June Pocket Rocket Challenge
-
@Nix said:
I have one, but have not used it much.I'm not fond of "pull-through" sharpeners. They tend to tear out microscopic bits of metal. (This is documented with carbide pull-through sharpeners; I don't know about ceramic sharpeners.) Additionally, pull-through sharpeners only allow for one set angle. This may be perfect for SAKs, but I prefer to freehand sharpen.
In a pinch, I'd use the pull through.
I like the stone element, although I've never achieved a fine edge with it. I think it is a bit coarse (mine feels rough when I use it). I do like the variety of curves and shapes the stone has. I'm sure it'll see some use when I go to sharpen the serrations on my Vic Skipper and Soldier. (I also have a taper diamond rod that might see use on those serrations.)
The Vic sharpener seems pretty hand and easy to stash in a bag or pocket. I think it is pretty good for a 'field tool', but I'm more comfortable with some of my other stones at home. I bet more capable sharpeners may feel differently though. Some guys seem to be able to get a razor edge off a cement block.

Carbide pull throughs hog off way too much metal, partially through people using too much force with them and them being misused. They're marketed as all you need, but it'd be like touching up your edge with 100 grit stones...
The ceramic pull through on the Vic is pretty incapable of the same kind of hogging since it's fine ceramic, it's more intended as a 'hone' it's actually the sole reason I bought the sharpener. In my misguided youth I sold off my previous system whenever I upgraded, leaving me with only the Wicked Edge and stones topping out at 600 grit. The Vic has so far proved good at rejuvinating a few blades like my dull old Swisscard with a couple dozen swipes of the pass through so I'm fairly happy with it. The stone is good enough, it's just a step beyond honing, ideally you'd strop or use the pull through before letting the edge need the stone.
Quick aside, so many people are unhappy in Amazon reviews because they expected an easy sharpener and then scratch up or mess up their knives, it's convenient but you still have to know how to actually sharpen to use it, which I think defeats the purpose of the product to some degree (unless they actually include instructions that is).
Overall pretty happy with it... besides it coming apart immediately and needing an hour of love with a micro drive and straight pin.
-
@GearedForwards said:
Carbide pull throughs hog off way too much metal, partially through people using too much force with them and them being misused. They're marketed as all you need, but it'd be like touching up your edge with 100 grit stones...The ceramic pull through on the Vic is pretty incapable of the same kind of hogging since it's fine ceramic, it's more intended as a 'hone' it's actually the sole reason I bought the sharpener. In my misguided youth I sold off my previous system whenever I upgraded, leaving me with only the Wicked Edge and stones topping out at 600 grit. The Vic has so far proved good at rejuvinating a few blades like my dull old Swisscard with a couple dozen swipes of the pass through so I'm fairly happy with it. The stone is good enough, it's just a step beyond honing, ideally you'd strop or use the pull through before letting the edge need the stone.
Quick aside, so many people are unhappy in Amazon reviews because they expected an easy sharpener and then scratch up or mess up their knives, it's convenient but you still have to know how to actually sharpen to use it, which I think defeats the purpose of the product to some degree (unless they actually include instructions that is).
Overall pretty happy with it... besides it coming apart immediately and needing an hour of love with a micro drive and straight pin.
Great info here. I'm currently planning on getting a sharpening system that would do well for Opinel knives, and of course Victorinox as well. Using a carbide pull through I was able to get a nice sharp edge, presumably because there's a full flat grind without a secondary bevel on the Opinel, but you know how rabbit holes can be. Since I was able to get a notable difference, I'm wondering if there are other options besides a) table top systems with clamps or b) a proper set of stones.
Is Vic the way to go for a pull through sharpener, or are there other good options?
-
@GearedForwards said:
The ceramic pull through on the Vic is pretty incapable of the same kind of hogging since it's fine ceramic, it's more intended as a 'hone' it's actually the sole reason I bought the sharpener.I'd like it better if the ceramic elements were cylindrical rods instead of squared off blocks. I've only used the pull-through feature to really, really lightly de-burr an edge. Again, I run into the difficulty that I use the stone freehand (Meaning I sharpen consistently at an angle of 12-60º on any given stroke. ;) ) but the ceramics are set for a specific angle*.
I'll try using the stone element a bit more often. Sometimes a stone smoothes out with a bit of use.
I do like the way the stone and cap can be inserted into the stone's sheath and the sheath used as a handle. Very Vic. Very handy.
- I have a Spyderco Sharpmaker. I usually take the triangular elements out of the base and use them freehand, too. I guess I don't like having to conform to other people's angles.

