firearms
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Huh. I've never thought to use a snap cap in a shot gun. Snap caps are important for rimfire, but I thought all modern centerfire (and a shotgun is really just another kind of centerfire) were fine to dry fire. Maybe that's not true, but I've dry fired a lot of shotguns a lot of times and have never had a firing pin problem.
Regardless, I'd probably just make my own "snap cap" out of an old shotgun shell.
On to another question:
When shoot clays, is there a significant disadvantage to using a 20 ga (in comparison to 12 ga), because there are fewer pellets going down range? I always sort of figured it was theoretical only, but maybe that's not true.
Regardless, I prefer the gentler kick of the 20ga.
Can't say as I have ever dry fired a shotgun.
Never seen a shotgun cap cap for sure. Learn something new everyday.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Huh. I've never thought to use a snap cap in a shot gun. Snap caps are important for rimfire, but I thought all modern centerfire (and a shotgun is really just another kind of centerfire) were fine to dry fire. Maybe that's not true, but I've dry fired a lot of shotguns a lot of times and have never had a firing pin problem.

Regardless, I'd probably just make my own "snap cap" out of an old shotgun shell.
On to another question:
When shoot clays, is there a significant disadvantage to using a 20 ga (in comparison to 12 ga), because there are fewer pellets going down range? I always sort of figured it was theoretical only, but maybe that's not true.
Regardless, I prefer the gentler kick of the 20ga.
Can't say as I have ever dry fired a shotgun.
Never seen a shotgun cap cap for sure. Learn something new everyday.
At the end of the day, do you fire off the last shells or do you rack them out? If you rack them out, how do you relieve trigger pressure?
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
Huh. I've never thought to use a snap cap in a shot gun. Snap caps are important for rimfire, but I thought all modern centerfire (and a shotgun is really just another kind of centerfire) were fine to dry fire. Maybe that's not true, but I've dry fired a lot of shotguns a lot of times and have never had a firing pin problem.

Regardless, I'd probably just make my own "snap cap" out of an old shotgun shell.
On to another question:
When shoot clays, is there a significant disadvantage to using a 20 ga (in comparison to 12 ga), because there are fewer pellets going down range? I always sort of figured it was theoretical only, but maybe that's not true.
Regardless, I prefer the gentler kick of the 20ga.
Can't say as I have ever dry fired a shotgun.
Never seen a shotgun cap cap for sure. Learn something new everyday.
At the end of the day, do you fire off the last shells or do you rack them out? If you rack them out, how do you relieve trigger pressure?
Like keep my shotgun unloaded?

-
@Mr. Whippy said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
Huh. I've never thought to use a snap cap in a shot gun. Snap caps are important for rimfire, but I thought all modern centerfire (and a shotgun is really just another kind of centerfire) were fine to dry fire. Maybe that's not true, but I've dry fired a lot of shotguns a lot of times and have never had a firing pin problem.

Regardless, I'd probably just make my own "snap cap" out of an old shotgun shell.
On to another question:
When shoot clays, is there a significant disadvantage to using a 20 ga (in comparison to 12 ga), because there are fewer pellets going down range? I always sort of figured it was theoretical only, but maybe that's not true.
Regardless, I prefer the gentler kick of the 20ga.
Can't say as I have ever dry fired a shotgun.
Never seen a shotgun cap cap for sure. Learn something new everyday.
At the end of the day, do you fire off the last shells or do you rack them out? If you rack them out, how do you relieve trigger pressure?
Like keep my shotgun unloaded?

:D
Somehow, I hear banjos in my head when I read that. ;)
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
@Mr. Whippy said:
[quote author=Mr. Whippy link=topic=53984.msg1054953#msg1054953 date=1426694464]
Huh. I've never thought to use a snap cap in a shot gun. Snap caps are important for rimfire, but I thought all modern centerfire (and a shotgun is really just another kind of centerfire) were fine to dry fire. Maybe that's not true, but I've dry fired a lot of shotguns a lot of times and have never had a firing pin problem.
Regardless, I'd probably just make my own "snap cap" out of an old shotgun shell.
On to another question:
When shoot clays, is there a significant disadvantage to using a 20 ga (in comparison to 12 ga), because there are fewer pellets going down range? I always sort of figured it was theoretical only, but maybe that's not true.
Regardless, I prefer the gentler kick of the 20ga.
Can't say as I have ever dry fired a shotgun.
Never seen a shotgun cap cap for sure. Learn something new everyday.
At the end of the day, do you fire off the last shells or do you rack them out? If you rack them out, how do you relieve trigger pressure?
Like keep my shotgun unloaded?

:D
Somehow, I hear banjos in my head when I read that. ;)
[/quote]That's funny.
-
this thread is deceiving... I was expecting far more of this:

:P
-
I have shotgun caps like the ones below.

