Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE NOTIFICATIONS 0 MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Can Opener Comparison

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Reviews
175 Posts 1 Posters 41.8k Views
  1. Home
  2. Tool Talk
  3. Reviews
  4. Can Opener Comparison
Can Opener Comparison
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • Nix Offline
    Nix
    Posts: 24,263
    Nix Offline
    Nix
    wrote on last edited by
    #163 Quote Reply

      @ReamerPunch said:
      I started this thread three years ago. :salute:
      And only now did I realize I had not done a list of all the tools I tested. So, here it is. :D

      :like:

      1 Reply Last reply
      • ReamerPunch Offline
        ReamerPunch
        Global Moderators
        Posts: 12,187
        ReamerPunch Offline
        ReamerPunch
        Global Moderators
        wrote on last edited by
        #164 Quote Reply

          Roxon Flex

          This is a quarter circle, properly sharpened and at the perfect length to properly engage the can rim.
          The tool is modular which means you can place the can opener in any position in the handle, but this does not really matter, thanks to the can opener length.

          Initial cut was very easy. The tool is extremely comfortable, thanks to all its rounded edges and tools flush with the frame.
          The opener did not get stuck between cuts, nor did it slip off the rim. There was no shrapnel in the food at the end, which is nice.
          Cutting was excellent and pretty consistent. I found myself mindful of aligning the can opener cutting edge right up to the rim, to get an easy cut,
          And trace easily around the rim.

          2 points for punching through.
          2 for comfort.
          2 for not jamming.
          2 for cutting.
          2 for not slipping.

          Total: 10

          1 Reply Last reply
          • Outback in Idaho Offline
            Outback in Idaho
            Posts: 5,432
            Outback in Idaho Offline
            Outback in Idaho
            wrote on last edited by
            #165 Quote Reply

              Found the Leatherman Garage #5 requires a motion of inserting the tab to squishing to the side wall on the cut. Works better.

              Bought some Victorinox Can Openers and am going to cut the tabs down to fit in the Large Bit Driver for a more proper and useful Can Opener. Am not too crazy about the idea of modifying the Garage #5 just yet.

              1 Reply Last reply
              • ReamerPunch Offline
                ReamerPunch
                Global Moderators
                Posts: 12,187
                ReamerPunch Offline
                ReamerPunch
                Global Moderators
                wrote on last edited by
                #166 Quote Reply

                  Oh yeah, Leatherman has a quarter-circle opener now. Hmm...

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • ReamerPunch Offline
                    ReamerPunch
                    Global Moderators
                    Posts: 12,187
                    ReamerPunch Offline
                    ReamerPunch
                    Global Moderators
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #167 Quote Reply

                      SOG PowerPint


                      Initial punch through was not bad.
                      The first three quarters of the can were going ok. I could trace along the rim adequately. The edge is short, and the bevel not that acute. With a Victorinox quarter circle, the edge is cutting along the rim in one continuous, obvious cut. The Pint was an interrupted, one break at a time sort of thing. It never felt smooth between cuts. Every cut felt like an isolated, single step, with the same resistance and force required as the original punching through.
                      At the exact 3/4 of the rim, the lid was being pushed into the can. The edge could not advance any longer, and just slid sideways along the lid (top right picture, where the opener is pointing). And I even tried going backwards from the end, to join the beginning of the cut to the end, and I could not even pierce the lid anymore.
                      For comparison, the Flex continued the cut, although with some difficulty.

                      The Rebar started backwards from where the pint started and went through the mangled, bent lid with no issue.
                      The pint never jammed or slipped off the lid. Ergonomics are not that good with the Pint. I had to exert a lot of force for every single cut. The tool is a little too small to hold comfortably.
                      To sum up, the Pint may be enough to open a can. It can pierce, it can cut, and it did not leave any shrapnel in the food. If you are planning to open multiple cans maybe take a Rebar or PST or something.


                      1 points for punching through.
                      0 for comfort.
                      2 for not jamming.
                      0 for cutting.
                      2 for not slipping.

