One of the reasons I keep picking Gerber over Leatherman ...
-
This is an amazingly well thought out post, and I tend to agree with you.
SOG also is able to be used in the closed position, with the handles and head pointed the same way, but I feel the same way about it in that configuration- the handles just open too wide to be of much use.
Def
Sent from my smurfing hunk of techno sorcery
-
I can better appreciate the shape of the Spirit/Swisstool (and normal pliers) now - to prevent hands slipping towards the plier heads. Spring loaded pliers would also help solve this.
I find the Skeletool usable both ways around but a spring would improve it a lot IMO.Are you going to compare with a Wave? I imagine it would be similar to the Surge which I find very comfortable.
-
Adjustable arc joint and slip joint pliers overcome the problem of having the handles too close or too far apart when gripping an item. That's why I often carry a Knipex Cobra pliers.
Incorporating that into a reasonably sized multitool which also has a wire cutter would be interesting.
-
This is my main complaint about the Wingman. The plier handles are wider open than the Wave's by a significant margin so the tool feels too big in the hands during use. That coupled with the spring action and the smooth steel grips means the tool slides backward in your hands during use. None of my other Leathermans seem to suffer that problem.
I must express a dissenting opinion regarding small tools, though. Compare a Squirt to a Dime. The Squirt is a better tool by far. The pliers are much grippier, the wire cutters work, the blade holds an edge, and the bottle opener isn't anywhere near as obnoxious. Only thing I liked about the Dime better was the paint. The Squirt's anodized coating feels much easier to scratch off. They're about equal in scissors; I don't really like the leaf spring design. Maybe if it worked more like a Wingman in that spring tension is removed when the tool is closed, but meh.
-
Great post and interesting comparisons !
-
Thanks for the insight. Honestly, it didn't occur to me to look at that aspect of a MT. I am a very light plier user and mostly its smaller stuff (bending sheet metal on a server housing and such).
Having hands fitting into glove size M I can say I have medium sized hands too (maybe leaning towards the small). So this is definitively something that would affect me coming a day where I need the pliers a lot.It also explains to me the benefit of sliding pliers. I was wondering about that and could primarily see the drawbacks.
Also, up till now, I was wondering why not everybody would copy SOGs power pliers never seeing any disadvantage apart from the added complexity for manufacturing. Maybe I'm not as smart as I thought :D.
Excellent observation, thanks for sharing. -
Thank you all, I really appreciate the comments.

This evening, I will continue where I left off and complete the series of posts as originally planned. After that, I'll address your comments as best I can, and look at taking/uploading additional pics as necessary - including a Wichard multitool with slip joint pliers. I hadn't originally photographed the Wave or Wingman either, so I'll look at those too

-
Great work there.

-
Excellent article 50ft, I look forward to reading the next bit. Thanks for putting the time and effort into this.

-
Very informative, I can see some of your reasons now. thanks.
-
I am going a different route and carry a pair Channel Lock slipjoint pliers with a Crater knife or SAK.
-
Excellent thread Al
I'm in the same boat as you with the average hand size. I hadn't really paid it much attention for the most part until a few months ago. I don't use pliers a lot anyway, and most times, it's not for anything large enough to require a wider grip.It does seem LM is guilty of this quite a bit, with the OHT being the exception from what I've experienced. SOG is horrible with this. That was a big negative for me with the PPP I have. Even though I don't have big hands and don't normally have to grip anything that large, it still felt odd how the handles just continued to splay out with no stop.
-
Continuing on ... :D
Leatherman's handles haven't alwys been as splayed as shown in several of the pics above. In fact when their tools were first introduced, the grip size was a lot friendlier to the more modest hand size than today's offerings. Here is the PST undergoing the same regime.


Of course these were rather uncomfortable tools to bear down on due to the lack of any rolled edges, zytel, or any other handle architecture to spread the load on the hands. That said, even wrapping the handle with a buff, or bandand, or even a shirt sleeve to add some padding, the grip is still more controlable and within the efficiency range for an average sized hand. This is one of the reasons why the older PSTs and Sideclip have crept back into my carry options. I feel the Pulse may be similar in the splay of the handles, but adds the rolled edges for increased comfort. Unfortunately, I just couldn't get on with the locks on that thing at all. In a way Leatherman tools have gradually become less ergonomic as time has passed.
Some would consider these older LM tools to be a more moderate duty plier, and I would consider these next two from Gerber to be moderate duty too.




