The December 2024 Utility Knife Challenge
-
Day 19
SDI 0443C "InGenuity"
[attach id=0 msg=2508952]
FrontThis SDI cutter has some odd plastic over-shell and caught my eye when it is released. Took the chance to get one of these in this challenge.
[attach id=1 msg=2508952]
BackIt is advertised to have received 3 design awards. The outside is very different from what you see from usual A-size cutter.
[attach id=2 msg=2508952]
Bottom[attach id=3 msg=2508952]
TopThe plastic shell is ergonomic for different holding position. The slider is on the top of the cutter and hence it is left-right hand friendly without flip mounting. Near to the tip there is a cut-out notch in the plastic shell and the metal rail, which they design for cutting small strings safely without drawing the blade.




-
Continue
[attach id=2 msg=2508954]
Notch near to the tip for cutting small stringsBut from the deep down you can see it is not very different from a usual stainless steel A-size model if the plastic "over-shell" is taken away. The slider is enlarged to make it accessible from the top. And the snapper/end cap is modified to fit the plastic shell. It comes with a 30 degree blade for precision work.
[attach id=0 msg=2508954]
Parts[attach id=2 msg=2508954]
How the top is assembled. Notice the long slit for slider to move at the top of the shell, it can actually be the weakest point of this design.


-
Continue
It is auto-lock and claims the lock can hold up to 5kg. SDI aims this model towards hobbits and crafters, and most of the effort is put into making this cutter comfortable to hold in various position.
[attach id=0 msg=2508955]
"Pen" - for precision cuts. The 30 degree tip of the blade gives a clear view of the thing being cut even if only "1 or 2 snap" of blade is exposed (2 snaps in the photo above). One may want to keep it to 1 snap length sometimes since the longer it is, the more wiggle it can have. The slightly triangular cross section of the body is very similar to some of the kid's pencils and is very comfortable and stable to hold it this way.[attach id=1 msg=2508955]
Index finger against the top - the thickness at the top help giving extra pressure to the cut.[attach id=2 msg=2508955]
Hand grip in palm - the rounder body (compared to usual cutters) is easier to hold this way. This is for doing things such as sharpening an end of a wooden rod or a pencil.In summary, SDI puts out something new to the utility cutter landscape. This cutter is easy to hold in multiple positions and I think they succeed in archiving their design goal. The only thing I can pick at it is, the tip play is not as small as I wish (compared to top NT cutter A-500/A-1000 or OLFA LTD-04).
Lastly an action shot, slicing up an envelop (nothing crafty, unfortunately)
[attach id=3 msg=2508955]



-
Day 18
Despite my reservations, the Prybrid X has performed admirably thus far. Today, it broke down about a dozen boxes. Blade is a bit gunky, but still usable.

-
@LoopCutter: I like the variety of blades available for that Stanley!
@kaevin @ReamerPunch: my snap-off utility knife is likely even cheaper. I've discovered it flexes when in use.
@cody6268: the cord cutter notch seems very useful. I should get a utility knife so equipped.
@AzteCypher: those look fantastic!
@JonesE: Fastback and Bond seems like a great combo!
@BPRoberts: I should soon be breaking down a box, for the first time in months.
Day 18
Today's test subject was a padded envelope. (Contents will be seen on a day that doesn't bring upsetting news.)
[attach id=0 msg=2508959]
The Stanley cut straighter, but the DeWalt cut cleaner. We have a tie.
[attach id=1 msg=2508959]
Utility knife record: 13-0.
Stanley record: 2-3-1.
DeWalt record: 3-2-1..jpg)
.jpg)
-
@Jones: Nice pair ups in d17 d18!
@FarmerX: the HFL has a large stainless rail, so it won't flex. If it flexes, the workers wouldn't get them, that's the minimal requirement for them. Your blade comparison is interesting. I have a brunch of A-size light duty snap off blades but seldom compare them. -
Day 17. No real use--other than the fact I took inventory again. My EAB was in the nightstand for ages, but it somehow disaappeared.
[attach id=0 msg=2508963]

-
I think my favorite is RP's design. Of the color options, I think I like the light purple (top row, second from the left) the best.
-
Day 18
Open Christmas card duty tonight.
[attach id=0 msg=2508984]

-
<u>Day 18</u>
EAB got some use today.
First, I had to free up some leaf bags from their bindings.

Then, I did.... this.

So..... for those that are wondering, yes, you can cut an onion with a utility blade. It will do so quite cleanly. However, you'll have a hard time cutting some nice looking onion rings. Just thought I'd point that out.
-
Day 19
My Olfa tap knife. This rocks. Nice and flat, and it cuts extremely well. And they're inexpensive. Thank you, Olfa.

