December 2025 Tool Box Challenge
-
@fullbreakfast said:
Now I might be wrong, but I don't think the rules require you to do that. You can't carry any multi-functional tools on your person, but I believe it is OK to leave the SAK in your kitchen drawer, the Leatherman on your work bench, and so on. And to use them if you have occasion to.Maybe vehicles is a grey area. I have a small pouch with some useful things in it in the door of the car, which includes a SAK and a UK legal MT (knifeless Fuse). They don't get used from one month to the next, they are there for just in case. I was planning on leaving that pouch where it is. But if there a ruling that vehicular carry is a no-no, I will take it out.
There are always rules questions. I think our friend Looper is saying he doesn't trust himself to not reach out and fiddle with a multi of some sort during the month. Watch a little TV. Eat some turkey. Clean his fingernails with a SAK. Accidentally. Oops, what did I just do? I think he is just doing a 'lock up the bottle in the cabinet just in case' sort of thing. Is he required to cleanse his domain of wicked multi thingies by the rules? No. Question two. Is someone taking the challenge free to use them if you have occasion to? Yes, but you will need to drop out of the challenge. The world doesn't end if you have to leave a challenge, right? Leave the pouch in your vehicle if you wish. Just don't use it. Prepare alternatives before you start the challenge. Does this mean that your wife/housekeeper/sister/brother/whatever can't use a multi tool to open the can of Bumble Bee Tuna in spring water to make sandwiches for the both of you? No. Sugar Bear or Bubba can do whatever they want. You can eat the sandwich with a clean conscience. This is your challenge, not theirs. Is picking up a multi to move it enough to disqualify? No. If your son leaves your Wave out in the rain, by all means dry it off and put some oil on it. Just don't use it. Or let him use it again if that is how he does it. How about taking a photo of your Spartan for Spartan Saturday? You would be using your multi for something in that case, I think. Take your Spartan or Surge or whatever photos during November and post those photos in December. Too strict? Maybe. Nobody has to post photos to the daily threads or clubs here. Many members never do. What if you want to post an Opinel or traditional knife photo? That is fine since it isn't a multi. Do that anytime you please. Get a multi in the mail or as a Christmas gift? Open it up, look it over, pass it around, enjoy. Just don't carry it or use it.G

-
@fullbreakfast said:
Now I might be wrong, but I don't think the rules require you to do that. You can't carry any multi-functional tools on your person, but I believe it is OK to leave the SAK in your kitchen drawer, the Leatherman on your work bench, and so on.And to use them if you have occasion to..Maybe vehicles is a grey area. I have a small pouch with some useful things in it in the door of the car, which includes a SAK and a UK legal MT (knifeless Fuse). They don't get used from one month to the next, they are there for just in case. I was planning on leaving that pouch where it is. But if there a ruling that vehicular carry is a no-no, I will take it out.
I read IMR's earlier post about this wrong. I think you can leave such things where they are, but NOT use them.
-
@IMR4198 said:
There are always rules questions. I think our friend Looper is saying he doesn't trust himself to not reach out and fiddle with a multi of some sort during the month. Watch a little TV. Eat some turkey. Clean his fingernails with a SAK. Accidentally. Oops, what did I just do? I think he is just doing a 'lock up the bottle in the cabinet just in case' sort of thing. Is he required to cleanse his domain of wicked multi thingies by the rules? No.
Question two. Is someone taking the challenge free to use them if you have occasion to? Yes, but you will need to drop out of the challenge. The world doesn't end if you have to leave a challenge, right? Leave the pouch in your vehicle if you wish. Just don't use it. Prepare alternatives before you start the challenge. Does this mean that your wife/housekeeper/sister/brother/whatever can't use a multi tool to open the can of Bumble Bee Tuna in spring water to make sandwiches for the both of you? No. Sugar Bear or Bubba can do whatever they want. You can eat the sandwich with a clean conscience. This is your challenge, not theirs.
Is picking up a multi to move it enough to disqualify? No. If your son leaves your Wave out in the rain, by all means dry it off and put some oil on it. Just don't use it. Or let him use it again if that is how he does it. How about taking a photo of your Spartan for Spartan Saturday? You would be using your multi for something in that case, I think. Take your Spartan or Surge or whatever photos during November and post those photos in December. Too strict? Maybe. Nobody has to post photos to the daily threads or clubs here. Many members never do. What if you want to post an Opinel or traditional knife photo? That is fine since it isn't a multi. Do that anytime you please. Get a multi in the mail or as a Christmas gift? Open it up, look it over, pass it around, enjoy. Just don't carry it or use it.
G

Thanks for making everything very clear!
This is making me think about adding a little pair of pliers to my EDC. I don’t carry a pliers MT on my person, because I know if I’m in the house I can grab a MT or a real tool, or if I’m out I will usually have a bag with me that hosts a MT. With the MTs in those bags off limits, I either have to find several pliers to put in different bags, or have one pair and keep it on me

