Leatherman Free P2/P4 Club and Feedback Thread
-
Maybe just pop a washer in the knife slot, so the tool could be reverted for resale later on?
-
As promised. The comparison photos. Free P4, Spirit, and Wave+.
Yes, I painted the part of the Wave file that shows when closed. Think making lists is OCD? hehe

Any questions, just let me know. :)
Scissors:

Big flat drivers. The P series big-flat doubles as a package opener/pry bar. The Spirit big-flat double as a pry bar/wire bender. Wave is a just a big flat and can be used for medium MT prying duties like opening rusty paint cans.

Side view of steel stock used and profile.

P series small flat doubles as an awl/sewing thingy. The Spirit has a small-ish dedicated flat-driver and actual pointy awl without sewing eye. Wave has reversible micro-phillips and flat-driver exchanger, but no awl to speak of.

Phillips drivers profile shot. The Spirit and P series phillips are similar in profile, but the P phillips would be better for #2 phillips and possible larger screw heads. Of course the Wave has the awesome bit exchanger, which includes from the factory a #2 phillips/medium flat combo bit.

Can openers. P series went with a semi-circle for the new line. No extra use for the can opener on the P series. The Spirit has a medium-ish flat driver on the tip. The Wave can opener has a nice wire stripper integrated.

Serrated blades. I used my butter-blade Spirit version for the shot.

Plain edge blades. I used my regular blade Spirit version for this shot.

Wood Saws. All tapered and sharp as smurf. The P4 saw is thick and stout feeling. The Spirit saw is thin and would jam less easily, but be a little weaker. The Wave saw is in between the two.

FILES. O.k. Wave and Spirit win this one HANDS DOWN. I won't go into too much detail, but all of them are nicely cut/made(with the Spirit and Free files being precision cut). The P2/P4 file is very short with a cross-cut side and single-cut side. The Spirit has a cross-cut on each side with very slightly different aggressiveness(nearly redundant). Wave has a cross-cut side and diamond-coated side(diamond coated is very nice for fine finishing file-work.


Combo tools. The previously pictured P series flat driver is also a package opener. The Spirit has a tool dedicated to being a chiselly-thingie and wire-stripper. Spirit wins this one hands-down. Wish LM had done more of the circle grinding edges on the P series. The P series does offer a small wire stripper on the medium flat driver, complete with Carl Sagan style instructions etched onto the blade.

Pliers. Free series has a beefy pivot, but small bolt-area. Spirit has a small bolt area, but has more room in the bolt area, because the cutters are ridiculously small compared to modern tools. P4 and Wave+ have replaceable cutter blades, which I really like. Victorinox needs to follow suit with replaceable cutters AND stop using rivets on the SwissTools. I like screws I can tighten/loosen/service the tool with.

P2, P4, Spirit, Wave, and Charge TTi in a row.

P2 and P4 side-by side shots.




-
@AimlessWanderer said:
Can I test your brain on one thing, please? What would be stopping someone buying a P4, and removing the knife layer to make it bladeless, if they lived/worked somewhere where a knifeless tool would be advantageous? I can't see anything beyond needing to shorten the screws a little, except maybe the lock release
I think the tool can be disassembled and reassembled easily enough, but there are a lot of parts to get back into place. The large screws use a nylon patch, which won't get any more solid over time. The small screws however use high strength chemical thread locker, and will get harder to remove over time. Applying some heat will break the bond though.
The straight blade is precisely 0.100" thick. The mounting hole is 0.120" in diameter. You could replace the blade with a washer that is up to 0.35" in diameter. McMaster part: 99604A101 probably would work.
Another option is to laser-cut some other useful implement out of 0.1" plastic, or water jet something from metal. -
Just wanted to thank you ZapWizard for your pictures and post
. Really neat to see the tool taken apart and photographed. I qapprectiare all you've added to this thread. I was also wondering who would be the first to take their tool apart :D. -
@Aloha said:
Really neat to see the tool taken apart and photographed. I qapprectiare all you've added to this thread. I was also wondering who would be the first to take their tool apart :D.My other daily carry is a "Make Warranty Voider" . 8)

This is the result of two evenings of 3D modeling so far. (I haven't yet modeled the pliers.)
On previous tools I only made a representative model, accurate only on the external most dimensions and any parts the holster interacted with.
This time I wanted to challenge myself to make a extremely accurate 3D model. I also did it as a sort of skill builder, to get better at CAD and product design.

After I took it apart: I took a macro photo on each part with a ruler in the shot. I use this, along with calipers, to 3D model each component in detail. The accuracy this way ends up about +/- 0.3mm.
The blade image above could for example be used by an enterprising individual to make a replacement blade from better steel (To those able to do that
send me one when your done).Once I sign up for R&D access forum: I will make a thread to get feedback on potential mods and holster designs.
-
Great photos GLBM. Holy smurf they took ages to load on my crappy internet connection though. Do you resize them at all?
Oh and
@gerleatherberman said:
Think making lists is OCD? hehe

-
Lots of great info on the Free :o

and Welcome to
Zapwizard
Great exploded view of the Free as well

-
Excellent pics GLBM and ZW

-
@LoopCutter said:
I appreciate each who have shared their impressions and pictures of the new toys.One item I have not read, yet, is the pocket clip and how the P2 and P4 will ride in a front pocket.
Thank you AWL[emoji14]
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Ok, here is a pic of my P2 clipped in front right pocket.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Looks like a good fit.
-
@Syncop8r said:
Great photos GLBM. Holy smurf they took ages to load on my crappy internet connection though. Do you resize them at all?Oh and

thanks, Syncop8r!
I like to offer pics that can be blown up. I forget some people don't have super fast internet connections. Sorry about that.
Good point out.

