Alec Baldwin
-
I know this is a it of a touchy one, and I'm sure we all have our own thoughts, but I'm pretty certain we can all be mature about it.
First off, what an absolute tragedy that one person Halyna Hutchins was killed and the director, Joel Souza was injured when a prop gun with a live round loaded into was fired at them.
My thoughts go out to their families and friends, as this is such a terrible shock and must be very difficult for them.
But, if I'm honest, I truly feel bad for Alec Baldwin. Despite his politics, which I will admit I never agreed with, he now has to live out the rest of his life knowing he has caused the death of someone else- an innocent someone, who ment him no harm. Unless he is a complete sociopath, this is going to haunt him greatly, and I wouldn't wish that on my worst enemy, let alone someone I think is just another Hollywood phony wind bag.
There are rumors that there were some tensions between union and non union workers behind the scenes, and some suggestion that a live round was placed intentionally, and I very much hope that the people responsible for that are brought to swift and harsh justice.
My understanding of the film industry is that, ever since Brandon Lee was killed, there is an armorer on site who's sole responsibility it is to maintain, check, load and prepare all of the firearms on site, and ensure that none have live rounds or could potentially cause unintended injuries. Whoever that person is, I imagine they aren't too happy with themselves at the moment.
My last thought, or at least the last one I am going to share in this post, before my inner conspiracy theorist starts showing itself, is the firearms themselves. Why, in the name of all that is holy, does Hollywood even still use real firearms? You don't have to watch a lot of Adam Savages YouTube channel to see that props can be made that are indistinguishable from the real thing easily. So, why use real firearms at all, knowing there is the potential for something like this to happen? Especially when considering the wanton disregard for proper and safe firearms handling that is the mainstay of the movie industry? Not to mention the potential for CGI nowadays that could draw in muzzle flashes after the fact.
But, getting back to the original point, my thoughts go out to everyone affected by this, and I truly hope that anyone who wilfully contributed to this incident is repeatedly molested in prison for the rest ofntheir days.
Def
-
The only explanation I can think of, is that historical firearms were sourced in a rushed haphazard manner by Props and then somehow weren't examined by the Armourer. It sounds like a chaotic set.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
My last thought, or at least the last one I am going to share in this post, before my inner conspiracy theorist starts showing itself, is the firearms themselves. Why, in the name of all that is holy, does Hollywood even still use real firearms? You don't have to watch a lot of Adam Savages YouTube channel to see that props can be made that are indistinguishable from the real thing easily. So, why use real firearms at all, knowing there is the potential for something like this to happen? Especially when considering the wanton disregard for proper and safe firearms handling that is the mainstay of the movie industry? Not to mention the potential for CGI nowadays that could draw in muzzle flashes after the fact.Firstly, CGI still isn't good enough for some things, and those who know even a little about something can usually spot it. Puppet aliens in Star Wars from 1977 still look more realistic than CGI of the current day.
Also, it takes much longer and costs a lot more to get a CGI gunshot looking even half decent, bearing in mind you don't just need the muzzle flash to look right but also have to perfectly nail the lighting effects on *every *surrounding surface, too - Now multiply that cost up by the number of gunshots you have, especially in an action film...Secondly, 'real' firearms again are usually the cheapest option. In most cases they will be semi-auto, so would need something down the barrel to create sufficient back pressure to cycle the rounds, which in most cases would be a chamber insert that reduced the internal space and so prevented a live round from being loaded anyway. Dedicated prop weapons are usually made of monkey metals and would more likely burst apart from the pressure of a live round. In the context of a Western, though, historically correct models of prop may not be available, so live versions are the next option and older weapons with mechanical actions (revolver, underlever, etc) do not need blank adapters to cycle the action.
There are many valid, and semi-valid, reasons why 'real' firearms are the best/only option, but the solution is simpler - No live round should ever be present on a film set. Doesn't matter how real a gun is, if the ammo isn't there to be fired through it.
To me, that is the real issue here. If something is flammable, you keep all sources of ignition far away. If something can shoot, you keep all live ammo well away.
