Anyone watch the tv show Alone? [SPOILERS!]
-
@downt said:
they apparently take anyone that's female, transgender or a minority, cause they get so few such applicants, I guess? anyway, if they are your "expert instructors" God help you if you ever actually need to do this sort of thing, because they can't.If they have so few applicants, and you think they are all so hopeless, then you should have no problem signing up and winning the show next season.
As for me I hope to never have to do anything like that. My ambitions are limited to staying alive until resqued if smurf do happen when I'm out and about. Mind you, in bad conditions that can be challenging enough for even a short while.
As for expert advice I wouldn't look to neither reality shows or youtube. We have locals who live outside on a daily basis, and who are fully capable of living off the land all year round. That is based on traditional ways of life evolved over the thousands of years that humans has been living in these areas. I'd rather put my trust in that well of knowledge and experience over fancy modern gear and theories.
-
@Vidar said:
. We have locals who live outside on a daily basis, and who are fully capable of living off the land all year round. That is based on traditional ways of life evolved over the thousands of years that humans has been living in these areas.
Our Bushmen don't have the skills for cold weather, but they are just one group of people in the world that would laugh at these "challenges"
In my country there are people in the rural areas that live very much as their ancestors did. I've seen guys paddling a mokoro on the Zambezi river, middle of nowhere heading home, and let me tell you they are machines, you see rippling muscles under those black skins. They've been at it all day and I can't even stay upright in one of those "boats"
They need a hook and 2m of fishing line to fill a boat with fish......we go out in motor boats loaded with all the newest gear and blank......@downt said:
They wont be arrowing any lynxes, from what I've seen of the way they walk on the show. Like cattle, clunk clunk.From my limited experience I can only agree, question is are they filming when they have a real opportunity....?
If getting the shot. film wise, counts more than filling the belly........does not compute
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
Our Bushmen don't have the skills for cold weather, but they are just one group of people in the world that would laugh at these "challenges"Yes indeed. If the challenge was on their home turf there wouldn't really be a competition. Then again, part of the competition is about putting the contestants into new environments and see how they adapt. One of the reasons I find many participants impressive is that they do.
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I've seen guys paddling a mokoro on the Zambezi riverI had to google those :) Those mokoros are not unlike our river boats up here. I guess that makes sense - river maneuvering probably have fairly similar challenges everywhere, so design evolution gets similar too.
@Gerhard Gerber said:
They need a hook and 2m of fishing line to fill a boat with fish......we go out in motor boats loaded with all the newest gear and blank......Over here that is one of the ways to judge people you meet outdoors. If you're out and about and meet someone walking around with little gear, half normal clothes, and maybe a simple plastic carry bag or two then chances are the person is quite comfortable outdoors and knows the region well.
-
@Vidar said:
I had to google those :) Those mokoros are not unlike our river boats up here. I guess that makes sense - river maneuvering probably have fairly similar challenges everywhere, so design evolution gets similar too.That depends what your search brought up.....
The mokoros that tourists get to experience are fiberglass copies, the real thing is another beast......
They're made from one mildly hollowed out tree trunk, upright is not their preferred orientation, they leak, and they are heavier than you could imagine!
I got on one in the backwater in front of the lodge where I worked, went 3-4m and very nervously came back.......constant balancing act.
-
@Vidar said:
Over here that is one of the ways to judge people you meet outdoors. If you're out and about and meet someone walking around with little gear, half normal clothes, and maybe a simple plastic carry bag or two then chances are the person is quite comfortable outdoors and knows the region well.This might be of interest to some.....
The guys cut a few reeds, the hook and line and tied to the thick end of the reed and they rest the reed on the water - your all-natural bio-degradable fishing rod is also a float/bite indicator.
They tend to have 4 or 5 "rods" resting on the side of the boat right infront of each, and I have seen big fish take the whole rig before they can grab it. 8) -
@Gerhard Gerber said:
They're made from one mildly hollowed out tree trunk, upright is not their preferred orientation, they leak, and they are heavier than you could imagine!I got on one in the backwater in front of the lodge where I worked, went 3-4m and very nervously came back.......constant balancing act.
:D My mistake - I got some long wooden boat from the search. River boats here have a preference for staying upright - leakage and weight varies.
Boat and balancings act seems like a combination better avoided. Sounds like a wise decision! :D

-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
This might be of interest to some.....The guys cut a few reeds, the hook and line and tied to the thick end of the reed and they rest the reed on the water - your all-natural bio-degradable fishing rod is also a float/bite indicator.
They tend to have 4 or 5 "rods" resting on the side of the boat right infront of each, and I have seen big fish take the whole rig before they can grab it. 8)Interesting using it the other way around. I fear our wood would just sink instead of indicate, but worth a try just for fun.
Over here natural branches was sometimes used by people who fished without a license where that was required. The punishment for getting caught was typically confiscation of the fishing gear.. :P
-
I caught the first two episodes. I am no hunter but I always think boiling the meat of critters would be best to kill whatever lurks within?
Good point about his heart meds and the possibility of stomach woes.
I spied a Leatherman BO used by one of the females
.I guess the show is keeping with the cold climate theme. I was kinda hoping for a different climate. Poor guy with the busted leg. He was just commenting how walking on that surface was like walking on plates. Did anyone else see the lady cut herself before it happened? I was cringing while watching her use her knife. I am glad it wasn't as bad as it could have been. Glad she's still in the competition.
I'm no fisherman but I'd sure as heck be fishing my arse off. I wonder if having the bow and arrows some contestants feel pressures to hunt with them? Be really bad arsery to bring home big game.
-
Yes, she did not appear comfortable with that knife. I had told my wife about 30 seconds before, “she is going to cut her hand”
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-