- I have a Spyderco Sharpmaker. I usually take the triangular elements out of the base and use them freehand, too. I guess I don't like having to conform to other people's angles.
-
@ElevenBlade said:
Is Vic the way to go for a pull through sharpener, or are there other good options?The Spyderco Sharpmaker is a nice tool.


-
@ElevenBlade said:
Great info here. I'm currently planning on getting a sharpening system that would do well for Opinel knives, and of course Victorinox as well. Using a carbide pull through I was able to get a nice sharp edge, presumably because there's a full flat grind without a secondary bevel on the Opinel, but you know how rabbit holes can be. Since I was able to get a notable difference, I'm wondering if there are other options besides a) table top systems with clamps or b) a proper set of stones.Is Vic the way to go for a pull through sharpener, or are there other good options?
I've had great luck with the bottom ring of a coffee mug. A light touch up after breakfast to start the day. Some soup bowls work good too!
-
@Nix said:
The Spyderco Sharpmaker is a nice tool.

When you're as clumsy as me, would you be able to keep the angle steady? Do you just need to keep the blade perpendicular to the base? Is there an advantage to using this over a set of stones? (I'm guessing the answer is yes, and that it's actually easier to maintain a consistent angle) Can it get as sharp as 8000-10,000 grit stones? Am I asking too many questions?

-
@ElevenBlade said:
When you're as clumsy as me, would you be able to keep the angle steady? Do you just need to keep the blade perpendicular to the base? Is there an advantage to using this over a set of stones? (I'm guessing the answer is yes, and that it's actually easier to maintain a consistent angle) Can it get as sharp as 8000-10,000 grit stones? Am I asking too many questions?
You've got the idea: blade stays perpendicular to the base and the edge is stroked down the triangular "rods".
I think it is easier to keep a consistent angle with the Sharpmaker than with stones. (Unless, like me, you treat the rods like stones....)
The Sharpmaker comes with two sets of rods medium (grey) and fine (white). To start, use the corners of the grey rods (more aggressive), then the flats. The switch to white rods, corners first, then flats.
I can get a really nice edge using the white rods. Especially if I strop afterwards. Is it a 10K grit edge? I don't think so. I use a 12K stone to finish my straight razor for shaving. I am guessing that Murray Carter could use the white rods to get a shaving edge, but I don't think I could. I have a small pink ceramic stone that I picked up at a woodworking shop. That beauty is extra-fine and puts a super edge on a sharpened knife. I sometimes go from grey to white to pink.
I haven't settled on any one system. I have water stones, diamond plates, Arkansas stones, Sharpmaker, Edgepro, and some ceramic rods. They all work. Even a good coffee cup will work, but definitely strop the edge...on Carl's belt.

-
@ElevenBlade said:
Great info here. I'm currently planning on getting a sharpening system that would do well for Opinel knives, and of course Victorinox as well. Using a carbide pull through I was able to get a nice sharp edge, presumably because there's a full flat grind without a secondary bevel on the Opinel, but you know how rabbit holes can be. Since I was able to get a notable difference, I'm wondering if there are other options besides a) table top systems with clamps or b) a proper set of stones.Is Vic the way to go for a pull through sharpener, or are there other good options?
If you want to just use a pull through then I'd just get the Vic dual sharpener and make sure you keep on top of your edges, which is pretty easy to do since they made it as portable as a sharpie.
If you want a beginner/intermediate system then the rod systems are where you want to go. The angle is set by the rods, most systems give you at least two different angles to choose from and pack down self contained.
The Sharpmaker is great and was my last system (I regret selling it tbh, I should have kept it to keep my sharpening options more rounded), but if you're unsure what you want and don't want to drop a lot of money to test it then I recommend getting the Lansky Turnbox. It's the same principle as the Sharpmaker but less bells and whistles:
-Two set angles
-Coarse and fine ceramics
-Packs down into the small block of wood that actually makes it a system. It's literally 6 holes drilled into a block of wood.
As for the Sharpmaker, Spyderco does make higher grit rods that will fit it if you really want, they're not the cheapest of things though.
-
@Nix said:
You've got the idea: blade stays perpendicular to the base and the edge is stroked down the triangular "rods".I think it is easier to keep a consistent angle with the Sharpmaker than with stones. (Unless, like me, you treat the rods like stones....)
The Sharpmaker comes with two sets of rods medium (grey) and fine (white). To start, use the corners of the grey rods (more aggressive), then the flats. The switch to white rods, corners first, then flats.
I can get a really nice edge using the white rods. Especially if I strop afterwards. Is it a 10K grit edge? I don't think so. I use a 12K stone to finish my straight razor for shaving. I am guessing that Murray Carter could use the white rods to get a shaving edge, but I don't think I could. I have a small pink ceramic stone that I picked up at a woodworking shop. That beauty is extra-fine and puts a super edge on a sharpened knife. I sometimes go from grey to white to pink.
I haven't settled on any one system. I have water stones, diamond plates, Arkansas stones, Sharpmaker, Edgepro, and some ceramic rods. They all work. Even a good coffee cup will work, but definitely strop the edge...on Carl's belt.