So I'd want to know why the bleep anyone even had live rounds to hand. -
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Despite his politics, which I will admit I never agreed with, he now has to live out the rest of his life knowing he has caused the death of someone else- an innocent someone, who meant him no harm. Unless he is a complete sociopath, this is going to haunt him greatly, and I wouldn't wish that on my worst enemy, let alone someone I think is just another Hollywood phony wind bag.Why are his politics (which I suspect I would probably side with) even relevant?
-
There may or may not be, depending on your perspective, but I do find it somewhat hypocritical when Hollywood actors make millions of dollars using firearms in an unsafe manner on film, then spend their off time trying to have forearms banned.
Mr.Baldwin was a very outspoken anti-gun celebrity, who has now killed someone by using a firearm in an unsafe manner. While it may or may not be relevant, it is ironic.
Like anything else, a firearm is a tool, and, if he actually knew anything about firearms, he would know the one simple, basic rule that starts any firearms training- always treat every firearm as if it is loaded.
If this was a special effects shot where he was supposed to shoot at the camera, that is one thing, and proper precautions should have been taken. There are rumors (and yes, we all know better than rumors) saying that Mr. Baldwin was annoyed at having to shoot another take, and so he jokingly pointed the gun at them and fired, only to find out too late that rounds were live. I desperately hope that this is not true.
This blatant disregard for firearms, real, loaded or otherwise is something I can honestly say, is something that none of the forearms owners I know would ever consider.
Def
-
He is an actor, he is there to act, surely it is someone else's responsibility (the armourer?) to ensure the firearms are safe? I believe he was handed the gun and told it was "cold" meaning unloaded.* A gun in the hands of actor is a prop.
I have also heard rumours that there have already been two previous gun safety incidents on set and and some staff had quit over concerns.- I have seen a "blank" round pop a balloon from about 5 metres away.
-
Why in the world would there even be live rounds any where on the set of a movie let alone in a gun used in the movie.
-
@Syncop8r said:
He is an actor, he is there to act, surely it is someone else's responsibility (the armourer?) to ensure the firearms are safe? I believe he was handed the gun and told it was "cold" meaning unloaded.* A gun in the hands of actor is a prop.
I have also heard rumours that there have already been two previous gun safety incidents on set and and some staff had quit over concerns.- I have seen a "blank" round pop a balloon from about 5 metres away.
Agreed- as an actor he is handed a prop and expected to do the dance that has been programmed for him.
There should have been an armored on site who is responsible for the firearms- ever since the incident that killed Brandon Lee on set, I believe that has been a requirement.
There should have also been absolutely no live rounds anywhere near the firearms used on site.
These are the big questions- how did a live round get there, and how did it make it past the armorer? And, why was Mr. Baldwin firing at the cinematographer and director in the first place? Was it a staged shot, or was he trying to be a smart ass and firing at them?
Def
-
I guess we will just have to wait to find out.

When a firearm becomes a prop is it no longer a firearm?
Can it be both?
Should a prop firearm be treated as an actual firearm (ie treat as loaded, point in a safe direction, identify your target etc)?

-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I do find it somewhat hypocritical when Hollywood actors make millions of dollars using firearms in an unsafe manner on film, then spend their off time trying to haveforearmsfirearms banned.
Granted, I don't know a whole lot about what transpired in this case, but it seems that Alec Baldwin failed to follow another basic firearms safety rule or two: don't point your firearm at anything you don't intend to shoot/always keep your firearm pointed in a safe direction. The set sounds like a complete train-wreck, what with the tensions between workers and a seemingly feckless armorer.
This was senseless and completely avoidable. Perhaps having a rangemaster on set and teaching everyone involved in production some basic firearms safety would be wise.
-
@Syncop8r said:
I guess we will just have to wait to find out.
When a firearm becomes a prop is it no longer a firearm?
Can it be both?
Should a prop firearm be treated as an actual firearm (ie treat as loaded, point in a safe direction, identify your target etc)?

You are asking the wrong guy. I exercise proper trigger discipline with my drill, reciprocating saw, glue gun, caulking gun etc.
Better to be in and maintain the habit rather than have that kind of accident.
Def
-
The only person I trust is myself. I could never take the word of another when handling firearms. At my club, we check always to ensure a firearm is safe, and I will do it even if the guy who wants to show me his new pew pew checked it safe infront of me.
