The December 2024 Utility Knife Challenge
-
Continue
Photo of all my cutters:
[attach id=0 msg=2510626]Final thoughts:
In this challenge, I bought 9 new cutters. Making it a total of 25 in the end. Some of them I have been wanting to get for a long time. Many of these look the same in the look or even in the feature list, but when unboxed and used actually they are different.Out of these brands, I like NT and Olfa the most. They are the best hands down. SDI and Tamiya are okay. Tamiya is lacking the tighter tolerance and precisions nowadays and slide more to the "bigger and strong" side with less precision with special features they think would be useful for their audience like the driver tip and fins in some of their models. SDI lacks polish in some of their models. I think they can "do it" but choose not to, to keep their cost down. They have innovated in their design with ingenuity series or the model which I do not own like the 3006C.
There are still some models I want to get hold of like the 3006C mentioned above, the Knipex CutiX, the NT A300 we used to use in art lessons, the NT K200RP and Olfa 180 which are the original forms of S-202P, the wood composite OLFA WD-AL, the NT L-2000GRP etc, but I should stop before my wife gets mad.
Thanks Dan for the challenge and all of you who joined or tag along and bared with my utility cutter obsession. Hope you enjoyed.

-
@LoopCutter: great bones on that Stockman! I assume it's a 75?
Yes, a 75. Covers are CASE’s Mediterranean Blue. Steel is SS.
Thank you😉 -
@Farmer X said:
~
@LoopCutter: sky blue bone? I bet that's pretty!
~I owed you a picture back from day 6
The package contained a MiniTrapper in Sky Blue, a back up since I had not found a Trapper in the requested color.
[attach id=0 msg=2510635]
I did finally find a regular trapper in Sky Blue, arrived on 12/23!
So during my search and digging deep in dealers inventory my search for one knife, allowed me to fine four additional knives. A mini (pictured), a pocket worn grey bone Tribal, and two different Sea Dragon models. 🙄

-
Day 29: no use for the knife. However, while opening my dinner, I found I've been wrong about Wenger can openers for a decade. They don't suck.
On the eve of the Buck challenge, I surprised to learn my beef with the Wenger can opener wasn't design flaws, but simply user error. Honestly, I've found that adjusting the angle (I was letting the tool pierce too deep into the can), it's faster than just about every other knife-based can opener I have, and might even tie with my P-51.
Hard to believe that I've had Wengers with can openers for a decade, but just now figured out how to use them. The reason they kept getting stuck in the can was because I was letting the can opener go to far.
[attach id=0 msg=2510649]

-
Day 30
Today's pic is my surprise favorite of the challenge, the Prybrid X. When it came in, I thought it was going to be too wimpy for much of anything. I expected the prybar to pry the knife apart and the xacto blade to be too small for much use. And while I wouldn't want to be stranded in the woods with it, or have it be the only multi for the rest of my life, it handles my basic EDC needs pretty well in a nice little package. Also, comes with a spiffy lanyard. Sometimes you just want just enough, and the PB-X does that.
The full size Prybrid would be a great companion for working around the house, giving you a bit better pry surface and a larger blade. I think I'll probably swap the blade in mine and put it in the tool box.
Speaking of blades, I made it through the whole month without having to change once. It helps that I rotated between four tools.
The Lockdowns are a step up from Gerber's previous SAK-a-Like series (the Armbars), but still not great. Of the two, I prefer the Pry (the Drive's bit driver leaves a lot to be desired, and the scissors are handy). I think they get a little closer with every try at a knife based MT. Maybe we'll get a winner out of them in a couple years (hopefully one they make state-side, I think Gerber has one of the biggest US vs outsourced quality ranges in the industry.)
A utility blade is plenty for basic stuff like cutting cord and opening packages. Wouldn't really want it for food prep or whittling, but if you really hate sharpening knives (or do a lot of cardboard), you could probably get by this way.
Thanks for hosting FX! I'll see some of you in the Buck challenge for January!

-
Day 30

Badge awarded to Farmer X, kaevin, LoopCutter, JonesE, AzteCypher, Alan K., cody6268, BPRoberts.
If you have completed the challenge and I did not award you the badge, send me a PM, or request the badge and I'll get on it. Happy new year, and thanks to Farmer X for creating and hosting, and for the members who made this fun by participating and following!

-
@ReamerPunch said:

Badge awarded to Farmer X, kaevin, LoopCutter, JonesE, AzteCypher, Alan K., cody6268, BPRoberts.
If you have completed the challenge and I did not award you the badge, send me a PM, or request the badge and I'll get on it. Happy new year, and thanks to Farmer X for creating and hosting, and for the members who made this fun by participating and following!
Thank you

-
@cody6268 said:
Day 29: no use for the knife. However, while opening my dinner, I found I've been wrong about Wenger can openers for a decade. They don't suck.On the eve of the Buck challenge, I surprised to learn my beef with the Wenger can opener wasn't design flaws, but simply user error. Honestly, I've found that adjusting the angle (I was letting the tool pierce too deep into the can), it's faster than just about every other knife-based can opener I have, and might even tie with my P-51.
Hard to believe that I've had Wengers with can openers for a decade, but just now figured out how to use them. The reason they kept getting stuck in the can was because I was letting the can opener go to far.
[attach id=0 msg=2510649]
Yup, I discovered this in my Can Opener thread. The Wenger can opener is actually great, once you get used to that little quirk.