Do... do you at least put the rods flat in the sharpmaker like they intend or do you Nix that approach too?

When are you going to go whole hog and get a Wicked Edge 3.0? We know you still have the storage space

I got my first real strop (well piece of leather dedicated to the purpose) recently with my whittling starter kit, but for the life of me not sure how to cleanly spread the green compund it came with, it's really hard at room temp, do I need to heat it up?

Hopefully it'll do better than a belt does

-
Great info everyone, thank you.
Maybe more in-depth than I'm ready for at this point though. :(
Seems I read somewhere that the pull-through on the Vic sharpener is angled specifically at 20 degrees, the standard angle for SAKs. (Which coincidentally is the angle from the thickness of the nub on the toothpick, according to NikGyver. So it can be used to get the correct angle when free-handing.)
For now I'll stick with the Vic sharpener and stay on top of blade maintenance. Should I pick up a used SAK in way bad shape, then I might try some of that in-depth info!
-
@SteveP said:
Great info everyone, thank you.Maybe more in-depth than I'm ready for at this point though. :(
Seems I read somewhere that the pull-through on the Vic sharpener is angled specifically at 20 degrees, the standard angle for SAKs. (Which coincidentally is the angle from the thickness of the nub on the toothpick, according to NikGyver. So it can be used to get the correct angle when free-handing.)
For now I'll stick with the Vic sharpener and stay on top of blade maintenance. Should I pick up a used SAK in way bad shape, then I might try some of that in-depth info!
Prevention is usually better than cure!
...until you fall deep enough you just want the sharpening stuff to have it. One of us. One of us.

-
@GearedForwards said:
Do... do you at least put the rods flat in the sharpmaker like they intend or do you Nix that approach too?
When are you going to go whole hog and get a Wicked Edge 3.0? We know you still have the storage space

I got my first real strop (well piece of leather dedicated to the purpose) recently with my whittling starter kit, but for the life of me not sure how to cleanly spread the green compund it came with, it's really hard at room temp, do I need to heat it up?

Hopefully it'll do better than a belt does


Uhhhh....I don't see how the base would support a flat rod. My Sharpmaker is really old. It is possible that newer versions have that option. I just jam a rod between my outstretched thumb and middle finger of my left hand. The knife to be sharpened goes in my right. Somehow it all works out.
The Wicked Edge looks very good, but not nearly as much fun as freehanding. And those mechanical sharpeners always take a bit of time to set up. It is so much easier to pull out a stone and touch up an edge. It is hard to argue against devices like the Wicked Edge, but I encourage people to become comfortable with freehand sharpening. It is easy to carry a small stone while you are out on a trip. Vic's are not known for great edge holding, but if you have a small stone it is easy to touch up an edge. Which is why I got the Vic sharpener in the first place.
I really like the Sharpmaker, but I can't recall when I last used the base......

