Livarno, Romisen, C8, Small Sun cheap HID torches
-
-
For some reason that Small Sun really catches my eye. And at that price, hmm...
Does the switch seem durable?
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
For some reason that Small Sun really catches my eye. And at that price, hmm...Does the switch seem durable?
The first thing I thought when I opened its box and took it out was* "This looks like a really good product; a lot better than what I expected"*.
The switch feels fine, it does not have any wobble or side to side movement as you may find in DIY shop torches. Good, positive feeling, looks quite basic but I have not disassembled it too much (see pictures posted previously).
I threw one in the glove compartment of the car and it is there, ready for when needed and taking very little space. Way brighter and smaller than my Energizer 2AA water resistant torch I used to have in the car tool box.
I have no idea how well the switch will last if I were to turn it on and off several times a day, but the maker is a reasonably well known cheap brand so I expect it to last OK.
The components seem similar to the ones used in the other CREE products of Small Sun which are noticeably more expensive (over $10.. :ahhh) (Check focalprice and Exduct)There are some reviews in the site I bought it from, here:
One person had a problem with the switch, though I have no idea how many were sold in total (1 problem out of 100 or 1 problem out of 100000?). ???
To get the lower price ($3) I bought 3 and used a discount code I found on the internet.
Honestly, I wished I bought a couple more as they will make good presents. If they last I may still order a few more for that purpose and to just leave around for any emergency use.
-
Clickies aren't a big deal. As long as there's some kind of removable retainer holding it in, you can always replace them, and they're cheap. I'm not a fan of forward clickies, so I tend to swap them out for reverse clickies, and it's easy to do.
-
I got a couple of bike light sets with a 0.5W 15Lm front light and a 0.2W rear, red, light
Front light on duration up to 25 hours and rear up to 60 hours
Nice deep reflector, all plastic.
I was surprised by the amount of electronics in them; possibly to enable charging batteries, as written in the manual.Both are single mode only. (no flashing)
Some pictures:







-
In preparation for the summer I got this:
The Xtar D02 diving torch, well regarded in BLF etc.
I chose the 3AAA battery version so that I would have easy availability of batteries anywhere I go, whether I had a charger or not.


The torch arrived quickly (total cost $50) and came with a spare switch and rubber sealing rings.

From the manufacturer’s site:
XTAR D02 200m Diving CREE XP-G R4 LED Flashlight
50000 life span CREE XP-G R4 LED
Electrodeless magnetic control switch
260 max luminous flux
Good condensing orange peeled reflector
250m max range (on land)
Constant circuit constant brightness
Power by 3 x AAA(1.5V) battery
Anodized aircraft 6061 aluminium body, PMMA head cover
Amphibious 200m deep diving sealed compression resisted design
Safety magnetic switch design
2.5~4.5V voltage range
NetWeight: 185g
Size:48.0mm(head dia) * 28.0mm(body dia) * 146.0mm(length)
The torch was smaller than I expected; about the size of a C8 style torch.

Feels and looks well made. You can get cheaper diving torches but I have no idea if they will be as good as the Xtar.
It has a plastic front lens which can potentially be scratched, though if the plastic’s refractive index is similar to the water any scratches will not be noticed in the water as they will be “filled in”.

The battery container appears twisted, though I have no idea if this is the way it should be or not. Works fine.

The outside switch works without any, it seems, physical contact with the inside parts of it, possibly utilizing the effect a metal will produce in an electric field.
The torch stays off until you push the switch about half way up and then it starts getting brighter until it reaches its peak brightness when the switch goes all the way up.
The switch is quite hard to move and as pointed out before only seems to utilize half of its movement, as it is off in the first half. This variable beam brightness is useful in murky waters.
The contacts appear plated. Heat dissipation should not be a problem underwater.

