Access to Power -SOG 30-day Challenge! Starting June 1st! Access & Access Deluxe
-
Powernoodle Day 5
*
The "file" on the PowerAccess Deluxe is so poorly made as to be virtually non-functional. It would not smooth out the rough spots on this plastic outdoor garbage bin.* -
I like the finish of the PAD
If I really liked the PAD, I would probably really like the stonewashed finish. But as I pretty much dislike the PAD, it stinks up what I think about the finish.
Current Powernoodle Dynamic Assessment Rating ("CPDAR"): 4/10
I take it you don’t like the PAD then powernoodle

-
@Wspeed said:
Got a email from Chris@SOG and this is what he wroteI don’t have a good answer for you on the file. I’ve alerted Engineering and hopefully that will address the issue.
Here is the answer I got from one of our engineers
As a general rule, if it is non-structural (or not intended to sustain mechanical loads) it is soft wire. One example is copper electrical wire with plastic insulation. If it deoes sustain mechanical loads it is hard wire. Example chicken wire.
Hopefully this helps out.
Thanks Wspeed... a bit noncommittal on the file, that answer

@powernoodle said:
Powernoodle Day 5
*
The "file" on the PowerAccess Deluxe is so poorly made as to be virtually non-functional. It would not smooth out the rough spots on this plastic outdoor garbage bin.*I am not surprised, you won't be surprised to hear. It confirms what I surmised above based on my visual inspection and comparison with real files... The grooves are too shallow and narrow to form actual teeth between them, as should be the case for any file that deserves the name.
Note: the challenge checklist mentions "Find an imaginative use for this tool", as if the authors were somewhat hesitant to use the name bestowed upon it by SOG >:D
-
Yes not the answer we wanted about the file :ahhh
But if someone is going to take this seriously
We might get better tools in the future
And I could still get a reply back from Chris
Ones they have had a look at the file
-
Day 5
Today the light in the bathroom gave up
So a good opportunity to test the Philips driver
As the bit set is to short to reach the screwsNo real problems but the Philips driver would
of been better if it didn’t have that weird shape
A straight driver would of been betterI had to order in that stupid light
As no one around here had one in stock
So as soon as it turns up I will finish the job



-
@Wspeed said:
I take it you don’t like the PAD then powernoodle
I do not, and am going to return the PAD to Amazon. I would keep the PAD if it were just a mediocre MT. But I just feel that SOG has punked me by putting that thing on there that they call a file, when they know full well that it doesn't work. So I'm returning the PAD largely because I don't like being treated like a knucklehead.
Unfortunately, this means that I will drop out of the Challenge. I hate to abandon my comrades, but we don't know how these Challenges will turn out until we try. This is my first failure to complete a Challenge, but the return period on the MT is before the end of the Challenge so its now or never. I'll continue to watch and participate in some way, and maybe carry another SOG for the remainder as a small show of unity with the downtrodden.
I'm still a fan of the PowerLock and PowerAssist, though this experience has diminished my opinion of SOG as a maker.
Powernoodle Rating: not recommended.
Onward and upward!
*
The files on the PowerAssist and PowerLock are not awesome, but they do work. The Gerber MP600 and ST300 have aggressive files.*
*
Today's EDC. The orange Manly Wasp folder is an example of how to produce a superior tool. Its a true quality piece that displays excellent design and manufacturing, and is highly recommended.* -
@powernoodle said:
Powernoodle Day 5
*
The "file" on the PowerAccess Deluxe is so poorly made as to be virtually non-functional. It would not smooth out the rough spots on this plastic outdoor garbage bin.*:o
I am just perplexed now. Your PAD file, from comparing photos, is MUCH more poorly machined than the file on my PAD. I was under the impression that my file was as bad as it got. I was wrong.
Can the file on yours even smooth a fingernail? :ahhhAttached are two photos I took when comparing the PAD file to the PL file. The single cut side is laughable, but the other side shows the cross sections are slightly raised.
@Wspeed said:
I take it you don’t like the PAD then powernoodle
I do not, and am going to return the PAD to Amazon. I would keep the PAD if it were just a mediocre MT. But I just feel that SOG has punked me by putting that thing on there that they call a file, when they know full well that it doesn't work. So I'm returning the PAD largely because I don't like being treated like a knucklehead.
Unfortunately, this means that I will drop out of the Challenge. I hate to abandon my comrades, but we don't know how these Challenges will turn out until we try. This is my first failure to complete a Challenge, but the return period on the MT is before the end of the Challenge so its now or never. I'll continue to watch and participate in some way, and maybe carry another SOG for the remainder as a small show of unity with the downtrodden.
I'm still a fan of the PowerLock and PowerAssist, though this experience has diminished my opinion of SOG as a maker.
I fully understand and would probably do the same if I weren't an MT collector.
I could, at this point, recommend you request a replacement. However, knowing what we now know, I think you'd receive another monumental QC failure.Thank you for having attempted the challenge, powernoodle. I hope that SOG can redeem themselves one day (although I won't be holding my breath).



