Vic 111mm Backside Phillips is PANTS!! (that's bad...)
-
This is my OH Locksmith. Don't think I'll get a warranty repair on this one... :-\
-
I rarely use SAK phillips, so I've nothing to say on that part of it.
If it weren't for the custom jobby, I'd give Vic at least one chance at warranty before avoiding the whole 111mm line.
What I did notice as I was checking my 111mms for comparison.
The outer liner on my Three layer 111mms (OHT & Helmsman) is slightly thicker than the one on my two Layer 111mm.
I also noticed that the Inner liner on my OHT and (Dutch?) Army knife is steel, while the centre liner on my Helmsman is alloy. (I imagine that has something to do with the OHT and Army knife being Liner locking, while the Helmsman is Packlock)
Just some possible variables that might contribute to that sort of failure.
-
All backspring Phillips are only good for one thing , fistloads . as drivers they fail !
Chris
-
Well,
Looking at this rigorously,
If the Phillips head is normal to the plane of the screw/bolt, and force is applied normal to the handle surface we can figure out the torque. I figure maybe 60 lbs (260 newtons) of force applied, 1/2 to each end of the handle gives a torque of:
2(0.045m X 130N)= 11.7 Nm torque
From a website giving assembly specs for steel bolts,
a #4 grade 5 steel bolt (diameter of 2.8 mm, that's 10% bigger than the diameter of the 2.5 mm brass pin), dry assembly torque is 2 Nm
This was 6 times the assembly torque!
Oh, and this little bit from a site regarding bolts and materials
Brass
Brass is an alloy of primarily copper and zinc. Brass is highly corrosion resistant and electrically conductive. However, its use as a fastener is somewhat limited due to its relative softness. It is used primarily for its appearance.I think it is safe to say that the backside Phillips is under-engineered. Even if the outer liner was as stiff as a regular backspring, I suspect the brass would begin to stretch, fatigue and eventually fail, given the arrangement in the tool.
I'll replace the pin, but I don't hold much hope for this as a goto farm tool... :-\
-
wow Mr. Whippy! very interesting and thanks for that. (and sorry it broke on you)
I do not like the back philips but so many of my country-people (usa) like it.
Mainly because we are not a big wine drinking country and idea of a philips
instead of a corkscrew appeals to so many here (just my opinion) ::)In my case, for me when I first started getting into SAKs I wanted philips and
not the corkscrew, even the backspring one.(scene from 2010) "I didn't know...I didn't know!"
How inconvenient it was and impractical, and you have just increased that notion!but I have learned, from the smart people here and at SOSAK! ty sir

-
Update: Repaired.
A few pictures:
The sheared brass pin:

Both pieces of sheared off brass pin. New hardened steel pin in place:

The repaired liner. The steel pin donor next to it. Scales back on:

Beauty shot of the tool with Donors and Deceased. :)

-
I'll stick to a corkscrew. If the screw is that hard to get out, I'd rather just skip the whole thing and drink wine until someone arrives with a proper driver.
-
Which reminds me...
Hey Victorinox! Can we get a nice inline Phillips of a decent size? Not the Outrider type, I mean something more substantial. And go ahead and couple it with a magnifier while you are at it. I imagine a 111 Scientist or Yeoman would sell like ice water at a curry shop.
Can I get an amen?
-
Good to see it back up and running Nate! :)
(amen)
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
This is my OH Locksmith. Don't think I'll get a warranty repair on this one... :-\PLEASE don't take this the wrong way, but have you considered that this could just be down to your modification not being 100% spot on? I have never seen that on any SAK - ever, which probably doesn't mean too much, but for Neil to never have seen that - that really says something.
-
It may be that Wenger has the upper hand here. The Ranger-61 appears to have steel liners either side of the corkscrew, so I imagine their Philips drivers are similarly constructed.
I don't know whether the rivet-pin is strong enough to stop the liners pulling apart under high load, as I don't have any knives with Philips tools. Living in France, I tend to favour the corkscrew option.

