Ferguson
-
I just don't get it, right or wrong going out and breaking the law sure as smurf isn't going to do anything to help whatever cause you're rallying for.
-
This is something I've considered for a long time, and I have been watching the Ferguson situation closely. So, here's the answer (at least as far as I can figure).
The people out in the streets are not one monolithic group. They're not all after the same thing.
-
There are people out marching, organizing, and calling for visibility of what they feel are legitimate grievances.
-
There are criminals taking advantage of the police having to keep an eye on group 1 to go looting.
-
There are opportunists, who see group 2, and jump in on the looting.
-
There are people worked up into a frenzy, doing vandalism, and sometimes arson.
-
In at least one case, someone killed a guy, shot him to death, then put him in a car, and set the car on fire. So, someone is using all the chaos as a screen for murder. Who knows what the murder was about!
-
Some of group 4 might actually be arsonists, just waiting for an opportunity.
-
Some of the people marching with group one, might actually be instigators, TRYING to start stuff between peaceful protestors and police. The equivalent of internet trolls, but in real life. One article I read called this type of person an 'agent provocateur', but I don't think this definition fits exactly. It's almost more like the Joker, someone who just wants to watch the world burn.
8 ) Some folks might just see all the chaos as a big party. Get drunk, go out in the streets, bust a few windows. torch a car. whatevs.
- People might get swept up in the moment, and transform from one group to another. They start out angry and wanting to make a change through protest, get swept up in a crowd, and the next thing you know, they're helping tip over a police cruiser, because they're so mad.
The point here is that, by and large, the people breaking the law are NOT the people rallying to a cause. I would caveat that by saying sometimes the protestors DO knowingly and intentionally step outside the bounds of the law, like blocking highways, but these are peaceful, if unlawful, acts of civil disobedience.
The rioting, looting, and arson that seem to inevitably come with protests, those are people breaking the law, knowing that the odds of getting caught are severely diminished when everyone else is breaking the law at the same time. Opportunistic crime. During the first rioting/looting back in, like, September, in Ferguson, the police caught (if I remember right) 12 or so looters. 2/3 of them were not from Ferguson! They came into Ferguson to loot, because there was opportunity.
I have been thinking about how to describe this phenomena since the L.A. riots, but I didn't know L.A. nearly so well as I know St. Louis.
I might not be 100% right, here, but I think the model fits the evidence.
My problem is... EVERY TIME I've ever heard of big protest march things like this, there ALWAYS seem to be riots and looting. So... maybe spontaneous protests aren't such a good idea. When there are organized marches, where you get permits, and such, then you don't see that, or at least not to the same degree. Unsanctioned protested seem almost inevitably to lead to opportunistic crime by draining law enforcement resources.
My thoughts on the phenomena. Sorry for the long write-up, but this is something I've spent a lot of time thinking about. You CANNOT think of this as 'those people' doing this or that. They're not one monolithic group. Unfortunately, no matter how well-intentioned, the peaceful types are creating the opportunity for the criminal types.
-
-
We had a similar situation in Athens a couple of years ago, when a cop killed a 16 year old in cold blood (he didn't do anything). The same in Paris, at least twice. And in Istanbul. There are always vandals, thiefs, looters and other apolitical elements that take advantage of the situation to do their job.
-
Nope, I can absolutely appreciate the thought you put into that. Thank you. I'm not sure I could say much any better if I tried.
-
I agree with most of what you have said Lynn. Their are a couple things I would disagree with, but on a whole I think you are correct.
-
I also agree with that list.
What I often miss is group 1 clearly separating themselves from the other groups.
-
Heck people riot/burn/loot after a freakin sports game, so it's basically a bunch of smurfkickers who do it every opportunity they get.
-
@jzmtl said:
Heck people riot/burn/loot after a freakin sports game, so it's basically a bunch of smurfkickers who do it every opportunity they get.That's decadence for you...
@Etherealicer said:
I also agree with that list. +1What I often miss is group 1 clearly separating themselves from the other groups.
The crowds are almost never unanimous in what they want.
Trouble is somebody has an interest in you not being able to discern between the groups...
There is a class war out there and protestors must be seen exclusively as trouble makers though this isn't always the case.
Τα ΜΑΤ συνεργάζονται με χρυσαβγίτες.
2010 ΕΛΛΑΔΑ: ΚΡΑΤΟΣ ΔΟΛΟΦΟΝΩΝ - GRÈCE: Un État des Assassins
-
Can I just say,well done everyone! This is a very contraversal subject,and it's stayed on track and focused!

-
Excellent observation and summary Lynn.