In regards to the three blades not being identically oriented in that photo, the already shortish(relative to the P4 and Wave) SE blade looked WAY to short when placed with blade/edge-to-the-right, so a desicion was made to face it the other way to make the comparison fair. I hate that photo too.
-
@gerleatherberman said:
...
You could always use two security torx bits to tighten the pivot a little, if you're worried about any tools popping open when slipping the pliers or cutting something thick. But, if LM had made the tools tighter, then they wouldn't be easily opened OH and people would be talking about how tight they are. Catch-22.
...When I read this I thought you were right, and I wanted to comment that it reminded me of people saying they wanted torx bits on the Spirit instead of rivets, so they could tighten or loosen it. Which is also a Catch-22 since the rivets as they are don't need tightening/loosening, and what do I read on the next page ...

@gerleatherberman said:
... Victorinox needs to follow suit with replaceable cutters AND stop using rivets on the SwissTools. I like screws I can tighten/loosen/service the tool with.I can only speak for myself but I have never experienced any kind of loosening on the tools of my Swisstools or Spirits, that's the beauty about their design, it's rock solid. And the whole movements of opening the pliers and the click when you close them again are all pure mechanickal (no, not you Nick
), I mean ... I do like that the Free seems to offer the same experience, but I also do think that the magnets are a bit like cheating to achieve the same feeling people have on the Swisstools.And don't get me wrong, I really like what I'm seeing (and reading) here in this topic, from the pics shown here I would say that the Free looks like the lovechild of a ST300 and a Swisstool/Spirit. I mean, some of the tools have a real Victorinox look going on, the big flat/prybar, the combo tools, the design of the phillips and even the can-opener. To be honest, I always liked how sturdy the phillips was on the Swisstool/Spirit, but I preferred the tip of the phillips on the ST300/Rebar, especially when I had to use it for a longer period, for one screw it didn't matter, but if I had to use it on 10 screws or more, I always grabbed for my ST300 or Rebar.
And you're absolutely right about Victorinox needing to upgrade their tools with replaceable cutters. I don't understand why they haven't done it already, it wouldn't take much R & D to design it, and it would only affect the production of the plierhead, and I think it would boost the sales of the Swisstools quite a bit (I know I would like to get one right away, and by one I probably mean 4 or 5 ::)).
Anyway, really liking the looks of the Free P4 and I guess I've made my choice and I'm going to get myself one (but if it fits, I will wear it in one of my black sheaths ... :P).
;)
-
Sorry about my wording, T-G!
I meant to implicate the problem with the SwissTools as the problems I have with them. My Spirit is almost too tight to use after 30 days at my work. And I'd love to be able to loosen the pivots to clean them out and reduce nail breakage. A little metal dust got in my Spirit pivots and not you can see the half moon scoring in the pivots, because I can't get them perfectly clean/loosened. I do not like rivets for those reasons.

-
@gerleatherberman said:
Sorry about my wording, T-G!I meant to implicate the problem with the SwissTools as the problems I have with them. My Spirit is almost too tight to use after 30 days at my work. And I'd love to be able to loosen the pivots to clean them out and reduce nail breakage. A little metal dust got in my Spirit pivots and not you can see the half moon scoring in the pivots, because I can't get them perfectly clean/loosened. I do not like rivets for those reasons.

No need to apologize mate, I have no problem with what you said.
I mean, we all use our tools for very different things, and since I never had the tools on my Spirit/Swisstool tighten up I assumed this didn't happen on them. And I've always been able to clean them and remove any bits by cleaning them out using nothing but hot running tap water and a small brush. But like I said, you might use them for a lot of different stuff than I do.
P.S.: Just found out that the Free P4 will get to Belgium (and to me
) a little sooner than August ... 
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
No need to apologize mate, I have no problem with what you said.I mean, we all use our tools for very different things, and since I never had the tools on my Spirit/Swisstool tighten up I assumed this didn't happen on them. And I've always been able to clean them and remove any bits by cleaning them out using nothing but hot running tap water and a small brush. But like I said, you might use them for a lot of different stuff than I do.
P.S.: Just found out that the Free P4 will get to Belgium (and to me
) a little sooner than August ... 
thanks, man!
Glad to read they will be available soon! How many of each are you going to buy?
:D -
@gerleatherberman said:
And I'd love to be able to loosen the pivots to clean them out and reduce nail breakage. A little metal dust got in my Spirit pivots and not you can see the half moon scoring in the pivots, because I can't get them perfectly clean/loosened. I do not like rivets for those reasons.
I loved the Spirit until this happened to me also. It was a nightmare to get the tools opening and closing properly again, and they still feel a bit gritty. It was when this first happened that my true love for the Wave began.
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
Just found out that the Free P4 will get to Belgium (and to me
) a little sooner than August ... 
Ah... the wealthy 1%

I do want to see it when we meet up!!

-
@Buzzbait said:
I loved the Spirit until this happened to me also. It was a nightmare to get the tools opening and closing properly again, and they still feel a bit gritty. It was when this first happened that my true love for the Wave began.Funny you mention that. I've developed a strong affection for the Wave and Charge. The exchangeable bit drivers sealed the deal.
And, of course as you know, we can take the Wave apart and make it function like new again.The more people mention it, the more I wish, at least, the P4 had the driver exchanger or included a slip-over adapter that works with the bit kit.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login