Cordless drills, brushless?
-
@WhichDawg said:
until they get rid of past inventory and production, it will take years for the actual price to come down on brushless (I think)
That's what I'm afraid of, it's going to be the premium product for a while and price will show that. I'd love a FEStool but they are way out of my price range.
@Mr. Whippy said:
Just my opinion, but battery technology really drives what I use.Yep same here, they are always the first to die when the tool is perfectly good, and cost so much might as well just buy a new kit. Which is why I think those new B&D drill with exchangeable head is stupid, you'll just end up with a bunch of useless parts after the battery dies. Also I'm pretty sure the dewalt 20v IS 18v, it's just a marketing gimmick.
-
Also whats considered to be a good price for a 18v drill with two li ion batteries from a major brand south of the border? Trying to see if something is a good deal but not familiar with market.
-
@jzmtl said:
Also whats considered to be a good price for a 18v drill with two li ion batteries from a major brand south of the border? Trying to see if something is a good deal but not familiar with market.what I've seen from major markets/brands is around 150-200 us dollars for 1 or 2 drills (one impact, which is the hot item the past 2 years) and 2 batteries (18v) and a soft shell case.
also if your interested, many customers have told me the Milwaukee "Shockwaves" drill bits are fantastic! they last and take a beating, they do not wear down easy and are made really well. They say they no longer buy bits (other brands, cheap and even named brand) over and over because they have worn down (special design and materials). I swear I have no Milwaukee stuff and I'm not pushing them it's just what I hear

-
Thanks, that's a good reference point. I'm sticking with just a drill for now, don't have a use for impact driver since I'm not building any decks or sheds.
I don't think I've seen that in store, I'll keep an eye out of them. I've always used either regular HSS or cobalt bits depends on what I'm drilling, since I sharpen them I avoid any coated or fancy geometry bits
-
It is weird that despite buying tools all my life I have only heard of Milwaukee the past few months and until reading this I assumed they were a cheap no-name brand, as seen in many diy shops. I assume they are mainly sold in the states.
As said before I am more interested in the batteries; replaced my power tools with ones using li-ions lately as I was unhappy with never having a tool charged when I needed it. Apart from B&D I also buy the lidls tools as they are generally good and German made. I like brushless motors on rc toys :D
As it was also said before usually the battery dies and you cannot find a replacement. The funny thing is that all my cheaper power tools came with space brushes, whereas the expensive ones did not. I have only needed to replace brushes a couple of times on tools that were used for what should really be described as professional use .yes, this was sent from a phone!
-
@dks said:
It is weird that despite buying tools all my life I have only heard of Milwaukee the past few months and until reading this I assumed they were a cheap no-name brand, as seen in many diy shops. I assume they are mainly sold in the states.As said before I am more interested in the batteries; replaced my power tools with ones using li-ions lately as I was unhappy with never having a tool charged when I needed it. Apart from B&D I also buy the lidls tools as they are generally good and German made. I like brushless motors on rc toys :D
As it was also said before usually the battery dies and you cannot find a replacement. The funny thing is that all my cheaper power tools came with space brushes, whereas the expensive ones did not. I have only needed to replace brushes a couple of times on tools that were used for what should really be described as professional use .yes, this was sent from a phone!
I have noticed that US and Canadian members talk about tools I have never heard about before, they have their own brands which are rarely seen in europe.
If I would be buying a power tool, I would probably go for Bosch or something similar, they have Milwaukee and whatnot... same difference, no?
-
Bosch is a pretty big name here too. But it's the same for me when I was researching them, occasionally I come across an UK forum and I've never heard of the brands mentioned there. I never knew Panasonic made power tools, always thought they only do TV and microwaves. Some others like Metabo (sounds like a marvel supervillain) are here but not known to the general public.
Going with li-ion is the major reason I'm looking for a new one, my ni-cad dewalt works fine if the battery is charged, but most of the time I had to start with a half dead battery which is not enough if I want to drill more than a few holes.
-
Metabo is one of teh first Manufacturers making electrical power drills (at least in germany).
After always buying cheap hardware store cordless drills and replacing them aftzer 2 years, I decided I will no longer borrow my tools or leave them on site (the main reason I always bought cheap) and bought myself a Metabo cordless drill. It´s one of the "simpler" models, no hammer drill, just drill, but metal gears and gear casing, brush motor, 14,4 V 1,5AH LiIon battery - And a 5 year warranty, including the battery, even in commercial use. This is quite outstanding (especially here in germany where usually 2 year warranty is tops).
You can get spare parts, spare batteries, bigger batteries (3 AH)
That thing was worth every penny.
http://www.metabo.de/Produktkatalog-handgefuehrte-Elektrowerkzeuge.23744+M57d9a3e15fc.0.html
With non-commercial / or daily usage, I think the brush type engines will last you very long, when using them daily on the job, the brushless motor might be worth teh extra money - AFAIk the delivered power is comparable.
-
I have the Bosch 10.8V screwdriver, 10.8V impact driver, the most basic 18V combi drill and the 18V impact driver, all Blue. At work after getting increasingly pissed of with crap Ryobi tools and batteries I managed to persuade them to get a decent set, and we've got the 18V "Dynamic" series Bosch drill with three 2.6Ah batteries. It's great and wasn't too expensive in the grand scheme of things. It was actually cheaper to get that than 3 1.5Ah Ryobi batteries ???
