Electrical Help
-
My wife was nice enough to buy me a new starter, which I just installed. I can see why the manual suggested removing the exhaust as it really got in the way! I had to take out a two inch long bolt about a half a millimeter at a time because that's all the space I had to work with- if the exhaust wasn't in the way I'd have about 70 degrees in which to swing the ratchet! Of course, the bolts were pretty well stuck and trying to get them out a half millimeter at a time was quite a chore.
What really pisses me off is that the damn thing still won't start. I plugged it in to my trickle charger, and it won't even respond to the key turning without being plugged in (understandable since it's been dead for a week or so now), and when it is plugged in I get the dash lights and a really fast ticking noise, which is exactly what the old starter was doing, and I was pretty certain that meant it was dead.
I'm exhausted from having worked all night last night, then mowing the lawn and arguing with that stupid starter now, so I'm done for the day, but if anyone has any suggestions, there's always tomorrow.
Worst part is, we are having a gorgous long weekend, with weather over 20C and my Jeep isn't running which meanbs no cruising with the top down and no way to get my kayak to the water. :ahhh

Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
and when it is plugged in I get the dash lights and a really fast ticking noise, which is exactly what the old starter was doing, and I was pretty certain that meant it was dead.That sounds like battery couldn't supply enough power, not starter problem. Connect battery to the other car with jumper cable and see if it works.
-
The 12v power system was the extent of my usefulness

Hopefully someone else can help with the high speed ticking diagnosis
-
Thanks for the tip Jie- I hooked the VW up to it and it started. Not easily and not right away, but it started.
Now I'm still getting the Check Gauges light and the battery doodad is still all the way to the 19 side, which is what it was doing the other day just before dying. It's been running for about 20 minutes now and hasn't kicked the bucket yet. Should I just leave it running and the gauge will sort itself out or is this indicative of another problem?
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2

-
I ran it for about 45 minutes then shut it down. Absolutely nothing happened- no ticking, no attempts to start, nothing. Maybe I just need to leave it running all the time. ::)
Def
-
I know a bit about 12V systems, but nothing about auto-mechanics ... but I can tell you an alternator pumping out 19V is not a good thing :-\
-
Other than the not being able to start it thing and the gauge thing, it seemed fine.
Def
-
High speed ticking from a starter would mean that there is insufficient current from the battery to fully engage the starter.
The instrument cluster appears to be acting as though its processor is not getting enough voltage.
The likely causes are:
-
Either the alternator is not putting out enough current
-
Or the battery has a shorted cell, which is demanding all of the alternator's current
There is also a possibility of a loose connection that is preventing the alternator's output from reaching the rest of the electrical system.
One other possibility is that the powertrain control module is not controlling the alternator's output correctly.
-
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Other than the not being able to start it thing and the gauge thing, it seemed fine.Def

Well that's OK then, at least it's nothing to worry about :P

Have you got a multimeter to put across the battery terminals while It's running to see what it is putting out? If it starts off the jump leads from the other car I'd say the next thing is the Jeep battey. I can see that it may have struggled to start off the jump leads if your battery was trying to pull the power in, but 45 minutes should have put some decent charge back in. Try putting a meter across the terminals while it's not running ... ? The old set up might have shafted your battery mate, but don't go forking out for a new one till you know if that's the case or not
@turnsouth said:
High speed ticking from a starter would mean that there is insufficient current from the battery to fully engage the starter.The instrument cluster appears to be acting as though its processor is not getting enough voltage.
The likely causes are:
- Either the alternator is not putting out enough current
- Or the battery has a shorted cell, which is demanding all of the alternator's current
There is also a possibility of a loose connection that is preventing the alternator's output from reaching the rest of the electrical system.
One other possibility is that the powertrain control module is not controlling the alternator's output correctly.
Paul, could this be as simple as an earth fault? Would it be prudent to clean up all the earth connections to ensure there's a full circuit wherever there should be?
-
I'm thinking the faulty alternator or complete discharge may have fried the battery so it's not taking any more charge at all. When everything is off measure the voltage at battery terminals, it should be around 12v. Then start it up (if you still can by boosting with the VW) and measure again, now it should be about 14v. Any lower the alternator isn't charging, and if it's 19v there then the alternator is really smurfed, might want to avoid running the vehicle till you can change the alternator, I don't know what voltage the CPU can take before frying.
The battery is also probably dead, so take it to any place that sells them and do a load test, it's a hand held thingy and takes 30 seconds to do.
-
@jzmtl said:
I'm thinking the faulty alternator or complete discharge may have fried the battery so it's not taking any more charge at all. When everything is off measure the voltage at battery terminals, it should be around 12v. Then start it up (if you still can by boosting with the VW) and measure again, now it should be about 14v. Any lower the alternator isn't charging, and if it's 19v there then the alternator is really smurfed, might want to avoid running the vehicle till you can change the alternator, I don't know what voltage the CPU can take before frying.The battery is also probably dead, so take it to any place that sells them and do a load test, it's a hand held thingy and takes 30 seconds to do.
Good call

-
I would imagine it's most likely a loose connection given that it's a twelve year old truck and I just replaced two components in the electrical system.
I'll have to screw around a little and see what I can find. I do have a multimeter and I'll try to get a reading on the battery and see what's up with it.
I am really not looking forward to changing the alternator again... and the battery is only a couple of years old.
Def
-
@50ft-trad said:
Paul, could this be as simple as an earth fault? Would it be prudent to clean up all the earth connections to ensure there's a full circuit wherever there should be?Possibly, but it would not be my first guess.
The first thing that I would do is take the battery to any chain auto parts store and have it fully tested.

-
and in the meantime keep your eye on ebay for a tactical pink bicycle

-
So.... bad idea to drive it to my mechanic's to let him sort it out? :P
Def
-
Screw it. Its going in next week anyway to get the frame done anyway. I might as well just bring the whole thing down to him before I screw something else up.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
-
The bright side is that if he is anything like me, he will take great pleasure in explaining how modern, complex automotive electrical systems should be left to the professionals... ;)
-
... and if he's anything like me, he'll take great pride in taking the piss out of anything you've tried so far :D :D :D :D
-
Luckily he's nothing like either of you! :P
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login