Quick Test: MTs vs. Bike Break Cable
-
So, recently I had to replace a bike break cable (about 1.5mm in diameter). Not particularly difficult material to cut, or is it?
I had my MP-600 handy but it didn't work too well, so I did a little comparison
The Contenders
Knipex pliers, well used, well tried, for me the gold standard
MP-600, got this from Stew looking new but I have no idea how fresh it is.
Surge, brand new and barely used wire-cutters
Spirit, unused wire-cutters
Re-Charge, last minute addition because it was laying around, unused wire-cutters.Result
The picture shows representative results, in the end I did the cutting multiple-times.
KNIPEX. As expected, the Knipex performed admirably.LOOSERS
With the MP-600 and SURGE, the break-cable bent and went in-between the cutters (tested both parts, regular cutters and hard-wire cutters with no difference). Of course its possible to cut with those but you need to bend the cable back and forth and turn and twist the cable and cut multiple times.WINNERS
Both the SPIRIT and the RE-CHARGE simply clipped the cable into two pieces producing a clean cut.

-
Some detailed views of the LOOSERS
MP-600
Surge
After the first round, I was a bit taken aback that the Re-Charge did so well. So I went back for a second try with the Surge (same result). I then decided that for a representative overview, I should do 10 cuts each but this did not change the result a bit.
SPIRIT
Being mocked for its "inferior" wirecutters I think it did perform best (although the difference to the Re-Charge is marginal). Because I think the difference between Surge and Re-Charge might be due to manufacturing tolerance I tested two more Spirits (I don't have more Surges, Charges, Waves or MP-600). Both of those Spirits showed the same result as the first one, cutting the break-cable effortlessly.


-
How did the Surge go with the handle side stranded-wire cutters?

-
@zoidberg said:
How did the Surge go with the handle side stranded-wire cutters?
Didn't think of that (Surge noob)
Surge redeemed himself at first. That way it worked really well, 3-times. On the forth it got stuck, which is a real problem because the legs of the Surge buckled when I tried to open it up (a problem I did not have when using the pliers side wire-cutters).
End result was 7 clean cuts, 3-times it did not cut completely and twice of those got stuck badly. Because its quite a nuisance when it gets stuck, I would still count the Surge as a LOOSER, although it is capable to deliver a clean cut.

-
Ive never had much luck cutting brake/gear cables with mt's, my old wave failed many times, nice to know that my spirit might do better
,im oddly surprised as many say that the spirits wire cutters arnt that good
,need to try mine out now
,might even try the st1 vs spirit vs pst2 
-
What's this ??? Where's the SOG Powerlock to test

-
Thanks for those tests, Beat.

@Etherealicer said:
...
SPIRIT
Being mocked for its "inferior" wirecutters I think it did perform best (although the difference to the Re-Charge is marginal). Because I think the difference between Surge and Re-Charge might be due to manufacturing tolerance I tested two more Spirits (I don't have more Surges, Charges, Waves or MP-600). Both of those Spirits showed the same result as the first one, cutting the break-cable effortlessly.Not surprised one bit.
You misread the "inferior" wirecutters comments. The Spirit and Swisstool are excellent wire cutters for hard wire, fencing wire, ... anything heavy duty. Where they fail is at cutting soft, stranded wire. -
I guess the real issue is why you want to sabotage someone's bike. >:D
-
Thanks for the insight

I'm surprised at the difference between the Surge and Rebar plier heads. Or am I
yes, I think I am. I'd expect a bit of inconsistency but not on that spectrum.MP600 is a shame. I'm pretty sure a fresh MP700 would romp through it, but develop pivot play (too) quickly due to the internal spring. I'd expect the unsprung MP600 to not develop pivot play as easily
Glad to hear about the Spirit. I wasn't altogether sure how it would fare with it being stranded despite not being soft fine strands (which is where it mainly struggles)
-
@sawman said:
What's this ??? Where's the SOG Powerlock to test
In the mail from you to me, maybe

No, the only SOG I own is a Pocket Powerpliers and CrossGrip.
Pocket Powerpliers: Eat the cable like it was spaghetti.
CrossGrip: Surprisingly, the cable did not get stuck, but I also did not manage to cut the cable and my hand hurts now (I gave up after the second try). I kinda feel that with a better grip it could do it, if I find some tubes that fit over the handle I might try again.
Also tested the Squirt: It got stuck really badly. Ultimately I used to pliers to grip the tip and open it. Only one try here.