-
Great clarification Gary! 👍
I have items strategically placed throughout out the main floor in my house. Out of habit it is very easy to open the drawer and grab a Bond to help my worn fingers separate a lid from the juice bottle, or pry up the pull ring on the can of smoked treats.
A blade of a SAK CAN BE TO EASY to deploy! Do remove from sight. Replace with a SOD Buster or a BUCK 112
My movement s in December will need to be intentional, not muscle memory.
I have been practicing, not as easy as one may think!!!🥹
-
Yes, there will be some adjustments and breaking of old habits. For a month, anyway. A small pair of pliers, a knife, and maybe a screwdriver shouldn't be much of a hill to climb with a little forethought. This sort of substitution could certainly be lighter than many multis. The tools are separate, but so what? You could certainly bundle a few things together in a pouch, or put a rubber band or strip of tape around them for convenience.
By the way, using a Crescent wrench to scratch your butt, or using a house key to clean your ears doesn't make either a multi-tool. You could hammer in a nail with a pair of hefty pliers also without making it a multi-tool. Pliers often come with wire cutters as a part of their manufacture. That was covered in the ReamerPunch accords as applied in the first Tool Box Challenge. Pliers with a portion that could be used to cut wire are permissible. If the pliers have a bottle opener, or blade, or something that is a breach of the rules. Likewise screwdrivers able to use multiple bits are fine. Ratchets are also fine. It the ratchet or screwdriver has something like a glass breaker, fire starter, or wrench then that would be a fail.
A watch that does more things than show the time is fine. Alarms, timers, lighted dials, world maps, computing power. All good. A watch band with multi-tool capability would be a fail.
Most one-piece tools are a fail. Ones that are only screwdrivers, or a pry tool are fine.
Best wishes. G

-
Our friend Looper wanted me to show a photo of a Chapman screwdriver, I think? Maybe it was a Coleman sleeping bag. Probably not the last one. I will post a photo of an old Chapman. The later models had a plastic caddy. Best wishes. Gary

[attach id=0 msg=2553079]
-
@IMR4198 said:
Most one-piece tools are a fail. Ones that are only screwdrivers, or a pry tool are fine.I am thinking of carrying this little chap:

I figure that is valid, as the teardrop cutout is just there to assist in pulling nails, which is one of the main uses for a small pry tool, not a different function.
-
@IMR4198 said:
Our friend Looper wanted me to show a photo of a Chapman screwdriver, I think? Maybe it was a Coleman sleeping bag. Probably not the last one. I will post a photo of an old Chapman. The later models had a plastic caddy. Best wishes. Gary

[attach id=0 msg=2553079]What a beautiful mini ratchet set!

Where have you been hiding it?
-
@IMR4198 said:
Our friend Looper wanted me to show a photo of a Chapman screwdriver, I think? Maybe it was a Coleman sleeping bag. Probably not the last one. I will post a photo of an old Chapman. The later models had a plastic caddy. Best wishes. Gary

[attach id=0 msg=2553079]Perfect!
The bits having the friction ball in the bit are older, and was not sure you were describing what I was picturing behind my eye lids.👍👍👍
-
I had another mini ratchet like the one in the Chapman kit. They came on the Lyman 450 lubricator/sizer. There was a stem at the top which threaded down to put pressure on a plunger. The ratchet made one hand operation easy.
I used the Chapman fairly regularly along with some standard screwdrivers and such. Also a Mototool. I still have all of them, but don't use them much at all now. The extension fits either the handle or the ratchet. There is a set screw on the side of the handle to lock the extension. The bits have a knurled end to them. Sometimes when reassembling something, it was convenient to turn them with your fingers without any handle. Almost impossible to cross-thread something that way.
Best wishes. Gary

-
How far do you have to carry these tools for them to count? I have some upcoming workshop stuff in December which could be a good match, but lots of those tools would hardly be considered EDC. More like carriable, and then not too far..
-
It is not necessarily about carrying the tools, it is about going COLD TURKEY AND NOT CARRYING A MultiTool or Swiss Army Knife or a Multi-Functional Flat Tool
What we may select as if these items are not in our tool set.
A pliers, screw driver, pocket knife. As basics. Or, just a pocket knife.
-
Let me ask friend Vidar a question. What do you carry with you during your everyday life? I'm not interested in your workshop tools. Best wishes. Gary

-
Normally not much or a pocket SAK. A SAK or plier based multitool if doing relevant work. Some work clothes are preloaded. :)
Well, I guess that what was the answer. My tool box is pretty full, but those are definitely workshop tools for the most part.
-
It might be helpful to read a few pages of the posts from the last time this challenge was held. That would be a good way to get a feel for what it is all about. Best wishes. Gary
/post/2284896 -
Yes, those seem to be EDC sized tools. I just got confused about where to draw the line with the Tool Box heading, but the old thread made that a lot clearer.
-
@IMR4198 said:
Our friend Looper wanted me to show a photo of a Chapman screwdriver, I think? Maybe it was a Coleman sleeping bag.
@fullbreakfast said:
I am thinking of carrying this little chap:Please do!
Is there an NSN on the other side? -
I got out a pry bar yesterday. The only one I ever had, except for really big ones for prying apart parts of a building or something. A friend here sent me one for Christmas along with some other things. I said thank you for the various items and for the chisel. I was informed that it wasn't a chisel, it was a mini pry bar. Oops.
I VERY rarely pry anything. I sometimes use a screwdriver for something like that. Evidently I am in the minority judging from the number of bent knife blades and tools I see on used SAKs. I might carry my cute littlechipry bar during the challenge. It doesn't take up much room in a pocket. Best wishes. G

-
I know GARY has done a great job preparing us for this challenge.
As I have shared, having specialized tool kits has been my style since I started working in the electronics field service industry, 1973.
Today I visited the back of my pickup and retrieved a kit stored in my Stanley rolling tool locker.
[attach id=0 msg=2553215]
This kit was assembled about 1979, was lighter that a briefcase style grip, was used for repairing train printers, vertical tape stands, disc packs, and installations mainframe systems that filled a 40’ x 60’ computer room.
The only tool missing is my FLUKE multimeter, it is on loan to my son.I was actually searching for one of my small screwdrivers, but not there.
This was last used a few years ago at the PT gig at the Y, requiring and changing a display panel on the control panel for the lighting system that talked to the power control station in the electrical room.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login