Used Leatherman PST (Lynn's $10 MT Challenge)
-
The blade.
Cutting edge on the blade is about 2 1/2" long. For my tastes, it has a good shape. The inside folding of the tool puts the other handle somewhat in the way while in use, but if you absolutely need to get the blade flat, you can half-jackknife open the handles. There is no side-to-side play, and even if there was, the bolt holding it together could simply be tightened to remove the play.
As received, the blade would barely cut regular paper. I gave it 20 strokes per side on ceramic rods, after which it would cleanly cut regular paper, thin receipt paper, and phonebook paper.

This was honestly one of the easiest sharpenings I've done, considering the sharpness when I started. I was also fairly amazed at the condition of the blade, considering the overall condition of the tool when purchased. There are no nicks, dings, or rolled edges.
After the sharpening, and initial paper cut, it got a run at some cardboard. 10 passes across the corrugations.

Then I gave a shot at making some firestick curls in a piece of ash.

Here, I noticed that while the ergos are good, they're not GREAT. It's possible that I was still feeling effects from plier testing, but I could really notice the handle in my palm doing the cuts in the wood. This is a place where the slim width of the handle works a bit against the tool. It was not a huge deal, but noticeable.
This use, requiring pretty significant pressure on the blade, never felt out of control, and i never felt like the blade would close while pulling it free from the cut. The design of the tool is also such that should the blade collapse closed, it will hit the other handle before closing far enough to hit your hand. As with side-to-side play mentioned at the beginning of the post, you can control the tightness of the pivot to increase stiffness in opening and closing the tool, increasing retention in the open position. This isn't my preferred method of controlling blade retention, but it works. Using only backspring tension, blade retention in the open position is about like a Swiss Army knife with somewhat soft backsprings. It's okay, not great.
I don't think I'd want it as my main blade in a survival situation, and I wouldn't pick it for whittling, but for basic knife tasks, it's fine.
Blade:Pass (for light duty)
-
Drivers.
Hey, kids! Do you like flathead screwdrivers? Well, have I got the multitool for YOU! :D
The PST has 4 screwdrivers, a phillips, and three flatheads. Brand new, these are very precisely formed. As received, there's just a small amount of marring on the edge of the largest flathead. I have seen a number of used PSTs, and I would say by far the most common damage I've seen to them is to the smallest flathead screwdriver tips, which are very frequently torqued or broken. on this example, the small flathead is in great shape.
I was not going to cut the PST any breaks. From previous use, I knew it would handle a lot, so I went straight to hard use with the phillips, giving it a shot at a 3" wood screw in my back porch bench.

There was SIGNIFICANT flex in the tool, maybe 15 degrees rotational flex, while trying to loosen this screw, but it did it, and sprang right back into shape when done. This is as close as I've been in this Challenge to really feeling like I might be pushing a tool beyond safe limits. The driver held very firmly in the screw, with no sense that it would cam out, and at no point did it feel like the non-locking tool would collapse on me. But to be fair, I was not exerting a huge amount of downward force.
I gave it the usual round of testing on screws in my cabinets, but that was really just formality at that point.
I gave the large flathead a shot at hinge screws, and prying open a paint can, and it did fine at both. Then I did a sort of torture test on it...

That's a 15 degree or so flex while wedged between two 2x10s, and when released, it sprang right back into shape. There was no permanent deformation whatsoever.
The metal of this tool shows pretty good resilience to taking some bend and returning to shape. This is a MAJOR difference from the previously tested Mossy Oak, a tool with a good design and metal that would take and keep a bend fairly easily.
I have broken Leatherman tools before. They're not indestructible by any stretch of the imagination, but are pretty darn good.
The small driver is JUST small enough to slot into eyeglass screws.

The largest driver is a bit too large to slot into the screws in lightswitches and such, but the medium sized one works fine for this.
Drivers: PASS
Flathead for prying: PASSThe tool is really only limited by the force you can apply to a non-locking tool. Newer versions of the PST redesigned the shape of the Phillips and medium flathead so their line of force would tend to push them toward the open side instead of the folding closed side, but this is the original shape, and these drivers can collapse on you. You, and your fingers, are warned.
-
Other functions
The can opener/cap lifter
It sure does. This is about 1/3 of a small coffee can. I had to share opening duties with a couple other tools. The can opener works fine, but because of the width of the blade it has to push a lot more material out of the way than a Victorinox can opener. That requires a bit more force. I, personally, can work one of this style somewhat faster than a Vic's though. YMMV. There was no scraping on the inside of the can when I was done, so no metal splinters, although this can be an issue with this style of opener.
It works, although there's the chance of just punching through the top of the cap without pulling it off.
The Awl. I gave it a go at the same trashcan I used in my Huntsman test. It is considerably better at punching through this kind of material, and leather, than the Victorinox awl.

That's the GOOD news. The BAD is that while it's a good AWL, it's a terrible drill. I gave up after a few minutes of trying to get this thing to bore a hole in a half inch piece of ash, having made nothing more than a dent. Literally less than 1/16". It's good if you want to punch a hole in a tin can, or thin sheet material, or leather, or plastic, etc. Also, be warned, non locking awls can be iffy. I had no problem with this, but harder tests might show issues.
The file.
I put a nail in a vice, and used the metal saw on the side of the file to cut the nail head off.

I then took the file and tried to put a 45 or so degree angle on the end.