Anyway, I wouldn't worry too much about brushed/brushless unless you're using it a hell of a lot. All the decent brands have good warranties and you can buy spare parts. I rate Bosch, Makita, Hitachi but would avoid DeWalt as IMO you're paying a premium for the name only.
I have Milwaukee bits for my impact drivers and they're OK but nothing more. The Pozi bits lack definition - where a decent bit will hold on to a screw at most angles, the Milwaukee ones struggle even vertically. Their nut drivers are good though.
As for the Ryobi tools, one that should have been really useful was the angle grinder but you could only manage about one cut per battery with decent thin cutting disks. I've made up a couple of adapters to run them straight off a tractor battery and they work much better. The no load top speed is slightly lower but as soon as you load them up the difference is huge - it actually works pretty well! Good for repairs in the field.
-
Yeah I figured for my use either one is fine. Bosch (specifically HDS180-03) is what I'm looking right now, but haven't decided if I should get it now or wait for any Christmas discounts.
Dewalt is about on par with others price wise here, maybe they have a premium in Europe like Leatherman?
-
@Cupboard said:
I have Milwaukee bits for my impact drivers and they're OK but nothing more. The Pozi bits lack definition - where a decent bit will hold on to a screw at most angles, the Milwaukee ones struggle even vertically. Their nut drivers are good though.are those the Milwaukee "Shockwave" bits? which are totally different from their regular line.
-
The Metabo Salesperson told me their battery angle grinder will cut 8 Meters of 5 mm steel (ST 38) with one Standard battery (I guess with thin discs, but quite impressive nonetheless)
Not too shabby, I´d say - It would be a convenient addition to m Janitor toolbox, but as i use an Angle driver really sparingly, i bring my private 230V one to work when I need one... at least they pay the discs. -
@jzmtl said:
Yeah I figured for my use either one is fine. Bosch (specifically HDS180-03) is what I'm looking right now, but haven't decided if I should get it now or wait for any Christmas discounts.Dewalt is about on par with others price wise here, maybe they have a premium in Europe like Leatherman?
That's the one we have at work, we've only had it about 9 months but it's doing extremely well so far. I've accidentally thrown it on the floor and you wouldn't know.
Dewalt tend to cost a lottle more than Bosch and Makita whilst being a bit less good IMO. I'd choose one over a Ryobi but I'd choose either of the blue ones over the yellow one.
@WhichDawg said:
are those the Milwaukee "Shockwave" bits? which are totally different from their regular line.yes
Despite what I said about Dewalt above, their impact driver bits are an extremely good fit in screws and last well

I haven't had any particular problems with the Milwaukee bits, they just aren't as good as my others for fit.
-
Oh, and the Bosch drill has enough oomf to turn over a 5HP petrol engine for extended periods - useful when I was trying to fix the damned thing!
-
Most pros I see working seem to use Hilti cordless tools; look for the red colour...
When it comes to corded drills they seem to use B@D and some Makita.
Makita tries to sell itself as the professional's choice but I have used some of their angle grinders, small and full size and they did not seem to last longer than the rest. Dust kills them all. Dewalt are not common as they just seem to be more expensive than their sister company B@D for no apparent reason. They are mainly seen as a "designer" product for people who like to show off rather than use their tools.For drills I have a combination of B&D (one must be 40+ years old, all metal construction), Lidls, 15 year old Blackspur with its original battery.... etc
-
The Dewalt 20V group is supposedly going to be taking over their product line in the next few years. They are still going to make 18v stuff and support it but will be slowly phased out of the market. I currently use Dewalt drivers but am getting tired of their hit or miss performance. I will be switching to another brand. I have a Skil corded saw which is fantastic so maybe I will try a Skil drill. I used to work in the home improvement industry as a product rep and will not buy Ryobi due to their crappy build quality.
-
I'm a little confused on the dewalt 20v max, are they all brushless or only some of them?
Local store will have a sale on Bosch CLPK232-181 kit for a good price, although I don't know if I want an impact driver since I don't do any construction.
-
@jzmtl said:
I'm a little confused on the dewalt 20v max, are they all brushless or only some of them?Local store will have a sale on Bosch CLPK232-181 kit for a good price, although I don't know if I want an impact driver since I don't do any construction.
Impact drivers really excel at putting in screws in tough situations without stripping out the head AND in removing really stuck nuts (like lug nuts or nuts exposed to the corrosion of being out in the elements.).
-
Impact drivers are fantastic for many things, there's nothing better for self drilling screws. The Bosch 18V one will undo the wheel nuts on my car (M12, done up as tight as I can do with a 1/2" breaker bar) but that's about its limit.
You do have to be careful not to completely rip small bolts to shreds though - keep going once it's tight and you'll just shear the head off.Edit: oh, and of course the best thing about them is you have all this torque but little to no force on you. Unlike a drill which can wrench itself out of your hand, the impact driver just sits there happily beating the fastener in to submission.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Impact drivers really excel at putting in screws in tough situations without stripping out the head AND in removing really stuck nuts (like lug nuts or nuts exposed to the corrosion of being out in the elements.).How often do you use cordless impact drivers on vehicles? I thought about it as a possible use but many of the bolts especially inside engine bay don't have enough clearance to use one.
@Cupboard said:
Impact drivers are fantastic for many things, there's nothing better for self drilling screws. The Bosch 18V one will undo the wheel nuts on my car (M12, done up as tight as I can do with a 1/2" breaker bar) but that's about its limit.That's interesting to hear, a few of the reviews I've read actually said they don't have enough torque to remove lug nuts.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