At its full brightness the volume of light produced appears similar to the one produced by the Jetbeam BA20 so the claim for 260Lm seems realistic. (checked with a ceiling bounce test too).
The beam tests shown were performed indoors with some daylight, in the early afternoon.
Set-up:

Xtar, Jetbeam both on low and Livarno

Xtar on high

Xtar and Jetbeam on high


-
Romisen RC-T601

Though not on the Romisen website the general consensus seems to be that it is a genuine product. The construction and general look supports that too.
It is available with 2 or 5 modes and there is a theory that the 2 mode one has a better LED drive. I got the 5 ( high, medium, low and 2 Disco) mode one from : http://kaidomain.com/product/details.S010166 as getting the 2 mode one, from another dealer, would have been noticeably more expensive.
I originally intended to get a KD-C8 but the reviews on the latest ones were a bit worrying.
The torch is nicely finished feels solid, has aluminium reflector, glass lens and uses springs for battery contacts on both ends, has a centred CREE XML-T6 LED with a plastic protective cover for the electronics and anodized threads.


Head:

It takes an 18650 battery and can accommodate protected ones easily, with no modification needed.
Does not tailstand and has the stupid “next mode memory” setting, so every time you switch it on it goes to the next setting.
Comes with two weird strike rings on the body, which means it will not fit into some bicycle torch holders easily.

Depending on the battery voltage it will draw 1.7A to 1.4A on high.
Gets reasonably hot, quickly, something that I noticed on my other Romisen too.
Compared to another Romisen:
(Note the
Vs
label)
Anodized threads

**Compared to an Ultrafire C8:
**

The Ultrafire cap had to be modified to take protected batteries.

The Romisen has 3mm Al at the threads and the Ultrafire only 1.8mm.

The body thickness is similar as the Ultrafire thickens after the threads


<u>The Romisen weighs 166g and the Ultrafire only 140.</u>
Beam comparisons:
From the Left: Romisen, Ultrafire, Jetbeam, Trustfire

High

Low

Romisen Vs Ultrafire

And Vs Trustfire

The Romisen beam is very impressive.
It noticeably outthrows the Ultrafire and the Trustfire, despite drawing a lower current form the battery, compared to the Ultrafire. The whole construction and electronics in it appear to be a class above the Ultrafire, though it costs** 30%** more, which it is definitely worth it.
It will light up objects nicely at an impressive distance, nearly 30% further away than the Ultrafire. Surprisingly, the Romisen on medium is as bright as the Ultrafire on high. The beam has a nice spread around the hot spot, too.
I can now annoy neighbours a lot further away than I thought possible before.

If you can live with the weird strike rings and the extra length and weight then the Romisen is definitely worth the extra cost, compared to the cheaper Ultrafire.
-
Good round-up mate.
I have to say I've been quite impressed with the quality of my Romisen as well, they do seem to be a cut above many other 'cheap' lights. -
Thank you, this thread is getting pretty long even though I try to post only about the important torches.
Good to see some people still actually read it. 
Romisen are definitely worth the extra money, though I would not consider them that cheap. You do, for the extra money, get more upmarket finish, threads, possibly LED quality and electronics etc.
Really, for just a wee bit more you can get a Fenix or Jetbeam etc. with lower output but possibly better quality and functions. E.g., the Jetbeam BA20 is about $10 more than the RC-T601 above and should make most people pretty happy, for a long time.
However, a top brand with the throw of that Romisen will cost noticeably more...
-
MXDL SA-22

I am not big on zooms but this had a decent reputation on BLF so I got one.
Cree Q5 LED, runs on 3AAA or 1 18650 (adaptor supplied)
The torch is quite pretty.
Comes with a pocket clip and some rubber rings around its body.
Says Cree 7W on one side.
The zoom works by moving the LED with the reflector closer to or away from a concave (half) plastic lens, using a metal ring (the led does not, ever, touch the lens).



The torch has three settings: High, low, disco.
It has “next mode memory”.Claimed brightness is 400lm…. ::)
The contacts are protected by some magic paint.


I know this is very important to some people, so YES, it can tailstand!!

