Can Opener Comparison
-
Κ-7375
This is not a quarter-circle. The edge has far less belly and length, and the blade is not as tall as a true quarter-circle.

It engaged properly, or so I thought, and the initial piercing through was easy.
From then on, things get rough. The flathead tip is very wide, and in combination with the short, stubby blade, it was impossible to continue after just one cut. The flathead met the lid before the edge could cut into the lid to advance.

As with many mediocre quarter-circles, going backwards was far more efficient. The edge managed to trace around the lid, with little effort, no slipping or jamming. Ergonomics are average. The blade spine protrudes a little from the body, and there are some edges that also jab into my hand and fingers. It made little difference whether the scissors were attached or not.

As with all quarter-circles that work better backwards, this left sharp points around the rim. It did the job, albeit backwards, and was unable to completely remove the lid.

The lid was too mangled and the rim bent from trying to continue forwards after the very first cut, and I was not able to completely cut off the lid with this. I had to use the Rebar.
It does work, and if this is all you have with you, you will be able to open cans.

(this picture took 20 minutes to upload)2 points for punching through.
0 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
0 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.Total: 6
-
Roxon Flash S803
The can opener worked well. It engages the can properly and pierced through the lid effortlessly. Tracing around the lid was easy once I had found the perfect rhythm of operation. The cutting edge is shorter than the average quarter-circle can opener, so each individual cut will be shorter than with other tools. It never slipped off the rim, it never jammed, it did not create metal splinters. Ergonomics are quite good. The edges are chamfered and nothing protrudes from the frame.
The flathead once again acted like a stop. Not bad, but if it was not there, we'd have a longer cutting edge so we could make longer cuts, and open the can with fewer cuts.
Some sharp points were left behind, which happens with pretty much all the quarter-circles I've used.
Not a bad choice at all, and we have to consider that I went forwards with it being a quarter-circle. Had I gone backwards, it would have been less messy, albeit with more sharp points.
The main thing with this is that you have to find the right angle and keep a consistent, steady pace and motion, to get the most out of it.
2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
1 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.Total: 9
-
Gerber Flik
This is a claw, heavily modified, not only to make it fit in the tiny space they had available, but also to overcome how deep it is in the handle. The cutting edge sits at a different angle, so that the body of the tool will not be in the way when the edge and hook engage the lid.

If it was a traditional claw, with how deep it is in the handle, trying to engage the lid would have looked like this (Bibury 13 in 1) :

By moving the edge further back, the can opener edge and hook can engage the lid, with the rest of the tool away from the lid.
The can opener was seemingly designed to actually be able to open a can, within the limitation of space for a longer can opener.

Sadly, the good news, if any, stop here.

Piercing was easy. Holding the tool in an angle different to almost all other multi-tools was awkward. Once the can opener sinks as far as the edge will go, the tool is almost vertical. This alone makes the process challenging, but if only that was it.

Tracing is not easy. With most multi-tool can openers, you can go full circle around the lid without ever disengaging the hook from the lid. From the initial pierce to the final cut, the can openers are touching the can. With the Flik, this is not the case.
Not only does the vertical position of the tool mess with cutting, but the hook that would hold the can opener on the lid tended to slip off. Sometimes, when trying to advance along the previous cut, the edge would simply slide over the previous cut into the can, without making a new cut. Often, after a successful cut, the can opener would jam quite firmly into the lid.
The body of the tool was not bad ergonomically, but it did not matter. The process was not comfortable.

After the middle point, the lid was getting pushed into the can. I have never made such a mess with any other tool. I had to squeeze the can to force the lid to stay out of the food as I was trying to use the can opener for the second half of the lid.

It did not matter in the end. Nothing did. I discovered quite a few metallic shavings and burrs into the food.

You will be left with a lid with many jagged edges and sharp points, and a can of food that will be dangerous to consume. I kept seeing slivers in the food the more I looked, so I decided to throw away the food.

Why work around the space issue if the process of opening a can will be so awkward, and in the end ruin the food anyway? Drop the can opener, and make the Phillips square-shank, to make it stronger and fit the bit kit. This can opener is a disaster. It goes beyond being small. Even it being awkward to use would not matter all that much if it could open a can safely. But it cannot. It did a terrible job of opening the can, and most importantly, it ruined a whole can of food. Great job with this one Gerber. You matched the BuckTool's awfulness.

2 points for punching through.
0 for comfort.
0 for not jamming.
-12 for cutting.
0 for not slipping.Total: -10
-
Thanks again RP for an excellent can-opener review.

And for reminding us to always check the canned food for metal shavings
-
Oh, dear...... Gerber: "Legendary Blades". But it would seem for awl the wrong reasons........
-
Thanks for the review!
I had a Flik for many years.
Never had or ever tried to open a can with it.
It was a "Legendary" fail. [emoji23]Enviado de meu moto g(6) usando o Tapatalk
-
This video was a lot of fun to watch.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gFAStgFqbE0 -
Fun indeed, thanks for sharing it

The swivel-around-the-middle ones seem cool!Makes me want to search eBay for vintage can openers now

-
P-38

The quintessential manual can opener, the P-38 is a claw. It is interesting that the hook and cutting edge are not in the same axis. They are perpendicular to each other, which positions both at the perfect position. The hook meets the lid at a right angle, grabbing onto it wonderfully, while the cutting edge tip contacts the lid right behind the rim, and the perfect angle to pierce into it.

