Braided wire cutting.
-
Working at Best Buy construction I always tried to use my Wave, Charge or Surge to cut braided wire...worked 10% of the time. Always jam.

My savior was Knipex diagonal cutters. Never could find a reliable cutter on any of my multis. -
In my tests (in Etherearlicer's thread Zoidberg linked to above) the Spirit, Rebar and MP400 came out best at cutting stainless braided cable (bike brake cable). I haven't tried the Surge but will have a go today if I get chance.
-
Thanks for everyones input on this.
Yes, Etherealicers original thread is what made me assume the Spirit would come out top...but my own Spirit couldn't get through, took its bigger brother the swisstool to get the job done and with ease I must add.
I'll try again with LM's at my next opportunity, having said that I did try all the places on the plier head that have been listed above. Everytime the head just jammed and had to be forced apart using brute force or a screwdriver to pry open!! It really shouldn't be that difficult.
I'll stand by my "Rubbish" remark, I can't begin to say how appalled I was that the MUT EOD failed....WTF Leatherman!!Yes, I too love MT's, god only knows I have enough of 'em :D
And, I accept that ALL MT's (SAKs too) are a compromise in one way or another.....BUT, come on given the ridiculously high rrp of these tools they really should fair better than they have.Like I keep banging on about, I think its time they (Manufacturers) upp'd their game and transformed the MT into a serious tool and not just some cute plier with added gadget factor. It really does annoy me. These are very expensive items....very expensive! But yet cannot be relied upon 100%, which in my book makes them unsuitable for their proposed market.
I quite honestly couldn't give a toss about asthetics, colour, BO or SS, cute factor or tacticool what I need and dare I say demand, is a simple tool that can be relied upon, to that end I feel as though a high percentage simply fail to even achieve that.
"Rubbish" is the word
-
@tosh said:
Thanks for everyones input on this.
Yes, Etherealicers original thread is what made me assume the Spirit would come out top...but my own Spirit couldn't get through, took its bigger brother the swisstool to get the job done and with ease I must add.
I'll try again with LM's at my next opportunity, having said that I did try all the places on the plier head that have been listed above. Everytime the head just jammed and had to be forced apart using brute force or a screwdriver to pry open!! It really shouldn't be that difficult.
I'll stand by my "Rubbish" remark, I can't begin to say how appalled I was that the MUT EOD failed....WTF Leatherman!!Yes, I too love MT's, god only knows I have enough of 'em :D
And, I accept that ALL MT's (SAKs too) are a compromise in one way or another.....BUT, come on given the ridiculously high rrp of these tools they really should fair better than they have.Like I keep banging on about, I think its time they (Manufacturers) upp'd their game and transformed the MT into a serious tool and not just some cute plier with added gadget factor. It really does annoy me. These are very expensive items....very expensive! But yet cannot be relied upon 100%, which in my book makes them unsuitable for their proposed market.
I quite honestly couldn't give a toss about asthetics, colour, BO or SS, cute factor or tacticool what I need and dare I say demand, is a simple tool that can be relied upon, to that end I feel as though a high percentage simply fail to even achieve that.
"Rubbish" is the word
Lol Tosh this is how I feel about sogs files

-
Thanks for everyones input on this.
Yes, Etherealicers original thread is what made me assume the Spirit would come out top...but my own Spirit couldn't get through, took its bigger brother the swisstool to get the job done and with ease I must add.
I'll try again with LM's at my next opportunity, having said that I did try all the places on the plier head that have been listed above. Everytime the head just jammed and had to be forced apart using brute force or a screwdriver to pry open!! It really shouldn't be that difficult.
I'll stand by my "Rubbish" remark, I can't begin to say how appalled I was that the MUT EOD failed....WTF Leatherman!!Yes, I too love MT's, god only knows I have enough of 'em :D
And, I accept that ALL MT's (SAKs too) are a compromise in one way or another.....BUT, come on given the ridiculously high rrp of these tools they really should fair better than they have.Like I keep banging on about, I think its time they (Manufacturers) upp'd their game and transformed the MT into a serious tool and not just some cute plier with added gadget factor. It really does annoy me. These are very expensive items....very expensive! But yet cannot be relied upon 100%, which in my book makes them unsuitable for their proposed market.
I quite honestly couldn't give a toss about asthetics, colour, BO or SS, cute factor or tacticool what I need and dare I say demand, is a simple tool that can be relied upon, to that end I feel as though a high percentage simply fail to even achieve that.
"Rubbish" is the word
Lol Tosh this is how I feel about sogs files

Just curious: when almost all files fail a particular test, would you repeatedly single out only one of the brands repeatedly and subject only it to your scorn and derision? Or might that show a bias?
-
Isn't this more about anvil vs. bypass cutters and less of a quality issue