-
@Chako said:
The only person I trust is myself. I could never take the word of another when handling firearms. At my club, we check always to ensure a firearm is safe, and I will do it even if the guy who wants to show me his new pew pew checked it safe infront of me.Trust no-one (not even yourself) is a good motto. Always check, and only ever point a gun at something you intend to shoot is simply good practice.
For decades there was a bullet hole in the back door of my family's home. My mother refused to let anyone fix it as a reminder to everyone (but especially my father) that sometimes a gun that is supposedly safe because it is "not loaded" actually is loaded and can (and did) fire. Some of my brothers and sister were playing outside that door at the time, which led to some very anxious moments until they checked everyone was OK.
-
@Syncop8r said:
When a firearm becomes a prop is it no longer a firearm?
Can it be both?Nope and nope.
It remains a firearm, never actually a prop. This is why you have a Propmaster for props and a separate, dedicated Armourer who handles weaponry.
You can have a 'prop gun', which is a firearm either modified or specifically made to only use blanks and is incapable of even loading live rounds, never mind firing them... but it still remains a firearm. -
In this case it appears there were running problems on this set. I read one article that mentioned a body double on the set a week earlier fired two live rounds not realizing the gun was accidentally loaded with live rounds.
-
The ultimate responsibility for the death of this woman lies with the man who cocked the hammer and pulled the trigger.
It's striking that this anti-second amendment actor,Alec Baldwin, was the man who carelessly and perhaps negligently fired that weapon while aiming the muzzle at a human being.
People such as Baldwin,who work to eliminate the legal,private ownership of firearms by American citizens,apparently has no clue how to ascertain if a weapon is safe or not.Or was he in hurry to get the the scene shot,so he threw the most salient safety protocol,determining if the weapon was "hot", out the window?
All of the people I know,who are advocates for our Second Amendment,would have never made this mistake.We never take the word of another person to determine if a weapon is safe or not.We make that determination ourselves because we abide by the ten commandments of safety.Something that Baldwin didn't take the few minutes of time to do.
As a result of Baldwin's actions,an innocent woman lies dead and anther person wounded.
-
@toolguy said:
The ultimate responsibility for the death of this woman lies with the man who cocked the hammer and pulled the trigger.It's striking that this anti-second amendment actor,Alec Baldwin, was the man who carelessly and perhaps negligently fired that weapon while aiming the muzzle at a human being.
People such as Baldwin,who work to eliminate the legal,private ownership of firearms by American citizens,apparently has no clue how to ascertain if a weapon is safe or not.Or was he in hurry to get the the scene shot,so he threw the most salient safety protocol,determining if the weapon was "hot", out the window?
All of the people I know,who are advocates for our Second Amendment,would have never made this mistake.We never take the word of another person to determine if a weapon is safe or not.We make that determination ourselves because we abide by the ten commandments of safety.Something that Baldwin didn't take the few minutes of time to do.
As a result of Baldwin's actions,an innocent woman lies dead and anther person wounded.
THIS!!!!!!!!!
Even in Hollywood movies, the actors are coached to NEVER aim at the person they are supposed to be shooting. Its all a sham with camera angles that don't show from the shooters perspective that they are actually aiming off to the side of the target. Even blanks can injure, so the gun, even with the blanks, is NEVER EVER aimed at a live person. And this was NOT an accidental discharge. A single action revolver has to be manually cocked to be ready to fire. WHY did Baldwin cock the gun and point it at the people???????
Even if someone put a live round in the old Colt single action, Baldwins actions alone was the major contributor to the death. He alone cocked and pulled the trigger while pointing the gun at a human being. Was he stupid enough to joke around with what he thought was an empty gun????
Apparently he was.
Many hundreds of westerns have been made with nobody actually getting killed. John Wayne to Tom Seleck have a perfect safety record. All the shooing done on classics like "The Magnificent Seven" to "The Wild Bunch" had literally hundreds of rounds shot off, without so much as a blister from pulling the trigger so much. Baldwin shoots a low budget flick while cutting corners and someone gets killed. This after a couple of accidental discharges that scared some people.
Baldwin has some questions to answer.
-
As usual, I am hoping that there are as many answers as there are questions. I think that there is a chain of responsibility that goes beyond a Prima Donna trained monkey.
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login