Leatherman Free P2/P4 Club and Feedback Thread
-
I havent been around here for a while and really stopped by to see what people were saying about the Free series. I'm a bit surprised that alot of members here seem to like it? i just cant get on board with the tool selection, the metal filing attracting magnets and the locking tabs sticking out on the handle. i wear a Surge on my side 50hrs a week so i may be a bit jaded...i'm always comparing other tools to it, and they all fall short for my needs. maybe if they had one with replaceable bits and/or file/saw socket i would think differently, but if feel like the Free series are far from the best they have made like they are advertised.
-
@Walley said:
I havent been around here for a while and really stopped by to see what people were saying about the Free series. I'm a bit surprised that alot of members here seem to like it? i just cant get on board with the tool selection, the metal filing attracting magnets and the locking tabs sticking out on the handle. i wear a Surge on my side 50hrs a week so i may be a bit jaded...i'm always comparing other tools to it, and they all fall short for my needs. maybe if they had one with replaceable bits and/or file/saw socket i would think differently, but if feel like the Free series are far from the best they have made like they are advertised.Indeed. Many members mirror your feelings about the Free series. LM really did a bad job with promoting the Free P series. They went after the Wave-user market and the Free P2/P4 isn't going to replace a Wave in a work environment. I feel the market for the P series the same as high-end knives. Not all that practical, but well appreciated, for the design and quality. The tool is really awesome to use, but isn't very practical relative to the Wave in work environments.
I carried mine for several weeks and with minding where I laid the P4 down, managed to avoid a lot of metal debris and dust(I restore antiques, so steel wool and I are best friends..haha). The little bit I did get in/on the tool was easily blown off/out with compressed air or removed with packing tape.
And....The Surge is in a class of its' own. Can't really think of a tool that is more capable.

-
I have made bit adapters to fit my Wingman, Vic combo tool and straight screwdriver. They are easy and cheap to make. I am getting my P-2 tomorrow. I will check it out and see if they will work on it.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Bear and Son had an adapter for their rectangle shank Phillips.
So did the Harley Davidson BuckTool.One of them might actually fit the Free Phillips, but they're impossible to find.

And they might not fit anyway.
-
When the tool came out I thought "WOW" I want it! I waited for I while also because here in Italy it was not available and still it is..... Then I started to read the first comments and aside the fidget factor, the tool is pretty standard! I mean is absolutely awesome in its class but I can make the same thing with all other multis...... It has not interchangeable bit, that flat phillips not so nice compared with that one on super tool..... So now I wait a bit (probably more than a year.) to see reasonable price, than I will take my decision. For now the winner could be the charge for sure
-

The party trick of the Free P2/P4 is fidget factor. Yes, the all OHO/no fingernail needed things are awesome, but it just doesn't punch at the Charge's level. :ahhh -
More feedback from my side.
Due to my personal objective to present LMN tool in my native language on YT i ordered a P2...aaaand a P4 came instead.
And it was real usefull to compare with my "modded" with spacers P4
OEM tool is moor loose, especially o the pliers. The oil they use is much better than what i use, so implements open a little easier, altough my zytel spacers make the opening more refined :).
The handles have play, side play, out of the box, and everything inside moves along the scales. I wished they did not...at one point in the reassembling process i taught i f***cked something.
My modded one, when opening the main tools, they do not get so close to the pliers, i believe it is the bigger surface of the spacers...or maybe i just want to believe my ideea with larger surface spacers and thcker bolts.
Except the scissor, the scissor behaves the same, altough not so close tot the pliers when resting, yet it is new, and so was the modded one.
Proof of that 0.1mm space/tolerance on the pliers needed for smooth opening and closing.
I taught it was poor manufacturing , and this lead to my pliers not closing easy.
On the packaging it says one hand opening, true, yet with some exercise and not so smooth as the Wave &co, AAAAAND with the tools touching the pliers head