Draws 0.5A on high with 3AA and 0.6A with 18650 both set ups with freshly charged batteries.
Considering that the 3AA were at 4.04V and the 18650 at 4.15V the light should be a bit brighter with the 18650, at least to begin with. I have no idea (did not test) if it is regulated or not.The party trick of this torch is that by using the zoom you can see a real image of the LED, which looks like the Transformers symbol…


Here are some beam shots, with the Romisen RC-K4 with only
160lm.
The SA-22 is on the right.SA-22 on high, both zoom extremes shown.


And on low.

The total amount of light they produce appears similar. They both run on 3AAA and draw similar currents, though they have different LEDs and electronics.
Size comparison.

The quality is pretty decent for the price and there seems to be a reasonable (taking onto account the design) conduction of heat to the outside.
Good fun!

-
Are you a fan of the Romison ones? they have one that ive been looking at for a few days and am curious as to how they hold up and work? im looking at the Cree XP-G R5 Romison RC-R5, however they say it.. JR
-
-
Is the zoom function similar to the focusing of Maglites? Otherwise, I guess I don't understand what it's used for? ???
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Is the zoom function similar to the focusing of Maglites? Otherwise, I guess I don't understand what it's used for? ???Since I happened to have a mini maglite next to me..

The difference is that in the maglite you move the head of the torch, with the reflector thus the LED changes position in the reflector altering the beam pattern, whereas here the head does not move but as you turn the green collar round the LED which is stuck on the very shallow reflector (see 2nd picture) moves up and down, with the reflector.
Thus as the beam becomes less focused, by moving the LED away from the ideal focusing position the beam becomes more spread out and less concentrated lighting a larger area.
As you get away from that ideal focusing position the thick lens can not converge the beam in any way so you are basically getting the light as it comes from the shallow reflector.As shown in the pictures previously you go from a concentrated beam, a thrower, into a spread beam, a flooder in torch forum talk.
Thus you have various, functional and this is important compared to a maglite (allegedly), beam patterns, similar to carrying several torches with you.
-
@dks said:
I am not familiar with that model but Romisen have a solid reputation.I am happy with mine, though I do not use them hard enough to really test them
Im not one who thoroughly abuses my things, so longs as they hold up to above a normal day im happy, do you know anything about the AA size 14500 3v battery? thats the only thing i have against that model, (besides the thin wire clip) id have to get a new battery set, i mean it says that it will run on normal AA's but thats only 1.5v so i dont think its going to give off 100% unlike the 14500? JR
-
-
Ultrafire WF-501B XML-T6

Firstly I was quite surprised by how small it was. It is something you can easily put in your pocket.
Length about 13cm, thickness at the head about 3cm and at the body about 2.2cm.I expected it to be about the same size as my Ultrafire C8, which has the same basic specifications.

Came with a sheath for $12.50, which is reasonable for this product.
Does not tailstand and its rear button is not textured, but works fine.
It is a basic, lower tech torch, in that it has a drop-in XML-T6 module rather than a fitted, screw in one.

This can cause problems with heat dissipation as there is not, in theory, that much contact between the LED module and the body, but my sample got hot, noticeably, very quickly so there is definitely enough heat transfer to the outside.
It has an Aluminium reflector and the drop in appears well constructed, with a nice, thick, polished smooth reflector and a glass, secured, lens
Appears well constructed, for the price.
It runs on one 18650 battery, drawing 1.4A on high.
Note that a protected battery will not fit easily in it.
It has 5 modes, high, medium, low and two disco, with mode memory.The LED is nicely centred
The beam is a bit yellowish, like an ordinary filament lamp.
I took some beam shots with the C8 and the Jetbeam Ba20 on high.


And also some with the C8 and the RT-601 on high, again.


The wf-501 beam is decent enough, though it does not have a well defined hotspot. The beam appears similar to the one I get from the Jetbeam which, however, has an OP reflector. The volume of light seems similar to the C8.It is not dark yet, so I will test for throw later.
Generally I am quite happy with what it gives you in such a small package.

