Braided wire cutting.
-
I was browsing the forum the other night, nothing recent took my eye so looked further afield.
Found a thread on cutting braided wire (brake cable). It just so happened that at work I had been using SS braided cable on speSmurfpillst items intended for London Underground.The pliers at work are pretty crap no name jobbies. Yet they snipped through the cable with somewhat ease, which surprised me no end. I decided to bring all the small offcuts home to test on mine.
My cheap Hilka go to pair that resides in a small wooden tool box under the stairs, I actually custom built the box to fit on the shelf and to hold no more than a dozen or so needed tools, 4way screwdriver, tape measure, small hammer, PLIERS etc.
Well, mine just crushed it...peeved I went into the garage to get my "proper" pair (Stanley) cut straight through with a gratifying clean cut and a wonderfully reassuring noise whilst doing so.
My Bahco Cable cutters with special designed pivoted head couldn't get through!!... This I couldn't believe!!
"Okay, time for more tests"
Went upstairs and opened the LM storage box..... You know, I think LM need to go back to the drawing board!! Not a single model of theirs had the ability to cut through braided cable, Not even their EOD MUT!! laughable, unless ofcourse you are a soldier and suddenly find yourself in a situation where you need to cut braided cable...Tip, By a cheap stanley pair at less than a tenth or read on and possibly save a life if not your own!
Tested the SOGs...crushed it
The Schrades...crushed it
Wenger Ranger folding pliers..crushed it...as I type I've just heard a bang near the front door....Yes it's the Signal I bought used. The seller said it as like new, just checked the cutter.....pristine...just tried the cable test...
.....Part Cut, part Crushed it!! Leatherman, you gotta be smurfting me!!
Wait, I'm gonna go test the Gerbers MP 600 series
Well, Well this is an eye opener.
The Model with Carbide Cutters crushed it without severing any strands, the model Without Carbide Cutters, cut straight through...every time.The Victorinox Spirit crushed it. This surprised me too, as not only are my Spirits new they also fared better in similar braided wire tests here on the forum. The mighty Swisstool also surprised me...cut straight though.
Make of this what you will, but I think it confirms to me that leatherman are just a joke. Oh' tested the OHT too....crushed it, surge crushed it, ST300 crushed it Wave crushed it, Juice crushed it.....Yawn! a pattern is beginning to emerge!
-
I've never found a MT pliers that cut brake cables well,I guess it's because most sure cutters on MT's cross each other ,I find that jam up :-\
-
Hi Zed
Have to say I'm stunned by the crude mp600, I almost didn't even try it as I simply assumed as you say they would cross over and jam, yet it was the carbide versions that couldn't cut it!
Go figurei think leatherman need to ask themselves a few questions. Not a single model of theirs could cut the cable! Yet they are by and large the most expensive models tested here.....rubbish!!
-
Have to say I'm stunned by the crude mp600, I almost didn't even try it as I simply assumed as you say they would cross over and jam, yet it was the carbide versions that couldn't cut it!
Go figurei think leatherman need to ask themselves a few questions. Not a single model of theirs could cut the cable! Yet they are by and large the most expensive models tested here.....rubbish!!
I agree mate,oddly it's braided type wire that I've mainly needed wire cutters for,I've only ever owned 1 wingman but I'm sure there sure cutters don't cross as pinch together? Have you ever tested them ?

-
Hi Zed
Have to say I'm stunned by the crude mp600, I almost didn't even try it as I simply assumed as you say they would cross over and jam, yet it was the carbide versions that couldn't cut it!
Go figurei think leatherman need to ask themselves a few questions. Not a single model of theirs could cut the cable! Yet they are by and large the most expensive models tested here.....rubbish!!
I agree mate,oddly it's braided type wire that I've mainly needed wire cutters for,I've only ever owned 1 wingman but I'm sure there sure cutters don't cross as pinch together? Have you ever tested them ?

Believe it or not, I don't have a Wingman!!
For some reason I never wanted it. But I have a plethora of other Gerbers MP 400,500, 600, 650, 700, 800 strata, tread etc
I'll try and test them this afternoon. Also will try more SOG models. I've got some spare bike cable in the garage...if I can find it I'll test that too -
Food for thought... Was the braided wire under tension? A multi that cannot cut slack braided wire might be able to cut the same stuff under tension?

Not excusing the failures... Just thinking out loud. -
I am yet to cut braided wire with any of my Leathermans... but I notice one is meant to cut in an ever so slightly different place than when cutting hard wire.
When you look at their website for, say, the Surge http://www.leatherman.com/surge-3.html?dwvar_3_color=10&cgid=heavy-duty-multi-tools#start=1 and click on Stranded-Wire Cutters it says:"Concave cutters located under plier jaws for use on Stranded wire - smaller gauge wire bundled or wrapped together to form a larger conductor. The concave shape helps to keep the shape of the strands without crushing them."
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
Food for thought... Was the braided wire under tension? A multi that cannot cut slack braided wire might be able to cut the same stuff under tension?
Not excusing the failures... Just thinking out loud.No these were all off cuts around 6" long.
Funny what you say about cutting under tension...I actually noticed that at work, those cheap pliers were noticeably better when I was trimming the cable after it had been crimped inside brass cable terminals. -