-
Sorry to hear that you are returning the PAD
And a shame that you have to stop the challengeYes I totally agree about the file it’s a joke
But if that’s the only problem than in my opinion
It’s not a bad tool, but I still have to test all the tools
On the PAD so I still haven’t made my mind up
If it is a good Multi tool or notI hope returning the PAD for a refund goes smooth

-
I think that most tools on any make of Multi tool
Look low quality compared to the Swiss Army Knife tools
-
@Wspeed said:
I think that most tools on any make of Multi tool
Look low quality compared to the Swiss Army Knife tools
Hey W,
I have to respectfully say that isn't necessarily true. For starters, a high polish isn't indicative of better quality(polished tools tend to slip more than other finishes). And second, and I'll stop here, you'd have to hold and use a lot more MTs than you have so far.
As far as files go, the newer Vic stuff IS outstanding, but LM has used files of equal quality in several models. The Rebar is a standout in that regard.
I hope that didn't come off as rude in any way. Just wanted to show the other side of the coin.
-
That’s no problem GLBM

What I mean is that when I look at the crunch or Supertool
Like the screw drivers they are just a straight bit of metal
With the end ground down a bit so it fits a screw
They work fine but just aren’t made very niceI just feel that MT company’s concentrates more
On the pliers than their tools that goes in the models
-
@gerleatherberman said:
Your PAD file, from comparing photos, is MUCH more poorly machined than the file on my PAD.Yeah, and that pic is of the double-cut or "good" side.
Can the file on yours even smooth a fingernail?
No, neither side would shape a fingernail.
I do not begrudge a maker too much for allowing something to slip through CQ. But this is a design or manufacturing problem (a design problem, really) that is endemic to this MT. I don't think the file was ever intended to work because the design, even if perfectly executed in manufacturering, would still be more akin to a butter knife than a file.
Yeah, I could have continued to test the other tools. But if you know that you are going to break up with a lass, you might as well get it over now and move on. And my return window was closing.
I have be honest and say that it feels real good to have a Swisstool Spirit in my pocket. I might switch to an ST300 to get the endorphins going.
I hate not participating in this one, but God willing I will be around for future Challenges because I love MTO and love my toys. I think maybe there at least 2 Challenges starting in July.
-
@Wspeed said:
That’s no problem GLBM
What I mean is that when I look at the crunch or Supertool
Like the screw drivers they are just a straight bit of metal
With the end ground down a bit so it fits a screw
They work fine but just aren’t made very niceI just feel that MT company’s concentrates more
On the pliers than their tools that goes in the models
The OG ST and Crunch are very old designs from LM(the Crunch is still produced and has not been changed much since 1999). Perhaps something during or after the Kick\Fuse\Blast\Core era would be better to compare to. :)
@gerleatherberman said:
Your PAD file, from comparing photos, is MUCH more poorly machined than the file on my PAD.Yeah, and that pic is of the double-cut or "good" side.
Can the file on yours even smooth a fingernail?
No, neither side would shape a fingernail.
I do not begrudge a maker too much for allowing something to slip through CQ. But this is a design or manufacturing problem (a design problem, really) that is endemic to this MT. I don't think the file was ever intended to work because the design, even if perfectly executed in manufacturering, would still be more akin to a butter knife than a file.
Yeah, I could have continued to test the other tools. But if you know that you are going to break up with a lass, you might as well get it over now and move on. And my return window was closing.
I have be honest and say that it feels real good to have a Swisstool Spirit in my pocket. I might switch to an ST300 to get the endorphins going.
I hate not participating in this one, but God willing I will be around for future Challenges because I love MTO and love my toys. I think maybe there at least 2 Challenges starting in July.
I would hope SOG could rectify the problem, but their track record is abysmal at best, with cancelling the model being their solution with troublesome models(ex. PowerGrab and PowerDuo). However, all my rambling aside, I'll reserve judgement for the PAD until I see how they react to the file abomination.
I have to agree that SOG knew that the file on the Access series was terrible at best, and pointless to include, in the case of the PAD you received. It could be that SOG is having financial issues and pushed the product, even knowing it was faulty. Not an excuse though and seems self-defeating at best.