-
@Mr. Whippy said:
This is my OH Locksmith. Don't think I'll get a warranty repair on this one... :-\
PLEASE don't take this the wrong way, but have you considered that this could just be down to your modification not being 100% spot on? I have never seen that on any SAK - ever, which probably doesn't mean too much, but for Neil to never have seen that - that really says something.
Good question.
However, for this mod, I simply drilled off the pin heads, slid off the Locksmith blade/openers layers and slid on the OHT bits. Then put the outside (Locksmith) liner and peened the pins again.
If the pin had pulled through, I'd agree. In this case, it's clear that the pin was simply cut through by the tool.
Too much torque, too soft brass pin, too flimsy outside liner.
-
@glorn said:
Which reminds me...Hey Victorinox! Can we get a nice inline Phillips of a decent size? Not the Outrider type, I mean something more substantial. And go ahead and couple it with a magnifier while you are at it. I imagine a 111 Scientist or Yeoman would sell like ice water at a curry shop.
Can I get an amen?
Amen!
(BTW, inline tools have larger faces interacting with thick backsprings on bothsides--these features help prevent torquing to occur at the tool/brass pin interface (ie the backsprings on either side would have to bend out of the way to allow transmission of the forces). An inline Phillips, which could be "locked" at 90 degrees (like the cap lifter) would allow REAL torque to be safely applied.
-
It just seems odd that the single failure we have ever seen comes from a modded tool. Could just be a coincidence, but I don't like the idea of calling something crappy when it may not be anything due to the design or the manufacture. Peening could have weakened it or something?
I'd just not be writing off something yet which has proved reliable to many many others after this single failure.
-
Anyone want to offer up a sacrificial OHT? I'd be more than happy to torque off your Phillips...

Actually, any of the 111 mms with a backside Phillips... >:D
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Too much torque, too soft brass pin, too flimsy outside liner.I imagine the liners are meant to withstand the torque against the steel of the Philips, and the pin only exerts force to hold the liners in position. Once the pin head fails and the liners separate, the pin-shaft has no chance.
-
What would constitute a failure though? How much torque should it cope with?
-
I too have never seen one of these break :o I've never been a fan of this phillips and would always favour the one on my plier based multitool . I do however prefer my 111mm to have a corkscrew ;)
Dunc
-
@Benner said:
What would constitute a failure though? How much torque should it cope with?Well, in general, T-handled drivers are for high torque situations when the user wishes to apply more force to torque and less force to gripping the driver handle (increasing the frictional force to the driver handle).
I don't know the actual failure torque value for a standard T-handle driver. I can tell you, from my experience using torque wrenches, the failure in this case was well under the 30 Nm of a M10 frame bolt.
Using a thought experiment, if the outer liner was aluminum foil, and the pin was HighTorqium, the liner would immediately fail on torquing. (ie the liner wouldn't be able to retain the driver)
If the liner were made of thin aluminum and the pin were made of unbreakable String cheese, the pin would stretch, but only after the liner started to deform. If you change out the pin to HighTorquim again, the driver would start to rotate, but only as much as the liner would deform. At high enough torque, the liner would rip out at the hole just as the aluminum foil does. Make the liner twice as thick, and the deformation requires higher and higher torque values. Make the liner out of inch thick HighTorquim and the driver failure only occurs when the Phillips head twists off.
If the liner were again made of High Torquim and the pin were made of uncooked spaghetti, the driver would rotate and snap the spaghetti, but only if there is enough space that the driver can start to rotate. If clearance is 0 and the liners immovable, the pin receives none of the torque, with all of the torque applied between the corners of the tool and the adjacent liners.
Anyone who has worked with the liners knows they deform very easily. This leads me to believe that the outer liner deformed enough to allow torque to be delivered in significant amounts to the brass pin. Remember, this tool was modded a year ago and has been used since then. The repeated application of torque to the soft brass pin led to deformation and eventual failure. I believe any backside driver would suffer the same fate since the liner in any case will suffer deformation with high torque and will lead to shearing forces on the brass.
But that's just my theory. ;)
-
But are we to treat that driver the same as a T-driver? Are we really to expect the same performance out of a 111mm SAK as the "real deal"? (I'm just stirring it now :D)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login