-
-
After reading some good things about them I ordered a Tank007 E09, to use as a keychain torch.

I liked the fact that it was similar in size to a Fenix E05 but had 3 power settings, reaching 120lm and was reasonably cheap (about half the price of the Fenix. Currently the Fenix can be had for under $20).
I got mine from Manafont (14.30) http://www.manafont.com/product_info.php/tank007-e09-xpe-r2-3mode-led-flashlight-complete-aluminum-box-set-black-aaa-p-9258
but the cheapest current price seems to be from Dinodirect ($11.99) http://www.dinodirect.com/flashlight-super-mini-tank007-e09-cree-r2-lumen-led.html?DDID=3520-616Summary for the easily bored: I liked it and ordered 3 more, the end. Now go and read the next topic.
Tank007 (James Bond vehicle?) is a company similar to Romisen in that it produces/markets decent lower priced Torches, definitely a step above the lower end Chinese torches, costing of course more than them.
Their webpage http://www.tank007store.com/products/Tank007-E09-Mini-Keychain-Flashlight.html
Come in: Black, Pink, Grey, purple and maybe more..
According to the site:
Product Description
Tank007 E09 Cree XP-E R3 Mini Keychain Flashlight
(Note: some sellers claim different R version; it seems to be a product that changes continuously with several slightly different versions. See BLF for more) *Power Source: 1x AAA battery (Alkaline, NiMH; recommended: Eneloop, Lithium primary, 10440 Li-Ion, or Protected 10440 Li-Ion)
Run time: 120 lumens(33 minutes), 60 lumens(95 minutes), 10 lumens(1020 minutes)
7cm long and 1.5cm wide.
The torch comes in a nice plastic or aluminium container with spare o-rings
It is a bit longer than a Fenix E05 (E05-E09….)

Can tailstand

Comes with a smooth reflector.

There was some debris (looked like a dead insect or threads) inside the reflector. Unfortunately my understanding is that the whole head assembly is secured with glue and not designed to be taken easily apart, so I had to leave it like that. (see BLF, again, for more on that)
The finish is fine, no visible problems.
It also appears pretty tough. I have been carrying it on my keychain for a couple of weeks and there are still no visible scratches (from that…
).Drop testing.
. the torch has been dropped several times from heights ranging from 1m to 2m on hard floors. Apart from some paint being scratched of from the head no other damage has happened.The torch came with no instructions as such so originally I thought it was broken as it went from bright to really low after I played with it.. ::)
Basically it has a twist mechanism for operation. You switch it on by twisting (screwing in motion) the head and then you change modes by quickly turning the head clockwise-anticlockwise a bit.The threads came over-lubricated and work better after some cleaning. Still, no way as smooth in operation as the Fenix or a Jetbeam etc.
The **key ring was rubbish ** and started getting out of shap and stretching in a couple of days. I replaced it with one from a LM Micra.
I am running it on Duracells (Duraloops) but have also ordered some 10440 batteries too.
On high it is **pretty bright ** and can be used as your main light, not needing to carry a bigger, “proper” light. The medium setting is also very good, comparable to the Fenix one and lasts longer. The low setting is quite low and should be useful for reading.
The lower settings are with PWM http://www.tigerhawkt3.com/welcomemat/ledfaqs.htm#2 so a noise can be heard on low and it is possible, with a camera, to see the “gaps” between the beams..
Some beam comparisons then..:On high: Tank007 (120lm), Fenix (27lm), Jetbeam (270lm), Romisen (170lm)

Same, but designed to show the beams better:

Without the (single mode) Romisen. Tank007 on medium, Jetbeam on low (2 modes)

Without the (single mode) Romisen. Tank007 on low, Jetbeam on low (2 modes)

*Pros: good quality
Small and powerful
CheapCons:
Dirty and impossible to clean lens-reflector assembly.
Weak key ring
Not very smooth twist system*I ordered 3 more, to use and give as presents

-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
.... I shouldn't have read it, now I want it...