The Comprehensive Knife Based Multitool Thread
-
@ChopperCharles said:
What’s a suspension clip?The reason I bought a Ruike rescue knife over the victorinox was the pocket clip and carabiner...
Charles.
The clip hanging off the Alox Pioneer X is a suspension clip.
Instead of the handle of the knife staying clipped up against the inside of your pocket, regardless of how you stand or sit down..... a suspension clip does the job of keeping the knife easily at hand. Meanwhile, it lets the rest of the knife go where it wants in the path of least resistance within your pocket. You don't feel it (if you position the clip in the right place on your pocket).
You can attach this suspension clip to any Victorinox with a keyring. Mine is a generic P7 clip. Victorinox makes their own as well, but that clips on your belt and dangles all the way down to your pocket (if I understand it right).

-
@ChopperCharles said:
I don't mind an extra chunky multitool, so long as it's got the tools I need. My plan is a WorkChamp and scales for a Sentinel, to get the pocket clip. That'd be the perfect camping knife.Charles.
IMHO If you are willing to deal with the bulkiness and poor ergonomics of something like the Workchamp, I think you're better off carrying a Swisstool or a Surge. Charge if the Surge is too heavy for you. Swisstool is a meager 40 g more than a workchamp's weight. Either of these do more than the workchamp, they do it better and with better ergonomics. You can even put carry on clips on them too if you wish.
Look I am a Victorinox fan, I really am. But that doesn't mean that I wont recognize whenever they've designed something that is pointless . The workchamp, hercules and the workchamp xl ( same goes for the 130 mm one with pliers and such) are difficult to justify when you compare them with other Leathie and even Vicky plier-based multitools. Yes i know that this thread is about KNIFE based multitools, not PLIER based one. But still, the hercules, workchamps and the plier ranger grips (such as the boatsman and 174) are examples of tools that were designed as "knife-based" but by cramming too much into them, they rendered them as a worse proposition than a plier based multitool. I still think that if you do not want to carry a plier based multitool and must carry a knife based one, then do so but get a knife based one that is not too unwieldy and complement it with a smaller SAK or something like the Style PS or the likes that has whatever your knife based multitool doesnt have.
Just my two cents.
-
@EtherealityX1 said:
IMHO If you are willing to deal with the bulkiness and poor ergonomics of something like the Workchamp, I think you're better off carrying a Swisstool or a Surge. Charge if the Surge is too heavy for you. Swisstool is a meager 40 g more than a workchamp's weight. Either of these do more than the workchamp, they do it better and with better ergonomics. You can even put carry on clips on them too if you wish.Look I am a Victorinox fan, I really am. But that doesn't mean that I wont recognize whenever they've designed something that is pointless . The workchamp, hercules and the workchamp xl ( same goes for the 130 mm one with pliers and such) are difficult to justify when you compare them with other Leathie and even Vicky plier-based multitools. Yes i know that this thread is about KNIFE based multitools, not PLIER based one. But still, the hercules, workchamps and the plier ranger grips (such as the boatsman and 174) are examples of tools that were designed as "knife-based" but by cramming too much into them, they rendered them as a worse proposition than a plier based multitool. I still think that if you do not want to carry a plier based multitool and must carry a knife based one, then do so but get a knife based one that is not too unwieldy and complement it with a smaller SAK or something like the Style PS or the likes that has whatever your knife based multitool doesnt have.
Just my two cents.
Totally get that - and this idea has stopped me from getting the Rangergrip 74, which on the face of it covers all your bases..... nice big knife, openers and drivers and full-sized pliers. If you need more plier and you don't mind the belt sheath, they're a good way to go if you're a diehard Vic fan. For my purposes these days the most I need pliers for is to tighten bits and pieces on camping gear and the little ones on a Vic Hercules are good enough for that.
You're also pointing out the major advantage of going with a KBMT - the handle has to be comfortable as a knife handle. So the Workchamp and probably even the Hercules or Outrider lose that advantage. But again, personal preference varies. Alexanderre (MTo member) had been a LM guy for a long while and recently has switched over to a Workchamp and seems to be happy as a clam. Personally, I don't think I want to use any 111mm Vic that's more than 3 layers. I get the sense for most large hands the Outrider is narrow enough to be comfortable (based on YT reviews). The same goes for a Pliers based tool - where the advantage can be lost by the ergonomics - (I'm looking at you LM Supertool OG)
So - yep I'd have to agree with you that something as big as a Workchamp could be off the mark when it comes to being useful and "knife based", so it may be better to go with a plier's based tool at that point. That's even more evident with a Vic Boatsman or Rangergrip 74. Unless you just want the form factor of a knife above all (which is an assumption in the topic of the thread). This is where something like a lesser-known brand like Pohaku may have an advantage, where the handle ergonomics favor the knife even though there are medium-sized pliers included. Or in many/most cases, you'll forgo the pliers entirely and go for something like a Leatherman K4x.
-

