How do you read the forums?
-
I usually hit unread posts first but that's if I'm not looking for anything specific. I agree with a lot of the above statements, especially from Dave and Neil - it's not all about tools, which is why there is always something going on. I don't think we're in any danger of going anywhere either ;)
The break room is just that, a break from all the other stuff which is why your rant attracted plenty of replies. Many of us love a good rant and a laugh in there. It's a great part of the forum and doesn't detract from the really good stuff in the mods section etc - I always read anything new there. The threads with lots of good pics are worth going through so I don't mind hidden gems in there. I admit it's tricky to search for some things, especially if it's a pic you were after, but over all I think this forum is excellent.
-
how i read the forum:
- hit the swiss board
- jump to the edge
- dabble in the general
- breakroom
ocasionally check out the reviews. i think i've read several of andreas's reviews and some of the videos. commented only once. i do like to get others take on a tool and needs. sometimes it's an eye opener. i just read through jekostas review of the SanReMu knife and thought it was excellent. i did'nt post b/c i had nothing to add. frankly, it's one of the best reviews i've read period.
there are some posters here that i always enjoy what they contribute and you can usually know them better in an off topic thread. some used the phrase 'thread nazis' earlier and for sure MTO does not need them or want them i think. i like MTO the way it is formatted and run now. i have left a forum due to 'improvements'
re: the young people rant. i considered it a valuable insight into norwegian culture and the life and time of an intrepid scholar. from this and other threads i have come to know andreas and i no longer refer to him has 'cptno' which i did up until that point. -
@sappyg said:
there are some posters here that i always enjoy what they contribute and you can usually know them better in an off topic thread. some used the phrase 'thread nazis' earlier and for sure MTO does not need them or want them i think. i like MTO the way it is formatted and run now. i have left a forum due to 'improvements'
re: the young people rant. i considered it a valuable insight into norwegian culture and the life and time of an intrepid scholar. from this and other threads i have come to know andreas and i no longer refer to him has 'cptno' which i did up until that point.You do have a point with that one. I think my point came out a bit badly with the first post; I didn't mean that off topic should disappear, what I meant was that I wish that there was more activity in the other sections of the forum as well as the break room. I've mentioned several reasons for this of course and most of them have to do with my slight OCD wanting things to be neat and tidy, which I find is a lot easier when popularity = quality. Of course as many people have pointed out that is easier said than done because it's a lot easier to comment on something new and off topic, or help a new member with problems etc than it is to find something to add to a mod thread, or a picture thread or something like that. Hence the point and title of this thread points to how people read the forums in terms of what sections they visit etc, since I've seen people comment on some threads that they missed post X for a while because they don't really visit that part of the forum.
**
Here's an idea for the moderators**: how about creating a sticky topic in some of the subforums, and use those as a directory for the "must see" threads? For instance in the mod section it would include "epic" mods like the wave scissors etc. That way new members would have easy access to what old members considers the prime of the forum.
The problem with this is that because of the time limited edit system on here a moderator have to run the threads and update them in order to keep the first post updated.Speaking of which, I know the reasons why forum admins put time restrictions on the edit feature for normal members, however in my experience (which in this case actually counts for something) it's very rarely a problem that you can go back and edit posts whenever. Especially on a forum like this where, as far as I have seen, everyone are friends. The advantages of having an unlimited edit feature helps a lot with stuff getting drowned in large threads as the original poster can go back and keep the first post updated. I posted a few reviews yesterday - or more precisely last night - and had to convert the formatting from HTML used for my blog to BBCODE for the forum. I forgot to add the links and realized such when I posted the last review, and when I went back to fix that the first of the reviews had been locked for editing. I often update my articles both to fix typos, add information, links to later reviews etc and hadn't thought of this little issue when I started copying posts from my blog to the forum. As a result I went back and deleted the reviews I could and posted a link to my blog instead, since I can then edit that and not have to worry about two different versions being around.
Another similar example is mod squad posts where the original poster don't wait until a project is finished to post, an example being J-sews' Super Juice KF4. The ideal way for that thread to be "run" would be to also update the first post whenever new photos and information is added, so that someone who reads it for the first time can easily get all the actual information before getting to the comments. Granted J-sews in a mod and COULD do so, but for normal members that's impossible because we don't have access to edit after an hour or so.
Sales threads is another example of the same thing, it would be really nice to have the ability to update the first post as things get sold etc, instead of having to post the same post all over again time and time again to be able to update a list of things for sale.
So, how about it?

-
Bad things have happened here a while back that means post editing except for a short time isn't allowed. That's not likely to change, sorry.
Too many stickies and stickies get ignored :) Not a bad suggestion though and something to be considered

-
Some time ago we had a very knowledgeable member who posted a lot of interesting information on many exotic tools that most people have never even heard of. Then, following a personality conflict with another member, the first member went through all his old posts and deleted the information. Basically the result was punishing an entire community of enthusiasts for an altercation that took place off the forum that no one else knew about.
Also, I see a thread as a living thing, free to grow in whichever way the community chooses to shape it. Going back and changing it's starting point based on where it's going is unacceptable to me, as would everyone melting down their PST's because they are old, outdated and are outperformed in every way by more modern tools. You don't know what's next if you don't know what came before.
Def
-
Absobloodylutely

As for changing your sales threads, all you have to do is be nice to a mod ;)
-
@nuphoria said:
Absobloodylutely
As for changing your sales threads, all you have to do is be nice to a mod ;)
:ahhh :ahhh One of my pet peeves; sales threads where they don't get the title changed when everything's gone :ahhh :ahhh
Also on other forums when they go into their sales thread after it's all been sold an delete all the info ::) Why

TBH it can be a pain in the a$$ if you want to edit a post especially if you're an OCD nut like me and have realised a spelling mistake from yesterday :ahhh However, now I'm used to it :D It takes about 2 mins to PM a friendly mod to make the changes for you

On a side note I'd really have loved to have seen this information on these 'exotic tools'; sounds intriguing :D
-
As for that special case of the guy gone wild one solution would be to ban him and restore the posts, if that's possible on simple machines. On vBullitin all mods can access all versions of an edited post as well as deleted post and that way restore the posts
-
@Andreas said:
As for that special case of the guy gone wild one solution would be to ban him and restore the posts, if that's possible on simple machines. On vBullitin all mods can access all versions of an edited post as well as deleted post and that way restore the postsRestricting edit times was a lot more sensible solution that $300/year plus upgrades.
Def
-
Of course, all I meant was that I know that solution is possible with vbullitin so I thought it might be with simple machines to. But i do understand your reasons for not wanting free edits, and I actually agree with the part about letting threads grow - it's just practical to have an updated first post at times
-
start a new thread?
-
I use the unread topics option, but sometimes it is good to just have conversations about different things so we can grow closer as a online family. It is good to hear others good fortune so we can rejoice with them and the bad things so we can keep them in our thoughts and prayers. Even though I am a member of three forums this is where most of my time is spent.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login