Do you find this normal?
-
So my colleague in the UK with a similar job hired in the same time as me (10 years ago) and generally seen as better and more experienced than me was just fired last week by our new boss because "he wasn't good enough for the job". I was assured my position is secure for now and I shouldn't worry... but it kind of blew my mind...
I mean we had hundreds of people getting fired, but either the jobs were removed altogether, or they made a big stupidity, or they fought with a big boss or stole or they were just new and unsuitable... but noone was ever fired after 10 years for doing his job to the best of his abilities and someone could just do it better (and it's not a sales or top management job with set targets...)...
I mean it's disconcerting... after 10 years you're just not good anymore? Then why did they hire you in the first place? What about me? I still have 32 years until retirement... should I be concerned every day that a better person knocks on the door and I just get kicked out? I mean I mean I know I'm smart... but there are 5 billion people there... there are bound to be quite a few of them much smarter than me...
Am I overeacting? Should you have job security for granted when working for 10 years on your job and doing the best you can... ? :-\ -
A person with 2 years experience, or from a different country/asking for less money may be able to do the job nearly as good, but cost a lot less.
You do see a lot of employees get fired, when they start costing more than the company is willing to pay.
-
I wouldn't believe the reason your boss gave, and it certainly wouldn't hurt to prepare for if/when your boss decides it's your turn. Just the impression I got from what you described.
-
@dks said:
A person with 2 years experience, or from a different country/asking for less money may be able to do the job nearly as good, but cost a lot less.You do see a lot of employees get fired, when they start costing more than the company is willing to pay.
I know... that's why they fired the Norwegian guy... he aas earning more money than the rest of the 9 men team, including the Group manager. Also they were shutting down the local office and they replaced him with a German, a Brit and a Romanian.
This time it's strange as I don't think he was getting paid all that well plus they will be bringing another Brit based in London in his place I imagine ...
-
Unfortunately this sounds like a case of simple economic restrictions, absolutely do not believe what the management tell you.
I have employed a lot of people over the last 22 years and I have always been brutally honest behind the reason for letting people go, every single person who has had to go (or has left of their own choice) I have seen as a failure on my part.
That being said employment laws in the UK are actually quite strict, so there may some recourse for your colleague.
-
@jzmtl said:
I wouldn't believe the reason your boss gave, and it certainly wouldn't hurt to prepare for if/when your boss decides it's your turn. Just the impression I got from what you described.Could be... maybe she just didn't want to tell me the details...
Let's hope I pass my Oxford CIM exams... a British college diploma sure beats my Romanian ones... would make a nice ace in my pocket... -
Was he fired or made redundant?
One thing I will say is that there is no such thing as job security in the UK any more - you must always be prepared to find something else.
-
There could be more to the story than they told you then - you'll probably never find out for sure.
-
Could be anything from a new manager "demonstrating strength" to signs of things to come. I won't try and guess what it is in your case, I generally agree with most of what the others here have said already. It is very dependent on culture in the type of business, geographically, and so on.
All companies ask for their employees' loyalty, but from a certain size and/or a certain culture, the relationship from the corporate side will be strictly business (while still wanting the (one-sided) emotional attachment from the employee). One should always have an exit strategy, no matter how solid the company or how great the co-workers.
My colleagues may be my friends, but my relationship to the company is strictly business.
-
What Steinar says fits with my experience very well.
In 2010, at the age of 42, I was made redundant for the 4th time in my life (about the time that I stopped visiting this forum regularly). In those 4 jobs, I had served for 4, 10, 7 and 3 years respectively. I always got good feedback and appraisals from my employers but ultimately I still got the boot - sometimes the whole department got booted at the same time.
By the 4th time I'd had enough so I work as a contractor now. It doesn't give me any more security, but at least I've got money in the bank for when it happens these days!
-
I wouldn't believe the reason your boss gave, and it certainly wouldn't hurt to prepare for if/when your boss decides it's your turn. Just the impression I got from what you described.
Could be... maybe she just didn't want to tell me the details...
Let's hope I pass my Oxford CIM exams... a British college diploma sure beats my Romanian ones... would make a nice ace in my pocket...Making yourself more valuable is the key- if you stay at your current job they will probably want to keep you more as you will be more versatile. If they decide not to keep you, well, you have more skills and certifications to sell to another employer.
You really don't want to find yourself in the position I am in right now- I have done field work my entire career to this point, but thanks to accumulation of injuries, I am really not suited to field work anymore, and, at 41 years old, no one is looking to provide training for something else because there are very few long term benefits to someone who is already half used up. If they are going to train someone, they want someone younger and fitter that they can pay less to and abuse for a goodly number of years.
I'd also suggest checking my insurance policies if I were you- carpal tunnel or some other medical issue or injury taking you out of your primary industry would not be a good thing. experience doesn't mean smurf all if they have to hire someone else to do the work for you.
Def
-
Not normal or not strange.
You may not know the whole story either.I was let go after 24 + years, when management was installed by Venture Capitalist. After a year was
Asked to come back, it was a mistake. I was tasked to help return some business practices and approach profitability. After doing that and more, in a 1-1/2 years, I was separated again and watched as the VC sold my now very profitable division to a competitor.
Loyalty is no longer a two way path, business issues a check and when no longer needed, no more checks.
Always keep resume' up to date, eyes and ears open, and make sure your family and yourself are number 1. Period[emoji106]Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Loop cutter hit the nail on the head. Look out for your own because no one else will do it for you.
I swear sometimes I think we need a section here for members to post their CV's so that we can start out own business network!
Def
-
No such thing as job security. My work just canned 15 staff members, all with 20+ years. Now they are getting paid 30 days for every year they were here, which helps.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Indeed there is no such thing as loyalty at work, either with the employer or co-workers.
-
@jzmtl said:
Indeed there is no such thing as loyalty at work, either with the employer or co-workers.+1 always having a backup plan is important.
Corwyn, if havent in while brush up your resume, and start quietly reaching out to contacts in your line if work. This could just be a case if managment hushing up a potentially embarrassing scandal (employee was harassing colleagues, and was canned for example), or it could be a sign of things to come. You dont want to be unprepared if that is the case, and if nothing comes of it, you may end up finding a better job anyhow.
The bottom line is that you need to look out for you and your family. It sounds to me that your company has already demonstrated they dont care about loyalty to its employees. That should tell you something about how loyal you should be to them.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login