Vic 111mm Backside Phillips is PANTS!! (that's bad...)
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
This is my OH Locksmith. Don't think I'll get a warranty repair on this one... :-\PLEASE don't take this the wrong way, but have you considered that this could just be down to your modification not being 100% spot on? I have never seen that on any SAK - ever, which probably doesn't mean too much, but for Neil to never have seen that - that really says something.
-
It may be that Wenger has the upper hand here. The Ranger-61 appears to have steel liners either side of the corkscrew, so I imagine their Philips drivers are similarly constructed.
I don't know whether the rivet-pin is strong enough to stop the liners pulling apart under high load, as I don't have any knives with Philips tools. Living in France, I tend to favour the corkscrew option.

-
@Mr. Whippy said:
This is my OH Locksmith. Don't think I'll get a warranty repair on this one... :-\
PLEASE don't take this the wrong way, but have you considered that this could just be down to your modification not being 100% spot on? I have never seen that on any SAK - ever, which probably doesn't mean too much, but for Neil to never have seen that - that really says something.
Good question.
However, for this mod, I simply drilled off the pin heads, slid off the Locksmith blade/openers layers and slid on the OHT bits. Then put the outside (Locksmith) liner and peened the pins again.
If the pin had pulled through, I'd agree. In this case, it's clear that the pin was simply cut through by the tool.
Too much torque, too soft brass pin, too flimsy outside liner.
-
@glorn said:
Which reminds me...Hey Victorinox! Can we get a nice inline Phillips of a decent size? Not the Outrider type, I mean something more substantial. And go ahead and couple it with a magnifier while you are at it. I imagine a 111 Scientist or Yeoman would sell like ice water at a curry shop.
Can I get an amen?
Amen!
(BTW, inline tools have larger faces interacting with thick backsprings on bothsides--these features help prevent torquing to occur at the tool/brass pin interface (ie the backsprings on either side would have to bend out of the way to allow transmission of the forces). An inline Phillips, which could be "locked" at 90 degrees (like the cap lifter) would allow REAL torque to be safely applied.
-
It just seems odd that the single failure we have ever seen comes from a modded tool. Could just be a coincidence, but I don't like the idea of calling something crappy when it may not be anything due to the design or the manufacture. Peening could have weakened it or something?
I'd just not be writing off something yet which has proved reliable to many many others after this single failure.
-
Anyone want to offer up a sacrificial OHT? I'd be more than happy to torque off your Phillips...

Actually, any of the 111 mms with a backside Phillips... >:D
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Too much torque, too soft brass pin, too flimsy outside liner.I imagine the liners are meant to withstand the torque against the steel of the Philips, and the pin only exerts force to hold the liners in position. Once the pin head fails and the liners separate, the pin-shaft has no chance.
-
What would constitute a failure though? How much torque should it cope with?
-
I too have never seen one of these break :o I've never been a fan of this phillips and would always favour the one on my plier based multitool . I do however prefer my 111mm to have a corkscrew ;)
Dunc
-
@Benner said:
What would constitute a failure though? How much torque should it cope with?Well, in general, T-handled drivers are for high torque situations when the user wishes to apply more force to torque and less force to gripping the driver handle (increasing the frictional force to the driver handle).
I don't know the actual failure torque value for a standard T-handle driver. I can tell you, from my experience using torque wrenches, the failure in this case was well under the 30 Nm of a M10 frame bolt.
Using a thought experiment, if the outer liner was aluminum foil, and the pin was HighTorqium, the liner would immediately fail on torquing. (ie the liner wouldn't be able to retain the driver)
If the liner were made of thin aluminum and the pin were made of unbreakable String cheese, the pin would stretch, but only after the liner started to deform. If you change out the pin to HighTorquim again, the driver would start to rotate, but only as much as the liner would deform. At high enough torque, the liner would rip out at the hole just as the aluminum foil does. Make the liner twice as thick, and the deformation requires higher and higher torque values. Make the liner out of inch thick HighTorquim and the driver failure only occurs when the Phillips head twists off.
If the liner were again made of High Torquim and the pin were made of uncooked spaghetti, the driver would rotate and snap the spaghetti, but only if there is enough space that the driver can start to rotate. If clearance is 0 and the liners immovable, the pin receives none of the torque, with all of the torque applied between the corners of the tool and the adjacent liners.
Anyone who has worked with the liners knows they deform very easily. This leads me to believe that the outer liner deformed enough to allow torque to be delivered in significant amounts to the brass pin. Remember, this tool was modded a year ago and has been used since then. The repeated application of torque to the soft brass pin led to deformation and eventual failure. I believe any backside driver would suffer the same fate since the liner in any case will suffer deformation with high torque and will lead to shearing forces on the brass.
But that's just my theory. ;)
-
But are we to treat that driver the same as a T-driver? Are we really to expect the same performance out of a 111mm SAK as the "real deal"? (I'm just stirring it now :D)
-