So........the guy in the burnt area got more food that the rest put together


-
@downt said:
Even the fishing kit. I'd take it, but I'd take 25 BIG hooks, and use the fire, a couple of hard stones, and the modified Crunch tool to convert them into 2 hooks each, with barbs. Then I'd use the Crunch and the snare wire to convert them into 16 treblehooks and set at least half of them for mammals and birds.You wont, you lack metalurgical knowledge, what you describe will simply ruin your limited number of hooks.
Try it at home. Those thin hooks will just burn away and you will be left with scaled, soft wire at best, not usable for anthing. -
@LoopCutter said:
Yes, she did not appear comfortable with that knife. I had told my wife about 30 seconds before, “she is going to cut her hand”Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
a lot of people buy new better gear once they pass selection. that might be it.
-
A couple of MTs ( what appear to be Leatherman ), I believe I've seen a Wave BO and Surge. Shame about the cut but really glad she didn't hurt herself badly. Moras are sharp and they cut deep, maybe she didn't realize how well it would cut? I was more concerned she was cutting towards herself. Just glad she was able to clean it and continue on.
-
@Aloha said:
A couple of MTs ( what appear to be Leatherman ), I believe I've seen a Wave BO and Surge.What would a perfect multi-tool for Alone be like?
I figure you'll have a proper knife, axe and maybe a big saw anyway. So from the top of my head maybe a smaller knife for carving, a sharpening file, ferrorod (backup or main), small saw for small stuff, awl with needle head, tweezer, magnifying glass, tooth pick, scissor, pliers with cutters and precise grip, chisel/ flat screwdriver, full round PH screwdriver for arguing with tough knots and the like. Signal colors so it is easier to find.
-
From the web site, it list a Leatherman has the multitool.
I thought I observed the Surge tool locks and on one participant a large Velcro nylon sheath.Previous seasons the Surge appeared to be MT of choice, including a couple that where modded.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@Shuya said:
You wont, you lack metalurgical knowledge, what you describe will simply ruin your limited number of hooks.
Try it at home. Those thin hooks will just burn away and you will be left with scaled, soft wire at best, not usable for anthing.Agreed

Also, I know a treble hook has it's time and place, but in general a normal single hook has better hooking characteristics.
I would want some circle hooks in my kit....
-
Downt have many ideas, links and theories. Having ideas is good. To know that they are actually working ideas that will indeed improve upon todays proven practices they need to be tried and tested in real life conditions. Some might work, some will not, while others might provoke new experiments and evolve towards some new alternative ways. Alone in the wilderness with next to nothing is not the place or time to do fairly exotic experiments though.
I got rubbed a bit the wrong way when these got glorified over normal actually working practices and the attitude of how silly all those doing things the normal way are. I would be quite surprised if the participants on Alone haven't tried out quite a bit, and found what (kind of) works for them.
That said, I do appreciate learning about new concepts. I'll pickup that fire roll concept Downt mentioned, and I'll actually try it at some point. Before going off anywhere far though :)

-
@Vidar said:
That said, I do appreciate learning about new concepts. I'll pickup that fire roll concept Downt mentioned, and I'll actually try it at some point. Before going off anywhere far though :)
There's a youtube channel I subscribe to....wish I could remember the guy's name.......that is probably the best collection of alternative fire making methods I've seen.
That said, on most of these shows the people that counted in friction fire regretted it....
I would only want a multitool if I knew I'd have resources to make lures, and fish that would take them.
I forge on a weekly basis. I have, with myself and another person blowing on a BBQ fire (local hardwood) gotten a piece of a broken file up to critical temp, red hot basically, but you need a few degrees more to forge, never-mind forge welding. Sure you can quench it and get it hard, but then it needs to be tempered or it would break if you look at it wrong.
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
There's a youtube channel I subscribe to....wish I could remember the guy's name.......that is probably the best collection of alternative fire making methods I've seen.That said, on most of these shows the people that counted in friction fire regretted it....
I wouldn't depend on it, but interesting to know for its own sake. If I actually want a fire I'm boring enough to bring a lighter or matches.

One day I have some spare time I plan to make the mother of all fire pistons just for the heck of it. I like the concept, but the traditional design is a bit hit and miss. A fire piston that fire every time would be interesting. That would be rather expensive and on the heavy side, but maybe an interesting personal side project.
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I would only want a multitool if I knew I'd have resources to make lures, and fish that would take them.I think I would have brought one just for the options it brings for making or modifying stuff in general. Tarp, sleeping bag, snares, fishing line, pot, knife, axe, ferro rod - that is 8. The last two would be between saw, multi-tool, gill net and salt. Ok, I'm not sure about the multi-tool either. :)
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I forge on a weekly basis. I have, with myself and another person blowing on a BBQ fire (local hardwood) gotten a piece of a broken file up to critical temp, red hot basically, but you need a few degrees more to forge, never-mind forge welding. Sure you can quench it and get it hard, but then it needs to be tempered or it would break if you look at it wrong.I know that if I were to try forging fish hooks out in the wild it would likely end up with me having lots of holes in my fingers, some holes maybe closed off by stuck fish hooks, and hands which are burnt and beaten after trying to forge without tongs and using rocks instead of hammers.
Maybe I just didn't get the concept right.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login