EDC steel preference.....?
-
I hadn't seen that Buck 110. Very cool.

-
I like my 154cm. Great balance of all the advantages of different metals.
I like my 154cm. Great balance of all the advantages of different metals.
154CM is a very nice upgrade, thats still easy to sharpen.
@Nix said:
I've tried lots of steels, but 154cm seems to be a good all-around balance for me. :cheers:lots of people like to criticise Emerson for still using that same steel in their knives since 15 years ago, but he gave a personal response to that last week, ::)
I thought it was interesting especially to those in favor of 152CM/CPM154 :salute:and also, I know some of you (myself included) are very fond of the Buck 110,
do you know that Buck released an exclusive 110LW (lightweight) model this year with 154CM? It's called the Smokejumper :tu:https://www.skblades.com/product-page/the-smoke-jumper
Here's a thread about it, with pics :dd: love that red color
:like: Thanks for letting me know about this model. The price is excellent, provided it's about the same a leather sheath 420HC model is now. Upgraded steel, bright handles, and something a bit easier to tote around than some half-pound beast. Glad I waited when I wanted to buy one at my local knife store shortly after they came out (but I still ended up buying a Nano Bantam), and this is only $10 more than what they wanted for the standard model 110LT. And I really like that red and black nylon sheath. Nylon is truly better for a working knife's sheath because it can be easily cleaned.
Now if only they'll start offering the LT frame in a myriad of colors in the custom shop--this same knife, but with a black coated blade would be awesome. And I'd really like an orange or blue one.
-
For me, it's both high carbon and stainless. Really, I don't care as long as it holds an edge well and is easy to resharpen. So far, Sandvik 12C27, as used by Mora and EKA has performed best in terms of edge retention and corrosion resistance, as well as ease of resharpening. I cut up half a soft plastic (but still thick) kiddie pool with an EKA Swede 88, and it was still decently sharp. The Queen Big Chief I used (which is like an inch longer), which is 440A, had to be resharpened 3 times during the job on the other half.
-
I sweat a lot(kind of sweat that drips from pants and shirt, then leaves white marks of salt) and non-stainless blades get spotty and pitted in a day or two on my belt or in my pocket. I would have to oil a non-stainless blade several times a day. Can't be bothered. :ahhh
Stainless blades will spot up on my as well, but it takes a week or two, then being stainless, it is easy to clean off the surface spots. :)
being in a similar situation as you, GLBM; I wholeheartedly recommend you trying out an H1 blade,

any of them, preferably in Serrated Edge 8)It was an eye opener for me

Thank you for the information, TP!

I've been curious as of late about H1. I rarely use serrated, so I would go plain edge, but I do like the look of them. :D@Aloha007 said:
While I dont have H1 everything I've read about this steel and others experiences I agree with TP. Might be a good test of this steel GLBM. If I had one I'd send it your way for you to test.Thank you for the confirmation, Aloha!

I will put an H1 knife on my "to get list" and find one to buy/carry soon. Would be nice not worrying about the knife edge getting dull from just being in my pocket if I forget to oil it up.

-
I own a few non-stainless Damascus blades, otherwise it´s stainless all the way. Ease of maintenance being the most important reason.
-
There you go steel nerds: :salute:
-
I just ordered my first M390 knife

Let's see what all the fuss is about when it arrives.
-
Nice video, Gerhard!
-
I've really enjoyed his cut test videos, apart from finding him entertaining, I was really surprised by the results of his To The Max tests
My EDC is either H1 or 14C28, so I'm amazed by those super steels....
@microbe said:
I just ordered my first M390 knife
Let's see what all the fuss is about when it arrives.
I'm slowly coming to the conclusion that "one last knife" I want to buy must be M390 rather than XHP