-
@ReamerPunch said:
Badge awarded to Farmer X, kaevin, LoopCutter, JonesE, AzteCypher, Alan K., cody6268, BPRoberts.
If you have completed the challenge and I did not award you the badge, send me a PM, or request the badge and I'll get on it. Happy new year, and thanks to Farmer X for creating and hosting, and for the members who made this fun by participating and following!
Thank you!!
<u>Day 31 - For good measure</u>
Used the Valet Auto Strop to open up this bag of corn nuts. Nice clean cuts!

-
Just a quick check-in to say three things. Thank you to RP for making the badges happen!
I have the prize in-hand, so awl who earn the badge will be eligible to win.
And I ain't done yet...a little bonus will be posted not long after I get home. 
-
Thanks for the badge RP!

-
Thank you ReamerPunch!
JonesE
-
-
-
@Alan K: I can't recall when I last saw a palm tree.

@kaevin: you have quite the collection of cutters! :o Glad you enjoyed the challenge.
@LoopCutter: Case sure does a nice job with their bone!

@cody6268: Wenger can openers are awesome!

@BPRoberts: good to see the little Prybrid surprised you in a good way!

@ReamerPunch: thank you again for the badge, and I think all nine who completed the challenge have been awarded!

@AzteCypher: I sure do like CornNuts!

Based on the list in this post, here are those who completed the challenge and aren't me. This is the order in which everyone signed up, and the numbers will be used to determine the winner.
- Alan K.
- AzteCypher
- LoopCutter
- ReamerPunch
- kaevin
- JonesE
- cody6268
- BPRoberts
Now to pick the winner and add a couple of photos!
-
And here we go...
[attach id=0 msg=2510828]
Cody6268 is our winner! Cody, I'm not sure if I have your address, so please PM it to me just in case. I'll get your Gerber EAB Topos on the way as soon as humanly possible. (I have to work on Saturday, so I'll do my very best to make it happen on Thursday or Friday.)
And now for those new photos...
Day 31
Inspired by JonesE, I purchased this today.
[attach id=1 msg=2510828]
It's a Milwaukee Fastback, bearing the number 48-22-1501. The metal handle gives it a nice heft, and the blade opens and locks into place easily...just a push of the button and a roll of my wrist. I suspect some adjustment may be needed, as blade retention isn't as secure as I'd like. The cord cutter notch likely would have worked better if it wasn't so close to the blade tip. And I haven't figured out how works the scoring assist (not that I have much use for such a thing). So far, it's acquitting itself nicely.
[attach id=2 msg=2510828]
Thanks again to everyone for making this such a terrific challenge!


.jpg)
.jpg)
-
Congratulations Cody!

Thanks for the give away and for hosting, Farmer X! This was tremendous fun!
-
Day 30:
Spent the day on Flight Simulator: 2020 and some model train repair (more on that during the Buck challenge--I'll have to go by a new hobby shop to get some parts before I keep going). Had the Coast and Knipex for the train stuff, ancient Magellan GPS unit (for pulling up some saved coordinates) and Xbox controller on my desk.
I honestly found little a utility knife couldn't do, and I love the ability to swap out chipped blades instead of spending half a day repairing damage. I'm glad Farmer X hosted this challenge, as most of mine spend their days in toolboxes or as second potato--not my normal cutting tool (which as of late, is becoming more and more towards fixed blades around the farm). I'm surprised at how well they performed. The thin blades cut much better than a thicker pocketknife blade. Plus, I'm not afraid to scrape, or cut things that might quickly dull a regular blade.
So far:
Stanley. One of my favorites. Light, thin, and rugged. Easy to unlock as well. While the blades are hard to find (only a small farm supply sells them), they sharpen up well.
Valet. For light use, you can't go wrong. Weighs effectively zilch, is paper thin, and takes single-edge razor blades (need to order some without the reinforcement). That being said, the near-century old carbon steel blade in it still holds an excellent edge.
Klein. My work knife these days, and the one I often use the most due to the screwdriver. It is heavy, though.
Coast--pretty lightweight, but flimsy compared to the EAB.
EAB. Carried one for years. Personally, it's my recommendation for a first utility knife. Since my current one is still MIA, I'm grateful Farmer X has given me one of his.
Olfas.A little long for pocket carry, but light and very well made. I'm going to try a solid blade (non-snap off) in the larger one, as it's very easy to use one-handed. Thus, I can use it as a regular retractable blade knife.
[attach id=0 msg=2510849]

-
@ReamerPunch said:
Posted on December 31.
Nice one! :D
I enjoyed all the different models you posted.
I think I'll look into NT. I've been getting lots of Japanese tools from Amazon JP so I'll see what NT tools I can get.Speaking of NT
Discovered this a while back, it is interesting.[attach id=0 msg=2510864]
[attach id=1 msg=2510864]
RES-1200GP I think it is discontinued. More like a seat belt cutter and glass breaker with extra cutter function. I don't have a car to throw one into so, I will pass this one.Japanese also have a "middle size" between the light duty A size and L large size, they call it middle size H. And there is an extra large size as well. H and XL blades are hard to come by though.


-
Thanks Jones, Fx and RP. I'm glad that you enjoyed my posts.
Here the snap off ones are the major, and trapezoid utility blades are minority.
Thanks to you guys I've learnt about the Valet Auto Strop, Olfa CTN-1 (and get one myself) and also the Stanley 10-049 and many more.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login