SAK Stack Challenge 2026
-
I think I like the rules the way they were written in the description. In this month's Barlow challenge, there was a big opportunity to add in almost anything to qualify. Jack knives of various kinds, etc. All that stuff got weeded out to the credit of the host, etc. If 'specification creep' was allowed, then almost anything from a CASE Peanut up would have been a valid substitute. In the first Classic challenge that "What about this one?" and "Why not X?" was quibbled over until the challenge was almost ruined by "What ifs?" The Super Stack types already had their challenge. The 111s have their own challenge coming up. Adding more stuff only waters down the challenge.
Best wishes, G

-
@LoopCutter said:
I thought they have their own challenge.They do. I'm ok with them being here too, if anyone wants to carry one.
-
@WECSOG said:
They do. I'm ok with them being here too, if anyone wants to carry one.That is the same as accepting a SUPERtool variant being allowed in a REBAR challenge.
And, “ In fact I would really like to see someone enter the challenge with a Workchamp XL and help me decide if I really want one or not!
”You can accomplish the same objective by reading old challenges about the same tools.
-
I don't know enough about Leatherman tools to offer an opinion on that. But the SAK Stack challenge is not about the name; it's about the stack.
Besides all that, even if it were about the name, the XLT and XXL are still Swisschamps in name.But it's about carrying a SAK that is bigger and bulkier than most people are willing to carry. If someone wants to make it more challenging by carrying an XXL or even a Wenger Giant, that's ok by me. It adds to the entertainment value.
-
From the 2020 SAK Stack Challenge, hosted by comis:
@comis said:
Just got back from the pm, turns out the host do have some leeway on how to run the challenge.So let's welcome the Vic Swisschamp family to join(XL, XLT, XVAT, XXLT), and Wenger Tool Chest family(Tool Chest plus, Matterhorn, Snap Shackle and SGT fix it)!

-
Very nice! -
Very handsome, Gordon. Now you can turn something else into a Silvertech. Best wishes. G

-
@LoopCutter said:
Well the results are complete![attach id=0 msg=2588629]
From SIVERtech to SAPPHIRE
[attach id=1 msg=2588629]
[attach id=2 msg=2588629]
Thank you.

Nice!

-

My new sheath for my SwissChamp has arrived! I think I'm going to do the whole challenge with the one knife, even though I have some others that may qualify.
As long as we're throwing out opinions, my personal take is that the true spirit of this challenge is to carry anything with at least 6 layers (or at the very least, is at as thick as one with 6 layers). I think a Cybertool-S shouldn't really count for that reason, but I've never had one so I don't know how thick it actually feels when carried. On the other hand, I also have a Wenger Monarch and a Vic Outdoorsman that feel like they really should qualify, but the rules as written exclude them. Regardless, it doesn't really matter, because I'm going to carry a regular Swiss Champ.
In the end, I think what's important is that people carry some big chonker SAKs and use some tools. And of course, have fun!
-
@LoopCutter said:
Well the results are complete!From SIVERtech to SAPPHIRE
Thank you.


-
Another way around the badge issue is to have a completely different badge made up, such as the Pocket Giant Challenge, which would cover anything with 6 layers and up. As long as we have at least 10 people in a challenge, it's an option.
-
My new sheath for my SwissChamp has arrived! I think I'm going to do the whole challenge with the one knife, even though I have some others that may qualify.
As long as we're throwing out opinions, my personal take is that the true spirit of this challenge is to carry anything with at least 6 layers (or at the very least, is at as thick as one with 6 layers). I think a Cybertool-S shouldn't really count for that reason, but I've never had one so I don't know how thick it actually feels when carried. On the other hand, I also have a Wenger Monarch and a Vic Outdoorsman that feel like they really should qualify, but the rules as written exclude them. Regardless, it doesn't really matter, because I'm going to carry a regular Swiss Champ.
In the end, I think what's important is that people carry some big chonker SAKs and use some tools. And of course, have fun!
I agree on the CT-S. But, it qualifies only because the rules specifically state that any variety of CT qualifies.
The Monarch has 7 layers, so it qualifies. -
@Barry Rowland said:
Another way around the badge issue is to have a completely different badge made up, such as the Pocket Giant Challenge, which would cover anything with 6 layers and up. As long as we have at least 10 people in a challenge, it's an option.I'm open to that, if anyone wants to take it up. It would mean two new badges though; a 30 and a 60.
-
@mathmitch7 said:
I think a Cybertool-S shouldn't really count for that reason, but I've never had one so I don't know how thick it actually feels when carried.It feels like a 4-layer, since the main blade layer and opener layer are both normal layers, and the bit driver is effectively about twice as thick as a typical layer.
CT-S is the only one of the CT family I would actually consider carrying in pocket.

-
I fail to see what the issue is anyway. The way I'm doing it is pretty much the way it was done in 2020, when all this stuff was hashed out. I just clarified it by saying 85mm and up, 6 layers and up, and meeting the spirit of the challenge (bulky and a lot of tools). There was at least one comment in 2020 about making it 7 layers and up, but there are three named models (Champion A, Champion B, Cybertool Lite) with six layers. Bottom line for me is, if it is at least as big, heavy and feature-rich as an original Champion, it qualifies.
If I were going to create a new badge, I wouldn't disqualify models that meet the "stack" description. I would disqualify the Cybertool S (29) and Cybertool M (34). They're in because they are specifically named. The CT-S is thinner, lighter and has fewer tools than my Deluxe Tinker, yet it's in and the DT is out (rightfully so).
Since this is at its core a challenge to carry (not just display) a SAK that is bigger and bulkier than a large percentage of SAK fans would normally carry, let's concentrate on that.And, on that subject I want to discuss one knife that I intend to include. In fact I went ahead and bought one (wanted one anyway) specifically to include in the Challenge. That is the 111mm Work Champ. It is part of the Champion family, (even has Champ in its name) and its toolset puts it squarely in line with the spirit of the challenge. In fact it has the same toolset, plus a couple of additional tools, as the original Champion (both versions).
-
@nate j said:
It feels like a 4-layer, since the main blade layer and opener layer are both normal layers, and the bit driver is effectively about twice as thick as a typical layer.CT-S is the only one of the CT family I would actually consider carrying in pocket.

It might feel like a 4 layer, but it is still thinner and lighter than a Deluxe Tinker or Deluxe Climber.
I agree with you. If anyone wants to carry a CT-S for this challenge, I've no problem with it. But to me it would feel like cheating.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