Piercing was easy. The P-38 is designed perfectly to engage the can like it is supposed to.
Comfort is relevant I think. It does not make much sense to expect amazing ergonomics on something this tiny. It was not uncomfortable, and after only a few cuts, I was already used to the action, and was able to rock the can opener up and down, cutting with no issues. I never felt the slightest hint of it jamming or slipping of the rim. In fact, I let go, and the can opener sat frozen in position. It was not stuck or anything close to that, just sitting comfortably on the rim, thanks to the excellent angles of the hook and blade. Tracing along each previous cut was extremely easy and surprisingly fast, once I got used to the action.
It created a rather jagged edge, and I noticed a few metal specs on the table. These are not like the metal splinters that other can openers have produced, though I would prefer no shavings at all.
I will test this again and maybe go slower, and see if I continue to get metal specs.
Has anyone else noticed any metal specs with this?
2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
1 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.Total: 9
-
P-51

The big brother of the P-38, longer, thicker, heavier. Using this was a very similar experience to the P-38.
Piercing was extremely easy. The shapes and angles are the same, and this also engages the can perfectly. No slipping, no jamming, and still sitting in place when you let go.
This was a little more comfortable. It is longer, and I got a better grip, and thanks to the blade being slightly longer, I got longer individual cuts. The difference in leverage is very noticeable and much more than anticipated. After only a couple of cuts, the action felt intuitive and I was able to cut the rid faster than any other can opener I have tested. Speed was not taken into account when using can openers for this thread, but the P-51 would be the winner. While extremely fast, the cut was consistent, easy, it never slipped or got jammed, or advanced off kilter. Most importantly, there were no metal shavings of any sort with this. It left behind a clean edge, less jagged than that of the P-38.It may be heavier and larger than the P-38, but the difference in performance was very noticeable. It is still small enough for all sorts of kits, and certainly a fantastic companion to any multi-tools that lack a can opener or have a mediocre or unusable one.
I can not wait to open a can with this again.
2 points for punching through.
2 for comfort.
2 for not jamming.
2 for cutting.
2 for not slipping.Total: 10
-
I was looking forward for you testing them RP
I think this thread would be incomplete without thwm.Excellent results for such a "simplistic" design

-
@ReamerPunch said:
which positions both at the perfect position.I should become a columnist or something.

-
@McStitchy said:
I was looking forward for you testing them RP
I think this thread would be incomplete without thwm.Excellent results for such a "simplistic" design

I love the design. How can something this small be designed so well for its purpose, and perform so well? Does your multi-tool not have a can opener? Slip a P-51 in the sheath and you're set.

-
Yeah....ok... I'll get some :D
Will try to source them locally first. -
@McStitchy said:
I think this thread would be incomplete without them.
Nice work, RP! -
-
Another great video on pocket knife can openers.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qZzebR4AGzY -
@ReamerPunch said:
"which positions both at the perfect position."I should become a columnist or something.

You do a great job. I avoid long commentary because I would make and miss many more verbal blunders.
-
Can Openers tested so far:
Bear & Son Bear Jaws
Bibury 21 in 1Buck
Bucktool (original attempt)
BuckTool (left-handed - anticlockwise)
BuckTool (right-handed - anticlockwise)
BuckTool (left-handed - anticlockwise - second attempt)
BuckTool (right-handed - clockwise - whole can)Coast Pocket PaperWeight
Coast Pocket PaperWeight (second attempt)
Craftright (Generic Suspension clone)
Ganzo G302-B
Grand Harvest K2
Grand Harvest K2 (left-handed)
Grand Harvest K6
Grand Harvest 26-SWGerber
Flik
MP400
MP400 (second attempt)
Multi-PlierLeatherman
Charge AL
Juice CS4
Juice CS4 (second attempt)
MiniTool
PST
Rebar
Sideclip
Signal
(/post/1731584)
Surge
Wave Plus
Wave Plus (different grip)
WingmanNexTool Flagship Pro
NexTool Mini Flagship
Ozark Trail Multiforce
P-38
P-51Roxon
Flash S803
Flex (claw)
Flex (quartercircle)
Phantom S802
Storm S801 (default)
Storm S801 (modded)
Storm S801SSchrade USA ToughTool
Schrade USA ToughTool (second attempt)
Sheffield 10 in 1
SOG Pocket Power Plier
SOG Powerlock
SOG PowerPintVictorinox
Bantam
Cadet
Deluxe Tinker
Deluxe Tinker (second attempt)
Farmer
Farmer (second attempt)
Fireman (liner-lock version)
Fireman (liner-lock version - second attempt)
Hercules (slide-lick version)
OHO Trekker (liner-lock version)
OHO Trekker (liner-lock version - second attempt)
RangerGrip 79
Safari Hunter
Spirit
Spirit (second attempt)
Sportsman
SwissChamp
SwissChamp (second attempt)Wenger
Highlander
Highlander (second attempt)
Ranger 06 - Mountaineer
Ranger 06 - Mountaineer (second attempt)
RangerGrip 60 -
I started this thread three years ago.

And only now did I realize I had not done a list of all the tools I tested. So, here it is. :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login