-
As long as we are being geeky here.
Cedric's test came up on BF a while back and the consensus was there is something flawed in his tests.
I believe one of those things is his sharpening methods, early on he admits his skills are in flux. Cedric's all over the map, unknown stones Lansky, Tormek, KME, Worksharp. If he's going to do these kind of tests he needs one guided system and a consistent set of stones and sharpening angles. Even two tests per steel one polished edge and one toothy edge, some steels just won't hold a polished edge for flip.Another issue is he seems to not take hardness into account, you can't just test a random steel sample you have to find a maker that does their heat treat right. If you're testing steels alone you can't use steel from Ka-Bar and ESEE who run their steel soft for toughness and not hard edge retention.
Just on his low end steel test Cedric has made some serious errors. Cedric has Case true sharp (420HC) a near equal to Buck's Boss treated 420HC, that's the first time I've heard that. Case runs their steel very soft, where Buck pushes 420HC much harder.
440C is listed as an equal to Case CV not hardly, Case CV is just a modified 1075 or 1085. Pretty low end stuff.
AUS-8 will hold an edge twice as long as Case True Sharp 420HC. Well heat treated AUS-8 is very close to 1095.
One ZT CPM S35VN at 109 cuts and another at 198 cuts, whats going on there.
From my own test on Home Depot moving boxes one Queen D2 will out cut all three blades of a Case Stockman. Doesn't seem to match Cedric's test.Cedric did manage to show geometry helps, steel being the same all his 17 Degree per side edges out cut the 20 DPS edges.
-
Interesting, as I was just watching his REX 121 testing. There was some talk within the comment section of Michael Christy video about edge burn using worksharp on Maxamet. They do things differently but therein lies the result differences not to mention consistency in sharpening. Michaels video on REX121/Maxamet he touches on finding out why there are these differences.
EDIT. Just read an article written by Cedric I thought was pretty good.https://www.everydaycommentary.com/www.everydaycommentary.com/2017/7/7/cedric-and-adas-steel-test-and-results
-
@Dean51 said:
As long as we are being geeky here.
Cedric's test came up on BF a while back and the consensus was there is something flawed in his tests.
I believe one of those things is his sharpening methods, early on he admits his skills are in flux. Cedric's all over the map, unknown stones Lansky, Tormek, KME, Worksharp. If he's going to do these kind of tests he needs one guided system and a consistent set of stones and sharpening angles. Even two tests per steel one polished edge and one toothy edge, some steels just won't hold a polished edge for flip.Another issue is he seems to not take hardness into account, you can't just test a random steel sample you have to find a maker that does their heat treat right. If you're testing steels alone you can't use steel from Ka-Bar and ESEE who run their steel soft for toughness and not hard edge retention.
Just on his low end steel test Cedric has made some serious errors. Cedric has Case true sharp (420HC) a near equal to Buck's Boss treated 420HC, that's the first time I've heard that. Case runs their steel very soft, where Buck pushes 420HC much harder.
440C is listed as an equal to Case CV not hardly, Case CV is just a modified 1075 or 1085. Pretty low end stuff.
AUS-8 will hold an edge twice as long as Case True Sharp 420HC. Well heat treated AUS-8 is very close to 1095.
One ZT CPM S35VN at 109 cuts and another at 198 cuts, whats going on there.
From my own test on Home Depot moving boxes one Queen D2 will out cut all three blades of a Case Stockman. Doesn't seem to match Cedric's test.Cedric did manage to show geometry helps, steel being the same all his 17 Degree per side edges out cut the 20 DPS edges.
He's a nice guy and doesn't take himself too seriously and his tests were valuable from a real world perspective if only to have a nailed down anecdotal account to reference. The problem came when he started mixing sharpening methods into his list. Lansky polished in the same list as Worksharp convex edges. At that point all points of comparison collapsed and I stopped watching the lens tests particularly.
-
I've seen his videos and enjoyed them.
He's just not ready to test steel.
-
I'm a steel enthusiast. I like all kinds of steel. Most descent steel with a good heat treat and good edge geometry will give good performance. It is when you want to get past the good stage that things get interesting. :D
-
@Dean51 said:
I've seen his videos and enjoyed them.He's just not ready to test steel.
Everything else is fine, but that I cannot agree with......
Pete does not take himself too seriously......
He is intelligent and logical enough to recognize his own mistakes and shortcoming, given time those might be addressed.
(disclaimer) I don't know of anybody else with that volume of data, even if imperfect, and there's a lot of value in that.
He might not take hardness into account, but he's most definitely aware of it's influence unlike some YT'ers...........doesn't hit me as the type of guy that would benefit from owning a Rockwell tester......

-
@Gerhard, have you seen Michael Christys videos? He's has some great discussions on steel. I see Cedric commenting on his videos. A lot of his information goes over my head but its very interesting non the less.
-
@Aloha007 said:
@Gerhard, have you seen Michael Christys videos? He's has some great discussions on steel. I see Cedric commenting on his videos. A lot of his information goes over my head but its very interesting non the less.Yes, subscribed and I've shared some of his videos here.......but honestly I struggle to stay awake all the way through one......

I know he tests as well, but unless I've missed it (very possible) I haven't seen his results compiled or him discussing them?
And.......he's a masterful sharpener, but how many people can do what he does?
C&A is more real-world in that sense....
-
I've gotten to a point where I think there is a "point of diminishing returns". I don't think I 'need' CPM S110V or ZDP-189 for a daily knife. And the cost of knives made with these steels tends to be a bit prohibitive.
I know there are some amazing steels out there (and have tried a few), but I've found that I can can get a nice balance of utility, performance, ease of sharpening, and ease of maintenance from a few mid-range steels.
Experimenting--as a user--with different steels is fun for me, but I keep coming back to the basics: traditional steels with a good heat treatment are 'good enough' and likely more than I even need. The irony here is that I often 'abuse' steels that are often perceived as being less advanced or having lower performance, e.g. O-1 or 1095, because I wouldn't want to abuse my S90V knife (right?) and then find that these "lower performance", old-school steels perform amazingly well and are incredibly durable.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login