                      Total: 5

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • ThundahBeagle Offline
                        ThundahBeagle
                        Posts: 2,673
                        ThundahBeagle Offline
                        ThundahBeagle
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #168 Quote Reply

                          Good info here. Nice to see Rebar and PST as consistent winners as I have both. The 91mm Vics sort of go without say.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • ReamerPunch Offline
                            ReamerPunch
                            Global Moderators
                            Posts: 12,187
                            ReamerPunch Offline
                            ReamerPunch
                            Global Moderators
                            wrote on last edited by ReamerPunch
                            #169 Quote Reply

                              Roxon Flex - claw

                              The first opener Roxon released for the Flex set of modular tools was the quarter circle, but recently they also released a claw.

                              This was a very similar experience to using the Flex with the quarter circle. Of course, the can opener can be placed in any slot of the Flex, as it is modular.
                              The Flex is very comfortable to hold, with all its rounded edges. No hotspots whatsoever.
                              Initial piercing was very easy. The claw did not get stuck or slip off the can at any point.
                              There was no shrapnel left in the can, which is very important. Comfort, speed, getting stuck, these are all important,but what good are they if the food is unsafe to eat once you open the can?
                              Cutting was easy, much like with a Leatherman claw. There was no need to be mindful of aligning every consecutive cut. Tracing around the lid was effortless.

                              It is very interesting that Roxon has two excellent can openers for the Flex set of implements. If you are used to one and prefer it over the other, you can just have that one installed, and if you want to mix things up or try the other style, you can install that one. And they're one-handed as well. Nice.

                              2 points for punching through.
                              2 for comfort.
                              2 for not jamming.
                              2 for cutting.
                              2 for not slipping.

                              Total: 10

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • ReamerPunch Offline
                                ReamerPunch
                                Global Moderators
                                Posts: 12,187
                                ReamerPunch Offline
                                ReamerPunch
                                Global Moderators
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #170 Quote Reply

                                  GrandHarvest 26-SW

                                  Oh, boy. This is bad. Surprisingly bad, for how good it looked like it would be.

                                  0 points for punching through.
                                  0 for comfort.
                                  0 for not jamming.
                                  0 for cutting.
                                  0 for not slipping.

                                  Total: 0

                                  This can opener is tapered and sharpened on the opposite sides of the average claw, like the Leatherman or the Roxon modular claw.
                                  Having it be tapered and sharpened on the side that it is, the can opener is very difficult to use, as it wants to follow the orientation of the edge, like a chisel-ground blade. But instead of sinking to the left (away from the rim) as it cuts into the lid, the tip sinks to the right, making the tip scrape against the rim and wall. This, in turn, makes the can opener create metal filings, and it throws off the direction of the cut, making it extremely difficult to follow-up on that cut and advance around the rim.

                                  The initial punching through the rim was hard, which is odd. Even the worst can openers so far had a decent first cut. The lid unrolled where the first cut was attempted, making it impossible to continue cutting from there. A second initial cut had to be made. The edge is very well sharpened, so the can opener has no trouble cutting through the lid. The thing, is, it cuts arguably too well. It is so aggressive, that it cuts easily, making it very easy to cut in the wrong direction and throw off the cut orientation.
                                  Comfort is bad. The blade spine dug into my fingers. The entire process was slow, and cumbersome. The can opener slipped and jammed now and then.

                                  It is quite disheartening to see this claw look so good but perform so abysmally. If it was ground and sharpened on the opposite sides than it is, to match a Leatherman claw, it would surely be much better. I will give this another chance, maybe make shorter cuts, and place the tip a little ways away from the rim, to hopefully prevent it from scrape against the rim and wall, and make it cut and trace properly.

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • ReamerPunch Offline
                                    ReamerPunch
                                    Global Moderators
                                    Posts: 12,187
                                    ReamerPunch Offline
                                    ReamerPunch
                                    Global Moderators
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #171 Quote Reply

                                      Top: Grand Harvest and Bucktool, both tapered and sharpened on the opposite sides of a Leatherman Claw. No wonder they both suck.
                                      Bottom: Leatherman Core and Roxon Flex with claw. Both are sharpened and tapered on the opposite side of Grand Harvest and Buck, and performance is excellent.

