Shootout- Leatherman Skeletool vs SOG Reactor
-
How far can the Reactor jaws open one-handed?

-
@Nix said:
How durable are the SOG pliers?Those little gears are ingenious....but they seem....frail?
Maybe I'm just too rough on my stuff. :-[
The gears do less than you might think. The mechanical advantage, or multiplication of the gripping force, is created by having the handle pivot forwards of the plier pivots. All the gears do, is keep the centreline of the plier head in line with the centre line of the handles. If you were gripping something to pull along the tool axis, or using the cutters for example, the gears aren't subject to much force at all. They do come into play however, when turning a nut, or doing anything which may twist the pliers centreline away from the handle centreline. Even then, I do not believe the gears are taking the full torsional load. This is a different torsional load from the twisting of the screwdriver bit in the back of the plier head - different axis of rotation...
It's not a particularly easy concept to put across in words only, but I hope this helps to get a clearer understanding of what those gears are for. I do not believe they are quite the weak link that they might initially appear to be.
@Syncop8r said:
How far can the Reactor jaws open one-handed?
Good question.
-
Thanks, 50ft. Good explanation of an abstract concept.
I've pre-ordered the SOG PowerAccess Deluxe through the MTo store. I guess I'll get a chance to see!

-
The compound pliers for the SOG tool is one of the few things I really like about SOG multi-tools. I just wish they did not feel so flimsy in the handles compared to Leatherman.
Does SOG have IP on their geared compound pliers? Seems compound pliers in general have been around long before SOG. It would be cool to see Leatherman make a compound pliers tool. A Surge with a compound pliers would be a beast!
-
I'm liking the shootout. I wasn't the biggest fan of the Skeletool till just recently. I tried to carry it in the past but we didn't quite hit it off. Having made an effort I have had a change a mind. While it has a basic set of tools its a functional set. I've not handled the Reactor so this is really a good read.
-
So far I am liking the SOG

Never had one yet so i will be
Interested to see how it performs
-
While I really like the idea of these "shootouts" between two similar tools of different brands, I have to say - and maybe this is just me here - the price to feature ratio on both of these tools is abysmal.
I may follow this thread for the heck of it and for Grant' s sense of humor, but $60-$70 MSRP for a device with so few tool components drives me up a friggin' wall.
A new Wingman or a used 1st gen Wave cost less and does so much more. Hell, a new Rebar does WAY more at the lower price. I'm not as well versed in SOG' s line-up, but I bet they have a new something or other that's cheaper but has a more dense tool load out as well.
If they are going to give me half the tool load of a Rebar, it ought to cost about half as much. Not some overwrought, gussied-up, fancy schmancy designed scales just to puff up the price of a (maybe) $40 tool. My PS4 has more features.
**end rant. Thanks for your patience.
-
@mcb said:
Does SOG have IP on their geared compound pliers? Seems compound pliers in general have been around long before SOG. It would be cool to see Leatherman make a compound pliers tool. A Surge with a compound pliers would be a beast!There are many ways to make compound pliers. SOGs geared version is one of the compact sized ones though, and hence well suited for multitools.
The flip side is the doubled handle movement which makes the effective grip range of the plier (at least one handed) half of normal pliers. And I've noticed those tiny gears tend to poke me a bit if I just put it in my pocket. (I don't have the reactor though - just two of the others).
-
Great review!

I like the compound leverage of Reactor but the assisted opening is a con very big to me.
Could it be possible to disassist the SOG Reactor??
Thanks Mr Lamontagne ;)
Helloooooooo!
Removing the spring (or at least attempting to) is my next project. >:D
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Great review!

I like the compound leverage of Reactor but the assisted opening is a con very big to me.
Could it be possible to disassist the SOG Reactor??
Thanks Mr Lamontagne ;)
Helloooooooo!
Removing the spring (or at least attempting to) is my next project. >:D
Def
Coooool!!! :D
-
Part 4- Screwdrivers
To me the screwdrivers are probably the most used part of a multitool, or at least are tied with the blade for most used, and therefore they deserve special attention. Of course, as screwdrivers are part of the scope of this comparison, I imagine we were going to take a close look anyway….

Neither of these tools has on board, folding drivers as many tools do, and they both rely on replaceable bit drivers. That’s about where the similarity ends, as they are very different setups.
The Reactor has a strange way of going about it- the double ended standard ¼” (6mm) hex bit spends most of it’s time in the end of the smaller of the two plier handles, however is not meant to be used from that position. To use it, you have to pull the screwdriver bit out then insert it in the backside of the head of the Reactor when the handles are folded into the closed position. This allows the Compound Leverage to grip the bit twice as hard as your hand is gripping it and allows you to put a lot of pressure on extremely stubborn screws.
Of course, the draw back is that if you release the pressure on the handles the bit then becomes loose and potentially rotates, so you have to develop a bit of a technique to use it.

On the other hand, the Skeletool simply needs to be folded out as one double ended bit rides in the bit driver, and, assuming that is the bit you need, no further action is required. And, the Skeletool has a second double ended bit riding along which means it has double the screwdriver options as the Reactor. This would be a definite win for the Skeletool, except that it isn’t quite perfect either.
First and most obviously, the Skeletool uses Leatherman’s flattened bits, which I personally cannot stand. These bits are fine as long as you have the proper bit loaded on board, but if you don’t, you can’t just grab a bit out of a toolbox or at a local shop. There is a standard bit size for a reason, and Leatherman chose to ignore that standard. The Reactor, as with all bit driver equipped SOG models, accepts standard bits.