-
Thanks for everyones input on this.
Yes, Etherealicers original thread is what made me assume the Spirit would come out top...but my own Spirit couldn't get through, took its bigger brother the swisstool to get the job done and with ease I must add.
I'll try again with LM's at my next opportunity, having said that I did try all the places on the plier head that have been listed above. Everytime the head just jammed and had to be forced apart using brute force or a screwdriver to pry open!! It really shouldn't be that difficult.
I'll stand by my "Rubbish" remark, I can't begin to say how appalled I was that the MUT EOD failed....WTF Leatherman!!Yes, I too love MT's, god only knows I have enough of 'em :D
And, I accept that ALL MT's (SAKs too) are a compromise in one way or another.....BUT, come on given the ridiculously high rrp of these tools they really should fair better than they have.Like I keep banging on about, I think its time they (Manufacturers) upp'd their game and transformed the MT into a serious tool and not just some cute plier with added gadget factor. It really does annoy me. These are very expensive items....very expensive! But yet cannot be relied upon 100%, which in my book makes them unsuitable for their proposed market.
I quite honestly couldn't give a toss about asthetics, colour, BO or SS, cute factor or tacticool what I need and dare I say demand, is a simple tool that can be relied upon, to that end I feel as though a high percentage simply fail to even achieve that.
"Rubbish" is the word
Lol Tosh this is how I feel about sogs files

Just curious: when almost all files fail a particular test, would you repeatedly single out only one of the brands repeatedly and subject only it to your scorn and derision? Or might that show a bias?
I can't speak for the others, but I personally would weight the level of criticism based on how deficient the tool appears to be. Sometimes it warrents a negative comment, and sometimes a full weight rant - possibly even repeatedly ::) :D On that basis, SOG would indeed be criticised more than other makers :P >:D as I'm with Zed in considering the SOG files to be particularly poor

-
Here's a question: Is braided wire something that ANY pliers should be expected to cut easily?
-
@Syncop8r said:
Here's a question: Is braided wire something that ANY pliers should be expected to cut easily?IMO, no. It's a tricky task, particularly if the wire is hard material like stainless. I wouldn't expect a typical linesman's pliers with diagonal cutters to perform that well. You really need hard, sharp and close fitting bypass cutters that don't allow the cable to flatten as you cut it. In theory, the Surge/Rebar/MUT/OHT/Signal should be ideal for this, but there's obviously some variation in performance. IMO, the cast plier heads that most (all?) manufacturers use aren't up to repeated use on hard braided wire. Clean cuts on softer braided wire like copper seems to be dependent on a close fit between the two halves of the pliers head (if a bypass style) or accuracy of the cutting edges meeting (if side-cutter style, like the Wingman/Sidekick).
-
OK, so maybe we're expecting too much of them then. Any other opinions on this?

New Page Banana Dance

-
@Syncop8r said:
OK, so maybe we're expecting too much of them then. Any other opinions on this?
I completely disagree...
The whole attraction of the MT over a SAK is primarily the plier feature - if the MT were basically a bloated balisong with additional tools within, then fair do's.....horses for courses.But it ain't !
The MT is ultimately built around the ability to be used as a traditional pair of pliers - and therein lies the attraction.
It's pretty rich therefore to suddenly have to accept the plier concept is actually the archiles heel of the whole tool.
Clearly, the manufacturers haven't grasped what pliers are expected to do on a day to day basis. I cannot think of ANY plier manufacturer whose added replaceable carbide cutters - they simply used the correct steel first off.
Maybe MT manufacturers need to swallow their pride and accept their products are not upto industry standards - it would be wonderful if say SOG took advice from knipex, or Leatherman from Wera etc etc.
Suddenly the MT would have real stature and be able to hold its own.
-
OK, but some of your "traditional" pliers had issues with cutting it as well?
Also, are MT knife blades as good as dedicated knives? Are MT screwdrivers as good as dedicated screwdrivers? etc
-
@Syncop8r said:
OK, but some of your "traditional" pliers had issues with cutting it as well?Also, are MT knife blades as good as dedicated knives? Are MT screwdrivers as good as dedicated screwdrivers? etc
Those cheap pliers I tried cost £4 delivered! remind me again what the EOD MUT retails for....
Unless the blades have lateral movement, then I think most of us are happy. The screwdriver...It really would make a lot of sense if ALL MT's used the standard 1/4" bit. That then opens up endless possibilities. I use mainly Wera torsion bits, they are in a class of their own, far superior to ANY of the naff bits Gerber, SOG, LM, Victorinox supply. -
If I can find some braided wire (that isn't in some actual use), I'll get out some multitools and pliers and give them all a good go. Might be some interesting stuff to discover there. (I do know specialized cable cutters often have a rounded shape to prevent flatening the braided wires inside).
-
Perhaps may feel that a multitool needs to be the end-all of tools. I consider that thinking ridiculous... or at least unreasonable. By it's very nature and name, a multitool is a combination of different tools. It is compromise, a "jack of all trades, master of none." It is not the best option for ANY task. If an individual finds a tool that generally works well for the uses to which it will most likely be put, that's about all that should be asked of it.
If you want tools that work well in every situation, I'm sure there's a Snap-On truck somewhere that you can hire to follow you around. -
Wh
@aluminated said:
Perhaps may feel that a multitool needs to be the end-all of tools. I consider that thinking ridiculous... or at least unreasonable. By it's very nature and name, a multitool is a combination of different tools. It is compromise, a "jack of all trades, master of none." It is not the best option for ANY task. If an individual finds a tool that generally works well for the uses to which it will most likely be put, that's about all that should be asked of it.
If you want tools that work well in every situation, I'm sure there's a Snap-On truck somewhere that you can hire to follow you around.Multi-tools are by necessity compromises. But it is also about prioritizing various concerns, features and functionality up against each other. The level of compromise is not constant either; some multi-tools and designs are clearly better than others.
Leatherman/ SOG/ Gerber style multitools are based around pliers so expecting them to perform well at such tasks seems fair enough to me. They all also make the claim that they feature a wire cutter. Then expecting that to actually work doesn't seem too far fetched?
What I find interesting is if braided wire pose a more general difficulty, or just for the typical multi-tool overlap cutter design. Hopefully I find some braided wire of a not too extreme size laying around here somewhere.
-
@aluminated said:
Perhaps may feel that a multitool needs to be the end-all of tools. I consider that thinking ridiculous... or at least unreasonable. By it's very nature and name, a multitool is a combination of different tools. It is compromise, a "jack of all trades, master of none." It is not the best option for ANY task. If an individual finds a tool that generally works well for the uses to which it will most likely be put, that's about all that should be asked of it.
If you want tools that work well in every situation, I'm sure there's a Snap-On truck somewhere that you can hire to follow you around.Sorry, But I think that's a ridiculous assumption.
At work I EDC a Gerber Balance and a Rolson Box cutter. The box cutter see use every single day. The balance is a joke. The only reason I still edc it is because it has superb tweezers for removing steel splinters and a fantastic eyeglass screwdriver and to be fair the Fiskars scissors have never once let me down. But the pliers are worse than useless they are the absolute pits, as is the CE blade.
If I could find a better MT which had tweezers and eyeglass screwdriver I would probably chuck the balance in the bin. -
The Balance has never let me down, but then I've only ever used the pliers for light to moderate duty jobs. I think it's a great urban carry tool, but not something I would have carried when I was in heavy engineering companies. It did a good job in helping me fix my computer up though.

