Does crime pay?
-
It will not turn political, unless people start discussing bicycles, again...... :)
-
Perhaps we should add bicycles to the no-go list. Along with can openers.
-
apple Vs PC or android is also no go, from past experience here
-
@Steinar said:
White collar crime costs society more than blue collar crime, both in terms of human lives (fires, bad workplace safety, ship wrecks, pollution, etc, etc) and money. White collar crime is notoriously hard to investigate and prosecute. Crime pays.White collar crimes require a lot of skill, skill that by itself already should guarantee a good income, so it is really hard to gauge how well they pay on top of that. As you pointed out for white collar crimes, the damage caused by crimes is more than the crime itself (we could argue that selling drugs is a victim-less crime, as the only crime is selling a substance that has been defined as illegal, other than that it is not unlike selling alcohol).
From that I would say just because the damage can be great, does not automatically mean that the profit is big too.
@Steinar said:
I don't think a market explanation is very useful, though. Some people turn to crime because they have no marketable skills, some turn to crime because that's what you do in their social circle, and some people are just that big smurfholes.I agree it is not desperation that drives people into crime. It is their social-environment (including the music) and the person itself.
-
music ? :)
-
I voted no but then thought about it more. In the past I have downloaded music, movies and ebooks from torrent sites, and ripped CD's so we could all have them for our cars, all of which are a crime, so I guess yes crime does pay.
-
@Kevin Davey said:
I voted no but then thought about it more. In the past I have downloaded music, movies and ebooks from torrent sites, and ripped CD's so we could all have them for our cars, all of which are a crime, so I guess yes crime does pay.In the past it didn't feel like there was a real alternative for downloading music and movies. The only alternative was buying everything. But it simply is so frickin' expensive to buy CD's and DVD's etc. Yes, I did buy a lot, mainly series and my most favorite music. But most stuff wasn't worth the money they charged for it, so I downloaded it. And literally everybody downloaded music and movies, it didn't feel really "criminal".
Funny thing: those days even people at work were exchanging CD's and DVD's with downloaded stuff.
Why is that funny?
The people i'm talking about were judges (I work at the courthouse) :D
But nowadays everyone has Netflix and Spotify and stuff like that, myself included. These services made downloading not "necessary" and not paying off anymore. I don't download anymore, and I also don't see a lot of the people around me downloading anymore.
-
I voted no but then thought about it more. In the past I have downloaded music, movies and ebooks from torrent sites, and ripped CD's so we could all have them for our cars, all of which are a crime, so I guess yes crime does pay.
In the past it didn't feel like there was a real alternative for downloading music and movies. The only alternative was buying everything. But it simply is so frickin' expensive to buy CD's and DVD's etc. Yes, I did buy a lot, mainly series and my most favorite music. But most stuff wasn't worth the money they charged for it, so I downloaded it. And literally everybody downloaded music and movies, it didn't feel really "criminal".
Funny thing: those days even people at work were exchanging CD's and DVD's with downloaded stuff.
Why is that funny?
The people i'm talking about were judges (I work at the courthouse) :D
But nowadays everyone has Netflix and Spotify and stuff like that, myself included. These services made downloading not "necessary" and not paying off anymore. I don't download anymore, and I also don't see a lot of the people around me downloading anymore.
Same here, people used to sell downloaded DVD's at work and exchange downloaded music. I don't see it anywhere at work anymore and I haven't downloaded in years. I have amazon prime and stream my music off amazon prime music.
Kodi is quite good for streaming movies and tv series though

