Getting a multitool: Leatherman or Gerber?
-
"The Leatherman Wave...the Rugged and Manly Charge" :D
-
@turnsouth said:
Actually the rough edges are intentional. On the thumb hole they are a result of the stamping process, and are left there to add to ease of opening with less thumb pressure. On the edge the rough grind is to create micro serrations, for two reasons. 1. Long term edge sustainability, and 2. Increases the ability to cut through fibrous material.Sorry, but I don't buy that reasoning. The rough edges are there because LM didnt' want to pony up the cost to "finish" it. It's expensive enough as it is so I'm actually glad they didn't. I buy plenty of folding knives to know good opening hole machining when I see it. Also, I'd rather have my knife edge cut rather than saw or tear through whatever I am cutting.
While we're at the knife edge, what the hell is that edge angle sharpened to? It's 420HC! put 20deg on each side. That edge will roll at the first tough material it encounters. I'll be re-profiling mine.
It may seem I hate my Wave. Couldn't be further from the truth. I actually really like it. Just wish it was better. ;)
-
I didn't mean to start a debate! :D
I'm still thinking LM Wave, though I'll let you all know once the final decision's been made! :)
In the mean time, don't let me interupt! Carry on! :)
P.S. Every Wave I've seen seems to be decent quality and some have seem some serious use!
-
The day that "Fit and Finish", or "Slippy and Shiny" becomes more important than utility to me, I may agree.
However, I find the "precision" snap on the Spirit pointless and in fact, a hinderance, the high-gloss finish detrimental to the use of the drivers etc....
I enjoy the Spirit as a toy and a pretty thing, but when I need a tool, I'll go for something that deploys easily, performs better and is generally more versatile. What it looks like and the audible click are simply irrelevant when I'm driving a screw, or need a blade whilst holding onto a ladder.
I don't suppose we'll get any closer to solving this debate tonight than any other of the million or so times it crops up, but I'll repeat my oft repeated point of view that you can't consider "quality" without considering how "fit for purpose" and efficient a tool design is.
A hypothetical question:
If you took two high grade pieces of steel, fastened them together with incredible skill and precision, polished the whole thing up to a mirrored finish and then encrusted it in diamonds, then tried to pass it off as, I dunno, a washing machine - would you consider it to be a high quality item?
:P -
Dunno about a washing machine... It would make for quite a blink prybar though. :D
-
:D
Actually I have some of my best ideas when I'm being sarcastic, there's a bunch of people in the Swiss Forum that would buy them

-
Ah, in that case you could just make the pieces of steel 91mm (or something) long and call it "the layerless sak"... It would be UK- and DK-legal as well...
:P -
By god - I think you've cracked it.
Split the royalties 50/50?
-
Nah, the idea was all yours mate. Just send me a red alox layerless when they come out. ;) :D
-
You're top of the list buddy :P
-
@TangoDown said:
While we're at the knife edge, what the hell is that edge angle sharpened to? It's 420HC! put 20deg on each side. That edge will roll at the first tough material it encounters. I'll be re-profiling mine.From Leatherman:
What are the blade angles of our knives?
The main bevel grind (the overall angle that defines the knife) varies slightly depending on the product but is close to nine degrees.
The actual cutting edge grind for all plain-edge knife blades is 32 degrees. This is the same angle used on all our plain-edge blades — Crater and Expanse series and our multi-tools.
When sharpening with any system, the included angle should be around 32 degrees.
-
Just goes to show you that what matters most to people can be very different. I will agree to disagree with you Dave. I respect your opinion on this matter and do not wish to drag this on. Both are solid choices and the beauty of it is there are many more to choose from.
To the OP, I apologize for the hijacking into a debate.