I was pretty impressed with the speed at which it accomplished both of these tasks. I took down most of the material on the nail with the cross cut side, then tried to smooth it out with the single cut side, and both worked really well. Any problems seemed more a matter of user than tool. :D
Can Opener/Cap Lifter: PASS
Awl (AS an awl): PASS
Awl (as a drill): FAIL
File as metal saw: PASS
File as metal file: PASS -
So, closing thoughts.
First, stepping away from it as a tool in hand, this thing is pretty much a piece of genius design. If you look at the use of space inside the tool, it is extremely well used. that lends to a high tool density for its space. The next thing is, this is amazingly simple in construction. The tool narrows at the pliers, so the pin holding them in is not stressed unnecessarily, a point I made against the Mossy Oak MT in this challenge.
There are only two washers in this tool, flanking the file. I believe I know the intended function, but I think it actually works in two ways. I THINK that they're intended to allow a gap between the side of the handle and small flathead driver to keep the file from rubbing on those elements. However, it has a second, possibly unintended benefit, and i got to see it in this tool. It creates enough space for water to come out of the file. Since it's not as smooth as the other tools, it's more prone to rusting if the tool gets wet, and capillary action pulls water in or holds it in. However, in the specific case of this tool, I think what got into it was probably muddy water, and that held the water in place regardless.
Setting aside those design issues, does the PST have any other feature that sets it apart? I'd say yes. It is the lightest and probably most pocketable full size multitool I've ever encountered.
So it's fairly light, slim, with high tool density and pretty easy to maintain. What are the downsides?
The plier ergonomics almost can't be overstated how bad they are. As a PLIER based tool, this is a BIG hit. Less of a hit, but the fact that the tools don't lock puts a real upper limit on what you can safely accomplish with this tool.
So, is it worth $10

I watched ebay for a month. I feel certain that I could sell this tool in this condition for $30 easily, and it's EASILY worth that.
This is an extremely strong contender for the best $10 MT.
But there's one contender left to come.
-
Brilliant, excellent review Lynn!

-
Really cool to read!

-
Lovely PST too - it cleaned up nicely!

-
Very interesting!

-
Thanks, all.

@Fuzzbucket said:
Lovely PST too - it cleaned up nicely!
Yeah. I was honestly amazed at the transformation. I think it helped my view of this tool immensely that nothing was actually broken or damaged. Just rusty.
-
OK, I usually find them for $15 when I rescue them from the TSA- great find, and that guy is an idiot smurf.
So, what's next? Or are we just going to call it a three way tie for the two Vics and the PST and everyone else starts at 4th place?
-
I've got a beat up PST coming. Cost was $8.51. I think it is missing the file. This review makes me more excited to get it in hand.
-
@Yadda said:
I've got a beat up PST coming. Cost was $8.51. I think it is missing the file. This review makes me more excited to get it in hand.Awesome! I think you'll like it, even with a missing file. Someone here might have a spare, too, and they're not hard to fix. As I showed above, two pairs of pliers and the tool's apart. And it's not hard to reassemble, unlike some tools I've messed with.
-
@ironraven said:
So, what's next? Or are we just going to call it a three way tie for the two Vics and the PST and everyone else starts at 4th place?Well, YOU were going to call it after the Vics, so...
Yeah, still a strong contender to come. Not sure if it'll be the winner, but it's good.
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
I've got a beat up PST coming. Cost was $8.51. I think it is missing the file. This review makes me more excited to get it in hand.
Awesome! I think you'll like it, even with a missing file. Someone here might have a spare, too, and they're not hard to fix. As I showed above, two pairs of pliers and the tool's apart. And it's not hard to reassemble, unlike some tools I've messed with.

-
It's the only Multitool I carried for over 20 years and it served me well

-
@SteveC said:
It's the only Multitool I carried for over 20 years and it served me well
Care to give some thoughts on long-term use? How does the blade work for day to day stuff, or did you carry a separate blade? How did you find the ergo of the plier handles? How does the file hold up over time? Do you pocket or belt carry? Etc. I'm very interested to get the perspective from someone who's lived with it that long.
-
Quite a story indeed, and great job with bringing it back to life.

Very appropriate to test a PST now, too.

-
my OG ST came in similar condition, also cleaned up fine,

these tools used are a bargain most times, they come back to business in a breeze with some TLC. Also, this tool you tested was 21 years old, how many Ozark Trails, Les Stroud or Mossy Oak would work as good after two decades...I bet few of them

good tests and review Lynn, you always bring much fun and entertainment to this forum

-
@ReamerPunch said:
Very appropriate to test a PST now, too.
With the collector's edition one released, and a general thought of "how much would YOU pay for a PST", I had to bite my tongue while thinking "I guess at least $8".

@ThePeacent said:
these tools used are a bargain most times, they come back to business in a breeze with some TLC. Also, this tool you tested was 21 years old, how many Ozark Trails, Les Stroud or Mossy Oak would work as good after two decades...I bet few of them
While this is very true, it's also true that the tool as purchased was almost unusable. It's not just a question of how long they last. It's a question of whether or not you have the time and interest in doing the restoration work. If I had worked a minimum wage job for the amount of time I worked to fix this thing, I could have bought a new Rebar. Okay, maybe a gently used Rebar. :D
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
@ReamerPunch said:
Very appropriate to test a PST now, too.
While this is very true, it's also true that the tool as purchased was almost unusable. It's not just a question of how long they last. It's a question of whether or not you have the time and interest in doing the restoration work. If I had worked a minimum wage job for the amount of time I worked to fix this thing, I could have bought a new Rebar. Okay, maybe a gently used Rebar. :D
fair enough.
That's why when the tools you tested drew blood in this challenge and I read about how you spent "30 mins" :o sharpening a blade or nearly and hour between those two SAK's badly ground and sharpened edges, I thought to myself that not even I spend that much time on edges,* especially if they're from cheap knives*. :ahhhIf they're so damaged or bad, I put them through the Dremel :D and forget about "surgical precision sharpening"
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