See ya around this thread, powernoodle!

-
GLBM Day 5:
Used cutters to cut a computer power cable, chew off the jacket, and strip the three wires.
Bonus shot of my checklist. :)



-
Day 6
Desktop fan (powered by USB outlet on PC screen) had become really wobbly. Its pivots are secured by rather undersized Phillips screws... but tightening these with the PAD helped a bit (let's see for how long).

Edit: the possibility to use standard 1/4" bits is IMHO one of the best aspects of the PAD, and so is the way it's solved in a flexible manner with both a grip mount integrated in the pliers and the separate stub for the bit adapter; both variants have a magnet holding the bit in place. The stub has stops at 90° and 180°.
Word of caution: the stub for the bit adapter is formed rather like the 2D bits from Leatherman, and thus likely to have similar torque resistance, which is inferior to that of a normal 1/4" bit/socket combination. If you have to apply a lot of torque, avoid the stub and adapter and instead use the bit grip on the pliers (see e.g. my Day 5 post). The compound leverage of the pliers is of great help. -
Back to the "file" for a moment, if I may.
The pics below show the extent of the catastrophe on my PAD, in support of what I have described earlier.
This echoes what Powernoodle and Wspeed have concluded, and I wish SOG would take note and issue a statement with some reassurance on how they will address the issue.

Nevertheless, at this point it is the only major gripe I have with the PAD.
The somewhat flimsy blades have been mentioned, and while I agree with the sentiment, I think it is the best they could have done based on the geometry chosen for the handles, and the lock springs in particular, short of redesigning said geometry. The blades could not have been made wider and still fit inside the handles without interfering with the lock springs...
-
Day 6
Today I had to tighten the handle on the drawer
And the best fitting for the screws is the small driver
A job well done



-
Here are some pics of the file from my PAD
Well a bit of scratched metal
you can’t call it a file




-
I'm finally ready to start........
Day 01:
Used the knife to conduct the initial paper cutting test. I did strop the blade first. Very sharp, cleanly sliced fine catalog paper. Good start here!

-
I'm carrying the PAD in it's belt pouch, but took out the bit set.
The bit set is just a bit bulky (sorry for the unintentional pun there). This is a bit odd (ok, there I go again), since the bit driver capability is the real strength of the PAD. Perhaps after I've adjusted to carrying the PAD, I'll try adding the bits back into the sheath.
As I said in a previous thread, I find that the sheath is not well designed to carry both the bits and PAD, but it works just fine for the PAD alone.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login