Maintenance Multi-tool
-
My brother works as a Maintenance in large apartment complex, he loves the ST300
-
MP600 will hold up to the rigors of a farm

-
Thanks for the great feedback.
The bulk of the responses were favoring Leatherman. I was surprised to see only a few Gerber & Victorinox and no SOG mentioned.
I like the advice for the saw, thinking particularly for PVC pipe.
What do most people use their files for?
It looks like you get either file or saw on the Surge but not both at the same time. Is that correct? Can you swap the scissors out with the file or anything?
I have reasonably large hands so I'm not too concerned with tool size. At the moment I'm leaning toward the Surge or ST300 based on their heavy duty build. I like the one hand open blades on the Surge. The bit kit seemed "fiddly" to me as my first impression, but I have never used it. It sounds like it is pretty popular so they may have implemented it well. I like being able to use standard 1/4" drivers since they are easily replaceable. It appears this is the case with the Gerber MP600, but not the Leatherman. Is that correct?
I like the rotation option for the Gerber MP600 wirecutter insert.
Also appreciate the other suggestions for secondary tools (pin socket, bit wrench, etc)
-
You can change out the saw for the file and vise versa on the Surge. Also, if you get the bit extension, you can use 1/4 bits. The flat bits will surprise you. I use mine on the farm all the time and at work. The file is good for smoothing out metal and plastic and in a pinch, sharpen you blade. These are not cheap files. They work rather well
Something else you can check out is the SOG Powerlock. You can change out the tools for different ones and it will NOT void the warranty. Also, you can use sockets on it and 1/4" bits with it. If you are going to cut a lot of wire, SOG pliers are hands down the best, period.That's us mobile.
Nate -
Leatherman uses a special flat bit 1/4x1/8 that has hex sides so it can engage a standard driver. The bit driver accessories and extender both allow standard hex bits and are very useful but can be fiddly.
-
The Surges blade exchanger will accept Tshank blades. You now have a tool that can cut a variety of materials. The metal file for me has been used to knock down burrs. I've also filed down "just enough" material when cutting was over kill. There is a diamond side so you can sharpen your blade if needed. Great thing about the file is it can be removed so you can have the saw there if thats whats used more.
The blade exchanger is either saw or file not both at same time, you are correct.
The scissors are really nice on the Surge. You can mod the tool and remove them however I find when you need scissors, thats what works best.
Pick up a bit extender from LM, this will increase reach as the name suggest and allow you to use 1/4in bits as well. With this add on part you can also use sockets as well.
As far as fiddly goes, using LM flat bit vs 1/4in bits its a draw IMO. The flat LM bits being 2D vs 3D have not been an issue for my usage.
Not bad for all fitting in the LM nylon sheath ( minus sockets ).


-
Leatherman is usually the popular choice and will usually get the most recommendations. In your situation they do offer more potential candidates than other makers in my opinion. Generally they would not be my first choice (long story) but in this instance a Wave, Surge or ST300 should quite rightly be high on the list of suggestions
A few other thoughts
Leatherman Bit Kit: Lose/damage one bit, and you have to buy a full set to get a replacement. The bit extender works with the same driver (Wave and Surge), and converts them to full bits - however the reduced sized driver is still taking all the load. A compatible adaptor for the Phillips on the ST300 or MP600 would be stronger .... or the Victorinox Bit Wrench
(seriously, look into this)MP600 rotatable bits.... avoid!! If you're cutting soft stuff regularly, you will see reduced wear. If you're cutting harder wire however, they are likely to shatter/fracture as they are made of carbide (hard but brittle).
SOG has the compound leverage, but the wire cutters are easily deformed by harder materials, and their internal tools are lacking when compared against Leatherman, Victorinox and Gerber IMHO
Files? Deburring, cleaning corroded terminals squaring up a roughly cut pipe joint.... useful to have, even if not used regularly.
If I was going off to do the kind of work you're looking at, there's probably one other multitool I'd seriously consider taking. You'll probably know them as crate openers, but over here they tend to get called roofing tools... combined axe, hammer and prybar, and for the size of a small camp axe. Consider it the brute force solution to all problems that your pliers tool can't resolve :D mine has been surprisingly useful when it's not sensible to take a full compliment of dedicated tools.
-
Oh, just one more thing (said the wonky eyed detective), whichever tool you get, look it over thoroughly and take it for a test drive before you go off on your quest. Quality slip ups can and do happen, and you want to be sure you find and resolve any issues and address them before you head off