-
Got my replacement P2 yesterday.
I don't know if I am just hypersensitive now, but there seems to be a lot of play between the handle and plier head while opened.
Lots of wiggle to the sides.I assume that's normal due to the interlocking pins that line when closed.
Sent from my Pixel 3a XL using Tapatalk
-
It is normal for the P series, but tightening the pliers mount screw bolts a bit gets rid of a lot of it. Though, as a consequence, it doesn't flip around quite as freely. I find it perfectly usable when tightened up a bit though. :)
-
Allright then... Got myself a P2... More suited for my needs... Yet... I have some points to stress:
On the pliers side, one side has too much space. I need to tighten it. For the price, i wished LMN did that (hear me LMN? Do you hear our feedback)
Pocket clip aint that cool after all, way to high. I'm gonna loose it, aint my style after all.
I like the slimness and the fact that one side of the scales are... Curved somehow 3D( not flat) , would have been nice to be on both sides.
Wayyy wayyy to gressive with the serrations on the blade.
Other than that... I like it more than the P4.
P4 is thicker, flatter and has a saw and a serrated blade as extra. If it had a saw and file, than P4 would have ruled them all.

-
Congrats, Raoul!

Man, that is a boneheaded mistake from the assembler team with the screw not tightened down at all.

Out of curiousity, is your P2 dated?
-
No date code.
-
Know what bothers me the most? I want the P4 but can't believe that they chose to put a lanyard ring on the heavier tool...how does that make any sense? Shouldn't the p2 have the lanyard or each of them have both?
-
Now, that i used them both it makes sense.
Either way, new batch has pocket clip.
Pocket clip is quite big, high, stand out and affects the ergonomy. It does the trick while the tool is in the pants, yet it is too big.
P4 is quite thick, with the pocket clip it would have been too thick in that particular area. -
@Happy Gilmore said:
Know what bothers me the most? I want the P4 but can't believe that they chose to put a lanyard ring on the heavier tool...how does that make any sense? Shouldn't the p2 have the lanyard or each of them have both?I thought Leatherman changed this, I believe they sell the P4 with the pocket clip now on their site.
And if you get one with the lanyard ring, you can contact them and they'll send you a pocket clip (not to all countries apparently, but I guess being in the U.S. you shouldn't have any problems). I'm still waiting for mine ...
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
I thought Leatherman changed this, I believe they sell the P4 with the pocket clip now on their site.And if you get one with the lanyard ring, you can contact them and they'll send you a pocket clip (not to all countries apparently, but I guess being in the U.S. you shouldn't have any problems). I'm still waiting for mine ...
Brilliant, gj Leatherman.

-
I kind of follow this topic since the tool is out and agree but also disagree with some comments. Anyway I could not hold myself back longer and managed to put my itching hand on a P4.

First impression is as others said it’s a good tool. But definitely didn’t worth the asking price, not in the UK anyway.
I’m missing the changeable bits, the file looks short but quite aggressive even feeling it with my hand. The most useless tool on it the ruler. My model has a bit of a stiff pliers jaws pivot. Not sure if that’s the same with others I hope it would brake in soon. Time would tell how can this serve as an edc I guess.Good evening to you all (at least those in the UK/Europe) and good morning/afternoon to the rest of you!
I've just joined and so this is my first post (be gentle) Over the past 30 years I've had most of the classic LMT stuff, not to collect, but to use for my day job (Forces/Police and now Customs work, CBP in the states) I also own a couple for my voluntary role, SAR. However, like most here I also wanted to purchase a P4 (or maybe two) but just like others in the EU, was put off by the price. I have emailed LM customer service to ask about the disparity in price (US vs Everywhere else) and await a final response.
I will, of course, keep you updated as to their reply regarding the US vs EU (or in my case UK) pricing structure which, for those of you Stateside is $247 USD or £189.99 GBP) The most I've paid previously was for my last LMT (the original Surge) which now needs replacing and was £130 (or $164, based on todays rate)
That seems like a bargain compared to the P4 and, to make matters worse...I can't find my original PST anywhere....
Take care all and stay safe!
Darren.
-
Welcome to MTo Darren

Let us know when you receive something. I don‘t think we will get more than marketing blabla, but will see

-
Good evening, and welcome to
Darren.
Would like to hear LM's reply if you receive any
... hour you'll find your PST

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login