-
@50ft-trad said:
Thanks for the insight
I'm surprised at the difference between the Surge and Rebar plier heads. Or am I
yes, I think I am. I'd expect a bit of inconsistency but not on that spectrum.MP600 is a shame. I'm pretty sure a fresh MP700 would romp through it, but develop pivot play (too) quickly due to the internal spring. I'd expect the unsprung MP600 to not develop pivot play as easily
Glad to hear about the Spirit. I wasn't altogether sure how it would fare with it being stranded despite not being soft fine strands (which is where it mainly struggles)
Rebar vs. Surge: Me too, I wish I had more than one, just to check if its manufacturing, but I don't. I can't detect any play with either pliershead.
The MP-600 has some minimal play to begin with (I estimate that I can move the tips of the jaws less than half a mm). How does the MP-600 do with soft fine strands?
-
@powernoodle said:
I guess the real issue is why you want to sabotage someone's bike. >:DWhat can I say, he was in my spot. That was my spots...

-
@enki_ck said:
Thanks for those tests, Beat.
...
SPIRIT
Being mocked for its "inferior" wirecutters I think it did perform best (although the difference to the Re-Charge is marginal). Because I think the difference between Surge and Re-Charge might be due to manufacturing tolerance I tested two more Spirits (I don't have more Surges, Charges, Waves or MP-600). Both of those Spirits showed the same result as the first one, cutting the break-cable effortlessly.Not surprised one bit.
You misread the "inferior" wirecutters comments. The Spirit and Swisstool are excellent wire cutters for hard wire, fencing wire, ... anything heavy duty. Where they fail is at cutting soft, stranded wire.Thanks for the attitude adjustment (wow, that is an obscure movie reference, ten points for house MT.O if you get it :P).
-
You meant squirt, not Micra :D
With my ST300, I do cut stranded wire regularly (clothesline) but use the handle side, special stranded wire cutters. the pliers cutters are not very good for that
-
@dks said:
You meant squirt, not Micra :DWith my ST300, I do cut stranded wire regularly (clothesline) but use the handle side, special stranded wire cutters. the pliers cutters are not very good for that
There is no proof I ever wrote Micra :P, also I wrote this in the morning BEFORE the alarm went off, so technically, I was still asleep.
I tested that with the Surge too (that is the same pliers-head, right?). It got stuck, so it might depend very much on the composition of your stranded wire. Or it might be manufacturing tolerance. Strangely enough, the Rebar pliers-head did cut it well with the pliers cutters.
-
How did the Surge go with the handle side stranded-wire cutters?

Thank you lol
Ps: "Brake" ;-)
Nonononono... it's break because it gives you a short break from your ultimate collision with death... or sumsing...

Oh and in case you missed the Surge handle side stranded-wire cutters test... it failed!
-
Thanks for those tests, Beat.

...
SPIRIT
Being mocked for its "inferior" wirecutters I think it did perform best (although the difference to the Re-Charge is marginal). Because I think the difference between Surge and Re-Charge might be due to manufacturing tolerance I tested two more Spirits (I don't have more Surges, Charges, Waves or MP-600). Both of those Spirits showed the same result as the first one, cutting the break-cable effortlessly.Not surprised one bit.
You misread the "inferior" wirecutters comments. The Spirit and Swisstool are excellent wire cutters for hard wire, fencing wire, ... anything heavy duty. Where they fail is at cutting soft, stranded wire.Thanks for the attitude adjustment (wow, that is an obscure movie reference, ten points for house MT.O if you get it :P).
Dazed and Confused?

-
Spirit FTW! :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login