-
In Canada, the only time we see riots are after a Hockey win of the Stanley, or when Canada hosts the G8/G20. The hockey riots are just that, a bunch of whacked out fans that go on a rampage to celebrate the win, or loss of their favorite Canadian Hockey team. With these losers, a win or lose matters little.
Now when Canada hosts the G8 or G20, we get an international group of trouble makers that mix with our home grown ones...and these tend to get nasty. I recall a few years ago, a particularly nasty rumble with the police and rioters. It got out of hand by the police, following orders from very high up, that many got in trouble after the fact for inappropriate behaviour. In fact, there were police undercover agents planted in a few groups to stir things up to allow the police to get all hardcore. It was a giant PR disaster for the government and police forces after videos showing such provocateur agents were often the first to incite the riot. These were only identified after the fact once cell phone footage was reviewed by the community.
I sincerely hope such tactics will not be played out again...because there were a lot of peaceful demonstrators, and the few ruined it for the majority. But yeah, even Canada gets is share of stupidity, and I am unhappy to say this...from both sides of demonstrators and police.
-
Damn, when i read "Ferguson" in the topic, i thought you got one for your new house. ;)
www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=IL2YRDzpTL4
-
Rioting is sparked by many things underlying a group or community. As simple as it may be are as complex the reasons. The types of folks who engage from the onset are those who feel they haven't been heard to the opportunistic, they all have their reasons, right, wrong, or whatever.
LA has had some doosies when it comes to riots for sure as the world saw after the 1992's court ruling. I've always felt those who engage are people who feel disenfranchised and frustrated. Malcolm X said certain communities are powder kegs to which any, ANY spark will set it off.
We had protests here in my city as well as a result of the situation in your city. A few neighborhoods took to the streets and blocked traffic while others marched peacefully thru their areas.
Without getting too political, let me end with the growing "authority" of police in our county is typically the spark that sets these so called powder kegs off.
-
@firiki said:
The crowds are almost never unanimous in what they want.Trouble is somebody has an interest in you not being able to discern between the groups...
There is a class war out there and protestors must be seen exclusively as trouble makers though this isn't always the case.
More like a race war.
-
@Lichtbote said:
Damn, when i read "Ferguson" in the topic, i thought you got one for your new house. ;)www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=IL2YRDzpTL4
I am so glad I wasn't the only one who thought this.
I was so upset when I learned it was a fictional brand. I sooooo wanted a Ferguson.
Def
Sent from my smurfing hunk of techno sorcery
-
I do not buy the idea that the police are to blame for everything and that the mob stealing and burning property is innocent or put up to it by the police.
I am aware of the issues with the police in some countries but to keep blaming them for the troubles now because of what happened 20 or 40 years ago does not seem right. (I am not referring to the specific incident in question, but in general)
I do know of countries where the police is still the baddy (used as weapons by the regime, taking kickbacks/bribes for everything), but this is not true for modern, democratic societies.
And yes, I was thinking of the toilet too...

-
One shall not just ask for trust and respect, he shall earn it with hard work and action.
-
All I will say is that I don't think any of the destruction and mayhem that is going on is necessary.
-
Unless one considers the jury "bought" and the whole system corrupt (conspiracy theory), the REAL pressure on the grand jury was to indict. Afterall, that's NOT a conviction, it just means the officer is THEN actually tried in court on the charges. The grand jury knew that letting him go would lead to protests and likely rioting and yet they didn't think the evidence was enough to bring him to trial.
Much of that evidence wasn't released prior to the grand jury because witnesses changed their testimony after hearing their testimony contradicted the evidence. And the press is simply fueling this for financial gain. It's truly a sad demonstration of what's wrong in American society today.
-
I hear you DKS and personally I agree there is never a reason to react in a violent and non law abiding manner.
What I am referring to is Signs vs Symptoms like in medicine. I'm also referring to what people/groups who riot have echoed long before I was on planet earth. Riots are nothing new as we know and no country is immune. The last few riots that have sparked here in the US have been law enforcement related. What I was stating was those who have rioted have said what I last mentioned in my post.
I should have added government as well others and not singled out law enforcement my apologies. I don't want to get political in my tone so I paraphrased what has been said over the years and most recently. These aren't my views these were and are views expressed.
There are rumor that the "protestors" in my city were "professional" in nature and had other agendas.
Patience in highly charged situations like these needs to be exercised. Take the case back to court, appeal, or any number of responses rather than take it to the streets. I am not a hot head by nature and so rioting isn't something I would take to.
Let me say clearly;
I support all those who have chosen the law enforcement profession and respect the laws that govern my city and state. I have many friends and relatives who are part of this community. I again am stating was has been stated and echoed by those who riot.Lastly, what I never understood was those sports riots
.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login