I've never come across any SAK however abused that has a snapped pin. So this is really weird. I've seen deformed liners before but on corkscrew SAKs. These normally have bent corkscrews as well. I've seen older SAKs where every liner has split in two! but even then the pins were all OK. Its proper bizarre :ahhh
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
But are we to treat that driver the same as a T-driver? Are we really to expect the same performance out of a 111mm SAK as the "real deal"? (I'm just stirring it now :D)
That's wot it looks like... ???
Are you proposing a poser Victorinox tool! :o
Not at all (and you know it
:D) but are we really to expect that level of performance out of a SAK? Surely we need some level of sacrifice for the sheer amount of function we have in such a small package, perhaps ultimate strength is that sacrifice? -
Cor blimey :o
I've never come close to messing up a Vic like that - I think Mr W must have very big butch hands!
Whether the tools should be expected to deal with such high torque is a goods question - should we asking someone from Victorinox this?
-
@Benner said:
What would constitute a failure though? How much torque should it cope with?My point is that the first effect of over-stressing the philips is to stretch the brass pin holding the knife together. Using the bottle-opener as a lever would have a similar effect. And once the pin-head fails, the liner and pin-shaft will inevitably cede.
Now this is a modified knife: the part which is critical to the integrity of the knife against transverse forces -- the pin heads -- is exactly the part which has been re-worked. Mr. Whippy's breakage may be due to the fact that it's difficult to re-make the brass pin-heads to the same strength as the original.
With brass being as soft as it is, I'm surprised not to see more of this kind of thing.
-
It appears to be a shear of the brass though, not the head?
-
As long as the pin is tight, the screwdriver is twisting against the liners and not the pin itself. As soon as the pin lets go of the bushes holding the knife together, the liners move apart (as in the photo) and the screwdriver is twisting against the pin. At this point the knife is doomed: the screwdriver is now twisting directly against the thin, soft brass pin, which is likely to fail immediately.
The pin head must have failed first, before the body of the pin was sheared through. If the pin head had not failed, I guess the knife would have held together.
I can't claim the modified knife was weaker in this respect than an ordinary model, but it's a possibility.
-
Science!
It's the only way. I didn't have another 111 mm to use as an experiment so I picked out this 2 layer 91 mm SAK.
Here are the testing gear: NE size socket, SAK, Torque wrench:

I placed the SAK in the Vise so that the edge of the tool is free, that way the vise isn't acting as outer liners:

Long story short, I don't have an inch-pounds torque wrench. The tool failed at less than 10 Nm! :o

The failure appears to be EXACTLY the same mode as my 111 mm SAK. The Brass was cut through when the liners gave way.

Conclusion:
The backside Victorinox Phillips is in NO WAY to be confused with a T handle driver. Best used for pre-loosened screws. :(
-
See, I don't see it as a T-driver. I just see it as a driver hanging off the back of a backspring.
I doubt any of it is as strong as the "real deal" but that's the price you pay for compactness and the range of tools it offers.
Question is, is 10 NM the same as that of the 111mm SAK?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login