that old K98 is where you learned about clips?

-
[quote author=HarleyXJGuy link=topic=53984.msg1293315#msg1293315 date=1467223617]
[quote author=jerseydevil link=topic=53984.msg1293308#msg1293308 date=1467223405]
I can't believe I did that! I'm usually the first one to point that out! Sorry boys. :(JD the MTO Firearms thread police. Has a certain ring to it.
Actually, I think the Captain has taken over that position here...

Maybe, but let's face it, JD has forgotten more about weapon history and firearms than most of will ever know, put together.
Nate
:D Thanks Nate. I've been studying them since I was a little kid, learning how Dad's Mausers were different by helping him strip them down.....
[/quote]Maybe that old K98 is where you learned about clips?

[/quote]Technically those are actually known as chargers. ;) "Stripper clip" is the American common name for them but is wrong. Most likely I learned about clips from the Mannlicher-Carcano and the M1 Garand. Those are properly called clips. :)
-
So what's the difference between a clip and a charger?

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login