-
@50ft-trad said:
.... or the Victorinox Bit Wrench
(seriously, look into this)Is this the right one?
http://www.victorinox.com/us/product/Swiss-Army-Knives/Category/Accessories/Nylon-Pouch-with-Bits-Wrench/33340 -
@StephenAndMelissa Smith said:
@50ft-trad said:
.... or the Victorinox Bit Wrench
(seriously, look into this)Is this the right one?
http://www.victorinox.com/us/product/Swiss-Army-Knives/Category/Accessories/Nylon-Pouch-with-Bits-Wrench/33340That's the baby
Standard driver bits fit in both ends, and the case comes with a few standard bits and a few empty slots to add your own. Excellent little tool! -
@50ft-trad said:
If you expect to be cutting a lot of barbed wire or fencing wire, consider taking a separate pair of drop forged wire cutters, as these would be superior to the cast plier heads typically offered on multitools.+1 ^
MultiTool wire cutters may be damaged trying to cut wire that is too hard/thick
-
The ST300 and Surge were good suggestions, keep it simple with the ST300
Put a Spyderco Delica or Endura in your pocket and you are good to goI gather other dedicated tools will be available to you
-
Considering scissors are not on you list I think the Super Tool 300 would be a better fit. Nice long drivers. A real phillips. You can also get the bit driver to use normal 1/4" hex bits.
Bit Kit 3 | Leatherman
Leatherman Bit Kit 3 features Phillips #0 and #3, Torx T10–T15, and flatheads 0.2–0.075 in. Includes Hex 4–6mm for everyday repairs and adjustments.
Leatherman (www.leatherman.com)
The ST300 is a simple, effective, tradesman tool. You won't be disappointed with it. Hope this helps.
-
@Marcellus said:
I gather other dedicated tools will be available to youYes, I plan to have dedicated tools for major tasks. Looking for the multi-tool as a go to through out the day when I might not have my tool bag handy.
-
As an ex maintenance engineer I feel reasonably qualified to answer this. :D However I will say that this is still just a matter of opinion and there is always room for personal preferences. For me the Spirit X is the go-to choice. The comfy grip on the pliers and the long screwdrivers are what seals the deal IMO. Sorry to say that I'm not a huge fan of the flat LM bits, too fiddly and too short too often.
If you are going to be doing any serious amount of heavy steel wire cutting then I really think you'll want some dedicated cutters though. The replaceable ones on the ST300 and Rebar are definitely better than the ones on the Spirit, but they still pale in comparison to the real deal.
All the best with the project.

-
You think maybe a pair of 8" knipex bolt cutters? Or is that overkill?
-
@Demel said:
Considering scissors are not on you list I think the Super Tool 300 would be a better fit. Nice long drivers. A real phillips. You can also get the bit driver to use normal 1/4" hex bits.
Bit Kit 3 | Leatherman
Leatherman Bit Kit 3 features Phillips #0 and #3, Torx T10–T15, and flatheads 0.2–0.075 in. Includes Hex 4–6mm for everyday repairs and adjustments.
Leatherman (www.leatherman.com)
The ST300 is a simple, effective, tradesman tool. You won't be disappointed with it. Hope this helps.
Is the removable bit driver compatible with the ST300? How does it attach? on the flat head?
Good point on the scissors.
At this point I am leaning toward the ST300 or Surge.
ST300 Pros:
longer philips bit
has both saw and file at the same time (no scissors)Surge Pros:
has on hand open blades
interchangeable t saw blades
Interchangeable bits (Unsure, Seems to be mixed opinions on)How does the locking mechanism on the ST300 compare to the liner locks on the Surge?
Also note, probably correct on the wire cutters, will plan to used dedicated cutters most of the time and the MT cutters when in a pinch.
-
While i've never had a Surge, it's liner locks are similar/same as the Wave, and the locks on ALL of the leathermans you're looking at are all really solid.
Sometimes blades will have a very tiny amount of play when locked, but it doesn't affect their use, and more often, they're rock solid lockups.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