I've really got nothing to say but way to go Tosh. Shame there were so many failures and awful LM dominated those failures.
-
I've cut lots of braided electrical wire with Leathermans with out a problem, as well as solid copper and some very light steel wire..
I don't think it is a Letherman, Gerber, Victorinox failure, but the wrong tool for the job.
When it comes to braided steel cable you need a dedicated cutter. -
well, I don't do experiments of braided wire cutting, but I've had to cut it on occasion with my Multitool, and in all these years my experiences have been:
- SOG Powerlock didn't cut, just crushed, and I got to try several times and twist to finally get through. Damaged the SOG's cutter. You can still see the dent in there

- MP800 and MP600 with carbide inserts didn't go through tension wire on a fence, crushed it but it was impossible to finish the job. I had to go and get some proper tools
- Had to cut through two sizes of braided wire in an abandoned building. I had the LM Wave and the MP Pro Scout, the Wave didn't get through at first, and I had to try hard to cut the thinner wire.
Then I switched to the gerber and it went through the thin one in one cut, and the thicker one as well. No carbide inserts = WIN in my experience
I'd say Gerber's normal cutters are the best, and my SOGs are generally too soft for most wire and cable, I've dented three of them so far
-
@Syncop8r said:
I am yet to cut braided wire with any of my Leathermans... but I notice one is meant to cut in an ever so slightly different place than when cutting hard wire.
When you look at their website for, say, the Surge http://www.leatherman.com/surge-3.html?dwvar_3_color=10&cgid=heavy-duty-multi-tools#start=1 and click on Stranded-Wire Cutters it says:
"Concave cutters located under plier jaws for use on Stranded wire - smaller gauge wire bundled or wrapped together to form a larger conductor. The concave shape helps to keep the shape of the strands without crushing them."It's very difficult to see the difference between the stranded-wire cutting area and the hard-wire cutting area... but I believe the former is the tiny concave part.
First pic is stranded-wire cutting area, second is hard-wire cutting area:


-
I am yet to cut braided wire with any of my Leathermans... but I notice one is meant to cut in an ever so slightly different place than when cutting hard wire.
When you look at their website for, say, the Surge http://www.leatherman.com/surge-3.html?dwvar_3_color=10&cgid=heavy-duty-multi-tools#start=1 and click on Stranded-Wire Cutters it says:
"Concave cutters located under plier jaws for use on Stranded wire - smaller gauge wire bundled or wrapped together to form a larger conductor. The concave shape helps to keep the shape of the strands without crushing them."It's very difficult to see the difference between the stranded-wire cutting area and the hard-wire cutting area... but I believe the former is the tiny concave part.
Nope, **under **the pliers jaws ... handle side of the pivot ...
-
They say under in their description, but their pic shows it as being the tiny concave part of the replaceable hard-wire cutters (see my post above).
I have heard others say this - you mean just above the crimpers?
-
@Syncop8r said:
They say under in their description, but their pic shows it as being the tiny concave part of the replaceable hard-wire cutters (see my post above).I have heard others say this - you mean just above the crimpers?
Yeah, I'm pretty sure it's the area just above the crimps
I think they did this on one of their others too. St300? Surge? -
Just checked on their website: Surge, ST300 and MUT all show stranded wire cutters above the head. So either their pics are wrong or perhaps their description is.
I couldn't find any other models with stranded-wire cutters.
It would be good to get to the bottom of this... -
@50ft-trad said:
They say under in their description, but their pic shows it as being the tiny concave part of the replaceable hard-wire cutters (see my post above).
I have heard others say this - you mean just above the crimpers?
Yeah, I'm pretty sure it's the area just above the crimps
I think they did this on one of their others too. St300? Surge?Also on the Core just above the crimpers handle side.
-
Eth's thread... Quick Test: MTs vs. Bike Break Cable
One of mine... High Tensile Wire Cutting Test, Warning: Minor Tool Abuse
The SwissTool and MP600 struggled with the bare steel braid, no issues when sheathed, the Surge and BlackTip cut both fine.
I've found cutting under tension does make a difference.
Leatherman should include the stranded wire cutters (yes they are on the handle side) on their smaller MTs like the Charge and Signal.
-
@tosh said:
Went upstairs and opened the LM storage box..... You know, I think LM need to go back to the drawing board!! Not a single model of theirs had the ability to cut through braided cable, Not even their EOD MUT!!...Yes it's the Signal I bought used. The seller said it as like new, just checked the cutter.....pristine...just tried the cable test...
.....Part Cut, part Crushed it!! Leatherman, you gotta be smurfting me!!
Make of this what you will, but I think it confirms to me that leatherman are just a joke. Oh' tested the OHT too....crushed it, surge crushed it, ST300 crushed it Wave crushed it, Juice crushed it.....Yawn! a pattern is beginning to emerge!
Whereabouts on the Leatherman pliers did you cut the wire?
-
@zoidberg said:
Eth's thread... Quick Test: MTs vs. Bike Break CableOne of mine... High Tensile Wire Cutting Test, Warning: Minor Tool Abuse
The SwissTool and MP600 struggled with the bare steel braid, no issues when sheathed, the Surge and BlackTip cut both fine.
I've found cutting under tension does make a difference.
Leatherman should include the stranded wire cutters (yes they are on the handle side) on their smaller MTs like the Charge and Signal.
Thanks. So Leatherman's pics on their site are wrong then.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login