Corkscrew or Philips Head
-
Nobody said the philips could be used as a weapon. I noticed the two openers could be opened, and the philips (or corkscrew for that matter) can be opened, and then the knife can be palmed, closing your hand around it to form a fist with the philips poking out between your fingers, and with those two openers pointing up and down out of the top and bottom of your fist they will make for some wicked jabbing and slashing weapons if you get crowded and don’t have room to swing. The knife handle itself makes a fist pack and the three opened tools add some hurt to the punch. This seems like it would make a heck of a bar fighting tool to get you to the door and out. Or maybe to have tucked in your hand inside a pocket as you cross the parking lot to your car at night, or walk home through a rough area. Corkscrew seems it would be too uncomfortable compared to the philips.
-
Despite the fact that I carry and use both, I voted corkscrew. I find it to be more versatile and get a lot of use out of it even though I’ve only used it on a bottle of wine once.
I like the Tinker family just fine, but the corkscrew wins out for me and I definitely carry corkscrew models more often. Especially since I also always have a Rambler too. Between that and the can opener, I’ve got most Phillips screws covered.
-
I actually prefer neither as I carry a Recruit or some version of Alox (Cadet, Pioneer X) but if forced to choose I would pick the corkscrew for the 42 plus uses and the fact that the Philips is mostly redundant, given the can opener works really well on Philips screws, and it is awkward to use in the T position. That being said the corkscrew is not something I really have a great need for and it does create a terrible hotspot on a knife.
However if they had a Compact with the Philips I would probably carry that over anything else.
-
@Steelej1976 said:
However if they had a Compact with the Philips I would probably carry that over anything else.I wish they just made a Compact with an awl instead of the hook. The tip of the awl is a perfect box opening tool for splitting tape and saving the blades from being gunked up. But honestly the Compact falls short for me in more areas than that. I’ll take a Climber Plus please, with a Compact hook swap out to gain the nail file.
-
Got to be the Phillips for me. I'm a Super Tinker fan. The t bar Phillips does have its uses. I have never found the small 'Phillips' on the opener to be useful as more often than not the screws I need to get to are recessed. The Phillips on the rear does a much better job in this regard.
I use the toothpick and my fingers for knots, never had any trouble and never found a corkscrew to be easier. The corkscrew is useful for storage and, for me, the tiny screwdriver that sits inside is useful - however I have modified a small bit to slot into my Super Tinker and it works great. I'd like to post about it on the forum just not sure where yet.
I carried a knock off knife for a while. Nowhere near Vicrorinox quality but served me well for years (still going actually!) And it had both a screwdriver and corkscrew on the rear so was easy for me to choose based on what I actually used.
-
WOW cannot believe I didn't vote
. In years past I preferred the phillips hands down. The problem with feeling that way was my most carried SAK was Explorer. I also was carrying a Swisschamp. I'm not sure why my thinking was not in line with what I carried
.I appreciated the phillips but my vote now aligns with what I have always carried.

Corkscrew.
-
Seems like it always happens that if I’m carrying a corkscrew SAK I run into recessed Phillips screws all day. And if I have a Tinker in my pocket I will find 17 things the corkscrew would be pretty helpful for.
:ahhh 
-
@RustandToil said:
The corkscrew is useful for storage and, for me, the tiny screwdriver that sits inside is useful - however I have modified a small bit to slot into my Super Tinker and it works great. I'd like to post about it on the forum just not sure where yet.I'd really like to see what you did, if you don't mind.
-
Perhaps this is the answer! ;0)
Both and with slightly less torque issues with the Phillips toward the middle too.
Still prefer the inline though!
Which, for me, means corkscrew on the back given the choice of only one.

-
@marlowe221 said:
Seems like it always happens that if I’m carrying a corkscrew SAK I run into recessed Phillips screws all day. And if I have a Tinker in my pocket I will find 17 things the corkscrew would be pretty helpful for.
:ahhh 

-
@Jazz said:
I'd really like to see what you did, if you don't mind.I've just posted a video here: https://youtu.be/M7nVKMzYzyM but once I get back at my laptop I'll add a thread in the Mods section with some photos. Very basic but I've found it really useful!
-
I prefer the look and feel of the Phillips, especially when whittling with the small blade. I’ve come around to appreciating the versatility of the corkscrew-mini driver combination, but I don’t prefer it over the Phillips driver, even in SAKs with an inline Phillips.
-
Wow nearly 2:1 in favour of the corkscrew - Woo Hoo - Usually I thought this vote was closer!!
How about the Explorer or the 111mm Outrider - Both still only four layers, but get Phillips and corkscrew
PS. I know this is not the OP Q!!I need to do a post on my theory that Vic is against the backspring Phillips
-
Backside Philips gets my vote.
-
CS my preference.

My Telluride build has both...but my preference has moved to a layer Phillips that I can use, and CS/awl back tools.
[attach id=0 msg=2391490]
-
I like Philips,,
JR
-
Hello. One of my favorite models has always been the Climber, but I admit that although it is not in the best position and the corkscrew has as many uses as you can imagine, in my day to day the Philips is more practical for me... but no That is why I stop using models with a corkscrew. I have time for everyone. Perhaps it is more emblematic is corkscrew. But since I really like the space race, the models used were from the Tinker range
Is it like having to choose who you love more, mom or dad? -
Here's what happens to me.
I have kids. My kids are young (ages 6 and 3).
These kids have toys.
The toys often have batteries.
These batteries are always behind battery doors.
The battery doors are always screwed shut.
The screws are almost always recessed and almost always size #1 or #0 (size #1, 95% of the time).
Corkscrews don't do recessed phillips screws...
So.... that back Phillips can really come in handy!
-
@marlowe221 said:
Here's what happens to me.I have kids. My kids are young (ages 6 and 3).
These kids have toys.
The toys often have batteries.
These batteries are always behind battery doors.
The battery doors are always screwed shut.
The screws are almost always recessed and almost always size #1 or #0 (size #1, 95% of the time).
Corkscrews don't do recessed phillips screws...
So.... that back Phillips can really come in handy!
After this Christmas I experienced this with a kids drone, remote control cars etc. In the past I killed a Sak by over doing it with the backside Phillips, but may need to try again.
-
I have a manager on the keys for those :0)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