The second issue with the Skeletool bit driver is seen in all the photos so far, although you may not have noticed it- I have a different, non standard issue set of bits in mine because at some point the double Phillips bit has fallen out of it and gotten lost. With the open end of the Skeletool there is nothing to retain bits in it, and they go missing quite easily, which seriously negates the advantage of having multiples.
Further, if you should leave a flathead bit in the driver end then it sticks out just enough when folded to draw blood from any unsuspecting bit of flesh that it comes in contact with- such as when you reach into the pocket it is clipped in to get some change or your keys.

And then there is the form of the tool- in order to use the screwdriver the handles have to be folded out, either at a 90 or 180 degree orientation to the rest of the tool. This seems like it would be great to apply extra torque to a screw or get extra reach, but given the excess flex that results when tackling a resistive screw, I worry about permanently warping the Skeletool under hard use.
By comparison the Reactor can be used as hard as you want- the harder you grip it the harder you can use it. While it may be a bit more inconvenient, overall I have to give this point to the Reactor. Still, the Skeletool does have twice as many screwdriver functions as the Reactor, and that can’t be ignored. I’ll score this one as a tie and award a point to both.
SCORE- SOG 4, Leatherman 2
After 4 events the SOG Reactor isn't looking like such a bad tool after all, is it?

My personal preference on this one is the SOG because of the versatility of being able to use standard bits, which could come in handy for different types of screws or ones that are recessed, while you just kind of get what you get with the Skeletool. I really hate those flat bits.

But, fair is fair, and the Skeletool does have twice as many screwdriver bits on board as the Reactor, and Leatherman deserves recognition for that.
Def
-
I am not keen on the LM flat bits holder as it doesn't look
Like it can handle much force
I do like the how the SOG holds the hex bits
And the more you grip the handles the more it holds on
That's a very good feature
So far I still like the SOG Reactor better
Look forward to part 5
-
Extremely well organized and informative comparison.
Thanks Grant.
-
I don't love Leatherman's propitiatory bits much, especially since they won't sell individual bits. If I could buy individual bits as needed (I wear out #2 Philips frequently) I would not mind the flat bits one bit (pun intended :D) since it makes the tools thinner and thinner is critical to comfortable pocket carry IMHO.
So as much as I like the idea of using standard 1/4" hex bits I am afraid I hate the Reactors bit system. The storage location hurts no matter which way you store the bit when trying to use the pliers with any real force. It is a pain to use if you have to get into anything remotely close to a confined space around a screw. The need to squeeze the pliers or the bit slips is again a pain in some positions or again in tight use locations. The Skeletool as a screw driver has reach when unfolded and torque when used bent at 90 and no requirement to squeeze to utilize max torque.
I have after many years of carrying a Skeletool lost one bit, not from the bit holder itself but from the storage location on the handled (a location that does not hurt my hand in pliers mode). A quick pinch of the retaining strap with my Surge and I have never lost a bit again. The Reactor bit has ended up loose in my pocket more than once and I only carried it a few weeks before I went back to my Skeletool. I have no confidence that the Reactor will retain bits any better than a Skeletool, if not worst.
With the way I use my multi-tools I would have given the screw driver point strongly to the Skeletool, despite the propitiatory bits used. The Reactors screw driver was a real let down IMHO despite my excitement for standard 1/4" hex bits.
-
Nice to hear other members giving there opinion

-
@Grant Lamontagne said:

With the open end of the Skeletool there is nothing to retain bits in it, and they go missing quite easily, which seriously negates the advantage of having multiples.Funny, mine has a clip which keeps them in.
I would be more worried about them falling out of the storage in the handle as has happened to mcb.
Also, many of us find the screwdriver less awkward to use if the pliers are folded into the 'front' half of the Skele - creates more of a straight line to rotate around
(Kampfer has a good pic somewhere).
I can imagine the Reactor may not be able to reach some screws in tight spaces.
If you're using phillips the most, the convenience is you don't need to take the bit out like you do with the Reactor. I would try to avoid storing the flathead in the driver for the reasons you have mentioned.
Of course you can use standard bits with the bit extender but that wouldn't be comparing apples to apples. -
I went back through the thread and scored it myself. I call it 3-3, a tie.
If we had the data, I think the durability round would decide the contest for me.
Nice write-up, Def.

-
@Grant Lamontagne said:

With the open end of the Skeletool there is nothing to retain bits in it, and they go missing quite easily, which seriously negates the advantage of having multiples.Also, many of us find the screwdriver less awkward to use if the pliers are folded into the 'front' half of the Skele - creates more of a straight line to rotate around
(Kampfer has a good pic somewhere). -
Skeletool is Cyberdyne Systems Model 101 Series 800's standard issue breaching tool.
No way the reactor is that cool, matter of fact the Reactor isn't even reacting anymore only after two short years of production. It might sounds great and beats Skeletool on paper, but five minutes in hand I call it quit. The tool just feel cheap in hands, very weak liner lock, uncounterable amount of hotspots in knife, pliers and driver mode.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login