the UP Knife is a crazy looking and functioning tool..but dear god is it made well. This is a picture of mine.
-
Sanrenmu 7094 LTX-PIH-T4

-
@ReamerPunch said:
Sanrenmu 7094 LTX-PIH-T4


This looks sturdy. The phillips on the guf hook is a nice touch.. I'm sure it will work in a pinch, though it won't help much for recessed screws. -
The Phillips works but it folds if you press too hard.
-
@ReamerPunch said:
The Phillips works but it folds if you press too hard.thats scary. Have you seen the land knife?? Land 9047


-
The Land knife I’ve handled was surprisingly well done. The liner locks were good and the steel seemed okay.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Every few months I see this somewhere and think about getting it. It has a nice toolset, and is well made.
The thing is, it seems a little too big. I already have a Ruike LD51 and many 111mm SAKs, with far more tools than this, at about the same size. Plus, the Rebar is about the same size and weight, and has far more utility than this. So I never bother ordering it. -
@ReamerPunch said:
Every few months I see this somewhere and think about getting it. It has a nice toolset, and is well made.
The thing is, it seems a little too big. I already have a Ruike LD51 and many 111mm SAKs, with far more tools than this, at about the same size. Plus, the Rebar is about the same size and weight, and has far more utility than this. So I never bother ordering it.Exactly lol, It seems like there is both a weight cap and a dimensional cap on a "multitool knife"
-
@Happy Gilmore said:
Exactly lol, It seems like there is both a weight cap and a dimensional cap on a "multitool knife"I was just looking at the Leatherman Free K4 a couple of weeks ago. I've gotten so used to SAKs that the Free K4 seemed too big for me... but then it becomes a matter of habit I suppose. I'm one to get very accustomed to one knife or another. Though the Free K4 is bigger than the Skeletool ... so maybe it is what it seems.
The Vic Pioneer X is basically the toolset that i need/want on most days - so a Free K4 would make sense too.
If the Gerber Armbar wasn't going up in price, I'd probably have gotten one (despite the unflattering reviews)
-
@ElevenBlade said:
I was just looking at the Leatherman Free K4 a couple of weeks ago. I've gotten so used to SAKs that the Free K4 seemed too big for me... but then it becomes a matter of habit I suppose. I'm one to get very accustomed to one knife or another. Though the Free K4 is bigger than the Skeletool ... so maybe it is what it seems.The Vic Pioneer X is basically the toolset that i need/want on most days - so a Free K4 would make sense too.
If the Gerber Armbar wasn't going up in price, I'd probably have gotten one (despite the unflattering reviews)
personally I would not recommend the K4, the T4 on the other hand is amazing. The problem with the K4 has to do with the pocket clip. its so bad I set it up left handed but carry it in my right pocket.
-
**Camillus Pocket Block **


-
I've never seen that before!

-
@ReamerPunch said:
I've never seen that before!
It's gotten suprisingly little press. I can only find one review on it (on the Amazon site) and they give it 1/5 stars because apparently the liner lock is poorly designed (the tool next to the liner lock stands out higher than the lock itself so you can't reach it).
It looks cool though. I am a fan of the Camillus claw can opener (for nostalgic reasons) so its a bit of a bummer that they use the quarter circle - but I suppose adding the small SD is worth it.
-
That's pretty cool. Though I'm partial to a beer and beans knife myself... Gotta have a can opener.
I used to know a guy that had spent time in Europe, and had gotten into the habit of using tinned fish. Who knows where he would find so many varieties of tinned herring, sardines, mackerel etc. He'd bring them to work for lunch and drive everyone in the break room crazy. Fortunately he had a SAK with a slot in the Phillips to help open those up. Just a random memory....
-
RR1464
-
Well it looks like the Leatherman Crater lineup is being discontinued. Meanwhile, the Free series knife based tools like the T2 haven't really been all that impressive. I'm really curious to see what they come up with in the future.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
