firearms
-
@gdoolittle said:
Update on my Shield situation:Heard from the gun store owner i bought the gun from who I was having shoot my gun for diagnosis. He shot 200-250 rounds through the gun until, get this....
The frame cracked.
Yup. My brand new S&W M&P, performance center no less, frame cracked at 800 or so rounds. That being said, I completely trust the guy who was shooting it. He seems like a great guy and definitely knows his firearms and how to handle them, so I am not faulting him at all for this. He is also handling this situation very well for me. He is going to deal with S&W directly with the faulty gun and as soon as he gets another of these guns in stock, he will give it to me (with paperwork and everything of course) He has been great to deal with through the whole process.
So, when I get my 2nd brand new Shield I will post another update.
OK not heard of that before, good to hear you have a good gunshop to deal with

-
Wow, that's disappointing. :-\
-
Here is a picture that he sent.

-
Bloody hell.:o I though we were talking about some hairline crack, not the grand canyon! :ahhh
-
Good job that didn't fail while you were using it

-
Good job that didn't fail while you were using it

+1 Yikes!
Maybe you need to consider trading the replacement in on something else.
I would consider it but given the track record that s&w usually has and the fact that it is made in my own country I think I will stick with it. Plus the store owner didn't really offer to let me swap, he just offered me a new gun of the same model. If i were to swap though it would be for the Springfield xds.
-
I've seen polymer fail in that manner before. S&W Sigma, wasn't there when it happened but I've handled the corpse. You can find others like that. This looks like it sprung, the molding was wrong and the internal tensions were bad to begin with. Reason why Glock (both in Austria and the US made ones) get sonogrammed.
One question. Everything you fed it was jacketed, right? I've seen photos of a Glock that failed like this, after someone who couldn't read the manual had fed it a lot of soft cast bullets, not even gas checked. Ultimate THOU SHALT NOT with polygonal rifling- don't know if the M&P has that or not.
Also seen steel and aluminum frames fail more spectacularly.
-
Never been around when one let go (fortunately ) but have seen some of the results. Can happen with anything, but thankfully not common. Some years back in Virginia someone was killed when a shooter several lanes over put a modern load in an old damascus-barrel shotgun and it blew up.




-
@Smashie said:
I saw a post on twitter this morning that someone was confused as to the purpose of a four barrel rifle. It reminded me of the work by Johann Fanzoj and his Vierling safari riflehttp://www.fanzoj.com/en/gunroom/custom_built_weapons/other_rifles/vierling.html
Yeah <u>that's</u> awesome!!!
-
@ironraven said:
I've seen polymer fail in that manner before. S&W Sigma, wasn't there when it happened but I've handled the corpse. You can find others like that. This looks like it sprung, the molding was wrong and the internal tensions were bad to begin with. Reason why Glock (both in Austria and the US made ones) get sonogrammed.One question. Everything you fed it was jacketed, right? I've seen photos of a Glock that failed like this, after someone who couldn't read the manual had fed it a lot of soft cast bullets, not even gas checked. Ultimate THOU SHALT NOT with polygonal rifling- don't know if the M&P has that or not.
Also seen steel and aluminum frames fail more spectacularly.
Everything that i fed through it was mainstream manufacturer fmj and just 5 jhps so everything was jacketed.
-
Geeze, how did I miss this!!!!

Wow!!!!
-
Went to the range with my new shield and put 200 rounds through it. The action was much smoother, but the very first shot was a light primer strike (winchester 115 gr fmj). I had one more in the 200 rounds I shot. Will that go away as the gun breaks in? I don't know. Also, this one still does not return to battery on a press check unless I push it there. That part doesn't bother me, it was also like that with the old gun. What bothers me is the light primer strikes. Frustrated..... i really hope it is something that will go away as gun breaks in. The one on the right is unfired.

-
Glad it's running a bit better, though those light primer strikes are a bit worrisome. Is it maybe a case of hard primers rather than a problem with the pistol?
-
Gdoo, if you Google "S&W Shield light primer strikes" there's a bunch of hits.....
-
Yikes... well this is frustrating..
-
2 guns in a row? Please no.. maybe I should try to return it for something else.. ugh
-
Seems like you're snake-bit when it comes to S&W.
CZ makes some excellent pistols at very reasonable prices.
-
@ColoSwiss said:
Seems like you're snake-bit when it comes to S&W.CZ makes some excellent pistols at very reasonable prices.
I like the look of some CZs, I may check them out. I don't know if i will be allowed to really return it after 200 rounds though I may have to just swap it out again...
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login