                                      A claw does not need both bevels to be the same as a Leatherman to make it a good can opener. Wenger is tapered on opposite side of Leatherman claw, but sharpened on the same side.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • ReamerPunch Offline
                                        ReamerPunch
                                        Global Moderators
                                        Posts: 12,187
                                        ReamerPunch Offline
                                        ReamerPunch
                                        Global Moderators
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #172 Quote Reply

                                          @ReamerPunch said:
                                          GrandHarvest 26-SW

                                          Since I posted the review for that can opener, they changed the item listing pictures.
                                          Before, you could see the can opener clearly not placed correctly on the can.
                                          Now, you can barely see the can and the can opener tip. Still not placed correctly, though.

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • ReamerPunch Offline
                                            ReamerPunch
                                            Global Moderators
                                            Posts: 12,187
                                            ReamerPunch Offline
                                            ReamerPunch
                                            Global Moderators
                                            wrote on last edited by ReamerPunch
                                            #173 Quote Reply

                                              Field Ration Eating Device (F.R.E.D)

                                              Link Preview Image
                                              Field ration eating device - Wikipedia

                                              favicon

                                              (en.wikipedia.org)

                                              The F.R.E.D. is the Australian version of the P-38 can opener. The blade piece and cutting edge are nearly identical to the P-38, as was performance.

                                              Despite being larger than the P-51, the FRED performs much more closely to the P-38. The increased length of the spoon end would theoretically provide some additional leverage, but at the same time, the P-51 seems to be the perfect length for this. The FRED's edge length is also a little shorter than the P-51, so you will make slightly shorter cuts. Also, the last time I saw a hinge this oversized was in Schindler's List. The P-38 and P-51 have small, unobtrusive hinges.

                                              Initial punching through was extremely easy.
                                              Comfort-wise, not good, not bad. My thumb kept pushing against the bottle opener tooth, so I had to adjust my grip a few times.
                                              It never jammed and never slipped off the can rim.
                                              Cutting and tracing around the lid was easy. The edge is at a perfect angle to keep advancing with each cut. The tool weighs almost nothing so fatigue would occur only with an improper grip. The last cut, to completely remove the lid from the can, was also easy. Some can openers struggle to cut off the lid at the end, but the FRED had no trouble. The FRED left behind a somewhat jagged edge, very similar to what the P-38 did.

                                              As with the P-38, I did notice some metallic dust when I was done. This is not ideal. The P-51 left no dust behind. More testing will be done, but in short, this is a P-38 with a bottle-opener and an ice-cream spoon on it. The P-51 is smaller, more comfortable, will get the can opened in fewer cuts, and it does not leave any metal dust behind. If you are looking for a compact can opener to tuck into a wallet, the P-58 is the way to go.

                                              2 points for punching through.
                                              2 for comfort.
                                              2 for not jamming.
                                              1 for cutting.
                                              2 for not slipping.

                                              Total: 9

                                              1 Reply Last reply
                                              • BPRoberts Offline
                                                BPRoberts
                                                Posts: 3,383
                                                BPRoberts Offline
                                                BPRoberts
                                                wrote on last edited by
                                                #174 Quote Reply

                                                  For just an opener, I'd agree that the P-38 is most efficient . That said, I use the spoon part of my knock-off FRED at least a few times a year, so it can be worth it if you have the space.

                                                  1 Reply Last reply

                                                  Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                                  Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                                  With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                                  Register Login

                                                  • 1
                                                  • 2
                                                  • 5
                                                  • 6
                                                  • 7
                                                  • 8
                                                  • 9
                                                  1. Home
                                                  2. Tool Talk
                                                  3. Reviews
                                                  4. Can Opener Comparison
                                                  Reply
                                                  • Reply as topic
                                                  Log in to reply
                                                  COMMUNITY LINKS
                                                  EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                                  Operational Funds

                                                  Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                                  Make A Donation
                                                  November Goal: $300.00
                                                  Due Date: Nov 30
                                                  Total Receipts: $0.00
                                                  Below Goal: $300.00
                                                  0% funded
                                                  • Login

                                                  • Don't have an account? Register

                                                  • Login or register to search.
                                                  • First post
                                                    Last post
                                                  0