The MP700 and much maligned BG Strata are much more hand filling than the PST and offer a greatly increased handle comfort. The smooth rounded aluminium scales on the 700 and textured polymer on the Strata offer a very comfortable and secure grip, and in theory should be capable of allowing the user to exert full force against the handles with no discomfort whatsoever .... but there is a problem. If the user starts using these tools for heavy duty applications, the tool itself will suffer for it faster than most.
The reason for this is that both these tools have a hollow plier head which is fitted with a spring return. For delicate tasks the sprung pliers can be a real benefit, and the spring tension is well matched for the size of the tool. It is by no means underwhelming or overbearing, and offers a steady return to the open position, but still allows a good working feel of what you are gripping. Unfortunately, this hollow handle also concentrates the forces onto a smaller area on the main plier pivot itself, and this increases internal wear and reduces the life of the plier. My first MP700 was very smooth to start with, but after some extended usage and a few heavy applications, the pliers developed a bit of slop. This didn't impede the use too much other than the tool wouldn't fully close as the slack that developed in the plier head allowed the handles to come away from each other a bit when the tool was closed. Had these got gone back for warranty on another issue, I could see this increased wear becoming a factor and possibly even taking the tool to failure in time.
The BG Strata gets more of a kicking than it deserves in fairness, purely due to the celebrity branding/endorsement by the guy everyone seem to love to kick. I have used the tool for doing proper work when I had the boat, and the tool did absolutely everything I asked of it with no problems at all. That said, I would say that both these tools are suitable for moderate use on a regular basis, but are capable of the occasional heavier duty use when needed. Just don't use them for heavy duty all the time or you'll seriously reduce the working life of the tool.
Back on the subject of ergonomics though, if you are using these for moderate use, you can use these pliers all day long without the cumulative strain on your hands that you would experience from many other pliers based tools. That again means they are winners in my book. The pliers may take some injury from over exertion or prolongued usage, but your hands won't .... and you can't send your hands off for warranty like you can with these tools. Two very underrated tools for people who don't have to push their pliers to the limit.
-
@Monrogue said:
Excellent thread Al
I'm in the same boat as you with the average hand size. I hadn't really paid it much attention for the most part until a few months ago. I don't use pliers a lot anyway, and most times, it's not for anything large enough to require a wider grip.It does seem LM is guilty of this quite a bit, with the OHT being the exception from what I've experienced. SOG is horrible with this. That was a big negative for me with the PPP I have. Even though I don't have big hands and don't normally have to grip anything that large, it still felt odd how the handles just continued to splay out with no stop.
Even though we all suspected it, I still think it's quite brave of you to talk so openly about it
. -
Excellent thread Al
I'm in the same boat as you with the average hand size. I hadn't really paid it much attention for the most part until a few months ago. I don't use pliers a lot anyway, and most times, it's not for anything large enough to require a wider grip.It does seem LM is guilty of this quite a bit, with the OHT being the exception from what I've experienced. SOG is horrible with this. That was a big negative for me with the PPP I have. Even though I don't have big hands and don't normally have to grip anything that large, it still felt odd how the handles just continued to splay out with no stop.
Even though we all suspected it, I still think it's quite brave of you to talk so openly about it
.
-
Excellent thread Al
I'm in the same boat as you with the average hand size. I hadn't really paid it much attention for the most part until a few months ago. I don't use pliers a lot anyway, and most times, it's not for anything large enough to require a wider grip.It does seem LM is guilty of this quite a bit, with the OHT being the exception from what I've experienced. SOG is horrible with this. That was a big negative for me with the PPP I have. Even though I don't have big hands and don't normally have to grip anything that large, it still felt odd how the handles just continued to splay out with no stop.
Even though we all suspected it, I still think it's quite brave of you to talk so openly about it
.
Oh man, I really set myself up for that one huh? I didn't even realize it either
-
And finally .... The one that really surprised me.
I only discovered the real star of the show in respect of pliers ergonomics fairly recently, and even so it wasn't until I started putting this comparison together (or at least preparing for it) that I really noticed just how good these pliers really were in comparison to it's competitors in terms of ergonomics. Some of you will not be happy about this though.
It's a Gerber ....
... and it's a Chinese made one at that ....
Ignore all those purile "Chinese garbage" stereotypes though, just put all your prejudices aside for a moment, and take a look why for me the Gerber Diesel is probably "best in class" of all the 4.1/2" framed pliers based multitools when it comes to comfort and control when using the pliers


The longer wire cutters move the main gripping area forward, meaning the pliers don't need to open as wide to grip something the same size, and the handles start from a sensible position too. Added together the Gerber Diesel offers better control and ergonomics not just over it's 4.1/2" competition, but also many tools in the 4" frame size too.
For a direct comparison of the frame size, let's pull back up the photos of the Swisstool and ST300 from the beginning of this thread ...


As you can clearly see there is a massive difference in the control and comfort of these tools. In fact I probably have more purchase on the Diesel handles when gripping a 17.5mm diameter object, than I do on the Swisstool and ST300 when they are in the CLOSED position ...


Obviously this is merely one factor of this particular tool. Some people may absolutely have to have the indexable cutters of the ST300, or the pry capabilities of the Swisstool, or the reach of the screwdrivers of either tool - but when it comes to using your pliers for applying gripping force and your hands not feeling like a tank has run over them by the end of the day, the Diesel here is a big winner. Here is a full framed multitool which actually allows the user to harness the full potential from the tool's pliers.
The hand is working well within the efficiency range, the forces from the hand are applied effectively and efficietly to the handle, the load is spread comfortable everywhere is contacts the hand, it's not pinchy, there's minimal hotspots .... why the bloody hell can't anyone else make tools like this? For the fans of the MP600, this close relative also offers a woodsaw (absent from all other models), and the drivers (albeit no full 3D Phillips) offer a bit better length than the MP600. It kind of leaves me wondering not just why other companies aren't making tools this ergonomic, but why it took me so long to zone in on this tool and realise that a solution to the problem of the "legs akimbo" handle trend was already out there.
To be honest, I only really discovered this gem after the fate of the boat had been sealed, and so I haven't had to use this in the heavier applications that I had to subject other tools to. In all honesty I don't know how durable the teeth on the pliers are. I don't know how durable the wire cutters are ... though there is no hard wire notch provided, so I suspect these might be easily damaged in hard wire cutting, especially considering the acute edge geometry. That said, this is still a tool I am really glad to have bought to try, and one that I hope will serve me for a long time because I know my hands will be subject to far less wear and tear as a result of using them over more expensive alternatives. It might not be the best tool for every job out there, but I have every confidence I will get good service from it
Thanks for bearing with me this long through my rambling. Hope it was worth it :D

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login