-
Day 18
The black, no name folding utility knife had such a tight pocket clip it could not be carried using the pocket clip. I used my SOG PowerDuo (which has been my desk multitool for about 10 years now) to bend it slightly so it will now go over the edge of the pocket as intended.

-
*
The 99 is Stanley's original retractable utility knife, first manufactured in 1952. I think the organic, retro design is killer. The die-cast zinc body feels like a toy from the 1960's, and you can still get a 2-pack on Amazon for under $12. I hated missing this Challenge, but am game to do a Round 2 in 2025 with those who are interested, or I could fly a Solo Challenge.Great threat, peoples. Merry Christmas to everyone.*
-
Day 19
Decided to finish my Sharpmaker stone set.

-
@cody6268: did the EAB turn up?
@LoopCutter: I haven't gotten any Christmas cards yet.
@AzteCypher: your Opinel would be perfect for onion slicing. And Mrs. FX would never have tolerated me using a utility knife for food prep.
@ReamerPunch: I should show my tap knife, shouldn't I?
@Alan K: how easily did the pocket clip bend?
@powernoodle: I have a more recent iteration of that knife (or one that's very similar). That's another I should show.
@BPRoberts: I should get some diamond stones for my Turnbox. Not that they'd help much...
Day 19
Time to see how the utility knife handles this obnoxious "hairy tape." The box had a light dusting of snow when I retrieved it. :ahhh :ahhh :ahhh
[attach id=0 msg=2509100]
The two blades were pretty evenly matched until I needed to make precise tip cuts. Score one for the Stanley: its tip is a little better for that sort of thing.
[attach id=1 msg=2509100]
I was going to cut up the box, but it is still usable, so I just flattened it. And if you want to see what was in the box and yesterday's padded envelope, here you go.
Utility knife record: 14-0.
Stanley record: 3-3-1.
DeWalt record: 3-3-1..jpg)
.jpg)
-
Day 18: light cutting.
[attach id=0 msg=2509108]

-
@ReamerPunch said:
Day 19My Olfa tap knife. This rocks. Nice and flat, and it cuts extremely well. And they're inexpensive. Thank you, Olfa.
This one is interesting, what is the model? Is there a photo showing the blade as well? Olfa is really a "no BS brand".
@cody6268 said:
Day 17. No real use--other than the fact I took inventory again. My EAB was in the nightstand for ages, but it somehow disaappeared.[attach id=0 msg=2508963]
It is a cool tool/edc-box
-
Day 20
SDI 0444C-K InGenuity Pro
[attach id=0 msg=2509113]
Front[attach id=1 msg=2509113]
BackThis is a follow up/improved variation of the original InGenuity 0443C. This model shares the same concepts, top slider, ergonomic plastic shell.
[attach id=2 msg=2509113]
Parts[attach id=3 msg=2509113]
Back of parts



-
Continue
The main difference is the tip side design. Instead of having the string cutting notch, it features a plastic slider which locks the blade and stabilize the tip. Sliding the part towards the tip, the plastic will be pushed between the rail and blade, preventing side play and locks it. You can also lock it to prevent blade from accidentally drew out in your pocket. It gives the most stable cutting point with 1 snap length in locking position, in which all the sideway movement is from the blade flexing. That can be further improved if a 58 degree blade is used (less length protruding) when desired. I may switch this one to a 3M Ti Coated gold blade (58 degree).
[attach id=0 msg=2509115]
In most stable state, locked positionThe plastic shell is also modified to a round profile instead of triangular. While I prefer the triangular shape, this new profile is still comfortable to hold.
Action shot:
[attach id=1 msg=2509115]
Slicing a piece of used paper for warping chewed gum while studying[attach id=2 msg=2509115]
In original packageI think the string cutting notch of the original InGenuity has limited use, as you can always draw out a little blade to cut the string anyway. The lock is more useful than the notch, it also increase the precision when cutting finer details. I think it is an improved version. I like the black-gold colorway as well (it also has a white-gold colorway). If it had a metal body triangular body, I will absolutely love it even more. But I have to appreciate there is a brand continuously putting effort to improve the light duty cutter designs. Also kudos for SDI to put the ugly brand name and model sticker for the InGenuity series at the back. It would be even better if it is stamped/edged or silk screen like the front, but I think they finally realized how to tune the design to be more pleasing and they are on the right track.



-
Day 19
No use today. The pocket clip was not easy to bend because of the odd shape. It is shaped like a hockey stick to accommodate the string cutting notch and this odd shape made it want to twist rather than bend under the force of the pliers. If I had to do it again, I think it might be better to remove the pocket clip first, then use the counter force of two pliers against each other. I could bend it however and wherever I wanted it bent, then reattach the adjusted pocket clip to the knife.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login