They are really designed for people who store their gun assembled. You put them in and fire the gun. Unfortunately after a few times they begin to crack.. (especially if you take the gun apart and try to fire the pins using them, hitting the plastic instead of the metal...
)A used cartridge sound like a good idea, but, if you get into the habit of firing your gun with them to relieve the pressure on the springs (many people do that) there is always the chance that you will get a loaded cartridge/shell accidentally and use that since they look the same.
On most modern double barrel shotguns when you take the gun apart for storage you also cock, automatically, the pins. When I take the gun apart I use a piece of hard plastic to fire the pins which I keep in the case.
With respect to the springs getting damaged (softening or breaking) if kept under pressure/tension opinions vary. Some say it does not matter (and from a purely theoretical physics point of view it should not affect them) but, as we know when we leave a knife backspring "loaded" to soften it, if you do it the spring softens. I believe that this is because some microcracks happen in the spring, making it weaker.
With respect to dry firing your pins, the issue is twofold - you may damage/distort/break the pins OR make the hole through which they stick out larger by letting the fire through it without anything to stop it. It all depends on the size of the pins, the overall firing system, the quality etc.
Personally I always like to release the pressure on the springs, gently, especially on older and/or handmade guns where it may be very hard to find a replacement spring
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
When shoot clays, is there a significant disadvantage to using a 20 ga (in comparison to 12 ga), because there are fewer pellets going down range? I always sort of figured it was theoretical only, but maybe that's not true.In my opinion, it's theoretical. I've broken way too many clays with my 20ga pump gun. There are many speSmurfpillst trap and skeet guns chambered for 28ga, as well as many dedicated upland bird guns also chambered for the 28. I feel that the smaller guns handle easier than a 12, though this is in the case of shotguns like my old Stevens pump that were built specifically for the smaller shell and are lighter and a bit more graceful than a 12.
-
@dks said:
With respect to the springs getting damaged (softening or breaking) if kept under pressure/tension opinions vary. Some say it does not matter (and from a purely theoretical physics point of view it should not affect them) but, as we know when we leave a knife backspring "loaded" to soften it, if you do it the spring softens. I believe that this is because some microcracks happen in the spring, making it weaker.I personally am not sure where I fall on this. I do know the springs will weaken with use. Being compressed and decompressed over and over again. As far as leaving a spring compressed goes I do not think you can compare a knifes back spring and a firearms magazine or firing pin spring as one in the same. They are completely different springs and will react differently. All I know is people have found 1911 magazines fully loaded from World War 1 and fired them through a 1911 without issue. Take it for what it is, but that's a looooong time to have a spring compressed and it functioned perfectly. Now think about how much better the metal and springs are we are using now a days and you should not have any problems leaving a spring compressed. With all this said I still release any spring tension like on a striker fired pistol, but theoretically you should be good either way.
As far as snap caps go I never use them and probably never will. I can see the need for rimfire, but I still do not use them. For center fire I guess it is possible to cause damage to the hole that the firing pin protrudes from, but honestly I have never seen it happen and it is not a issue for me. I'm not saying snap caps are not a good idea though.
-
I bought them so that I could safely practise loading the shotgun for competition down the road...in my home. Not all that keen using used shells....from a safety standpoint.
-
Do you?

I thought it might be advantageous to be able to practice speed loading single shells into the chamber. That is why I bought those two snap caps. So that I could do that safely and hone my skills. I hear it is a good thing to train your muscle memory.
-
It is interesting.
There is a strong school of thought that practicing loading with snap caps encourages lazy thinking and careless handling of ammunition. These folks say, "Look, you're practicing with something you know is safe. Either you treat live ammunition differently (knowing that it's real) or you encourage careless handling of live ammunition (because you've trained to harmless snap caps, which may lead to unnecessaary carelessness with live ammo.)"
If you want to really practice, I would suggest installing a filed off firing pin and practice with live ammo. On an 870, swapping firing pins isn't all that difficult (from what I've seen ).
-
No thanks. Not in my house. :D
-
Got an itchy trigger finger, huh? ;)
I've loaded and unloaded guns in my home for years and years. No misfires, no holes in the ceiling. Do you have difficulties accidentally discharging nailguns too?

-
I've also loaded and unloaded my rifles in my home many times using live ammo. Personally the only "snap caps" I have are eight .30-06 rounds that have been reloaded without powder or primer, and have a small hole drilled in them. Why eight? So they will fill an M-1 Garand clip. For my 03A3, I only need five. :)
-
No I don't actually, but would rather not chance it in the house. I find safer alternatives to practice.
-
We have trickier laws for all of this here in Canada too.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