-
@Kevin Davey said:
I voted no but then thought about it more. In the past I have downloaded music, movies and ebooks from torrent sites, and ripped CD's so we could all have them for our cars, all of which are a crime, so I guess yes crime does pay.It is only "worth" it because you didn't get caught...
Of course here in Switzerland I pay a copyright fee when I buy paper/HDD/empty CD etc. On the other hand, downloading content is legal. -
I voted no but then thought about it more. In the past I have downloaded music, movies and ebooks from torrent sites, and ripped CD's so we could all have them for our cars, all of which are a crime, so I guess yes crime does pay.
It is only "worth" it because you didn't get caught...
Of course here in Switzerland I pay a copyright fee when I buy paper/HDD/empty CD etc. On the other hand, downloading content is legal.That's true
-
I have friends live in busy cities - they swear they pay less in fines than they would if they paid for parking all the time - they may argue that crime pays....
Could be a lot of decision bias there, no idea if they've done the math.
(Whether charging for parking is a crime in itself is open for discussion - If I've paid my federal taxes, state levies, and local council rates, along with the fact that I'm generally parking somewhere because I'm supporting a nearby business that also pays all of the above - I really feel I should be allowed to park somewhere without some git in a raincoat delivering divine justice in the form of a more or less arbitrarily valued fine)
I don't know how it works out on the mean streets of LA - but I know people who can "make a living" selling consumer quantities (ie, bottom level dealers) of marijuana and ecstasy.
Of course, being a tax-free income, they can also claim government benefits as being unemployed/low income - Whether they could make a living if it was "legal" and they had to declare the income, pay a % in tax, and not be able to claim supplements from the government is doubtful.
The ACCC (Consumer protection mob) are currently investigating aussie banks for stooging all their customers with high interest rates on loans compared to the rate set by the reserve bank - So, if you're any one of those bank CEOs / Managers / Other scumbag, Crime was definitely paying for the last few years while they skimmed Australia for 2% more of every loan going than they really should have been.
-
@dks said:
It will not turn political, unless people start discussing bicycles, again...... :)I know what was that guy/poster thinking? lol :D
bossI say yes, think of spam and porn, ways to make money off of others the question for me is "can you hurt others to make money" and some have no problem with that or refuse to think of it.
-
No comedy option huh, boooo.
-
I say yes, think of spam and porn, ways to make money off of others the question for me is "can you hurt others to make money"
Porn and other sex work is not inherently harmful to the members of the industry - it is just a shame that the industry is not well recognised and not offered the same protections/checks and balances that say, retail workers or builders are given (or for a more direct comparison, other entainers and personal service providers. In many countries a hairdresser has more rights than an escort), which makes it easy for people to be taken advantage of within that sector. - In much the same way that immigrants, young people, or casual workers are often poorly treated and underpaid in their professions.
/political
-
Crime pays. So long as you don't get caught.
And so long as you don't get caught, you're not a criminal.
-
@Sea Monster said:
I say yes, think of spam and porn, ways to make money off of others the question for me is "can you hurt others to make money"
Porn and other sex work is not inherently harmful to the members of the industry - it is just a shame that the industry is not well recognised and not offered the same protections/checks and balances that say, retail workers or builders are given (or for a more direct comparison, other entainers and personal service providers. In many countries a hairdresser has more rights than an escort), which makes it easy for people to be taken advantage of within that sector. - In much the same way that immigrants, young people, or casual workers are often poorly treated and underpaid in their professions.
/political
do you seriously think the majority of sex workers in this world are not used/abused?
-
@Sea Monster said:
(Whether charging for parking is a crime in itself is open for discussion - If I've paid my federal taxes, state levies, and local council rates, along with the fact that I'm generally parking somewhere because I'm supporting a nearby business that also pays all of the above - I really feel I should be allowed to park somewhere without some git in a raincoat delivering divine justice in the form of a more or less arbitrarily valued fine)Well, it is availability and demand that drives parking prices.
You want people to move around city centers with public transportation not the car, so you build cheap(ish) public transportation (carrot) and charge for parking or even have a city tax (stick).Btw, the guy giving you the ticket is just doing his job. And it is not divine justice but democratic, you could push for a vote to abolish parking fines.
-
People will turn to crime or commit one for numerous reasons, listing some of them here is pointless.
A few years back a politician here (when asked about him having off-shore companies) claimed that what's legal is also morally right.
I deeply disagree with his view and I mention it just to demonstrate why everyone's perception of right and wrong and what constitutes a crime differs based on their preferences and pursuits. Hate crimes and honour killings are other examples of this divergence of opinion.
In conclusion I'll say that crime can potentially pay off (or anyway, give one what they're after) but in reality it doesn't because it only makes our world a worse place.
@Steinar said:
White collar crime costs society more than blue collar crime, both in terms of human lives (fires, bad workplace safety, ship wrecks, pollution, etc, etc) and money. White collar crime is notoriously hard to investigate and prosecute. Crime pays.I don't think a market explanation is very useful, though. Some people turn to crime because they have no marketable skills, some turn to crime because that's what you do in their social circle, and some people are just that big smurfholes.

-
@dks said:
Does crime pay? (Crime in the general context and not the specific legal explanation)Would people commit it if it was not worth it?

I also remember a quote, that if hard work was away to get rich, then, there would have been a lot more rich people around.
I see people that commit serious or potentially serious crimes become celebrities afterwards. Celebrities that committed crimes making it appear that the crime made them the cool/hard/experienced person they are now.
People losing their money and other people's money and then again being able to start companies, be considered respectful, brushing aside the money losses that affected others.
People getting off on a technicality, or because a criminal act that is obvious to all cannot be proved in court, still being considered as good, decent people, in public. How many well-of people are totally clean or innocent (not the same)
Small criminals being considered as just naughty... Think of "only fools and horses", making it acceptable and cool to steal, a bit, if you are not rich..
Even in prisons people post photographs of the "high life", possibly whilst high...
(the question of whether someone who takes the allocated punishment for the crime is considered cleansed afterwards, is for a different poll)
General Context!

-
@dks said:
Does crime pay? (Crime in the general context and not the specific legal explanation)Would people commit it if it was not worth it?

I also remember a quote, that if hard work was away to get rich, then, there would have been a lot more rich people around.
I see people that commit serious or potentially serious crimes become celebrities afterwards. Celebrities that committed crimes making it appear that the crime made them the cool/hard/experienced person they are now.
People losing their money and other people's money and then again being able to start companies, be considered respectful, brushing aside the money losses that affected others.
People getting off on a technicality, or because a criminal act that is obvious to all cannot be proved in court, still being considered as good, decent people, in public. How many well-of people are totally clean or innocent (not the same)
Small criminals being considered as just naughty... Think of "only fools and horses", making it acceptable and cool to steal, a bit, if you are not rich..
Even in prisons people post photographs of the "high life", possibly whilst high...
(the question of whether someone who takes the allocated punishment for the crime is considered cleansed afterwards, is for a different poll)
People crave social media likes and are willing to do a lot of things for them. They might believe it is worth it, but considering how many get depressed and how short lived the reward is I'm not sure.
The same goes for criminals. In the moment, the crime might be worth it, it's just that the bill is/can be served later.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login