The Wave was the mainstay in a work setting, but the Gerber Multipliers served me well too. If the MPs had a pocket clip, the Wave wouldn't have had a look in. Sheath carry was not an option as it was a snag hazard. Even so, I never used them for the real tough jobs, and would reach for dedicated tools (pliers and cutters - and everything else) if I felt the task was beyond what a multitool was capable of. The multitools were convenient, and did make life easier, but were a long way from being industrial tools. It was the same on the boat too, and when running the boatyard. Cables were up to 90mm2 CSA handling very high ampages, Frequently used tools were circlip pliers, C spanners, peg spanners, and other tools you wouldn't expect on a multitool. Some of the wrenches we were using were over 3ft long, and still sometimes needed two men (one to hold the spanner, and someone you trust to bray the other end with a sledgehammer. I was working on machines that drilled holes over 14" diameter from solid, on components up to ten tonnes, and on tooling for machines that handled components in excess of 400 tonnes. Some of the lathes I've worked around had twin saddles, each with front and rear tool posts, and each tool on each tool post on each saddle was taking 90mm depth of cut - that's 720mm (over 28") coming off the diameter in one cut!!!
A multitool was still a very useful piece of equipment though, even though it wasn't up to industrial jobs. If you get one of those red hot turnings in the sole of your boot, you need to get it out NOW and not walk 5 or 10 or 20 metres to the nearest workbench. I never entered a machine shop that I wasn't familiar with, without a pliers based multitool and a decent torch. I don't think a multi will ever be a "do it all" tool, because we are all doing such different jobs in such different scenarios.
-
C'mon Al, give me a break....
The situations and environment you describe above are well out of the realms of any MT, that's just common sense.
My beef is the Tools they include are NOT justified by the high purchase cost nor the manufacturers claims.
It's very rare I see a tradesman who uses MT's, most have one lying around in their vans or tool bags but not on person.....the reason is purely because they are too limited in their use. Not that they are not feature packed, but because their features don't perform good enough to justify edc!There is without doubt a colossal market out there for task specific MT's that DO work. But if the truth be said the current MT with its (yawn) predictable tool loadout is just not worth the hassle of committing to carry on a daily basis.
We need to move away from what looks pretty and focus on practicality.
-
I think the fact that there aren't many task specific multitools out there should show that there isn't a colossal market for them. Leatherman and Victorinox are both arguably very good at marketing (better than they are at making tools, maybe) and they don't have them in their range. The companies that do offer task specific tools (Gerber, Wenger, SOG, Multitasker, etc) don't sell that many...
Most multitools are pretty good at most things for most people. If you need something more speSmurfpillsed, you'll have to use something more speSmurfpillsed.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login