With stropping compound, I have tried heating the compound first. I find it goes on too thickly.
Now I don't worry about getting an even coating of compound on the strop. I just rub the cold, hard compound over the surface in a couple directions. I rub it on without a lot of pressure, but I think the friction of rubbing it on still heats it enough to get it to stick to the strop.
As I strop the blade, the compound gets worked over the surface (to an extent). I think it is better to have too little compound on the strop rather than too much. I am a devoted stropping practitioner, but I'm sure there are some tips and tricks I could learn.
My thoughts on stropping as of this date:
• Top grain leather is better than the split side (balsa wood, thin cardboard, and thick paper can serve, too).
• A rigid strop (as compared to an old barber's belt strop) is best.
• Use a light amount of compound. If it builds up, remove it with steel wool or a scraper.
• Strop enough, but not too much. Over-stropping is a thing.
• Use a low angle to strop. A high angle can dull the edge, especially if you end up chasing an edge while over-stropping. If the low angle isn't doing the job, raise it slowly.....
• Green compound is great, the others (black and pink) are not needed (with possible exception of shaving razor)
• Slow and steady strokes seem to work best for me. Some gys like speedy stropping, but I haven't seen an advantage with that. -
Also: I love the Sharpmaker's rods for honing serrated blades. Simple scalloped serrations (Like Vic's or most kitchen knives) can be sharpened easily with the Sharpmaker's rods angled to use the corners.

-
Day 29
The Ambassador got a needed cleaning and sharpening after cutting tape, velcro with adhesive and aluminum foil.

-
Day 29, Very late post...
Today I took some notes using wife's Victorinox Signature

Enviado de meu moto g(6) usando o Tapatalk
-
Uhhhh....I don't see how the base would support a flat rod. My Sharpmaker is really old. It is possible that newer versions have that option. I just jam a rod between my outstretched thumb and middle finger of my left hand. The knife to be sharpened goes in my right. Somehow it all works out.
The Wicked Edge looks very good, but not nearly as much fun as freehanding. And those mechanical sharpeners always take a bit of time to set up. It is so much easier to pull out a stone and touch up an edge. It is hard to argue against devices like the Wicked Edge, but I encourage people to become comfortable with freehand sharpening. It is easy to carry a small stone while you are out on a trip. Vic's are not known for great edge holding, but if you have a small stone it is easy to touch up an edge. Which is why I got the Vic sharpener in the first place.
I really like the Sharpmaker, but I can't recall when I last used the base......

With stropping compound, I have tried heating the compound first. I find it goes on too thickly.
Now I don't worry about getting an even coating of compound on the strop. I just rub the cold, hard compound over the surface in a couple directions. I rub it on without a lot of pressure, but I think the friction of rubbing it on still heats it enough to get it to stick to the strop.
As I strop the blade, the compound gets worked over the surface (to an extent). I think it is better to have too little compound on the strop rather than too much. I am a devoted stropping practitioner, but I'm sure there are some tips and tricks I could learn.
My thoughts on stropping as of this date:
• Top grain leather is better than the split side (balsa wood, thin cardboard, and thick paper can serve, too).
• A rigid strop (as compared to an old barber's belt strop) is best.
• Use a light amount of compound. If it builds up, remove it with steel wool or a scraper.
• Strop enough, but not too much. Over-stropping is a thing.
• Use a low angle to strop. A high angle can dull the edge, especially if you end up chasing an edge while over-stropping. If the low angle isn't doing the job, raise it slowly.....
• Green compound is great, the others (black and pink) are not needed (with possible exception of shaving razor)
• Slow and steady strokes seem to work best for me. Some gys like speedy stropping, but I haven't seen an advantage with that.How old is... really old? I got mine something like 2013 I think?

You just turn the base over, the bottom accomdates the rods so you can use them as freehand stones:

I really like my Wicked Edge, I could do with higher grit stones, but I really want to upgrade to the 3.0 at some point, probably after an eventual move

I have only really stropped on the raw side of a belt or the heel of my hand (does okay actually).
Great tips though thanks! I looked at the DC4 combo stone recently, the leather pouch doubling as a strop was always a nice feature that appealed. Those sharpening cards (the one you carry in your wallet) are also nice but just too pricey over here to justify it since I don't really go anywhere to be away from my stuff anyway

-
@GearedForwards said:
How old is... really old? I got mine something like 2013 I think?
You just turn the base over, the bottom accomdates the rods so you can use them as freehand stones:
I think I got my Sharpmaker when the band R.E.M. was topping the charts and quiche was still popular. My base is just a chunk of plastic with holes in it. The underside is flat...sort of. Sal Glesser probably made it himself...in his garage...
I think it came with some brass rods that served as a guard....not sure where those went.

Still works, though. :D
-
@Nix said:
I think I got my Sharpmaker when the band R.E.M. was topping the charts and quiche was still popular. My base is just a chunk of plastic with holes in it. The underside is flat...sort of. Sal Glesser probably made it himself...in his garage...I think it came with some brass rods that served as a guard....not sure where those went.

Still works, though. :D
Does it work if you're not actually using it?

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login