The Wave is a fine choice. I have one myself and use it on occasion. And I'll use it some in the future too because it is a well designed MT. And I'll use my SOG's too for the features bring to the table.
-
@TangoDown said:
Just goes to show you that what matters most to people can be very different. I will agree to disagree with you Dave. I respect your opinion on this matter and do not wish to drag this on. Both are solid choices and the beauty of it is there are many more to choose from.No need to mate. Just tell Dave that "LMs rust, Vics don't" (preferably accompanied by "neener neener neener") and it's all set.
:P :DPS: FWIW Dave's opinions on multitools are (imho) among the most objective around here. He just has this thing for Swisstools and the whole Swiss perfection notion that manifests in a somewhat hostile way that makes him seem anti-Vic from time to time. He's not... If anything, he does know that "LMs rust, Vics don't". :D
-
Hobbit , if I were you , I would get a Wave . I'm not a fan of most Gerbers . Some of their models may be OK , I just don't have the patience to sift thru the Dreck ! The Wave is a competent multi that will give good service . Personally , I would prefer the Old Skool Wave without the new fangled bit holder , but thats just me .
Enjoy whatever tool you pick .
Chris
-
@Nikos said:
He just has this thing for Swisstools and the whole Swiss perfection notion that manifests in a somewhat hostile way that makes him seem anti-Vic from time to time.Haha. :D
I've never been hostile about the Vic tools, I just take exception to people stating, as fact, that the Vic tools are "perfection", when it's such a personal thing. The Swiss fans seem so bloody evangelistic too :D
The OP wanted to know whether he should get a LM or a Gerber as he'd narrowed it down to those already then there was the predictable "boing - buy a Victorinox" response :D (I'm not going to look back and see who did it so I can't be accused of singling anyone out, but the answer to "Leatherman or Gerber?" isn't "Victorinox" is it)? :P
-
Hi guys! A Merry Christmas to you all! Which means......
I recieved my Leatherman Wave yesterday! :D
Thanks to everyone! First use yesterday for it was to open a present where some cheeky person had taped over all the edges so you couldn't get your fingers under to open it! So not long after having the LM it had already had a use!
I'll report back some time next month again, as I've got a couple of shows on next month, mainly panto of course! "Oh no he hasn't" I hear you all cry! ;)
There is just two more things to ask :)
Firstly, what does EDC stand for!! I keep seeing it all over the forum! Is it EveryDay Carry? That's the best answer I could find from Google, and does seem to fit what everyone says, but I thought I'd make sure ;)
Secondly, I am nearly 18, yet, of course, that still makes me under 18! Obviously I'm not allowed to buy knives etc, but what's the law on under 18s carrying them? Obviously, the wave is a no no anyway, due to the locking blade (as long as they don't catch you ;) ), but what about smaller, non locking blades for under 18s?
Many thanks,
Hobit :) -
I'd vote wave . Build quality on Gerbers is suspect . The flik pliers are a good gimmick , not much use . I used to enjoy them for scaring the Doo Doo out of police and security , sounds lots like a semi getting it's slide racked .
Chris
-
EDC is every day carry.

-
Congrats Hobit - that's a great Christmas present you've got there, and I look forward to hearing how you get on with it as time goes by.
The question about the UK knife law....
I got this from Police-Information.co.uk as it seems pretty well laid out:
Public Place
Source: Criminal Justice Act, 1988. Section 139(1).
Offence: It is an offence for any person, without lawful authority or good reason, to have with him in a public place, any article which has a blade or is sharply pointed except for a folding pocket-knife which has a cutting edge to its blade not exceeding 3 inches.
Powers: Arrestable offence.
and the relevant bit:
Sell to under 16
Source: Criminal Justice Act, 1988. Section 141A
Offence: It is an offence for any person to sell to a person under the age of 16 any knife, knife blade, razor blade, axe or any other article which has a blade or is sharply pointed and which is made or adapted for causing injury to the person.
Powers: Proceedings should be by way of a summons only, unless any of the conditions of s.25 of PACE 1984 are satisfied.
There doesn't seem to be a minimum age to carry a blade provided you comply with the first bit I quoted.
From that, I deduce that if you can buy a knife at 16, and it's "legal" - you are fine

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login